
Sunday, October 19, 2008
Retail Memo: First Two Sprouts Farmers Market Stores Sprout in Colorado; Another Challenge to What The FTC Says is Whole Foods' Category Hegemony

Friday, April 10, 2009
Retail Memo: Newest Texas 'Newflower Farmers Market,' Which Sprouted From Parent 'Sunflower Farmers Market,' Blooms in Dallas, Texas

Sunflower Farmers Market founder and CEO Mike Gilliland stationed in the Dallas "Newflower Farmers Market" store's produce department on grand opening day. The word is that the produce department is the grocer's favorite of all. In fact, a Dallas Newflower store employee says that on the March 18 grand opening day that the CEO, who also bagged customers grocery as part of the opening, kept running off from the store front end to spend more time in the produce department.
Shoppers check out and get "checked out" at the Dallas "Newflower Farmers Market" store on grand opening day, March 18, 2009.
The produce department is a central departmental feature in the Sunflower-Newflower stores. Although the stores average about 15,000 -to- 25,000 thousand square feet, the produce department in the stores is much larger than an average store of that size would have. This is by design. Sunflower-Newflower prices both conventional and organic fresh produce at low everyday prices. This serves not only as a way to draw shoppers to the store but helps grow market basket sizes in the stores as well. Notice the no frills, farmers' market-style design of the produce department above in the new Dallas Newflower store. Doing so provides cost savings which allows for the everyday low produce pricing practice. It obviously also fits in with the chain's overall theme and name.
Inside the Newflower Farmers Market store that opened in Dallas, Texas on March 19, 2009. Notice the basic, no frills product refrigerated cases and the painted cement floors. This is part of the chain's no frills store design which allows it to offer natural and organic products at lower everyday prices than many of its competitors. The focus is on the the product and its price rather than on the store's design. The balloon the happy little girl is holding were given out to children, along with other treats, all day at the store's March 19 grand opening event. The balloon is doing a great job of holding her attention so that mom can concentrate on her shopping.Below is a selection of related, past stories and posts from NSFM:
~March 12, 2009: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market is Selling Brand 'Wild Oats'- We Offer Three Retailers We Suggest Could Benefit From Buying the Brand
~December 6, 2008: Retail Memo: Fast-Growing and Scrappy Sunflower Farmers Market Ventures Deep in the Heart of (Whole Foods Country) Texas
~October 27, 2008: Retail Memo: Sprouts Farmers Market Store Number Eight 'Sprouts' in Texas; Deep in the Heart of Whole Foods Market Country
~October 21, 2008: Retail Memo: Natural Grocers Joining Sunflower Farmers Market in Opening First Stores in Whole Foods Market's Home City of Austin, Texas USA
~October 21, 2008: Retail Memo: H-E-B Set to Open 127,900 Square Foot Hybrid Mega-Store in Houston, Texas Suburb; Miles and Aisles of Organic and Premium Delights
~August 15, 2008: Retail Memo: 'Business Week' Discovers Sunflower Farmers Market, Just As Many Shoppers Are Doing Daily
~June 19, 2008: Retail Memo: Two Food Retailing Chains (Among the Growing Legions) Who Fear Not the Whole Foods Market, Inc.-Wild Oats Juggernaut
~April 29, 2008: Independent Grocer Memo: Utah's 75 Year Old Harmons Combats the Big Chains With Low-Prices; Gets Ready For Whole Foods' By Going Upscale & Natural
~February 24, 2008: Retail Memo: The Whole Foods Mrkt., Inc. as Monopolist Fallacy: How Sprouts Farmers Mrkts. and Others Are Growing Into the Heart of Whole Foods Country
~December 20, 2007: Retail Memo: Natural-Born Category Killers
[You can follow Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on Twitter.com at www.twitter.com/nsfoodsmemo.]
Monday, October 27, 2008
Retail Memo: Sprouts Farmers Market Store Number Eight Sprouts in Texas; Deep in the Heart of Whole Foods Market Country

The new Murphy Marketplace Sprouts is the natural grocer's eighth Texas store. It has additional natural markets set to open in the Lone Star State, where supernatural foods retailer Whole Foods was founded and is headquartered, in Austin. The national and international natural grocery chain currently operates 15 stores in its home state of Texas. Sprouts Farmers Market currently has stores in Arizona, California, Colorado and Texas.
The new Murphy, Texas Sprouts Farmers Market unit opened on Friday. But a big grand opening celebration by the grocer and the developer of the shopping center is planned for this Wednesday, October 29.
The $90-million Murphy Marketplace shopping and lifestyle destination center of which the new Sprouts natural market is a part is owed and was developed by Langford Property Company. The center is located at the intersection of FM 544 and Murphy Road in Murphy, which is in East Collin County. The Sprouts' store is the first natural-specialty market in the county, according to Eric Langford, president of the development company.
Langford says the joint Sprouts-Murphy Marketplace grand opening event will kick off with a ribbon-cutting ceremony at 10:30am at the Sprouts natural market. In conjunction with the ribbon-cutting ceremony, Langford says the center will dedicate a special clock tower, which was donated for the shopping center by the area Chamber of Commerce. The tower cost $10,000 and adds a historic flair to the lifestyle shopping center, Langford says.
The new Sprouts' store will hold all sorts of grand opening activities on Wednesday, including food tastings, special promotions and events tied-in with the clock tower dedication ceremony.
Like its other natural products markets, the new Murphy Marketplace Sprouts Farmers Market store specializes in farm fresh produce, purchased from local growers when possible. Sprouts also offers a large selection of vitamins and supplements, all natural meats, fresh seafood, bins full of bulk foods, an extensive selection of natural, organic and specialty grocery items, imported cheeses, deli meats, prepared foods and more.
Sprouts Farmers Market stores average about 15,000 square feet.
The Sprouts' natural market is the retail food anchor of the new Murphy Marketplace center which covers about 76 acres. Among the center's other retail tenants include: a Lowe's big box home improvement store, 24-Hour Fitness, Wachovia Bank, Saxby's, Massage Envy, Monarch Dental, Red Brick Pizza, Smoothie Factory, Planet Tan, Mattress Giant, Azura Nail Spa, Firehouse Subs, Cristina's Fine Mexican Restaurant, T-Mobile, Whataburger and more, according to the developer.
Being the only natural-specialty grocer in the county gives Sprouts a competitive advantage in this fast-growing and changing part of Texas. In fact, Sprouts has been locating a number of its Texas stores in regions in the state where no natural-specialty markets exist but where the emerging demographics and growth patterns offer good current and near term opportunity.
For example, According to the City of Murphy, the median household income for the city is $111,000-plus. Nearly 90 percent of the city's residents are college-educated. College-education is one of the key demographic variables that correlates to prime natural foods consumers. In fact, education-level is the top criteria Whole Foods Market uses in terms of locating one of its stores in a city or neighborhood.
Murphy's population has more than quadrupled since 2000, from 3,000 residents to more than 14,000 in early 2006. East Collin County, where the city is located, also is one of the fastest-growing counties in Texas. The new shopping center is regional in its scope, so the Sprouts' natural market is expected to draw from a much larger population base than just Murphy's 14,000 residents.
According to research conducted by the city, county and the developer of the new shopping center, FM 544 (the highway where the center is located) supports traffic of nearly 40,000 vehicles per day. In other words, at least 40,000 vehicles drive past the Murphy Marketplace daily.
The city of Murphy was established in the late 1800s during the time the railroad was extended into the area. It quickly became a shipping hub for the local farming and ranching families. As it did for other Texas towns, the railroad gave Murphy residents the opportunity to import building materials that were not locally available. Bricks that were mass-produced in Bedfordshire, United Kingdom and slates from North Wales were incorporated into the construction of new buildings.
Along with these new materials came the "Victorian" architectural style. The Victorians invented a way to make big panes of glass, called "sheet glass." So Victorian houses had bigger windows. Victorians also loved to decorate their houses by embellishing these large windows and by adding bay windows, iron railings, Flemish bonding and other decorative brickwork patterns. Early Murphy residents were quick to adopt this affluent style into their new homes.
Murphy Marketplace has blended many of these local design elements into the architectural design of the retail center. The center's -- and the new Sprouts natural market's -- design features include the use of soft earth tone colors, simple building lines, colorful canopies, decorative lighting and extensive landscaping in keeping with the community's design theme. Walking paths, shade trees, water features and gathering areas also provide a place to stroll, play and visit with friends, creating a strong sense of place in the center.
In this October 21 piece, "Retail Memo: Natural Grocers Joining Sunflower Farmers Market in Opening First Stores in Whole Foods Market's Home City of Austin, Texas USA," we wrote about how two other fast-growing natural foods retail chains, Sunflower Farmers Market and Natural Grocers, are joining Sprouts Farmers Market in opening stores deep in the heart of Whole Foods Market, Inc. country -- Texas.
That Sprouts already has opened and currently operates eight natural foods markets in Whole Foods' home headquarters state, with more new stores on the way -- a new Sprouts store is planned to open in McKinney Texas in the summer of 2009 and another in Coppell, Texas in late 2009, for example -- demonstrates the marketplace (and Sprouts) disagrees with the argument by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) that Whole Foods Market, Inc. has a monopolistic or hegemonic position in the natural and organic products retailing space as a result of its merger with Wild Oats last year.
Do smaller competitors really open stores in an aggressive manner in the home state of a retailer that has a monopoly in the natural and organic products retailing segment? Of course not. They do so because they see a niche and an opportunity to compete, which means competition exists.
Add to Sprouts the fact Sunflower and Natural Grocers are both opening stores in Texas and the FTC's argument becomes even more silly.
Further add the significant competition in Texas from supermarket chains like H-E-B and United Supermarkets' Market Street banner, Safeway-owned Randall's, Costco, Wal-Mart and a few others in the state (all retailers deep into the natural and organic foods categories) and the FTC's argument looks like pure folly.
And Texas is far from an isolated example. It's the same all over the U.S. Whole Foods Market is faced with stiff (and getting stiffer) natural and organic category competition from regional natural foods chains like Sprouts, Sunflower, Natural Grocers and others, including independents and Co-operatives in some places, and national and regional supermarket chains (and local independent grocers), as we wrote about in this October 19 piece focusing on the Colorado market.
Also toss in the national mass merchandisers and club chains: Wal-Mart; Target; Costco; BJ's Wholesale; and Wal-Mart's Sam's Club. All are deep in the natural and organic products categories -- and getting deeper. Then there is Trader Joe's. And we are just getting started. Tip of the iceberg stuff. There is no lack of category competition at retail for Whole Foods Market.
This competitive fact is true in California, Oregon and Washington State, the Midwest, the South, and the eastern U.S. In all U.S. regions natural foods retailers and supermarkets -- national, regional and independent -- all are challenging Whole Foods in the natural and organic products retailing segment in various ways. We can't find one region in the U.S. where a person with real knowledge of natural products retailing could say Whole Foods has a real monopolistic position. Rather, the supernatural retailer is actually fighting for its life nationally.
Despite this market reality, the FTC plans to hold a new hearing in February, 2009 to discuss what it says is Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s monopolistic position in the natural and organic category retailing segment. This despite the fact every shred of empirical evidence shows it isn't the case. We even wonder how many of the current members of the FTC will be around in 2009 when a new President has taken office following next week's election?
Perhaps it's time to have a Boston Tea Party in front of the FTC offices in Washington, DC as a symbol of how this government agency continues to waste resources and U.S. taxpayer money in its non-marketplace reality-based pursuit of a natural and organic products category retailing monopoly that doesn't exist. We suggest organic tea of course.
There are real monopolies out there after all. Whole Foods Market, Inc. just isn't one of them.
[Editor's note: Natural~Specialty Foods Memo owns no stock in Whole Foods Market, Inc. Nor does it have any sort of business or professional relationship with the company.]
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
Retail Memo: Natural Grocers Joining Sunflower Farmers Market in Opening First Stores in Whole Foods Market's Home City of Austin, Texas USA

The Austin, Texas store, which Natural Grocers says is scheduled to open in January, 2009, will be the natural grocer's first Austin unit and its third store in Texas. Currently there is one Natural Grocers store in Dallas, at 7515 Campbell Road, which opened just last month. A second store is scheduled to open next month in Amarillo.
At about 11,000 square feet, the Austin Natural Grocers market is far smaller than the typical new Whole Foods Market store.
However, it's not much smaller than the small-format natural foods stores being opened by two other fast-growing chain's -- Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Market. The stores of these two natural products retailers average about 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet. The Dallas Natural Grocers store that opened last month is about 14,000 square feet.
Sunflower Farmers Market also plans to soon open a store in Whole Foods Market's home city of Austin, joining Natural Grocers in its backyard invasion of Whole Foods' home turf. In June of this year, as we reported, Sunflower Farmers Market announced plans to open its first store at 1901 W. William Cannon Drive near the intersection of Manchaca Road. We also reported Sunflower said at the time it plans at least three stores in the Austin area.
Natural Grocers also says it plans to open at least two more stores in Austin if the first store performs well. Those stores would be in the city's Arboretum area and in South Austin, according to Kemper Isley, who is the co-president of Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage.
Asked why the retailer is going to locate a store right in the heart of Whole Foods country, Isley says "Austin's demographics fit well with the company's model of a traditional natural foods store." He also says he's not concerned about going into the backyard of Austin-based Whole Foods Market, Inc.
The Austin Natural Grocers' store will be located across the street from Central Market, the upscale natural-specialty format banner of 310-store Texas-based food and grocery chain H.E. Butt (H-E-B). Central Market stores are popular in Texas. The markets feature lots of natural, organic, specialty, gourmet, international and fresh, prepared foods in an upscale setting.
"We've always considered ourselves synergistic with Whole Foods and I think we’ll be the same way with Central Market," says Isely.
In other words, Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage believes being located across the street from the Central Market and not to far away from a Whole Foods Market unit in Austin will actually help the store's sales rather than hurt them. At least the Colorado-based natural retailer is betting on that premise.
The Natural Grocers' stores are a bit more traditional or orthodox natural foods markets.
For example, the stores offer only organic produce items, no conventionally grown. Additionally, The company's product ingredient standards tend to be stricter than those of Whole Foods Market and other chain natural products retailers. The stores also put a heavy emphasis on selling natural supplements, devoting about 20% of the store's square footage to the category.
Natural Grocers' stores are modern though. In addition to selling natural and organic food, grocery and non-foods products, the stores also offer specialty and gourmet items as long as those products meet its standards, for example. The store design also is modernistic in look and approach.
Like Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Market, Natural Grocers puts an emphasise on price, trying to offer everyday retail prices lower than those at Whole Foods' stores and other competitors.
Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage currently has 28 stores. All but three of the stores -- the current Texas store open in Dallas and stores in Santa Fe and Albuquerque, New Mexico, -- are in Colorado.
But like Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Market, Natural Grocers is in a fast-growth mode. Company co-president Isely says the natural products retailer is looking at four locations in North Texas beyond its existing Dallas store and will look at other locations elsewhere around the state.
Additionally, he says the retailer is looking to potentially open stores in Utah, Wyoming, Arizona and Oklahoma. All four of these states would be brand new markets for Natural Grocers.
The retailer first ventured outside of its home base of Colorado in 2003, opening the two stores in nearby New Mexico. It wasn't until five years later that it opened its first store in a third state outside of Colorado, opening the Dallas last month. Now another store follows in Austin in January, 2009 -- and Natural Grocers' store count and new market growth appears to be in rapid-development gear.
Related Stories from Natural~Specialty Foods Memo:
>October 19, 2008: Retail Memo: First Two Sprouts Farmers Market Stores Sprout in Colorado; Another Challenge to What The FTC Says is Whole Foods' Category Hegemony
>October 21, 2008: Retail Memo: H-E-B Set to Open 127,900 Square Foot Hybrid Mega-Store in Houston, Texas Suburb; Aisles of Organics and Premium Delights
>Click here to read a selection of past posts about the FTC/Whole Foods-Wild Oats acquisition issue.
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
Small Format Food Retailing Special Report: Sprout's Farmers Market Gets $22 Million in New Financing; Will 'Sprout' 100 New Stores Over Next 5 Years

Sunday, February 24, 2008
Retail Memo:The Whole Foods Mrkt., Inc. as Monopolist Fallacy: How Sprouts Farmers Mrkts. and Others Are Growing Into the Heart of Whole Foods Country

Yes, indeed, not only did the Boney family fail to get that memo, apparently they also failed to read the numerous articles in the grocery trade and newspaper business publications which have suggested the Whole Foods'/Wild Oats' deal is going to kill retail competition. And, they certainly must have turned a deaf ear to the numerous industry suppliers, retailers and others who argue the same thing.
Thursday, June 19, 2008
Retail Memo: Two Food Retailing Chains (Among the Growing Legions) Who Fear Not the Whole Foods Market, Inc.-Wild Oats Juggernaut
Sunflower Farmers Market founder and CEO Mike Gilliland in the produce department of one of his natural foods stores. The Sunflower Farmers Market stores are built around the produce department, which is generally located in the center of the store, and features conventional, organic and locally-grown fresh produce at prices considerably lower than Whole Foods Market, Inc. stores and most upscale supermarkets. With six stores coming to Texas and a new store in Boulder, Colorado, will Gilliland, already not a freind of John (Mackey), and his fast-growing Sunflower Farmers market chain become the new thorn in John Mackey and Whole Foods' side?Claims by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC)--which continues to argue and appeal to the U.S. Federal Appeals Court in Washington D.C. that the Whole Foods Market, Inc.-Wild Oats Markets, Inc. merger has created a natural foods retailing monopoly and should be broken up--aside, two food retailers, among the many, are taking on the combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats juggernaut in two U.S. markets: Whole Foods' backyard home state of Texas, where it got its start and which it protects closely, and in Hawaii, where the supernatural retailer is launching four new stores as its entry for the first time into the multi-island-state market.
Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has argued that the FTC, along with retailers and suppliers who share its position vis-a-vis Whole Foods, are with all due respect plain wrong. In fact, we've been arguing and writing since last year when the acquisition-merger of Wild Oats by Whole Foods Market, Inc. was announced, that it would actually stimulate and increase natural foods category retailing rather than decrease competition.
Our argument is simple: Wild Oats was basically no longer an innovative (or for that matter very good) natural foods retailer. However, it's position as the number two supernatural foods retailer after Whole Foods tended to suppress innovation by other retailers to a certain extent because they viewed the category in many ways as a two retailer contest.
Certain retailers like Sunflower Farmers Market, Sprouts Farmers Market, Trader Joe's and some others were well on their way to competing in the category in their own unique ways. However, we've watched what in our analysis is a floodgate of players willing to take on Whole Foods Market, regardless of if they are natural foods retailers or supermarket companies, emerge since just late last year.
The joining of Wild Oats into Whole Foods provided some creative deconstruction in the retailing category. After the dust settled a bit, numerous retailers realized it wasn't such a mega-deal after all; that in fact there was plenty of competitive space available to them in the natural foods retailing space--be they natural foods format food retailers, hybrids or supermarket operators--to take on Whole Foods in regional markets throughout the U.S.
Sunflower Farmers Market: Texas bound by way of Boulder
One of the most aggressive post-merger competitors in the natural foods retailing space, albeit much smaller than Whole Foods, is Colorado-based Sunflower Farmers Market. Late last year the "fighting tiger" natural foods retailer, which operates natural foods supermarkets which range from 15,000 -to about 30,000 square feet with a focus on fresh produce and natural products for less (retail price), raised $30 million in new financing and announced it would more than triple the number of stores it has (currently 14) over the next three -to- four years. Plans call for having 21 stores open by the end of this year alone and 30 or more by the end of 2009.
Sunflower, which was founded and is headed by Mike Gilliland, the founder of Wild Oats, not only is expanding the number of stores it has in the Western U.S., but also is going right at Whole Foods with plans to open six stores in Texas, Whole Foods Market, Inc's home state, where it was founded and has its corporate headquarters.
Sunflower Farmers Market also plans to open its first store in Boulder, Colorado where it is headquartered. Boulder also is where Gilliland founded Wild Oats and has lived for decades. Boulder also is now Whole Foods' second hometown, having acquired Wild Oats which was based in Boulder, and the numerous stores it operated in the city. Gilliland left Wild Oats well before the acquisition-merger with Whole Foods Market, Inc.
Sunflower Farmers market founder and CEO Gilliland and John Mackey, Whole Foods Market founder and CEO, had a falling out many years ago, and to this day don't speak socially at industry events and other functions. Let's say Mike Gilliland isn't on the "friend's of John" email buddy list; nor is Mackey on Gilliland's Yahoo messenger "buddies" list in turn.
The Austin-American Statesman, based in Whole Foods' Texas hometown of Austin, has a recent (June 3, 2008) piece about Sunflower Farmers Market's decision to move into Texas with an initial six stores, including a 30,000 square feet natural foods supermarket in Austin, which Gilliland says will beat Whole Foods Market retail prices by 15% or more everyday in all categories, and even more in fresh produce.
Of course, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo is certain Whole Foods will fight back against that price undercutting on its home turf. Despite that, Sunflower is a serious competitor despite being so much smaller. It's good at what it does, and fears not Whole Foods Market post the Wild Oats' acquisition.
Hawaii: Defending the home turf with a new format and chain
Hawaii is a state in which Whole Foods Market is making a major new store opening effort in an attempt to become a major player in food retailing on the islands. Whole Foods has never had a store in Hawaii. But its changing that by having four stores in development at the same time: two in Honolulu (a huge 67,000 square foot unit and a smaller 27,000 square foot store); a store on the island of Maui (26,366 square feet), and a 40,000 square foot Whole Foods superstore on the island of Kailua. There also are future plans for even more Whole Foods stores in Hawaii.
Most Hawaii food retailers, especially those with upscale and natural foods offerings, have been extremely concerned and worried about the competitive impact Whole Foods Market's arrival on the islands will have on their businesses and the market, and fear a significant loss of business from the successful every place it goes natural foods grocery chain.
However, that's not the case with all of Hawaii's food retailers. Hawaii-based The Sullivan Family of Companies, which operates the Foodland, Sack-N-Save and Food Pantry chains, which are conventional supermarkets and discount supermarkets, has created a brand new format designed to compete in the natural and specialty foods space with Whole Foods Market on the islands.
The new chain or banner, called Lahaina Farms, gets its start next Wednesday when the first small-format (14,000 square feet) Lehaina Farms natural foods supermarket opens in the Lahaina Gateway Lifestyle Center in Lahaina, which is on the island of Maui, where one of the four Whole Foods stores will open possibly as soon as later this year.
The first Lehaina Farms store (not all of the new natural-specialty format stores will necessarily be called Lehaina Farms by the way, according to the company) is a combination natural, organic, specialty and fresh foods store with an upscale but price-conscious focus.
The Maui News, the Island's main newspaper, has a feature article in today's issue about the venture by the company best known in Hawaii for its Foodland chain, which is a longtime fixture on the islands.
Although the retailer's experience is primarily with conventional and discount supermarkets, it apparently hasn't heard about the Whole Foods monopoly as it's creating a natural foods chain of its own at a time in which Whole Foods Market, Inc. is making a major play in the Hawaii food and grocery retailing market.
The cup runith over: Lots of competition for Whole Foods
These two food retailers are just the tip of the iceberg in terms of grocers who don't buy the now tired argument by the FTC and some retailers and vendors that Whole Foods has achieved monopoly status by virtue of its acquisition of Wild Oats. In fact, one wonders if it had it all to do over again if Whole Foods Market, Inc. would have even bothered doing the deal, since it's caused lots of distraction for the retailer. But yes, they would do it again no doubt.
Additionally, although the retailer isn't talking about it, Whole Foods has found many of the former Wild Oats stores to be lacking in many ways, both physically in size and in condition, as well as the poor locations of many of the stores.
While John Mackey recently said the integration and conversion of the Wild Oats stores to the Whole Foods banner and system is going well, we've talked to a number of Whole Foods employees who've told us numerous aspects of the process have been a pain in the portion of the hog that sells for the cheapest price per pound. Chief among these pains being the condition of many of the former Wild Oats stores, as we mentioned above, along with some of the poor locations.
We've written about numerous other retailers that are putting a competitive challenge to Whole Foods in the natural products retailing category. These include smaller natural foods retailers like Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Markets, Trader Joe's, and numerous independent natural foods retailers.
It also includes mega-supermarket chains like Safeway Stores, Inc. with it's upscale Lifestyle format supermarkets, the newer versions of which keep looking more and more like a Whole Foods store, but with the added benefit of selling basic groceries as well.
Additionally, in Texas there's HEB, which continues to build mega-upscale stores that rival Whole Foods in look and product selection. There's also Market Street in Texas, which is building and opening some of the most interesting upscale supermarkets full of natural and organic products in the U.S.
On the east coast there's Wegman's, which of late has been opening 100,000 square foot supermarkets that combine basic groceries, specialty and organic products, fresh, prepared foods and non-foods items in a format that losing nothing to a Whole Foods superstore.
Southern California alone has Sprouts Farmers Markets, Henry's (which Whole Foods sold as part of the Wild Oats acquisition) SuperValu-owned Bristol Farms, upscale Gelson's, Trader Joe's, Vons' upscale Pavilions stores, numerous independents, and now Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, which sells lots of organic foods at discount prices, all as key competitors to Whole Foods in that market in the natural products' niche
There are many more; we could use another four thousand words and still just be getting warmed up. But we will same that for next time; as we plan on featuring these and many more retail players in the days and weeks to come here on Natural~Specialty Foods Memo.
Meanwhile, we suggest the FTC move on. Might there be some monopolistic or price-fixing issues in the oil industry that could warrant a closer look. After all, the top three U.S. oil companies' senior executives have bigger combined expense accounts than Whole Foods Market, Inc. has annual sales. Well, almost as much.
Friday, August 15, 2008
Retail Memo: 'Business Week' Discovers Sunflower Farmers Market, Just As Many Shoppers Are Doing Daily

We first started writing about Sunflower Farmers Market, which was founded by former Wild Oats Market, Inc. founder Mike Gilliland (pictured above in a store produce department) who is the company's CEO or 'Head Sunflower,' last year (when NSFM was started) at a time when most publications devoted very little if any ink to the natural foods' grocer.
We've continued to regularly report on the retailer's developments and write about what we often call the natural foods retail space category-killer because of its discount prices on natural and organic products, especially fresh produce and shelf-stable food grocery items.
With the $30 million Sunflower Farmers Market raised early this year, it's embarked upon a fast-growth new store strategy, as we've written about. This growth strategy even includes opening stores in Whole Foods Market's home territory of Texas.
We often suggest that Sunflower and Sprouts Farmers Market combined offer much more of a competitive challenge today to Whole Foods Market, Inc. than Wild Oats did pre-acquisition. Of course, Sunflower and Sprouts don't have as many stores as Wild Oats had before merging with Whole Foods Market last year. (There were 110 Wild Oats-owned stores when Whole Foods acquired the chain last year.) However, both "fighting tiger" natural foods retailers are growing so fast it won't be too long until they reach that number between them.
Sunflower Farmers Market has started getting attention from both the mainstream supermarket industry trade press and the consumer business press in the last couple months. This is for two primary reasons: The natural grocer's raising of the $30 million in investment money earlier this year and its resulting rapid new store opening program, and because the editors and reporters for these publications now read blogs like Natural~Specialty Foods Memo and others regularly. We know this because we often get email communications from newspaper business section writers and others about stories we write about or news we break regarding the industry.
Business Week, arguably the mainstream media bible of business and industry in the United States, recently published a feature article on Sunflower Farmers Market and its founder Mike Gilliland--who by the way is no friend of John (Whole Foods' John Mackey that is). The two are the natural foods industry's version of the chemical reaction that results when you mix oil and water together if you've ever seen them in the same room together, even if that room is one of the two huge exhibit floors at the east or west coast Natural Foods Expo industry trade shows held annually.
We thought the Business Week article was pretty was well done and informative and therefore wanted to bring it to our readers in case you didn't see and read it in Business Week in late July. Plus, we are on vacation today--so we aren't writing an original piece or two like normal.
Sunflower Sprouts Fresh Stores and Consumers
Mike Gilliland, Wild Oats' founder, has big plans for his fast-growing Sunflower Farmers Market
by Jessie Scanlon
Page Morgan-Draper still shops at her local Albuquerque Whole Foods (WFMI). But, says the mother of two: "We're not made of money." That's one of the reasons she stops at a Sunflower Farmers Market on her way home from work three days a week. The fast-growing chain of grocery stores in five Western and Southwestern states specializes in produce, much of it organic, bought directly from farmers and sold at almost Wal-Mart (WMT) like prices—two pounds of organic broccoli for $3 and 99¢ for a pound of apples, to quote recent specials at Morgan-Draper's local store.
With its "Serious Food, Silly Prices" tag line, Sunflower targets consumers like Morgan-Draper who want to eat healthy, natural foods, but can't afford—or don't want to pay—gourmet prices. As Sunflower CEO and co-founder Mike Gilliland puts it: "We're a cost-conscious Whole Foods."
But Gilliland wants to do more than just pick off that high-end grocery's belt-tightening shoppers. His prices, and the weekly Sunflower sales advertised in the newspaper beside the local supermarket ads, are an attempt to lure consumers at the middle-to-low end of the market. The potential genius of Sunflower is its appeal to consumers at both ends of a market that's increasingly split between low-cost big-box stores and wholesale clubs on one end, and high-end retailers at the other.
Growing His Second Chain
It's an innovative strategy that's easier said than done. The relative newcomer is virtually surrounded by highly aggressive competitors, from Whole Foods to the increasingly organic Wal-Mart and its recent small-format spin-off, Wal-Mart Marketplace (NSFM Editor's note: it's Marketside not Marketplace), itself launched in response to British brand Tesco's U.S. effort, Fresh and Easy.
But higher food prices—up 5% nationally between April, 2007 and April, 2008, according to the most recent figures from the Bureau of Labor Statistics—could give Sunflower a boost, as even middle class consumers become more price-conscious. And Sunflower's emphasis on organic produce, much of it grown locally, should appeal to the consumers that spent a total of $1 billion at farmers markets in 2006. Buoyed by these trends—and by a $30 million investment by private equity firm PCG Capital Partners in December, 2007—Sunflower is in the midst of a rapid expansion, growing from its current 14 stores to some 21 locations by the end of 2008. Fifty stores are planned for five years from now.
Sunflower is almost a déjà vu for Gilliland, who founded Wild Oats with his wife, Libby Cook, in 1987. "Back then, most people couldn't spell 'tofu,'" says the natural-foods pioneer. Despite some missteps as a first-time entrepreneur, he built Wild Oats into a $2.2 billion company before stepping down as CEO in 2001. (The more successful Whole Foods bought Wild Oats in 2007 for $565 million.) He launched Sunflower in 2002.
Pricing, Pricing, Pricing
There's a reason Gilliland thinks Sunflower will do well against his longstanding rival. The company's farmers-market format is based on a California chain called Henry's Market, one of the many companies Gilliland had acquired when he was Wild Oats CEO. As his company and Whole Foods expanded, he increasingly found his stores under pressure. "A Whole Foods would open nearby and the typical Wild Oats would lose 30% to 40% of its business overnight," he says.
But stores based on the Henry's Market format competed well because they were less intimidating to the casual natural-foods shopper and appealed to the demographic that didn't want to pay for the glitz of a natural-foods superstore.
Pricing is key to Sunflower's strategy and its drive to undersell Wal-Mart. Gilliland claims that at least 80% of the store's produce beats the giant's prices. He and his team have been rethinking myriad aspects of their business, trying to "squeeze pennies out of everything," he says. Sunflower buys its produce by the truckload directly from farmers; local trucking is done by Sunflower staff, using company vehicles. Construction, too, is managed in-house by Gilliland's brother, who outsources some jobs to skilled workers. This allows Sunflower to build a new store for less than $2 million, or $70 a square foot, compared to the $150-per-square-foot industry average for a new supermarket.
In terms of design, the stores are no-frills. "They're nice stores, but not works of art," says Gilliland. "Whole Foods is like a museum!" Of course, it's "silly prices," not sleek design, that he's going for.
A natural surge?
At least in the short run, analysts aren't convinced that Sunflower's market-bridging strategy will succeed, especially when it comes to wooing low-end consumers. "Let's get real," says David Livingston of DJL Research. "[Sunflower] simply does not have the economies of scale in terms of labor, rent, and purchasing power [to beat Wal-Mart]." Apart from produce, Sunflower's prices are higher than the giant's, although they're competitive. While consumers who are tired of the big-box shopping experience may be willing to pay a bit more at a friendly, smaller-format store, it's far from certain they will.
Considering the other ends of the market, Paul Weitzel, a managing partner at Willard Bishop, says: "I don't think people who shop organic are as price sensitive as some." But with the economy tightening, more consumers are going to focus on value.
It's too early to call Sunflower a resounding success, but its strategy seems to be working. Same store year-over-year sales are up by double digits, according to Gilliland. Looking forward, the company will benefit from consumers' continued focus on fresh produce and on healthy foods. According to Progressive Grocer's 2008 Annual Report on the industry, retailers expect produce to be the most-shopped food category this year, followed by private-label products—double good news for Sunflower.
"We expect a surge over the next five years as naturals go from niche to mainstream," says Willard Bishop's Weitzel. "Sunflower will be well-positioned for that."
Jessie Scanlon is the senior writer for Innovation & Design on BusinessWeek.com.