Wednesday, January 16, 2008
Retail Memo: Wal-Mart and Safeway Stores Could 'Box' Tesco in With New Small Format Stores
The news that mega-retailer Wal-Mart will build four (to start) 20,000 square foot grocery markets named "MarketSide" in the Phoenix, Arizona metropolitan region adds new, additional competitive pressures to Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small format stores.
These Wal-Mart "Small Marts," which at 20,000 square feet are about 5,000 to 7,000 square feet bigger than Fresh & Easy stores but half the size of the retailer's Wal_Mart Neighborhood Market format, are likely to be similar in format to British grocer Tesco's small format grocery markets.
Based on what we currently know--from published reports and additional information from our sources--the small format stores will offer a mix of basic groceries, prepared foods, and specialty items. This mix is similar to Fresh & Easy's. At this point, we aren't sure what else the "MarketSide" stores will merchandise, but are rather sure they will feature some version of this basic grocery, fresh foods mix, along with whatever else the stores will sell.
As out readers know, we reported recently that Pleasanton, California-based Safeway Stores, Inc. has secured leases in the San Francisco Bay Area region of San Jose for five new, small format stores the retailer plans to open later this year. While we don't yet know the name of these Safeway small format stores, we have fairly good information they too will offer a mix of basic groceries and prepared foods.
Neither of these developments are good news for Tesco's Fresh & Easy. Just two months ago, Fresh & Easy stood as basically the lone food chain pioneer in this hybrid small format, basic grocery/fresh foods merchandising arena. Had this remained the case, Fresh & Easy would have had plenty of time to rollout its numerous planned stores in California, Arizona and Nevada, perfected its format, and not had to share the media limelight with two powerhouse, US-based retailers--Wal-Mart and Safeway--as they are having to do now.
This won't be the case however. Wal-Mart's initial opening later this year of four stores in Arizona, all four in areas where there are Fresh & Easy stores, and Safeway's opening later this year of five stores in the San Jose region in Northern California, will put a competitive check on Tesco. (Tesco plans to start opening Fresh & Easy stores in Northern California later this year. The grocer also will build a distribution center in Stockton, in Northern California, to serve up to 50 stores in the region it wants to build in the next two years.
Both Wal-Mart and Safeway are major retail brand names. Safeway, which is based in Northern California, will have a major marketing advantage with its small format stores against Fresh & Easy. Safeway also already has all the supply-chain and marketing infrastructure in place to serve these new, small format stores. The grocer operates about 300 supermarkets in Northern California, including numerous stores in and around San Jose. It's corporate headquarters is about 30 miles from the San Jose region. It also has a distribution facility nearby.
Wal-Mart already has a number of Supercenters in Arizona, including in the Phoenix region where it will open the small format "MarketSide" stores. The chain, like Safeway has all of it's logistics in place, to say the least. As the world's largest company and retailer, Wal-Mart will have no problem matching Tesco on selection, price and marketing muscle. Arizona also is one of the best food markets for Wal-Mart. Opening it's first small format stores there is, in addition to going head-to-head against Fresh & Easy, a smart move in general for the retailer.
Like a game of chess on a chessboard, Wal-Mart and Safeway have the ability to box Fresh & Easy in: Wal-Mart in Arizona (to start) and Safeway in Northern California (to start). Safeway also has numerous supermarkets (over 400) in Southern California, where its Vons' stores are the number two food dollar market share leader, just behind Kroger Co.'s Ralph's. Further, the grocery chain also has a retail presence in Nevada.
Safeway already is looking to Southern California to possibly locate some of the new, small format stores, and can do so easily as it has the same fully-developed infrastructure it has in Northern California. (Safeway has this fully-developed supply-chain ability for the entire Western USA. For that matter, for the entire USA.)
Wal-Mart can go anywhere. The mega-retailer actually developed the "MarketSide" stores in the San Francisco Bay Area, where a team of executives spent months developing the format. Expect stores in Northern California (urban and suburban stores), Southern California and elsewhere. The global giant knows no geographical--or supply chain--limitations.
So, just a couple months ago, the United Kingdom's biggest grocer was sitting alone on top of the small format, hybrid grocery/prepared foods format in the U.S. Today, just a blink of the eye later, there are two major competitors--the world's biggest retailer, Wal-Mart, and the number one food retailer in the Western USA, Safeway.
The result of these two retail players getting into the game in the Western U.S. means Tesco's mission has just become even harder than it already was. Creating a completely new enterprise--Fresh & Easy, a new format, supply chain and all else, is hard enough in and of itself. For Tesco to now operate and grow the venture with Wal-Mart and Safeway on its heels will be in many ways an even bigger challenge that those original red-coated British invaders faced when they tried to rest the former colony away from a bunch of upstart Americans who wanted their own, sovereign country.
Tesco is good though, and they shouldn't be discounted. They've built their Tesco Express small format chain into the best in Europe. But Wal-Mart and Safeway are equally good, especially in their food retailing homeland. Of course, Wal-Mart isn't the most nimble of food retailers. It will be interesting to see if the mega-retailer can make the transition from big box, mass food retailing to small format, niche retailing. They've done so to a certain degree with their 45,000 square foot Neighborhood Market format. However, at best they have thus far earned a B- with that format.
Wal-Mart has just hired a veteran of UK food retailing, Jack Sinclair, to run its U.S. grocery operations. Sinclair isn't just any veteran of UK food retailing. He spent many years with Tesco, and knows the British retailer's operations (including small format) well. For those who think Wal-Mart is merely dabbling with the "MarketSide" format and stores, the hiring of Sinclair should lay those thoughts to rest.
Safeway has become as nimble a retailer that exists in the U.S. (and internationally for that matter) these days. The grocer has turned its retail business around with its upscale Lifestyle format. It continues to innovate with the format with its new stores, adding new departments and in-store features.
Safeway also has what is perhaps the most successful premium and organic store brand in the business today, with its O' Organics grocery and fresh foods brand. Think we might see some O' Organics brand products in the new, small format Safeway stores?
Safeway also owns an upscale restaurant in the San Jose area, and has been using it to develop innovative, fresh prepared foods items which we believe will find their way into these new, small format markets. The small format store business isn't something Safeway just thought of. The grocer started a research project targeting Tesco's Fresh & Easy venture at least two years ago, and has been working on its small format development program for at least that long.
As we've been writing about here for nearly six months, there is a small format food store revolution happening in the U.S.--and in Europe and Canada. Doing battle are not only Tesco, and now Wal-Mart and Safeway Stores, but a host of others. German grocer Aldi plans on building as many as 100 of its no frills, price-impact, small format grocery stores a year in the U.S. for the next few years. The retailer already has nearly 900 of the little, no frills discount grocery stores in the country. Aldi also owns California-based small format specialty grocer Trader Joe's, which is another major competitor for Fresh & Easy.
Giant Eagle supermarkets also is building more of its Giant Eagle Express small format stores, which are similar to a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market store.
Whole Foods Market, Inc. will open its prototype Whole Foods Express later this year in a former Wild Oats store in Boulder, Colorado. Look for these Express stores from Whole Foods to have lots of fresh, prepared foods items, especially grab-and-go, high-quality but convenient offerings. Also, don't be surprised if some of these Whole Foods' Express stores pop-up in California, one of the supernatural grocers best markets--and one of its top target regions for store development and growth over the next five years.
There's much more going on in this small format revolution. [You can read many of the pieces we've done by typing-in the key words: small format, small format revolution, small format retail food stores, small format grocers, Small Marts, Fresh & Easy and similar phrases in the search box at the top of the blog. Type just one phrase at a time in though. Also use the tags at the end of this piece as search words.]
Meanwhile, the small format revolution's battlefield is becoming a bit more complex--and more intense--for Tesco's Fresh & Easy.
Wal-Mart and Safeway, independently, are flanking the British grocer from two sides--Wal-Mart in Arizona, Safeway in California. We will see one or both of these retailers converge on the middle--Nevada--soon as well. Of course, the big battle, and the big market, is California, south and north. It's a state of nearly 40 million people, which is bigger than most European countries. We suggest you'll see Tesco, Wal-Mart and Safeway battling it out with small format stores in California beginning later this or in early 2009.
The revolution has just started though. Don't rule Tesco's Fresh & Easy out. But don't underestimate Wal-Mart and Safeway either, especially when it comes to not wanting to loose food dollar market share in their home country--and in Safeway's case, on it's home turf.
This revolution won't likely be televised. But we will continue to report on it and write about and analyze it here for our readers. Stay tuned.
Monday, October 22, 2007
Monday Morning Java
Wal-Mart Moving Closer With its New 'Small Mart' Format Development
ere Tesco is building dozens of Fresh & Easy stores, the Financial Times also is reporting that Wal-Mart is building two of its 42,000 square-foot Neighborhood Market grocery stores in the Coachella Valley, a fast-growing desert region about 100 miles east of Los Angeles. The first store, in the city of Coachella, is expected to open sometime next year. The second store will be in La Quinta and is likely to open near the end of 2008 Tuesday, October 23, 2007
Tuesday Talking Points Memo
At a meeting with stock analysts today Eduardo Castro-Wright, chief of Wal-Mart USA operations, confirmed that new smaller Format stores are a key part of the retailer's new strategy.
The map above shows the concentration of Wal-Mart stores (all formats) in the U.S. as of 2004. Many more stores have been built over the last three years, especially in the Western and Midwestern U.S., where Wal-Mart has less store concentration.
Eduardo Castro-Wright, head of Wal-Mart's U.S. operations, said today the mega-retailer plans on improving its returns on investment by building fewer stores and stores that are smaller than its current Discount, Supercenter and Neighborhood Market formats. Castro-Wright made this comment today at Wal-Mart's stock analysts meeting, which was broadcast over the internet. The two-day meeting concludes tomorrow.
Yesterday we wrote about a report from the Financial Times newspaper that Wal-Mart has trademarked two names--"City Thyme" and "Field and Vine"-- to be used for "unspecified retail grocery store services," according to the trademark filing. You can read our piece from yesterday here.
Additionally, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) was one of the first publications to report (on August 22, 2007) that Wal-Mart has a team of executives in San Francisco, California researching and developing two small footprint stores--one an upscale, convenience-type grocery market similar to Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores and the other a small footprint health and Wellness store, which in addition to selling health and wellness products would have a health clinic in-store, among other features. (Read our August 22 article here. When you get to the page linked, scroll down to "Mid-Week Natural~Specialty Foods Roundup.")
Today's announcement from Castro-Wright indicates to us that what we call the "Small Mart" format development--the upscale convenience-type store and the health & wellness concept--are likely to be part of the retailer's new "smaller store" strategy. Additionally, from a grocery retailing perspective, Wal-Mart is likely to build more of its 42,000 square-foot Neighborhood Markets.
The new "Small Marts" in development by the San Francisco-based team are the most interesting to us in terms of the retailer's now confirmed strategy to focus on building smaller stores and building less stores. In a September 6, 2007 piece, The Invasion of the 'Small Marts": Will There be a Small Format Revolution by U.S. Retailers, we discussed Wal-Mart's research and development of the upscale, convenience-type grocery market and small foot print health and wellness-oriented stores in light of UK-based Tesco's launch of its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores next month.
Tesco's first six Fresh & Easy upscale, convenience-type markets, which put a major emphasis on fresh, prepared foods, open on November 8 in Southern California. Over 100 stores are currently in the pipeline for Southern California, Arizona and Nevada, and stores in those two states--as well as more in Southern California--will begin opening at a rapid pace after the first six open on November 8. Tesco also will build stores in Northern California in 2008, beginning with its first one in San Jose, which we reported here last Friday.
Our sense from talking to industry observers and following the "Small Marts" development very closely is that Wal-Mart is likely to develop and rollout the upscale, convenience-type format stores first. It's not by chance CEO Lee Scott sent his team to California to develop the format(s). After all that's where major global retailing rival Tesco has based its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets headquarters and huge new distribution center--and where it will build and open the majority of its stores. And having the team based in San Francisco we believe is because Wal-Mart is looking initially at an urban strategy for the two "Small Mart" stores.
Both the upscale convenience format and health & Wellness concept would make sense in urban San Francisco, San Jose and Los Angeles initially for example, and then rolling them out to the suburbs after that, either in the same format or with some changes. Wal-Mart is basically unable to build Supercenters in these urban areas, both because of a lack of land and due to stiff opposition from municipal governments, citizen's groups and others, to the Supercenter format. These "Small Marts" would allow the chain to gain market share in highly populated, high-dollar markets where it currently isn't a player. In other words it would be all new dollars for Wal-Mart.
The other comment from Castro-Wright at today's analysts meeting, that the retailer will build fewer Supercenter and Discount format stores, we see as fitting-in well with the new small store initiative. Wal-Mart had planned to open 265-270 Supercenters in the U.S. this fiscal year. However, Castro-Wright said today he expects only 190-200 of those stores to open. And as part of the reduction in Supercenter building strategy the retailer will build only 170 Supercenters next fiscal year and "the figure will likely be less than 170 in future years," he said.
This development obviously opens the door to the "Small Mart" format stores, more Neighborhood Markets, and any other smaller store formats we either don't know about at present or that Wal-Mart doesn't even know about itself yet.
Wal-Mart also plans on focusing more internationally as it feels it's reaching saturation in the U.S. to a certain extent. The retailer said today by 2010 40% of its spending on new stores would be spent abroad, up 10% from current overseas new store development spending of 30%. Currently, international sales account for about 23% of Wal-Mart's revenues.
The chain has been under pressure from investors over declining returns on its 4,000 U.S. stores business. The strategy of building fewer Supercenters and Discount stores, and the development of smaller stores, is in part designed to address Wal-Street's concerns. Wal-Mart is cutting its capital expenditure budget from its original forecast of $17 billion for this fiscal year to about $15 billion , according to CFO Tom Schoewe. The retailer says building smaller stores and fewer Supercenters takes less money, thus the $2 billion or so reduction in capital expenditures.
The Wal-Mart analysts meeting continues tomorrow in Arkansas. Tomorrow's meeting also is being webcast. We will be looking for any further comments regarding the "Small Mart" format developments, and will bring them to our readers here if they happen.
Monday, December 10, 2007
Monday Morning Java: Safeway Small Format Stores On the Way

Thursday, August 7, 2008
Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Does Wal-Mart Plan to Build A $10 Billion A Year 'Small-Mart' Empire?

Below is today's report from the Financial Times:
Wal-Mart sees Marketside as $10bn chain
From the: Financial Times
By Jonathan Birchall in New York
August 7, 2008
Wal-Mart, the world’s largest retailer, says the new small Marketside grocery stores it is to launch this autumn could expand to a chain of more than 1,000 stores, delivering $10bn-plus in annual sales.
The retailer plans to open 10 of the 15,000 sq ft Marketside stores initially, including four in the Phoenix area, where they will be competing directly with Tesco’s recently launched US Fresh & Easy store concept. Wal-Mart’s executives have described the Marketside stores as a pilot project, although it is the first new store format to be launched by the company in a decade. But a job advertisement for the retailer indicates the scale of its ambitions for Marketside, saying the format “is expected to start with 10 stores and evolve to between 1,000-1,500 stores with over $10bn annual sales."
At less than a 10th of the size of the average Wal-Mart superstore, Wal-Mart said the new stores would be aimed at “the needs of a time-starved, higher-income consumer that is interested in convenience and premium fresh, natural and organic offerings.”
The approach contrasts with Wal-Mart’s experience with the Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market stores it launched 10 years ago, which are about the size of a traditional US supermarket.
In response to an inquiry from the Financial Times, Wal-Mart stressed the Arizona stores were a pilot project. The retailer subsequently removed from its website the job advert that included the more ambitious targets.
Wal-Mart’s superstores are built around high volume and low cost, and the group has faced challenges in adapting to the supermarket-sized Neighborhood Market stores it launched in 1998, opening more than 140 outlets. The Marketside stores will require a fast turnover of stock, which could be a difficult fit with Wal-Mart’s distribution system.
Tesco has opened more than 60 Fresh & Easy stores in California, Arizona and Nevada since November and plans to have several hundred operating during the next two years.
Wal-Mart, the largest US grocer with more than 20 per cent of the market, is developing the Marketside format as growth slows at its 2,500-plus superstores.
The Marketside format is also expected to spearhead a broader drive by the retailer to improve its overall grocery offering.
Safeway and SuperValu, two of the largest US supermarket chains, are also experimenting with small, local formats.
Natural~Specialty Foods Memo Analysis
As our readers know, we've been covering Wal-Mart's Marketside format development closely as part of our extensive coverage of what we termed the small-format food and grocery retailing revolution in the U.S.
The Marketside stores, which will feature in-store, fresh prepared foods (and in-store seating for about 9-10 customers along with take out), specialty and natural foods and groceries, fresh meats and produce, along with a limited selection of basic grocery items, will average about 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet--which is a fraction of the size of its Supercenters, which are about 180,000 square feet on average, and less than half the size of its 45,000 square foot Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market supermarkets.
The format's focus will be on consumers who desire quality foods at reasonable prices. The first four Marketside stores are scheduled to open in the phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan region this fall.
We started covering the Marketside format development last year, and have broken numerous stories about its progress. During this more than one year coverage of the story, we've developed some very good sources.
We talked to a couple of our Wal-Mart sources today about the Financial Times report. One of those sources, who has been very good thus far, told us the mention of an eventual 1,000 store, $10 billion a year Marketside chain was on the job advertisement online board. However, the source says not to take it too seriously, not to think it means plans call for such a chain in the near future.
Rather, the source says its an internal long range goal number, and it didn't belong on the job board website, which is why it was taken down after the Financial Times reporter contacted the company about it.
This doesn't mean Wal-Mart doesn't plan to be aggressive with its Marketside format--just not 1,000 stores, $10 billion a year aggressive in the short to medium term.
As we've reported, Wal-Mart is looking for additional Marketside sights in Arizona, in addition to the four set to open this fall. The retailer also is looking throughout California and Nevada (Tesco Fresh & Easy country along with Arizona), as well as in other U.S. states.
Thus far we've reported for example that Wal-Mart is considering signing a lease for site in Reno, Nevada, along with in various particular California locations for the stores.
The current poor U.S. economy also has factored into Wal-Mart's planning for its Marketside small-format fresh food and grocery stores, according to our source. That source says because the stores will be more upscale in design and positioning--along with putting an emphasis on fresh, prepared foods--the retailer is exercising caution as it is well aware of the current consumer trend in the U.S. to trade down to discount food stores like its Wal-Mart Supercenters.
This fact isn't putting the brakes on Marketside. Rather, its providing a moderating theme to how fast the retailers grows the stores.
After all, there is no need to open Marketside stores in the way for example that Tesco is opening new Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores--about at a pace of one new store every three or four days on average--since Wal-Mart's strategy with Marketside is part of a multi format strategy while Tesco is engaged in a single format--Fresh & Easy--U.S. food and grocery retailing strategy.
Having said that, we are currently working on reporting about a couple possible Marketside store sites in California. We hope to write about just where those locations are soon. Like we said, Wal-Mart is taking a moderate, but still plenty aggressive, approach with its new, small-format Marketside retail development and format.
Thursday, August 30, 2007
Thursday Talking Points Memo

The Neighborhood Markets are complete supermarkets which offer a full selection of groceries and perishables, fresh meats and produce, non foods and all the other supermarket selections. The stores also have drive-through pharmacies and some have in-store restaurants as well.
Currently Wal-Mart as 118 Neighborhood Markets in the U.S. The stores merchandise about 28,000 items.
Neighborhood market history
Wal-Mart started off rather aggressively building Neighborhood Markets in the late 1990's to the early 2000's but has slowed down the pace considerably in the last several years. The format has been mildly successful--more successful in some regions and far less successful in others. Wal-Mart recognizes this fact, which is in part why they haven't been building very many new stores of late.
The Neighborhood Market is a small supermarket by today's standards. Wal-Mart designed it to be a niche format between their supercenters and their competitor's superstores. But the format really hasn't found itself. It's too big to be a true "convenience" format but too small in most cases to compete with the larger 65,000-90,000 square-foot new stores that most supermarket chains are building today.
Re-invigerating the Neighborhood Market format
This fact is partly why Wal-Mart is now looking at another new format, an approx. 10,000 square-foot upscale convenience-style store. It's also partly why the retailer continues to put its major focus on the supercenters which include a large supermarket in them. As such the Neighborhood Market is a relatively to not so successful format and its further development is receiving only minor attention from Wal-Mart.
This doesn't have to be the case for Wal-Mart and its Neighborhood Market format however. NSFM has an idea and positioning direction which we believe would not only re-invigerate the format at Wal-Mart but also allow the chain to express some of its more recent corporate and retail eithics and merchandising philosophies.
Format one would essentially be what the Neighborhood Market is today, with some additions and changes. First we suggest increasing the store footprint size. The current stores range from about 42,000 square-feet to about 55,000 square-feet. We would expand that to a range of about 55,000 square-feet (the smallest size) to a high-end size of about 80,000 square-feet. The smallest stores would be no smaller than 55,000 square-feet and the largest stores up to 80,000 square feet.
This increased store footprint is more in-line with what chain supermarket operators like Kroger, Safeway, Supervalu and others are building today. The larger stores would allow the Neighborhood Markets (format one) to better compete with these chains. With this larger footprint we suggest Wal-Mart expand the stores' produce departments, make an in-store eating place a standard feature, add an in-store cafe/coffee bar to all stores, make service meat and seafood a standard feature (along with self-service cases) and expand the stores' perishables offerings.
We also suggest they add more natural, organic and specialty groceries and integrate the items in these categories in-line with conventional and corporate/private label groceries throughout the core of the store.
Further, we suggest adding small but comprehensive health and wellness centers in each Neighborhood Market (format one). These centers would feature nurse practitioners who can provide minor medical treatment for a discount cost. They also would sell a complete selection of health products including vitamins, nutritional supplements, small medical equipment (especially for seniors) and related heath and wellness items.
This department can be tied-in with the format's current in-store pharmacies. The focus would be on health and wellness with minor medical care, professionals offering health advise and selling the products to supplement that advise. In addition to the upscale, convenience-style format Wal-Mart is currently developing the retailer also is developing a small footprint, stand-alone health and wellness stores Having the health and wellness departments in the Neighborhood Markets would create excellent synergies with the new stand-alone health and wellness stores once they are created and rolled out.
NSFM believes the changes and additions to the current Neighborhood Market format (format one) would dramatically improve the viability and shopping experience of the current and future Neighborhood Market stores
In our analysis we also think Wal-Mart might consider dropping the Wal-Mart name from the Neighborhood Markets. Instead of "Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market" the stores would simply be called "Neighborhood Market." This has a more community-oriented feel to it. It also takes the Wal-Mart brand off of what is designed to be an alternative to big box shopping which most consumers associate with Wal-Mart. We aren't 100 percent convinced this is needed at his point but strongly believe it should be seriously considered.
Format Two: A second Neighborhood Market format
It's format two though that has NSFM excited, and we believe offers excellent potential for Wal-Mart to re-invigerate and make successful its Neighborhood Market format.
Neighborhood Market format two is a medium-size footprint natural and organic products "category killer" grocery store. NSFM suggests Wal-Mart take the basic Neighborhood Market store footprint and shrink it a bit for the new format. The stores would be about 35,000 square-feet. They would feature a complete selection of natural and organic groceries, produce, meats and seafood, and perishables. The stores also would have an extensive selection of natural and organic nutritional supplements, skin care products and non-foods. A combination in-store restaurant/cafe/smoothie-type bar would be part of the format. A good way to look at the format is Whole Foods (with a few differences and limitations) in a smaller box.
The format's focus (or mission statement) would be "Natural and Organic Foods For Less" or something similar. The format would be a "category killer" for these products, beating Whole Foods and other natural foods stores and supermarkets significantly on the retail price points of organic groceries, perishables and non-foods.
The stores could be built in such a "less frills" but still upscale way as to keep operating costs down. And with Wal-Mart's buying, distribution and logistics systemt he chain would be able to beat the best retails currently out there while still making decent margins. After all being the price leader is Wal-Mart's strategy in terms of dramatically increasing its natural and organic product offerings in its supercenters.
The stores need to be upscale and attractive but also have the look of a "lower frills" retailer at the same time. This is important for the "category killer" positioning. A too upscale store suggests higher prices. However, a too bare-bones store isn't inviting and would discourage shoppers, as well as not keeping them in the store for as long a period of time as possible which is key for impulse buying.
The chain also can build the stores in such an environmentally sound manner that things likes energy use will be dramatically reduced compared to a typical supermarket. For example, lots of use of skylights for lighting, ceiling fans, top-grade insulation and other green building and energy-reducing principles. This is good for the stores positioning in addition to cost-reduction as environmentalism will be a big part of the format's draw along with it natural and organic product offerings.
This Neighborhood Market natural foods "category killer" format will need a name. And the Wal-Mart brand name should not be part of it. The name must evoke natural products retailing as does Whole Foods, Wild Oats or Supervalu's Sunflower Market stores. In fact Supervalu's Sunflower Market format is somewhat a model for what we are calling Wal-Mart's Neighborhood Market format two. There are major qualitative differences between our concept for Wal-Mart and the current Sunflower Market format however. Chief among these differences is size. Sunflower Market stores are only 15,000 square-feet. (See Tuesday's Talking Points Memo for a discussion about Sunflower Market.)
Why the category killer format will work
Why do we think this format would work for Wal-Mart? There are 4 basic reasons. First, the natural and organic products categories are moving from a niche market to a near-mainstream one. They aren't there yet but moving in that direction fairly rapidly. Wal-Mart knows this which is why they have launched a major natural and organic grocery initiative in their supercenters. Kroger Co., Safeway Stores and other retail chains, including Target, know this as well.
Second, Wal-Mart needs a way to re-invigerate its Neighborhood Market format as well as to be able to break out of its big box format in order to serve regions and neighborhoods where community members do not want--and fight against--supercenter stores. Format two allows for both these things in conjunction with our first point above.
Third, the natural and organic categories allow for higher margins even if the products are sold for a discount provided the retailer has the buying and logistics systems to make it work, which Wal-Mart does. The "category killer" natural foods stores for example can sell organics at substantially lower retails than Whole Foods or supermarkets can and do and Wal-Mart can still make a higher overall gross margin in these stores than they can make selling conventional groceries in a supercenter. (I'm not suggesting the gross sales between the two would be anything close to similar, merely that the margins would be higher on albeit significantly lower overall volume in the natural foods format stores vs. the supercenters.)
The last reason is "first-mover advantage." It might be in five years, ten years or perhaps a little longer, but a retail chain (or even a start up) is going to launch a "category killer" retail format focused on the natural and organic categories. We've seen this with specialty and gourmet foods, wine, beer and spirits and other categories. The natural and organic category is ripe for the picking at retail for this--and getting riper. (NSFM believes it will be closer to five years or less rather than ten for a "category killer" natural and organic foods retail format to emerge and begin to position its stores nationally on a selective basis.)
With it's buying and logistics advantages, corporate philosophy embracing natural and organic products along with environmentalism and sustainability--and its need to break out of the big retail box--Wal-Mart might just be the perfect candidate to be first in creating this "category killer" natural foods store Neighborhood Market format.
The existing retailer or start up that decides to become the "first mover" in this category in a significant way is going to have all the advantages. NSFM thinks it is worth further analysis, study, thinking and discussion by Wal-Mart.
Thursday, November 20, 2008
Retail Memo: Here Comes Wal-Mart USA -- Again and Again and Again

Eduardo Castro-Wright, CEO of Wal-Mart USA, was feeling his retailing oats a bit on Tuesday at the Morgan Stanley retail conference in New York City. He also made news at the conference, which is something Castro-Wright seems to enjoy doing despite Wal-Mart's generally tight-lipped culture. Tuesday's Morgan Stanley retail conference was broadcast over the Internet.
"I've read and heard most of the (retail) industry is struggling," Castro-Wright said to a few laughs from attendees during his presentation at yesterday's retail conference.
"But Wal-Mart is seeing positive trends," the head of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s North American operations told analysts and others attending his presentation . "Customers now are shopping more frequently (primarily because of cheaper gasoline) and there hasn't been a significant change in how much they spend during each visit," he said.
Earlier this month Wal-Mart reported a nearly 10% rise in quarterly profits as consumers appear to have flocked to the discounter's stores. This despite the severe economic recession, and despite the fact other combination grocery and general merchandise mass merchandise retailers like Target and Costco are struggling. Target Corp reported a near-24% drop in income on Tuesday and Costco reported a 1% quarterly loss a couple weeks ago.
Holiday food and grocery price reductions every week
Castro Wright said Wal-Mart is rolling back prices on many food and grocery items for the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays, meaning numerous (particularly holiday-related and staple items) grocery prices in all of the retailer's stores beginning this week are even lower overall than they were last week, he said. The rollbacks will remain in place for the Christmas holidays as well, Castro-Wright said.
In addition, every week between now and Christmas Wal-Mart will do additional price rollbacks on food, grocery, general merchandise and holiday-oriented items and products, Castro-Wright said.
Addressing the current cutback in consumer spending across the board in the U.S., including on food and groceries, the Wal-Mart USA CEO said: "The consumer will spend when you have the right prices and offerings. So with Christmas coming, I thought I would give you a little confidence."
More new formats
Eduardo Castro-Wright also talked about Wal-Mart's expansion in the U.S. for the company's 2009 (current) and 2010 fiscal years at yesterday's Morgan Stanley retail conference.Breaking a little news he said the mega-retailer is currently working on developing a new "high efficiency" retail format that would have higher sales per square foot than some of its current stores. According to our sources this is a smaller version of the Supercenter.
The executive said Wal-Mart also is looking at using smaller-sized stores to enter markets where it does not have a presence today, this includes its new 100,000 square foot smaller Sam's Club prototype store it's been testing, along with its new small-format Marketside fresh foods and grocery stores (four open so far in the Phoenix, Arizona region as we've reported), its 43,000 square foot Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market supermarkets, and its new hybrid Wal-Mart Supercenters, the first of which opened in Modesto, California last week.
We've been suggesting most of this year that Wal-Mart will use its new small-format Marketside and other new, smaller-format stores to penetrate market regions such as the San Francisco Bay Area in California, as well as urban regions in the state like Los Angeles and San Diego, where it has little opportunity to locate mega-Supercenters because of both geographical limitations and objections by city governments and community groups to the giant stores.
At about 100,000 square feet that Supercenters, which is in a remodeled vacant retail building, is about 80,000 square feet smaller than the average-size Wal-Mart Supercenter. It's "hybrid" because it's in a formerly vacant building rather than being built from the ground up which is what Wal-Mart historically does with its Supercenters. Despite the smaller size the Modesto hybrid Supercenter has a full supermarket inside, offering a complete assortment of fresh foods and groceries. About 40,000 square feet of the total 100,000 square feet of the store is devoted to food and grocery items. The remaining 60,000 square feet contains general merchandise products just like a larger Supercenter.
Adding food and grocery items to Walmart.com
Castro-Wright didn't address it during the conference on Tuesday but Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has noticed Wal-Mart has listed thousands of food, grocery and non-foods items on its Walmart.com Web site, indicating the retailer will soon be offering food and groceries at its online store, along with all of the other products it sells there.
There are no prices on the food and grocery items at Walmart.com as of yet. However we're told by a good source the prices are coming soon. Our source also tells us Wal-Mart will ship the items via UPS and Federal Express, just like it ships all of the general merchandise products it sells via its Web site. Amazon.com sells a huge selection of food, grocery and beverage products on its Web site, and ships them via these same carriers as well, for example.
Add another national format -- actually more of a product line extension to Walmart.com -- to the mega-retailers multi-format food and grocery retailing empire: online grocery retailing. Its cheap -- no stores, cheaper marketing costs and the like -- and its national. More importantly it will provide Wal-Mart with yet another niche or piece of the multi-format puzzle in its all out battle to dominate food and grocery retailing in the U.S., where it now is the national market share leader.
Hundreds of new U.S. stores in FY 2009 and FY 2010
The Wal-Mart USA CEO also said on Tuesday that despite the fact the company has cut back the number of new stores across all formats it plans to open in the U.S. in its 2009 (current) and 2010 fiscal years, it doesn't mean the retailer plans to be merely playing around the edges in terms of new store openings.
In fiscal year 2009 (the current fiscal year) Wal-Mart plans to launch 191 new stores of various formats -- Supercenters, Sam's Club stores, Neighborhood Market supermarkets, Marketside small-format food stores and others -- according to Castro-Wright. That compares to the 218 new units Wal-Mart opened last fiscal year (2008).
In fiscal year 2010, Castro-Wright said Wal-Mart will launch between 142 -to- 157 new units in the U.S.
Considering the size of most of the Wal-Mart format stores, particularly Supercenters and Sam's Club stores, that's still a whole lots of retail square footage for the 2009 and 2010 fiscal years. Additionally, that's a whole lot of new square footage in what many say is a mature retail market, the United States.
Castro-Wright said Wal-Mart would focus the majority of these new stores on what he called 15 "opportunity markets" in the U.S. that the retailer has identified and says account for nearly 40% of total retail sales. He didn't detail these 15 regions on Tuesday. However, we are working on our sources to find out the 15 market regions and will report the information when we get it.
Monday, January 7, 2008
Retail Memo: The International Small Store Format Revolution Marches On
lar readers are aware, we've been reporting on, writing about, and offering analysis on the international small format food retailing revolution for the last 4-5 months.Friday, November 21, 2008
Retail Memo: Wal-Mart CEO Steps Down; Head of International Operations Mike Duke to Lead Retail Giant; USA Chief Castro-Wright Promoted
In a move today that took nearly everybody by surprise, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. replaced CEO Lee Scott with Mike Duke (pictured at left), the head of the mega-retailer's international operations. Duke will take over as CEO of Wal-Mart in February, 2009. Wal-Mart's investors responded to Duke's appointment by sending the stock up $2.26, or 4.5%, to $52.92 on Friday. The consensus among analysts is that Duke is a good retailer and deserved the CEO's job.Duke, a former department store executive, only joined Wal-Mart in 1995. he was named to head the company's international division in 2005, making his three year rise from that key position to CEO a meteoric one. Prior to joining Wal-Mart, Duke's 23-year retail career included work for Federated Department Stores and May Department Stores.
When he joined Wal-Mart in 1995 Duke first led the company's logistics divisions and U.S. Wal-Mart stores before being named international chief in 2005.
Wal-Mart also today promoted the CEO of its Wal-Mart USA operations, 53-year-old Eduardo Castro-Wright, to vice chairman of the corporation, effective immediately. He's slated to take on additional responsibility in global procurement.
The announcement paved the way for what some say is his eventual ascension to the top job at Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Many believe Castro-Wright, who is considered an extremely excellent retailer, is ready now to be CEO. However, his promotion is a pretty clear sign he's next in line for the position if he wants it whenever Mike Duke leaves. Duke held the same vice chairman position Castro-Wright was just promoted to, as did Lee Scott, before being named CEO. Duke and Scott were responsible for different aspects of Wal-Mart's business though as vice chairman.
Current CEO Lee Scott, who has worked at Wal-Mart for three decades and served as CEO for the last nine years, isn't going away anytime soon though. He will continue as chairman of the executive committee of the board and as an adviser to Mike Duke through January 2011, Wal-Mart spokesman David Tovar said today.
The timing of the announcement caught most people in the retail industry and on Wall Street by surprise. Changes at the top for huge corporations like Wal-Mart generally don't come towards the end of the year or before the holiday season. Additionally, such changes are usually made at the beginning of a major corporation's fiscal year, which isn't the current case at Wal-Mart.
"Lee (CEO Scott) decided the time was right for him to retire and approached the board about doing so," Tovar said. "The board has an ongoing and rigorous succession plan process. We think the right time is now. It's a time of strength for us."
Wal-Mart didn't name a successor to Mike Duke today as part of the changes at the top for the world's largest corporation and retailer. Duke is Wal-Mart's most senior international executive, which is a key post. Some are suggesting the fact a replacement wasn't named today for Duke could mean Wal-Mart might make an outside hire to replace Duke for its most senior global executive position.
Lee Scott's nine years as the head of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. has been overall a very successful tenure.
Under Scott's leadership, Wal-Mart has put a relentless strategic and operational focus on value that has clicked with shoppers facing myriad economic concerns. He has also put a major emphasis on revamping merchandise assortment, improved store layouts and shored up Wal-Mart's environmental and labor image, positioning the chain as a Wall Street darling after a prior streak of criticism by the media, labor and environmental groups. Wal-Mart currently is the only company on the Dow Jones listing that's up for the year, for example.
Additionally, Wal-Mart has also become the number one seller of food and grocery products in the United States in terms of overall national market share. Prior to Scott's taking the helm as CEO nine years ago Wal-Mart wasn't even close to achieving that distinction.
As CEO Lee Scott launched a massive new store opening program in the U.S. and internationally, focusing mostly on the retailer's mega-Supercenters and Sam's Club warehouse format club stores, but also on its discount stores and Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market supermarkets.
The CEO also has led an aggressive new format development program at Wal-Mart. All of the new Wal-Mart formats in the United States for example -- the small-format Marketside grocery and fresh foods stores; the "Community Market" Hispanic prototype store, the first of which opened in Texas earlier this year, the new smaller (100,000 square feet) Sam's Club prototype; the new Supercenter prototype design, and the new hybrid, smaller Supercenter located in vacant buildings (the first one, at 100,000 square feet located in a former big box supermarket building, opened in Modesto, California on November 12 -- have one basic thing in common: They all offer lots fresh foods and groceries for sale in them.
That all these new formats sell food and groceries as a primary or key feature isn't an accident. What likely could be seen historically as one of the two most important contributions Scott has made during his nine year run as CEO at Wal-Mart could very well be his decision to put the retailer on the path to becoming the dominant seller of food and grocery products in the United States -- and eventually the world. In fact it's this ficus on consumables that most analysts attribute to Wal-Mart's current success in the U.S. and globally during the severe economic recession and financial meltdown.
Scott's relentless pursuit of consumers' food and grocery dollars also led to a decision earlier this year at Wal-Mart USA to start converting scores of its Wal-Mart discount format stores throughout the U.S. in hybrid Supercenters by adding 15,000 -to- 50,000 (depending on the available space) square feet to the discount stores, all of it and then some being devoted to consumables, including fresh produce and meats.
Most of these ideas and concepts for the U.S. came from Eduardo Castro-Wright, who yesterday was the CEO of Wal-Mart USA and today is the company's new vice chairman. However Lee Scott gets CEO credit just like he gets faulted for the negatives, as it should be.
Lee Scott's other major historic contribution has been push as CEO to make Wal-Mart an even bigger global retailer than it was when he took over the head office eleven years ago.
Under Scott's leadership Wal-Mart acquired the Asda chain in the United Kingdom, making it that nation's second-largest retailer after Tesco.
The company grew business in Latin and Central America dramatically.He did a joint venture deal bringing Wal-Mart into India, which has the world's second-fastest growing economy after China.
Scott grew Wal-Mart-China in a huge way, even saying it will someday in the not too distant future become the retailer's largest market, eventually surpassing the United States in terms of sales.
Most recently Scott inked a deal to bring Wal-Mart stores to Russia, which also has one of the world's fastest-growing economies, although that growth has slowed considerably since oil dropped from $142 per-barrel to $50 a barrel in just the last couple months. But it will rise once again -- the price of oil that is.
By naming Mike Duke, the head of its global business, as the new CEO, Wal-Mart is clearly sending a message that it plans on becoming an even bigger international retailer. The retailer's international division, which Duke heads, accounts for more than a quarter of Wal-Mart's $400 billion in annual sales. The company's future growth is globally. Although there's still room to grow sales in the U.S., it's the retailer's most mature market and pales in comparison to the opportunities internationally.
During his tenure as head of international operations, Duke had some hits, but also some big misses. For example, In 2006, Wal-Mart withdrew from Germany and Korea, two big setbacks for the company. And despite taking control of its Japanese business in 2007, Wal-Mart continues to struggle there.
Successes though include Brazil, which has experienced phenomenal growth and serves as a model for Latin America, and India, where Wal-Mart scored a coup by forming a partnership with Bharti Enterprises to expand in that country despite local opposition from mom-and-pop retailers. Add China to the list as well.
And Asda in the United Kingdom is doing extremely well despite that country's economic recession and its position as a distant number two to Tesco. Tesco has a 31% UK market share to Asda's about 17% share. But Asda has consolidated its lead over number three Sainsbury's, which was neck-to-neck with Wal-Mart-owned Asda just two years ago for number two, but now has about a 14.5% share to Asda's about 17%.
Beginning next year when he takes over Mike Duke will have a much different political agenda to contend with as CEO than Lee Scott did during the last eight years of the Republican Bush Administration. With a new Democratic President, Barack Obama, and a Democratic majority in both the U.S. house of Representatives and U.S. Senate, issues such as unionization, which Wal-Mart has been able to keep at bay, are going to become much more pressing for the company -- and for the new CEO.
If organized labor can get the Employee Free Choice Act passed, a provision of which ("quick check") allows workers to merely check a box if they want to be represented by a union rather than going through the current and sometimes elaborate secret ballot voting process, it will make it much easier for unions like the United Food & Commercial Workers (UFCW) to organize store-level Wal-Mart employees, something the union has failed to do for decades. President-Elect Obama and a majority of House and Senate Democrats support the Employee Free Choice Act. Therefore its prospects for passage in 2009 currently look strong.
New CEO Duke also will have some political fences to mend globally; fences he has yet to mend as head of Wal-Mart's international operations.
For example, in September, Mexico's Supreme Court chastised Wal-Mart for paying employees partially in vouchers that could only be used at company stores. The court compared Wal-Mart to the Mexican dictator Porfirio Diaz, who ruled the country from the late 1880s to 1911.
Wal-Mart is now Mexico's number one retailer of food and grocery products. As such it can't afford to get on the wrong side of the government.
Other global issues include its Asda chain in the United Kingdom. That nation's top three retailers -- Tesco, Wal-Mart's Asda and Sainsbury's -- have been involved in a multi-year battle with the British government involving charges of anti-competition and price fixing. Earlier this year Asda CEO Andy Bond directed executives of the chain to cooperate with British government authorities against competing chains in return for a promise that the retailer wouldn't be prosecuted or fined. The issue is still taking shape but Asda isn't completely in the clear yet either.
It will be extremely interesting to see who Wal-Mart names to replace Mike Duke in the key position of head of international operations.
Additionally, with Eduardo Castro-Wright moving from CEO of Wal-Mart USA to his new position as vice chairman of Wal-Mart, that opens up the key position of head of U.S. retailing, which remains Wal-Mart's single-largest division in terms of annual gross sales.
We will be watching this closely because since so much of Wal-Mart USA's strategy is focused on selling consumables, and developing new formats that feature food and grocery products, we would expect a person with a food and grocery retailing background perhaps to assume Castro-Wright's position.
Of course that's far from a given since Wal-Mart is fairly deep with food and grocery sector talent below the USA CEO position. However, naming a person with extensive food and grocery retailing experience, either from inside or from outside Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., would send a strong signal that Wal-Mart is even more serious than ever before about becoming the dominant force in food and grocery retailing in the U.S.
[Photo Credit: Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.]
Friday, October 19, 2007
Friday Feature
Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets stores have been all over the media in the past few months, including here at Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM). Far less attention and coverage (virtually none really) has been given to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania-based Giant Eagle, Inc.'s new Giant Eagle Express store format and its first (and currently only) store which opened in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania in May of this year. The Giant Eagle Express stores are a hybrid, upscale neighborhood grocery and convenience store. Sound familiar? The Pittsburgh store which opened in May is about 13,000 square-feet and features a large, fresh prepared foods selection, basic and specialty groceries, fresh meats, fresh produce and in-store service deli and bakery departments featuring upscale offerings.
The prototype express store also has an in-store cafe with free wireless internet service, a drive-through pharmacy and an automobile fuel service area outside, branded with the GetGo gas banner, and physically separated a bit from the Express market.