Showing posts sorted by relevance for query whole foods express stores. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query whole foods express stores. Sort by date Show all posts

Saturday, September 13, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Not Technically 'Small-Format' But Whole Foods Market, Inc. is Going 'Smaller'


Small-Format Food Retailing Special Report

Amid a sluggish economy and slowing sales growth, Whole Foods Market Inc. is scaling down the size of new stores as the company finds massive grocery stores in most markets can't be justified.

The Austin, Texas, natural and organic grocer now plans to target new stores sized between 35,000 -to- 50,000 square feet, more than 20% smaller than what the company identified a year ago as its "sweet spot" amid successes with some large locations. The company is also renegotiating leases at several stores for smaller spaces than originally signed.

The size reduction by Whole Foods doesn't now make it a charter member of what we've coined as the small-format food retailing revolution going on in the USA. Instead it puts Whole Foods' stores right about in the middle in terms of the current average size of new supermarkets being built in the U.S.

For example, supermarket chains such as Safeway Stores, SuperValu, Inc., Kroger and most others are building new supermarkets that average about 45,000 -to- 60,000 square feet on the one end. Others such as regional players Wegmans (eastern U.S.) and HEB (Texas) have been building mega-supermarkets of about 100,000 square feet, at the other end. Then you have the small-format stores from Tesco (Fresh & Easy), Safeway (The Market) and Wal-Mart's soon to open Marketside, all which average from 10,000 -to- 20,000 square feet.

At its new "sweet spot" of 35,000 -to- 50,000 square foot stores, Whole Foods actually returns to its roots of the 1990's, when that was the size stores the natural grocer was focusing on. In the late 1990's to the present, Whole Foods went mega, opening numerous stores in the 70,000 -to- nearly 80,000 square foot range.

Smaller stores come with a host of lower fixed costs for rents and utilities, and also require fewer employees to run. That can help bolster key profitability metrics like sales-per-square-foot and sales-per-employee and improve the company's return on invested capital.

The smaller format was on display last week when Whole Foods opened its latest location in Richmond, Va. With 45,000 square feet of selling space, the store is smaller than most new ones open in recent years. But the store has mostly the same merchandise as larger stores, which should equate to comparable sales at lower costs.

It was also without any sit-down eateries that have driven up development and operating costs at some other stores. A Whole Foods in Fairfax, Va., for example, has four in-house restaurants including a barbecue joint called the Smokehouse.

The smaller Richmond store, meanwhile, has barbecue dishes available for self- service in addition to a hot food and salad bar, brick-oven pizza and a wine bar and cafe.

The moves for smaller locations come as Whole Foods is exhibiting signs that even the wealthiest consumers are cutting back on their consumption. Same-store sales rose just 2.6% at Whole Foods locations open at least a year, a far cry from the double-digit gains the food retailer enjoyed just a few years back.

Strong sales growth led to seemingly unmitigated growth by the chain, and store sizes followed suit. In 2005, Whole Foods opened its largest location, an 80,000-square-foot store in its Austin backyard that the company calls " enormously successful," and started to steadily increase the size of new locations.

But those larger format stores failed to live up to the performance of its Austin location and those in other dense, urban environments like New York. "

To be sure, Whole Foods, whose 270 stores average roughly 35,500 square feet, has continued to sign leases and open locations similar to its traditional layout and size. But the consumer spending slump has caused the company to rethink its development strategy, and retrench to store sizes from the past.

"With hindsight, reflection and some data points in front of us, we see that the really large stores are very powerful in limited markets and circumstances, and that smaller stores can also produce great returns for us," Chief Executive John Mackey said in an earnings call with food retailing analysts and media last month.

The real estate strategy is one of several moves Whole Foods is using to get back on track after its shares have lost more than half their value this year. The company has recently tried to emphasize value by offering more discounts and incorporating a value message into its marketing.

It is also planning on cutting back on new stores altogether, lowering its fiscal 2009 target to 15 new stores, down from a prior estimate of 25 to 30, as we reported previously.

Whole Foods also recently fired 42 headquarters employees as a cost savings measure.

As we've reported previously in Natural~Specialty Foods Memo, Whole Foods has had plans to open the first of its small-format Whole Foods Express concept stores in a former Wild Oats natural foods store building in Boulder, Colorado.

Initial plans called for that first Whole Foods Express store--which is designed to average 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet and offer a limited assortment of natural and organic grocery items and feature fresh foods, such as produce and ready-to-eat and ready-to-heat prepared foods--to open this fall. However, as we previously reported, Whole Foods has been unable to agree on a new lease with the building's landlord at the Boulder site, which currently is still being operated as a Wild Oats banner store, so it has yet to start converting the building into the Whole Foods Express prototype store.

In fact, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has now learned the Whole Foods Express concept is under review, as nearly everything at Whole Foods is, because of the supernatural grocer's significant drop in profits in the last quarter, which has resulted in the new strategies discussed in this piece, along with others.

Building and operating smaller stores isn't anything new for Whole Foods. In fact one of the chain's best-performing stores from a sales per-square-foot perspective is it 14,000 square foot store at 414 Miller Avenue in Mill Valley, in Marin County in the San Francisco Bay Area. That store averages between $500,000 -to-$600,000 a week in gross sales, according to sources in a position to know.

The Mill Valley store is where Whole Foods' co-president Walter Robb got his start. He opened the store in the early 1990's as the store manager, using his success with the Mill Valley store to move on to President of the Northern California Division and then eventually into his current position.

Additionally, the majority of the stores Wild Oats stores Whole Foods acquired in the merger last year are no bigger than 35,000 square feet, many being much smaller than that.

Whole Foods currently has plans to build some new stores even smaller than its new "sweet spot" size of between 35,000 -to- 50,000 square feet. These include two stores in San Francisco, one in the city's Noe Valley neighborhood and the other in the famous Haight-Ashbury district. Both of these stores are in the 17,000 -to- 20,000 square foot range. Another new store in development in Capitola, which is in Northern California's coastal region, also is smaller than 30,000 square feet.

We generally define a small-format food store as from 10,000 -to- 20,000 square feet in size, as do most others. The two San Francisco Whole Foods stores in development listed above fit that small-format definition. The Capitola store comes very close.

These however aren't specifically designed small-format stores like the Whole Foods Express prototype is. Therefore, it's our analysis that Whole Foods should move forward with its Express format.

If it can't open the first store in Boulder because of the lease problems that's fine. There still are numerous places where it makes even better sense to open one of the stores, particularly in an urban location where such a store makes much more sense for Whole Foods than it does to do so in Boulder, where the decision to do so was based largely on the fact that after acquiring Boulder-based Wild Oats, Whole Foods found itself overstored in the city of Boulder.

However, it pledged not to close any of the stores in the city that was home to Wild Oats. Therefore the natural grocer decided to turn one of the former Wild Oats stores into the Whole Foods Express as a way to differentiate the Whole Foods brand in the now overstored city.

We suggest opening a Whole Foods Express store in San Francisco or New York as a first test. It makes good sense to do from numerous perspectives, including geography, density, cost, maximization of sales per-square-feet, and more.

Feel free to agree, disagree and offer your perspective by clicking the comment link below.

Monday, June 23, 2008

Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s Plans For its First of the Format 'Whole Foods Express' Small-Format Market in Boulder, Colorado On Hold


Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s plans to convert the Wild Oats natural foods market at 2584 Baseline Road in Boulder, Colorado, Wild Oats' former corporate headquarters town, into the first store of its Whole Foods Express small-format, fresh foods-centric natural and organic foods format store has been put on hold, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has learned.

As we reported last year and updated throughout this year, Whole Foods' has planned to have the Whole Foods Express market in the converted Wild Oats' store open by the end of this year, possibly as early as late summer. However, the lease on the Wild Oats market building is coming due, and Whole Foods is currently in negotiations with the landlord of the building, which is located in Boulder's Basemar Shopping Center, over the terms of a lease extension, according to Will Paradise, Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s Rocky Mountain region president.

A spokesperson for the landlord would only say the lease discussions are ongoing and that no agreement has been reached as of yet.

When Whole Foods acquired Boulder-based Wild Oats Markets, Inc. last year, it inherited a number of Wild Oats banner and owned natural foods markets in the hometown city. These stores include: A Wild Oats store at 1651 Broadway; a Wild Oats Natural Foods Marketplace (a larger store) at 303 Marshall Road in nearby Superior, Colorado; the Wild Oats banner store at 2584 Baseline in the Basemar Shopping Center (the one set to be turned into the Whole Foods Express store); and Ideal Market (at 1275 Alpine Avenue), a Wild Oats'-owned store it bought from a local independent many years ago but retained the name because the store and the store name have historic significance in Boulder.

Whole Foods is currently remodeling Ideal Market, and will keep the name, according to Paradise. The remodeled historic boulder store is set to open in August, paradise says.

The supernatural foods retailer converted the larger former Wild Oats Natural Marketplace store into a Whole Foods Market banner store in January.

Another project coming up in Boulder is to remodel the Wild Oats store at 1651 Broadway. Whole Foods has a unique plan for this store, which is to completely remodel it and rename it Alfalfa's, which was the popular Boulder-based natural foods store chain Wild Oats acquired in the late 1990's, according to Rocky Mountain region president Will Paradise. Wild Oats renamed all the Alfalfa's stores Wild Oats.

It's doubtful Whole Foods is attempting to create a new national, or even regional, banner by bringing back the Alfalfa's name, although they might use it to a limited extent elsewhere in the Rocky Mountain region.

Rather, Whole Foods has approached the Rocky Mountain region, and especially Wild Oats' hometown of Boulder, Colorado, in a unique way because of its history of being where the no longer Wild Oats Markets, Inc. was founded, along with the fact Whole Foods inherited numerous stores in the city.

Prior to the Wild Oats acquisition-merger, Whole Foods had only one Whole Foods Market in Boulder. That store, which is located on Pearl Street in the city, still remains open along with the others mentioned above. Whole Foods has plans to enlarge and remodel that store as well. Plans are to have the project completed by late 2010 or early 2111, according to Paradise.

Meanwhile, with the lease negotiations for the Wild Oats building, which is set to be converted to the first of the format Whole Foods Express, still in progress, it appears the conversion of the store into the new fresh, prepared foods-focused 15,000 -to- 20,000 square foot natural and organic small-format food store is in limbo at present.

Since Whole Foods has had problems arriving at the lease extension terms with the landlord thus far, the retailer has yet to begin converting and remodeling the store to the Whole Foods Express format. Therefore, it's unlikely that even if the parties agreed on the terms of a lease extension this week, it would be possible for Whole Foods to open the Express store this year.

The supernatural foods retailer hasn't given up on or shelved the Whole Foods Express format though, according to Paradise. Rather, it's a lease extension issue on the Wild oats store building, not a format issue.

Converting the store into the Express format though is key to Whole Foods' Boulder strategy, which is to have two Whole Foods banner stores, one Alfalfa's (which will have some format differences as well), one Ideal Market (which is a bit different format than a Whole Foods market), and the Whole Foods Express small-format combination fresh, prepared foods and natural foods market.

If the lease negotiations fall through, it's likely Whole Foods would close the Basemar Shopping Center Wild Oats banner store.

The conversion of the Basemar Shopping Center store also is important in that it will be Whole Foods' first Whole Foods Express format store and thus a model for any others the retailer might want to open in other parts of the U.S.

It also would spell Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s introduction into what Natural~Specialty Foods Memo calls the small-format food retailing revolution currently going on in the U.S. and internationally--with players like Trader Joe's, Tesco's Fresh & Easy, Aldi, SuperValu's Sav-A-Lot, Safeway's "The Market" format and numerous others all leading the charge in America.

We will report on any new developments regarding the lease negotiations between Whole Foods Market, Inc. Rocky Mountain region and the Basemar Shopping center Wild Oats store's landlord as information becomes available. At present though, it's our best analysis that it's unlikely the Whole Foods Express store will be able to open at the Boulder location this year.

Friday, March 14, 2008

Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market to Dramatically Expand in the United Kingdom; Will Open Up To 30 New Stores in the U.S. in Fiscal 2009


Austin, Texas-based supernatural and lifestyle grocer Whole Foods Market, Inc. plans to expand from its current one store in London, England under the Whole Foods' banner, to additional stores in the London Metropolitan region and elsewhere in the United Kingdom.

In addition to its current 75,000 square foot Whole Foods Kensington High Street flagship store in London, Whole Foods Market, Inc. owns the small natural and organic foods' chain Fresh & Wild, which it acquired from its British owners about four years ago. The Fresh & Wild natural and organic foods' markets are located in and around London.

At the time of the Fresh & Wild acquisition, Whole Foods' CEO John Mackey said the grocer was buying the British-born natural foods chain in part as a stalking horse, in that it would provide a base of business in the UK so that Whole Foods could eventually start opening larger stores under its Whole Foods banner. Mackey also said then, and repeated recently, that most if not all of the grocer's new stores in the UK would be under the Whole Foods banner rather than Fresh & Wild.

The grocer started doing just that almost a year ago when it opened its first Texas-sized (75-k square foot) Whole Foods Market in London. The London flagship store got off to a bit of a slow start. However, business has picked up dramatically over the last couple months.

We've now learned Whole Foods has hired a two commercial retail agencies in London to search for new store sites in the London Metropolitan area and beyond in other parts of the UK.

Those two agencies, Green & Partners and Gilbert, have been given marching orders from the grocer's Austin, Texas corporate headquarters to look for potential store sites of between 20,000 square feet -to 75,000 square feet within an hour or so drive from central London as the top priority, and elsewhere in the UK as the secondary priority. Twenty thousand square feet is considered a very decent-sized supermarket in London. Seventy five thousand square feet--the size of the grocer's flagship store in London--is considered a massive supermarket in the region.

Whole Foods has taken a further step, which demonstrates the grocer is serious about its UK expansion. That step is the hiring of Nina Shores, who is the former retail property director for British retailer Bank Fashion, to head up the supernatural grocer's UK expansion program.

Additionally, during a recent trip to the store in London, numerous store-level employees mentioned to us they were aware that Whole Foods' is looking for sites throughout the UK. One store team member said he was thinking about quiting because of a lack of advancement opportunities at the single store. However, he said he was told by a higher up not to worry because the grocer was going to be opening many stores in the next few years, and that there would be multiple opportunities soon.

Whole Foods' target customer in the UK is similar to its target shopper at home in the U.S. College educated, and post undergraduate degree-holders, are key. Upper income is a key demographic as well. Additionally, ethical consumers, "greens" and health conscious shoppers round out Whole Foods' key variables when looking for neighborhoods to locate it new United Kingdom stores in.

There are plenty such neighborhoods within a one hour's drive of central London. And many more throughout the United Kingdom. Further, London is arguably the current global capital of ethical and green or sustainable consumerism, which fits Whole Foods' retailing and merchandising philosophy extremely well.

UK upscale supermarket chains Waitrose and the Co-op (and Sainsbury's in part) are currently the primary grocers of choice for London Metro region consumers who fit the Whole Foods' demographic profile.

And, of course, there are the Whole Foods'-owned Fresh & Wild stores already in the area. Those stores are much smaller than a typical Whole Foods' banner store, and as a result carry a much smaller selection of natural and organic products. They also don't have the extensive in-store prepared foods venues and other special lifestyle features that a 45,000 -to- 80,000 square foot Whole Foods' banner store does. They do have a nickname similar to Whole Foods' "Whole Paycheck" in the U.S. though. The British wags call the stores "Fresh & Wildly Expensive."

Our UK industry sources have told us a number of sites in Metro London and elsewhere in the UK have been rumoured to be high on the short list of possible locations for new Whole Foods' banner stores. These potential sites include: numerous locations in the city of London, the dockland banking district's Canary Wharf, Manchester, Bristol and Edinburgh.

We, nor do our UK sources, know the number of Whole Foods' banner stores the grocer wants to open in the United Kingdom. What we do know though is Whole Foods Market, Inc. knows it needs a critical mass of stores in the region in order to do its brand of merchandising and promotion. As such, we believe the supernatural retailer will embark on a multi-year new store development program in the UK--beginning first with opening new stores and filling out in the London Metropolitan region.

Along with that strategy, we see the grocer opening stores at the same time--but at just a slightly slower pace--in key parts of the UK that fit its education, income, environmental and ethical consumer demographic variables best. In other words, the UK is no longer a mere retail test for Whole Foods Market, Inc.. Rather, it is along with Canada becoming nearly as important corporately as the grocer's U.S. expansion plans are.

Whole Foods' to open up to 30 new stores in U.S. in 2009

Speaking of those U.S. expansion plans. Whole Foods' announced today in a filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission that it plans to build and open between 25 -to- 30 new stores in the U.S. next year. That's a new store opening somewhere in the U.S. at a rate higher than one every other week.

The 29-30 new stores will all likely be no smaller than 45,000 square feet (except in special cases like urban neighborhoods where there are geographical limitations of course) and as big as 80,000 square feet. The new stores also will be located both in regions like Texas and the west and east coasts, where Whole Foods' already has a substantial number of stores, and in new areas of the U.S. where the grocer has little or no current retail presence.

Whole Foods also is set to open its Whole Foods Express small-format, convenience-oriented prototype store in a renovated former Wild Oats market building in Boulder, Colorado later this year. If that test--and format--proves successful, we could see the supernatural grocer join the growing small-format grocery store revolution in the U.S. with additional Express stores in other parts of the country perhaps even beginning next year.

From what we've been able to learn thus far, the Whole Foods Express format will be about 15,000 square feet -to- 20,000 square feet in size. It will feature a limited selection of natural and organic grocery products, fresh produce and meats and other perishables.

A key feature of the Express store will be an extensive selection of natural, organic, healthy and tasty ready-to-eat and ready-to heat prepared foods. We also expect to see some sort of an in store cafe in the Express store, as well as a small version of a Whole Foods-style in-store Bistro food service venue.

Friday, October 19, 2007

Friday Feature

Giant Eagle Beats Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets to the Punch With it's Upscale, Express Format

Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets stores have been all over the media in the past few months, including here at Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM). Far less attention and coverage (virtually none really) has been given to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania-based Giant Eagle, Inc.'s new Giant Eagle Express store format and its first (and currently only) store which opened in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania in May of this year.

The Giant Eagle Express stores are a hybrid, upscale neighborhood grocery and convenience store. Sound familiar? The Pittsburgh store which opened in May is about 13,000 square-feet and features a large, fresh prepared foods selection, basic and specialty groceries, fresh meats, fresh produce and in-store service deli and bakery departments featuring upscale offerings.

The prototype express store also has an in-store cafe with free wireless internet service, a drive-through pharmacy and an automobile fuel service area outside, branded with the GetGo gas banner, and physically separated a bit from the Express market.

Privately-held Giant Eagle had 2006 sales of $6.5 billion. The family-owned retailer is the 22nd largest food retailer in the U.S.. The chain operates 156 corporately-owned supermarkets and 69 franchised stores. Giant Eagle also operates 128 traditional convenience stores under the GetGo banner.

In addition to the Giant Eagle banner, which the majority of the chain's supermarkets fly under, the retailer also has the Market District banner. The stores under this relatively new format are upscale supermarkets focusing on fresh foods and specialty, ethnic and natural foods offerings. There currently are two Market District stores, one in Pittsburgh and another in Bethel Park, with more planned. Giant Eagle supermarkets, convenience stores and now the upscale Giant Eagle Express stores, are located in Pennsylvania, Ohio, West Virginia and Maryland.

The Express store(s) are positioned to be more than upscale, infrequently shopped stores. Rather, by combining a decent assortment of basic groceries and non-foods along with the more upscale prepared foods, fresh produce and meats, and specialty offerings, the retailer wants to be a regular shopping stop for busy consumers.

Bret Merill, Giant Eagle's marketing vice president, describes the Express store(s) as "the contemporary neighborhood grocery store that provides fresh, convenient and affordable groceries and meal solutions to customers with on the go lifestyles." The Pittsburgh Giant Eagle Express, which is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, currently offers the same retail prices on groceries and similar goods that Giant Eagle supermarkets do, and the company says they plan on maintaining this policy.

Giant Eagle says they have a great deal of enthusiasm about the Express format and plan on opening more stores soon. Chain executives included the drive-through pharmacy as they want to compete with traditional drug stores as well as fill what they believe is a gap in the food retailing market between large supermarkets (most recently built Giant Eagle supermarkets are between 80,000 and 90,000 square-feet for example) and traditional convenience stores. (The chain's GetGo traditional C-store format stores range from about 2,000 square-feet to 5,000 square-feet.) Noted food industry consultant Willard Bishop recently made a similar point in a report saying his research shows there's a place between the evolving supermarket and evolving convenience store, noting that consumer lifestyles are driving shoppers towards more fresh and prepared foods.

The Giant Eagle Express store(s) share much in common with UK-based Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets, which the British retail chain is launching in the Western U.S. The first six Fresh & Easy stores will open on November 8. (You can read more here.) In fact, Giant Eagle executives have said Tesco's Fresh & Easy retail initiative in the U.S. was a major motivator to them in designing and building the Express format.

This isn't suprising as Tesco's U.S. initiative is notable for a number of reasons. First is the fact the Fresh & Easy retail operation is a from-the-ground-up startup for the retailer. Before now Tesco had no operations at all in the U.S. The retailer has built a huge distribution center and other infrastructure in Southern California, as well as designing and having numerous stores already under construction at the same time, with many more stores in the development pipeline.

This major store building effort is the second reason the Tesco initiative is notable. Their currently are 100 Fresh & Easy stores either being built or under development. Further, the retailer plans at least 500 stores in the next five to six years. Long term plans call for Fresh & Easy to be a "Starbucks like" concept with a critical mass of stores in regions throughout the U.S. Tesco has said they want to create a $6 billion dollar in annual sales division with Fresh & Easy over the next 10 to 12 years.

Lastly, Tesco is the world's third largest retailer and a very successful one at that. When the global Tesco creates an initiative like Fresh & Easy, not only does it get attention--but the initiative is usually well researched like the Fresh & Easy format was, and thus is ultimately a success.

In addition to Tesco and Giant Eagle Whole Foods Market, Inc. is in the process of converting a former Wild Oats store in Boulder, Colorado into a new prototype upscale convenience-type format called Whole Foods Express. Sounds familiar doesn't it? The Whole Foods Express format also puts an emphasis on fresh, prepared foods, especially quality grab-and-go type items. The store also will feature a limited selection of natural and organic products sold in the chain's supernatural format stores. In-store features such as bakery, cafe and an eat-in area also are planned, according to industry sources and Whole Foods people we have talked to. Expect to see some other features as well based on the concept of convenient shopping without compromising the Whole Foods quality brand.

The world's largest retailer, Wal-Mart, is watching this "small mart" store development trend closely, especially Tesco's Fresh & Easy initiative. We coined the term "small marts" when we reported in August/September that Wal-Mart has a high-level team living and working in San Francisco developing two small format convenience-type stores. One is a small footprint upscale food store like Fresh & Easy and Giant Foods Express, and the other is a similar small size health and wellness format store which in addition to selling these type of items would also have health clinics in-store.

In this September 6, piece, The Invasion of the Small Marts: Will There Be a Small Format Revolution By U.S. Retailers, we discuss Wal-Mart's planning process as well as Whole Foods' initiative, and Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets. We also discuss the fact that California-based retail chain Safeway Stores is researcher the "small mart" concept, especially Tesco's Fresh & Easy operation, and is planning on developing their own convenience-oriented upscale stores depending on the relative success of Tesco, according to CEO Steve Burd. We also offer an analysis in the piece on the format concept in the U.S. and the relative merits of its success and potential for growth.

Meanwhile, Giant Eagle has its first Express store open and is actively looking to open more throughout its market regions. From what we hear the Pittsburgh prototype store is doing well. We're told by local shoppers and industry observers that the upscale fresh foods like the Panini and other gourmet sandwiches, ready to eat complete meals, salads and other fresh offerings including baked goods, are selling well--and taste good.
These same observers also told us the store's cafe sees lots of activity including business people and others taking advantage of the free wireless internet service and using their laptop computers as they drink their cappucinos or lattes and enjoy the cafe's fresh baked muffins. Most also said the basic and specialty grocery selection was rather good for a store its size and that the retail prices were fairly reasonable. You can read some comments from Pittsburgh-area residents who have shopped at the Giant Eagle Express store here.

One unique opportunity we believe Giant Eagle has going for it--and is taking advantage of--with its Express format is the ability to co-brand with its other operations. For example, the drive-through pharmacy is named "Giant Eagle Pharmacy" like the pharmacies located inside its Giant Eagle supermarkets. The store's outside fuel station is branded as a GetGo fuel station like those included with its traditional convenience stores.
Lastly, the natural and organic foods area in the Express store(s) is branded as "Nature's Basket," the brand Giant Eagle uses to designate natural and organic offerings in its supermarkets. This "co-branding" is done tastefully and in an understated manner so it doesn't overpower the primary brand which is Giant Eagle Express. Giant Eagle is a long-time, popular retailer in its market area with strong retail brand equity which we think will fit well in the way it's being used in the Express format store.

As we're seeing with Tesco, Giant Eagle, Whole Foods and potentially Wal-Mart, Safeway and others, this neighborhood market/convenience-type retailing format is beginning to get some attention in the U.S. Although Tesco has yet to open a Fresh & Easy store, the expectations are high. Tesco isn't new to this format globally however. They operate many "Tesco Express" stores in Western and Eastern Europe.
The question is if the format will go over well in the U.S. This question can be answered in part with a yes based on the fact that Pennsylvania-based Wawa Food Markets has been very successful for decades with its upscale convenience store format. Wawa opened their first store in 1964 and adopted an upscale format for their stores some years later. Today Wawa, the pioneer in upscale convenience-oriented grocery retailing, has 500 stores located in five states.

There are a number of qualitative differences between the Fresh & Easy, Giant Eagle Express, Whole Foods Express and Wawa stores. However, the principal of upscale, convenience-oriented fresh foods and grocery retailing is the same--and Wawa has demonstrated it can be extremely successful and not just in upscale demographic regions and neighborhoods.

Giant Eagle and Whole Foods are just testing the waters. Tesco is going flat out with its Fresh & Easy stores. Wal-Mart is making a major research and development effort into its upscale, convenience format--an initiative we believe will come to fruation soon with an announcement of a prototype store for each of its two "small mart" formats. This relatively new format story is just beginning.










































Friday, August 24, 2007

Breaking News and Analysis

Federal Court Gives Whole Foods the Green Light on Wild Oats Acquisition: Overules FTC Appeal


Late Thursday afternoon (Aug. 23, 2007) a federal appeals court in Washington D.C. rejected the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) objection to Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s friendly acquisition/merger of rival Wild Oats Markets, Inc.and gave Whole Foods and Wild Oats the green light to move forward with the merging of the two natural foods retailers under Whole Foods' corporate ownership.

Whole Foods Market, Inc's CEO, John Mackey, says the company will go forward on closing the deal rapidly. "We are pleased to have cleared what we expect to be our last legal hurdle," Mackey said in a statement. We look forward to closing this merger and believe the synergies gained form this combination will create long-term value for our customers, vendors and shareholders as well as exciting opportunities for our new and existing team members."

Whole Foods' tender offer to purchase all outstanding shares of Wild Oats Markets, Inc. expires Monday. It's expected Whole Foods will begin closing the merger as early as then.

Here's an Associated Press Business story which provides further details on the federal court decision. http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070824/ap_on_bi_ge/whole_foods_merger_15

Whole Foods Markets issued a press release on the federal court decision and on the company's plans to move forward. http://www.wholefoods.com/investor/pr07_08-23.html

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo's Analysis of the Decision:

Natural Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) believes the federal court made the right decision in rejecting the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) arguments that the Whole Foods/Wild Oats' deal would lead to higher retail prices in the "premium grocery segment." And we believe the court was right to make its decision in the rapid manner it did so the deal could be saved.

The FTC argument was wrong for a number of reasons. First, Whole Foods Market, Inc. already gets a premium price point for the products it sells in it's stores. For example, Whole Foods' gross margins are double that of supermarket industry giants Kroger and Supervalue.

That said, Whole Foods has recently been lowering some of it's retail prices on natural and organic groceries because of competition. This isn't competition from Wild Oats however. Rather it's from large mass merchandisers and supermarket chains like Wal-Mart, Inc. Kroger Co., Supervalu, Inc., Safeway Stores, Inc. and a few others. All four of these national chains (one the largest retailer in the world, the others the top three U.S. supermarket chains) are making serious commitments to natural and organic products merchandising and pricing these goods below what Whole Foods traditionally has been retailing the items for.

Therefore this is the second reason why the FTC was wrong. The increased natural and organic products merchandising programs and aggressive retail pricing of these four industry giants, and a few others, is what's putting competitive pressure on Whole Foods. These chains will continue exerting this pricing pressure. If anything the result will be Whole Foods' lowering more natural and organic product retail price points rather than raising them because they have acquired Wild Oats.

The third reason the federal court was right--and the FTC wrong--is that the number of stores Whole Foods is acquiring in the Wild Oats deal isn't of significant numbers to allow any sort of price-raising or competitive dimunision Wild Oats has 110 stores. Of those 110 stores 35 of them are under the Henry's Farmers Market and Sun Harvest banners. Whole Foods is selling these 35 stores to a newly created subsidiary of Southern California-based Smart and Final, Inc. The Henry's and Sun Harvest stores are a natural foods/basic grocery/specialty market hybrid of sorts and don't fit into Whole Foods' merchandising philosophy and program.

With the sale of the 35 stores Whole Foods will be left with 75 Wild Oats-acquired stores. Additionally a number of these stores are either located too close to existing Whole Foods stores to keep open or are too small for the grocer to express it's merchandising strengths in. Therefore it's likely Whole Foods will need to sell off some of these remaining 75 stores. Let's say Whole Foods only ends up selling or closing 10 of these stores for the reasons above. That would leave the supernatural grocer with 65 stores as a result of the deal. These are far more stores than Whole Foods could build from the ground up in say 2 or 3 years. But it's hardly enough to create a retail price monopoly on natural and organic products.

In fact, NSFM believes in the long-run the deal will actually spur more entrepreneurship in the natural foods retailing sector. We're likely to see some new independents spring up. With the banner Wild Oats no longer in the market there will be some backlash to "Whole Foods all the time" and smart independent natural foods retailers will capitalize on this by opening new stores.

Additionally we're already seeing major chains like Supervalu creating natural foods stores like it's Sunflower Market. Sunflower Market is a natural foods supermarket which also features extensive specialty foods and groceries. The chain says it plans to grow the Sunflower banner throughout the U.S. Supervalue also owns Bristol Farms in Southern California, an upscale specialty format with extensive natural products merchandise. Supervalu has said they plan to grow this banner outside of Southern California. The first Bristol Farms opened not too long ago in Northern California (in San Francisco) and you can expect more stores to open on the west coast soon. The chain also is likely to take this upscale banner national.

Kroger and Safeway Stores both looked closely at buying Wild Oats but decided against making an offer. These chains seem to be more interested in adding extensive skus of natural and organic groceries to their existing and new stores at present rather than creating a stand alone banner like Supervalue. But it's something both chains talk about and are studying. Both chains also have expanded, more upscale formats, for their new stores in which natural and organic products play a major merchandising role across all categories. Both chains, as well as Supervalu, also have created corporate/private label natural and organic grocery lines and continue to grow them. Perhaps the Whole Foods/Wild Oats deal will even be an encouragement to these chains to create a natural foods stand alone format(s).

Based on the evidence and arguments we presented above NSFM believes the federal court acted properly in swiftly denying the FTC appeal and giving Whole Foods Market, Inc. and Wild Oats the green light to move forward on the deal. NSFM also believes the deal won't be an avenue for Whole Foods to increase retail prices on natural and organic products. To the contrary we argue the supernatural grocer will feel increased competition in the natural and organic sector from large mass merchandisers and supermarkets and as a result will keep it's retail prices and margins about right where they currently are in most cases, and in some cases even have to lower retail prices.

Lastly NSFM argues the deal will in the long run actually stimulate and create more competition in the natural foods retailing segment. Whole Foods is selling 35 stores under the Henry's and Sunflower banners to a subsidiary of Smart and Final, Inc. in Southern California. Smart and Final is a large, publicly held corporation and it's likely to grow these banners in terms of store count and geographical reach. Further we see independents stepping in as an alternative to "Whole Foods fatigue", the notion that anything so popular as the chain turns off some people who will then look for alternatives like independent natural foods stores. These two developments will lead to increased long run competition in the sector.

The last competitive stimulant--and it's a big one--to this increased long-term competition is the emergence of the mega mass merchandisers and grocery chains into natural and organic products retailing in a big way. Whole Foods has served as a study laboratory for these retailers for years. And in the last 2-3 years the mega-chains have began phase two of their study of Whole Foods, which is implementation. The mega-retailers are going to grow much more aggressive in natural and organic products retailing--and they have the cash to do so. All of these factors combined are in the long run going to end up creating a much more competitive natural and organic products retail market. That's primarily why the federal court was right in it's decision.





































Wednesday, May 21, 2008

Retail Memo: Whole Foods Getting Small (er) With Two New Stores in Northern California to Be Located in Vacant Supermarket Buildings

Santa Cruz's historic and famous Beach-Boardwalk turns the city of about 60,000 into a community many times that size from late spring to the end of summer when tourists from California and thorughout the U.S. flock to the seaside resort community to play, shop and eat.

Mega-supernatural foods retailer Whole Foods Market, Inc. is departing from its practice in recent years of building primarily big and super-big new stores in the 55,000 -to- 80,000 square foot range throughout the U.S.--and especially in California--in the coastal Northern California cities of Santa Cruz and Capitola, where it's currently developing smaller-footprint 32,000 square foot (Santa Cruz) and 23,800 square foot stores (Capitola).

The two stores also will be located in currently vacant, former supermarket buildings, something Whole Foods has done in the past but not often, as it prefers building stores from the ground up.

In fact, the Santa Cruz store site, which is going to be in an empty former Albertsons supermarket building at 911 Soquel Avenue in the Eastside shopping center, was only going to be 24,000 square feet, about the same size as the one in nearby Capitola.. This week however Whole Foods was able to acquire two buildings next to the empty supermarket, allowing it to expand what will be the city's future Whole Foods store by 8,000 square feet for a total of 32,000 square feet.

Locating the two new stores in the vacant buildings makes good sense because vacant land is near impossible to find in the two coastal cities, and when it's available the cost is out of this world. Additionally, the two buildings--one a former Albertsons store as mentioned in Santa Cruz and the Capitola site a former Ralph's supermarket--have been vacant for sometime, therefore Whole Foods likely acquired them for a reasonable cost. Reasonable for the region that is.

The Santa Cruz and Capitola units will be full Whole Foods Market stores rather than versions of its new Whole Foods Express format, according to a Whole Foods executive in Northern California who asked we not name them.

The first Whole Foods Express store is set to open in a former Wild Oats store in Boulder, Colorado soon. The Whole Foods Express format is about 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet, will feature a wide-variety of fresh, prepared foods, and a limited assortment of natural, organic and specialty foods and products.

At under 24,000 square feet, the Capitola Whole Foods store will be even smaller than the Santa Cruz store. That planned Whole Foods' store is located on 41rst Avenue in the coastal city, which is just a few miles from Santa Cruz.

Smaller stores aren't a new thing for Whole Foods, just a departure from its practice over the last 5 -to- 10 years of primarily building stores from the ground up in the 55,000 up to 80,000 square foot range.

Locating stores in empty retail buildings also is the exception rather than the norm for Whole Foods Market, Inc. The retailer generally likes to built brand new stores, but has renovated empty buildings before, especially in places like Northern California where vacant land can be hard to find and premium-priced.

For example, last year Whole Foods opened its European Market Hall-style store in downtown Oakland in Northern California's San Francisco Bay Area. That store is in a former automobile dealership which the grocer completely demolished and renovated into the store which is designed similar to a European food hall.

Whole Foods also has a number of smaller stores in Northern California, the majority of which were built and opened prior to the last few years however. Those stores include it's first and currently only store in the University city of Berkeley (a second, bigger store is planned for Berkeley as well), it's Los Gatos store near Santa Cruz, and its sales per-square-foot-busting store in the Marin County city of Mill Valley, along with a few others.

The Mill Valley Whole Foods store, which is where the grocer's co-president Walter Robb started with the supernatural foods retailer as a store manager in the early 1990's when he helped design it and opened it, has only 15,000 square feet of selling space but averages in the neighborhood of $600,000 a week in gross sales.

Crews from Northern California's John Sutti & Associates, a retail design and building firm which has built and renovated most of Whole Foods' stores in Northern California over the years, are currently demolishing the Santa Cruz store site in the former Albertsons' building and preparing it for renovation, according to our Whole Foods' source in Northern California.

The Santa Cruz and Capitola stores will be the first Whole Foods markets in both cities. The grocer has a fairly new store in Monterey, but that city is about a 45-minute drive from Santa Cruz and Capitola. It also has another store in Los Gatos, which is about 30 minutes away depending on traffic.

Both cities have prime natural foods retail consumer demographics--higher than average post high school educational levels, higher than average income, a large "foodie" and health/organic foods'-eating population, a large counter culture population--and Santa Cruz has a number of independent natural foods stores that all do very well.

For example, Santa Cruz-based multi-store New Leaf Community Markets currently has two stores in Santa Cruz and is in the process of building a brand new 17,800 square foot natural foods store on the city's westside. New Leaf has to a large degree "owned" natural foods' and products' retailing in the city of Santa Cruz for the three decades or so it's had it's stores in the city of about 60,000.

Whole Foods' opening a store in Santa Cruz is going to put serious competitive pressure on New Leaf, even though it's building its own new store and has two others in it's hometown city.

Additionally, New Leaf was supposed to be acquired by Canada's Planet Organic, Inc. However, a couple weeks ago Planet Organic backed out of the deal because it said it decided not to float a planned $15 million stock offering, part of which was to be used to buy New Leaf, because of poor market conditions. [You can read our May 5 piece on the Planet Organic aborted buyout of New Leaf Community Markets here.]

New Leaf had earlier indicated to Natural~Specialty Foods Memo and others it needed the cash from the acquisition/merger (New Leaf's owners were still going to run the operation post-acquisition) to finish building the new Santa Cruz store on the city's westside and to complete another new store its' currently building in nearby Half Moon Bay.

New Leaf's owners have said they are still well enough financed to complete and open the new stores, and to operate fully. However, since the grocer did say when it jointly-announced the deal with Planet Organic executives at a press conference in Santa Cruz the cash from the acquisition was needed for the new store expansion and other purposes, there is some skepticism as to whether or not New Leaf will be able to move forward completely without finding either new financing on its own or another suitor, which they likely should be able to do in our analysis.

Santa Cruz is the county seat of Santa Cruz county, which has about 300,000 residents. Capitola, an artsy and tourist-oriented city of about 15,000 located just a short drive from Santa Cruz, also is in Santa Cruz County.

The economies of both cities are heavily dependent on tourism. Santa Cruz and Capitola draw tens of thousands of visitors each week in the summer months, some for weekends, others for longer stays.

Santa Cruz is home to its historic and famous Beach-Boardwalk, a beachside playland featuring various rides, attractions, entertainment venues, food stalls and restaurants, and other attractions for kids and kids at heart. The Santa Cruz Beach-Boardwalk is one of California's top tourist destinations, drawing not only Californians but visitors from throughout the U.S.

The cities are only a short drive from the Bay Area's Silicon Valley region, and many people in San Jose and the surrounding cities have weekend homes in the Santa Cruz area, as do people from California's Central Valley where summer temperatures often top 100 degrees. For these folks, Santa Cruz is a place to get away to for cooler weather and relaxation on the weekends.

The fact Capitola is a major tourist destination and weekend home retreat should allow Whole Foods to have more than enough customers for it's new store even though the city's population is only about 15,000.

Santa Cruz also has a campus of the University of California, which is a major employer in the city and of people who live in Capitola and other nearby cities. County government also is a major employer in Santa Cruz since it's the county seat. Health care is a fast-growing industry in the town as well, especially since there are many small communities nearby without their own hospitals and major medical offices.

Lastly, food and wine industry and related businesses and industries plays a big part in the Santa Cruz and Capitola economies. Whole Foods fits in well in this regard. Both cities are home to many restaurants, ranging from cutting-edge California cuisine and organic foods-only operations, to ethnic eateries who's menus span the globe.

The area also is home to numerous organic farming and food production companies, as it's nearby America's prime growing region for fresh market vegetables, the Monterey and Salinas Valley region. The region's farmers are leaders in the U.S. organic foods industry as well.

There also are numerous specialty, natural/organic and artisan food producers in the region, which isn't surprising considering the organic farming industry and the "foodie" and wine culture which permeates the area, not to mention the prime soil inland from the coast.

The University of California at Santa Cruz also has a well-respected program in sustainable agriculture, which not only serves as an educational and research hub for the industries but also has resulted in many people staying in the area after graduating from the program because of it's coastal beauty and the numerous opportunities in sustainable farming and food production.

With the store in Santa and the one in Capitola both opening early next year, Whole Foods is going to make a major impact in the two cities and surrounding area.

With it's commitment to local foods selling, the two branches of the United State's number one natural foods' store retailer will open new market opportunities for many of the area's smaller organic and sustainable farmers and food producers.

The stores also will offer the respective communities' large base of natural and organic food shoppers more product variety compared to what's currently available to them in the area's natural foods stores and supermarkets.

Whole Foods is making a major push in Northern California, and the stores in Santa Cruz and Capitola are part of that new store growth initiative.

Whole Foods currently has 24 stores in Northern California. All but two--Sacramento and Fresno--of those stores are located in the Bay Area or the Coastal region near the Bay Area.

The supernatural food retailer currently has 20 new stores in various stages of development in California. Out of those 20 new stores in development, 13 are in Northern California. All of those 13 are set to be opened by the end of 2009.

Further, Whole Foods announced earlier this year it would double the number of stores in Northern California, from its current 24 to about 50 in the next four years. The region is not only one of the grocer's top revenue producing regions, it's one of it's top growth target markets as well.

Saturday, August 16, 2008

Retail Analysis Memo: Growth and A Tale of Two Retailers-Tesco and Whole Foods Market: Is One Ripe For Acquisition and the Other Ripe For Acquiring?


Natural~Specialty Foods Memo Analysis and Opinion

Whole Foods Market, Inc. and Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market are two very different food retailers, but they do have at least one similarity.

That similarity is the fact for the last couple years both retail chains have been locking up new store site leases throughout Northern California at a breakneck pace.

Whole Foods, which these days tends to build primarily mega-natural foods supermarkets in the 45,000 -to- 75,000 square foot range, with some exceptions of course, currently has 13 new store locations in various degrees of development in Northern California. Eleven of the 13 locations have signed leases.

Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, which is the U.S. division of United Kingdom (UK)-based international retailer Tesco, the third largest retailer in the world, is engaged in its own leasing frenzy in Northern California. Thus far, Tesco has locked up leases on 43 sites for its small-format combination fresh foods and basic grocery stores in Northern California--21 locations in the San Francisco Bay Area, 20 in the Sacramento/Vacaville/Farfield region and one in Modesto, in the Northern San Joaquin Valley, and one in the south coastal city of Seaside near Monterey.

The 43 store locations are just those Tesco has either confirmed or we have identified independently. The retailer is in the process of securing many more new store site leases at present. The first of the 10,000 -to- 13,000 square foot Northern California Tesco Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market grocery stores are scheduled to begin opening in early 2009. Just as its been the case since November, 2007 in its current Southern California, Nevada and Arizona markets, expect to see Tesco open a new Fresh & Easy store in Northern California about every 3 -to- 4 days beginning early next year.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. though, unlike Tesco's Fresh & Easy, is putting the brakes on its new store opening plans for at least the next year, including in Northern California, which strategically is one of the natural grocer's top new store development markets for the next few years.

Last week after reporting poor sales and profit numbers, Whole Foods announced it planned to scale back the number of new stores it plans to open in the U.S. next year from the 25 -to- 30 it had planned to open in 2009, to just 15. As mentioned above, 13 of those new store locations are in Northern California.

On Friday, David Lannon, president of Whole Foods' Northern California division said that as part of the grocer's 2009 new store opening reduction plan, all but two of the 13 planned new stores in Northern California are subject to not being opened next year as originally planned. He said the retailer is committed to eventually opening all 13 stores in Northern California, but that it's obvious in light of the fact Whole Foods will only open 15 new stores nationally in the U.S. next year, that most of those 13 stores won't open in 2009 as planned.

According to Lannon, the two Whole Foods stores that will open for sure in Northern California is a store in the south coastal city of Santa Cruz (set to open in the first quarter of 2009) and one in Roseville, which is a suburb of Sacramento. That store is scheduled to open in November, 2009. It will only be Whole Foods Markets' second store in the fast growing Sacramento Metropolitan region. The existing store is in Sacramento.

Lannon and a team from the Northern California division office plan to meet with landlords and developers of the 11 leased sites to determine the status of each project and discuss the future in light of Whole Foods corporate plans to reduce the number of new stores it will open next year by nearly half. Final decisions on moving forward and scaling back will be made at Whole Foods' corporate headquarters in Austin, Texas, Lannon says.

Meanwhile, Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market is moving full bore ahead, not only with its plans to open the 42 Northern California combination fresh foods and basic grocery markets next year, but also scouting out additional sites and signing additional leases for them throughout the region.

In addition to the Bay Area and Sacramento region, Tesco is looking for additional store sites (it already has the one in Modesto) in the Northern San Joaquin Valley cities of Stockton, Manteca and Tracy, additional locations in Modesto, and in other communities in the region.

Tesco also is looking for Fresh & Easy store sites in the Monterey/Salinas/Santa Cruz area where it recently inked a deal for a store site in Seaside, next door to Monterey.

Further, it's looking to lock up leases for additional Bay Area stores in all nine counties, along with more stores in the Sacramento/Vacaville/Farfield area.

The retailer's strategy is to have stores throughout the Bay Area, to Sacramento on the I-80 corridor, from Sacramento throughout the Central Valley, and out to the south coast. Five stores are set to open in the Bakersfield Metropolitan region next year, along with six in Metro Fresno. The retailer also is looking for a couple store sites in the Merced County region.

The net result will be to have Fresh & Easy Neighorhood Market grocery stores from Southern California, where there currently are about 37 of the markets (there are 71 stores total thus far in Southern California Metro Las Vegas, Nevada and in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan area), through Bakersfield and Fresno, into the Northern San Joaquin Valley, out to Sacramento, into the San Francisco Bay Area, and over to the south coast, by the end of 2009.

This strategy will give Tesco the beginnings of a critical mass of food stores in California, which it plans to then add additional units to throughout 2009 and 2010, likely ending up with around 200 stores in California by the end of 2010.

One shouldn't attribute the fact Tesco is going forward so aggressively with its new store development program in Northern California, while Whole Foods Market, Inc. is putting the brakes on its, to Whole Foods' being the only one of the two food retailers having sales and profits problems.

Although it hasn't released any sales numbers yet, we know Tesco is losing millions with its start up Fresh & Easy. A big part of this loss is just that start ups lose money, especially very aggressive retail start ups like Fresh & Easy is.

But the start up explanation is only half of the equation. Thus far Tesco's Fresh & Easy stores have been underperforming to Tesco's internal target, which was weekly sales in the average 10,000 -to- 13,000 square foot stores of about $200,000 per-week. Our sources and research says on average the stores have been doing about half that sales number, although they've been picking up in the last couple months because Tesco has been launching some aggressive promotions, including distributing lots of coupons good for a whopping $5 off total grocery purchases of $20 or more in all its Fresh & Easy stores.

The fact is though, Fresh & Easy USA is a major initiative for Tesco, which is the world's third-largest retailer with annual sales of over $83 billion last year. The United Kingdom-based retailer plans to loose money on its Fresh & Easy U.S. venture for sometime--although it didn't initially count on losing as much as it has so far.

Compared to Tesco, Whole Foods Market is a tiny food retailing fish, with sales in the $6 -to- $7 billion dollar a year range. However, Whole Foods isn't much of an international retailer, with just a few stores in Canada and a handful of stores in the United Kingdom, the rest being in the United States. Therefore, that fact, combined with its focus on the natural and organic foods categories (it doesn't have the sales luxury of selling basic groceries in other words) makes Whole Foods a very impressive food retailer in scale and sales domestically. It's just not anywhere near the scale of a Tesco--or a Walmart, Inc., Kroger, Safeway, SuperValu and numerous others.

And in the case of going forward with new store opening plans rather than putting the brakes on such plans, being an $80-plus billion a year international retailer that has lots of cash on hand helps, compared to being a $7 billion a year retailer who's fate--unlike Tesco's which has operations all over the globe---lies 100% on its U.S. stores' performance, which thanks to the poor U.S. economy is taking a serious battering right now.

Nonetheless, Tesco would covet having a $6-plus billion a year U.S. division like Whole Foods Market, Inc., although it would likely prefer it to be under a more traditional food and grocery retailing format, rather than one focused on natural, organic, fresh and specialty foods categories. Or perhaps it wouldn't? The U.S. economy will boom once again, and upscale will be back in for many.

But, we also know that Tesco senior management has looked on Whole Foods in the U.S. in many ways with a keen eye, particularly admiring what its done in the organic fresh foods and grocery categories. And when Whole Foods opened its first store in London in the UK last year, Tesco watched closely. Unfortunately for Whole Foods Market, Inc., the retailer has lost $18 million to date on that London store, but business has picked up at the 70,000 square foot London food emporium, and it's drawing many more shoppers than it was just a year ago.

In the UK, Tesco is very deep in the natural and organic foods categories across all store categories, including dry grocery, fresh foods and even non-foods, particularly with its own store brands, which are the leading selling items in many categories throughout Britain.

Tesco is the UK's leading food and grocery retailer, controlling an impressive 31% share of the country's food and grocery sales market. Number two Wal-Mart-owned Asda has about a 17% share. Number three Sainsbury's about 15.5%. The remaining percentage is split among numerous food and grocery chains, including Morrisons (4th ranked) the Co-operative Group (now number 5 after just having acquired the Somerfield supermarket chain), Waitrose, Marks & Spencer, small-format German discount grocers Aldi and Lidl, and and a few others.

Last year when the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) made the first of its many legal challenges (which are still going on) against Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s acquisition-merger of Wild Oats Market, Inc., saying the deal would give Whole Foods' monopoly power in the supernatural food retailing category--an argument we've argued is wrong--we wrote that the FTC and others are forgetting Whole Foods Market, Inc. is a rather small fish in terms of overall food and grocery retailing in the U.S. (There are 21 retailers ranked above Whole Foods in terms of annual sales in the U.S. Further, the majority of these retailers are regional rather than national food retailers like Whole Foods is.)

As a result we wrote that Whole Foods Market, Inc. itself could become an acquisition target in the near-to-medium term, especially since major U.S. retailers like Safeway Stores, Inc., Kroger Co., SuperValu, Inc. and many others have moved into the natural and organic foods retailing space in a big way.

Thinking about how Whole Foods is having to scale back its plans to open about 30 stores in the U.S. next year to 15, while Tesco will likely open well over 100 new Fresh & Easy stores next year in California alone (granted the Fresh & Easy markets are much smaller than the average new Whole Foods store is), as well as is now moving into India and further growing its already impressive international business, our thoughts turn back to that Whole Foods as a potential acquisition target, as this month marks about a year since the Wild Oats acquisition.

While we believe based on source information Tesco eventually has bigger strategic plans in the U.S. than acquiring say a Whole Foods Market, Inc.--such as possibly acquiring something on the order of a Safeway or SuperValu, Inc. for example, along with growing Fresh & Easy into the Chicago Metro, Florida and New York markets--acquisitions are as much situational as they are long-term strategic opportunities.

A year ago, with its stock at an all time high, not even a Tesco or Wal-Mart, Inc. would likely consider acquiring the natural foods chain, even if they coveted doing so. But today, Whole Foods' stock is 70% below that all time high of just a year ago, and its being forced to cut back on its rapid new store growth program dramatically for the first time in two decades.

Additionally, Wall Street, which as recent as 6-7 months ago was super-bullish on Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s stock, is now bearish on the natural foods retailer. Whole Foods after all is a public company with numerous major institutional stockholders who must be satisfied. This is particularly the case since these investors are used to Whole Foods' stock going north rather than south in terms of value--at least until now.

This brings us to Tesco. If it wants to be a major player in food and grocery retailing in the U.S., it's going to have to eventually acquire a good-sized retailer or two at least. Although it's launched what is perhaps the most aggressive food retailing start up in modern history in the U.S. with Fresh & Easy, even if it opens 150 stores a year for the next five years (doable but tough to sustain and do well), it will still be a minor overall player with about 800 small-format stores. Nothing to sneeze at, but not in the big leagues either.

With Whole Foods' stock 70% below last year's high, along with the retailer having to scale back its new store opening plans for next year by nearly 50%--which means it doesn't have enough cash to go forward even while turning in poor sales and profit numbers in the short term--Whole Foods' is ripe to be acquired. The natural grocery chain also announced yesterday it will lay off about 43 employees at its Austin, Texas corporate headquarters.

If Tesco were to acquire Whole Foods, it could do many things for the international retailer. First, it would give it an immediate annual sales base of nearly $7 billion in the U.S., which is nothing to sneeze at, even for an $83-plus billion a year international retailer.

Second, it gives Tesco what arguably is the best upscale natural, organic and fresh foods format in the world. Imagine what a retailer the scale of Tesco could do with Whole Foods if it could do it right?

Third, it gives Tesco, which has the cash to expand Whole Foods internationally, an upscale natural, organic and green retailing format that it could expand throughout Europe, Australia, parts of Asia and even to the oil rich Arab countries where the UK's upscale Waitrose and the U.S. gourmet grocer Dean & Delucca are opening stores.

Lastly, at home in the UK, which on a per-capita basis has become the world's leading organic foods retail market, Whole Foods would give Tesco a banner which it could use to eventually dominate the natural foods' retailing space like its done in the grocery and general merchandise spaces with its various Tesco banner stores, ranging from hypermarkets to its small-format Tesco Express convenience-style grocery stores.

We believe Whole Foods CEO John Mackey and the company's board of directors would fight any acquisition, and likely would fight a deal offer from a British-based chain like Tesco even more so. However, if Whole Foods' performance doesn't improve dramatically in the next two quarters say, such a fight could be very difficult if such an acquisition were to come from Tesco or any other major retail chain. Nobody knows this better than John Mackey and the Whole Foods' board, since it was a fledgling, poor performing Wild Oats Market, Inc. it acquired about a year ago.

Is Tesco interested in acquiring Whole Foods Market, Inc.? We don't know. However, like we mentioned earlier in this piece, acquisitions are as much situational as they are long-term strategic. What we do know is that a couple U.S. supermarket chains are watching Whole Foods' performance closely, and that the A (acquisition) word has been tossed around by these chains, at least hypothetically.

What we do know is that Tesco has the cash to acquire Whole Foods without any trouble if it wants to. The possible political battle if it were to be a hostile acquisition, which would likely be the case at least right now, is another matter altogether. We doubt if Tesco is up for that just now.

However, when it comes to publicly-owned food retailing chains, circumstances change rapidly. Performance rules the day. For example, before investor Ron Burkle bought a major chunk of Wild Oats Market, Inc., became chairman of the board, and engineered the replacement of the company's CEO, both Wild Oats' board and key executives were adamant they would never sell to Whole Foods. That changed rather fast once Burkle got involved.

One could see a similar situation happening with Whole Foods. In fact, Burkle was a major player in brokering the Whole Foods-Wild Oats acquisition-merger. He's been rather low-key of late in the supermarket sector, but Whole Foods' current situation is one that brings out Ron Burkle and other investors like him who are adept at engineering just such acquisitions once they make a substantial investment in a company. Burkle still has stock in Whole Foods Market, Inc. from the Wild Oats acquisition, by the way.

Don't be shocked if in the not too distant future you see Whole Foods going from being charged by the FTC and others as a monopolist acquirer to being acquired itself.

Will it happen this year; next year? We have no idea. What we do know is that the chances of Whole Foods being acquired now are about 100% higher than they were just a year ago. That alone is worth paying attention to.

Editor's note: Watch for an upcoming story and analysis of retailer's we think would benefit overall by acquiring Whole Foods Market, Inc. An 'America's top Whole Foods Market, Inc. acquisition parade' if you will.

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Retail Memo: Whole Foods, Wild Oats and Boulder, CO...And the Rocky Mountain News' Editorial Take On FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.


FTC v. Whole Foods Market - Whole Foods Market v. FTC

Prior to its acquisition in the summer of 2007 by Whole Foods Market, Inc., Wild Oats Market, Inc. called the Colorado city of Boulder, where the natural grocery chain was founded by Michael Gillian, its headquarters hometown. The company was among the city's biggest employers. Ironically, Gillian, who left Wild Oats long before the acquisition by Whole Foods, founded his fast-growing Sunflower Farmers Market chain, which is headquartered in Boulder, in the city just a few years ago. As a result, Boulder may have lost its Wild Oats' but it did gain a Sunflower.

Boulder, a city of about 100,000, is famous for spawning natural products companies. Along with famous names like Wild Oats and organic dairy company White Wave Foods, Boulder is home to numerous smaller but fast-growing natural products companies like popular new-age beverage maker IZZE Beverage Company (which food and beverage giant PepsiCo acquired in 2006) and Rudi's Natural Bakery, among over a score of others. [Check out a list of 55 Boulder-based natural products companies at this list alone: Food Companies in Boulder, Colorado (CO).]

Although Boulder did start out as a draw for the creation of natural products companies in what could be described as a most natural way -- it's geographical setting, the fact it has always drawn numerous people who are counter cultural thinkers, the region and city's focus on healthy lifestyles, for example -- over the last few years it's place as a center for the natural products industry has been aided by "Naturally Boulder," which is an economic development initiative supported by the city of Boulder, Colorado and designed to create new natural products companies in the Rocky Mountain city.]

"Naturally Boulder" was established in 2005 by the city of Boulder and the Boulder Economic Council to provide support to help grow area natural and organic products businesses, help retain existing natural products businesses, attract natural products companies to the region, mentor new business leaders, and promote Boulder as a center for the natural and organic products industry.

Among other activities and programs, "Naturally Boulder" hosts educational seminars in partnership with the city's Small Business Development Center, networking events, and publishes an e-newsletter focusing on natural product local and industry news. The newsletter is distributed via email free to interested individuals.

Each year since 2005, "Naturally Boulder" holds a multi-day natural products' entrepreneurs' conference in the city. The most recent conference was held recently October 29-30 in Boulder.

[You can learn more about "Naturally Boulder," it's programs and its annual conference at its Web site here.]

Since its acquisition of Wild Oats last summer, Whole Foods' has obviously closed the headquarters operation in Boulder. However it has kept a large presence in the "natural city," basing its Rocky Mountain division in Boulder, as well as operating all of the former Wild Oats stores the natural grocer had in the city except one, which it closed because prior to the acquisition it was in the process of building a new Whole Foods natural market, which is now open, just down the street from the Wild Oats Market it has since closed.

Whole Foods decided to go with a multi-banner store strategy in Boulder. It has removed the Wild Oats name in favor of Whole Foods, but it also is changing the name of one former Wild Oats store in Boulder to Alfalfa's, which was a popular natural foods chain Wild Oats' acquired many years ago.

Additionally, Wild Oats bought a popular independent natural foods store in Boulder many years ago, Alpine Ideal Market, and kept that name on the store. Whole Foods also is retaining that name and is remodeling the Ideal Market store.

There are four Whole Foods Market-owned stores in Boulder: two under the Whole Foods banner, the Alfalfa's banner market and the Ideal Market. That's plenty for a city of about 100,000, even if it is Boulder. For example, Whole Foods has four stores in San Francisco, California a city with about 800,000 residents.

Whole Foods' had planned to convert one of the four (the one on Baseline Road, a former Wild Oats unit) stores in the city into what it has said will be the prototype of a Whole Foods Express market, a small-format (15,000 or so square feet), convenience-oriented natural foods store with an emphasis on ready-to-eat, grab-and-go prepared foods, and ready-to-heat fresh, prepared foods items.

However, as we've previously reported, Whole Foods has had a lease renewal problem with the owner/landlord of that store which has delayed its conversion into the Whole Foods Express store prototype. Meanwhile, with all the problems Whole Foods is having, the natural grocery chain has pretty much put the whole Express format store concept on hold as it attempts to regain sales, income and stock value in the current recession, along with its focus on fighting the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which is trying to overturn the Wild Oats' acquisition, as we've been reporting on and writing about extensively the last two weeks, as well as regularly since last year.

Whole Foods has made an extensive effort to keep close ties to Boulder post the Wild Oats' acquisition, both for logical (its Wild Oats' former headquarters city) and political (there was much concern in the city about losing Wild Oats' headquarters) reasons.

Additionally, because of Boulder's strong natural products company and consumer setting and environment, it makes good business sense for Whole Foods to keep as close of ties as it can to what can perhaps be described as Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s second headquarters city.

Further, Whole Foods' has always had ties with many of the Boulder-based natural foods companies since they are key suppliers to the retailer.

Keeping all of the above in mind, we read with interest an editorial today in the Rocky Mountain News by Vincent Carroll, who is the editor of the Colorado daily newspaper's editorial pages.

In the editorial, Carroll opines on John Mackey and on Whole Foods Market, Inc,'s lawsuit against the FTC. Since Boulder, Colorado is a city so closely intertwined with the Whole Foods-Wild oats merger, as well as with the natural products industry as a whole, we wanted to bring our readers a voice from the region regarding the FTC-Whole Foods issue.

Below (in italics) is Vincent Carroll's editorial from today's Rocky Mountain News. The recent (this week) quotes from John Mackey in the editorial, and Vincent Carroll's editorial argument, both sound very much like the arguments Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has been making against the FTC's case for many months now.

Rockey Mountain News - Colorado
Editorial Page: Wednesday, December 16, 2008
Some 'monopoly'
By Vincent Carroll

John Mackey has a point. The CEO of Whole Foods wonders why, if his company is the fearsome monopolist the federal government imagines, that sales haven't soared since its merger last year with Wild Oats.

In fact, he says, same-store sales are down.

"How can a monopolist have negative same-store sales?" Mackey asks. "The whole thing is ridiculous.

"There's only one place Whole Foods has a monopoly, and that's in the imagination of the lawyers at the Federal Trade Commission."

Whole Foods this month sued the FTC over its continued efforts to unravel a merger with Boulder-based Wild Oats - a merger that a trial judge originally approved. That ruling should have ended the matter. Instead, the FTC - propelled by a surreal belief that Whole Foods threatens to corner the market on premium organic food in cities such as Denver and Boulder - pursued the case, and an appeals court unexpectedly sided with the government.

The upshot: Whole Foods might be forced into the costly exercise of trying to untangle - or at least abort - the integration of two grocery chains that is substantially complete.

And for what? Supposedly so that customers won't be hostage to the "higher prices, reduced quality and fewer choices" that the government implausibly predicted would follow the merger. Yet with so many grocery options available to the public, Whole Foods would have to be crazy to think it could treat customers with disdain once it gobbled up a rival.

Alas, it is too much to expect a federal agency to entertain second thoughts about punishing a first-rate company at a time when consumers are trying to economize and, according to The Associated Press, "the rotten economy is eating into sales of organic foods." To the contrary. The FTC has scheduled the Whole Foods case for an administrative trial in February.

At least the company isn't deluding itself. Its lawsuit compares the FTC to the Queen of Hearts in Alice in Wonderland, who famously declared, "First the sentence, then the evidence."

Maybe the judge will award Whole Foods points for gallows humor.

[Vincent Carroll is editor of the editorial pages at the Rocky Mountain News . Reach him at carrollv@RockyMountainNews.com.]

Boulder and the Denver, Colorado market region are among the 29 or so U.S. market regions the FTC claims Whole Foods Market, Inc. has a monopoly in, in what it calls the "premium organic retailing" segment. With four natural foods markets, one could argue that could be true at least within the city limits of Boulder. In fact, we think Whole Foods is overstored in the city and needs to probably either close one of the four stores or convert one to the Whole Foods Express prototype like it said it would do last year, then see how it does.

But Boulder resident Michael Gillian, the founder and CEO of Boulder-based Sunflower Farmers Market, doesn't think Whole Foods Market owns Boulder or the Denver Metro region...or the state of Colorado, or Arizona, New Mexico, Utah, Texas and elsewhere in the western and southwestern U.S. where the fast-growing natural foods chain is opening new stores. But then he's a Boulder natural products' industry entrepreneur, not a member of the FTC. Fast-growing Sprouts Farmers Market has the same opinion as Sunflower, having recently opened two new stores in Colorado, with more to come, as it is doing throughout the west.

FTC v. Whole Foods - Whole Foods v. FTC: Recent Natural-Specialty Foods Memo linkage:

December, 15, 2008: Retail Memo: Eight Members of U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee Send Letter to FTC Chairman Regarding FTC's Legal Case Against Wild Oats' Acquisition.... December, 13, 2008: Retail Memo - Analysis & Commentary: More On FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc. and Whole Foods Market, Inc. v. FTC.... December 9, 2008: Organics Category Memo: Wither Organics? Organic Food & Grocery Category Sales Down; But Double-Digit Growth Still Likley With Mass Market Lift....

December 9, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Markets' 'Whole Legal Paycheck:' Three Top Washington, D.C. Law Firms Teaming Up On The Natural Grocery Chain's FTC Lawsuit....December 9, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market CEO John Mackey and Team Launch First Aggressive Attack Against the FTC's Legal Case at Press Conference This Morning....December 8, 2008: Retail Memo: Mr. Mackey (and the Whole Foods Market Troops) Goes to Washington....December 8, 2008: Retail Memo: Breaking News - Whole Foods Market, Inc. Files Lawsuit Against the FTC; Argues the Regulator Violated the Company's Due Process Rights....

December 7, 2008: Retail Memo: New Seasons Market CEO Brian Rohter and Whole Foods Market Co-President Walter Robb Discuss and Debate the Subpoena Issue Online....December 7, 2008: Retail Memo: New Seasons Market CEO Brian Rohter Speaks Out Again Today on the Whole Foods Market, Inc. Subpoena of His Company's Data....December 7, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market Retains Top Washington D.C. lawyers and Politically-Connected Lobbyists to Plead its Case Against the FTC....

December 6, 2008: Retail Memo: Fast-Growing and Scrappy Sunflower Farmers Market Ventures Deep in the Heart of (Whole Foods Country) Texas....December 6, 2008: Retail Memo: Fast-Growing NF Chain Sunflower Farmers Market Responds to Whole Foods Market, Inc. Subpoena For Sales, Financial and Related Information....December 3, 2008: Retail Memo: More on the Whole Foods Market-New Seasons Market Subpoena Issue; FTC Holding Firm For February, 2009 Hearing....

December 2, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market, Inc. Closes $425 Sale of Stock to Private Equity Firm; Adds Members of the Firm to its Board of Directors....December 2, 2008: Retail Memo: Portland, Oregon-Based New Seasons Market CEO Brian Rohter Responds to Whole Foods Market's Paige Brady....December 2, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods' Paige Brady Responds to Yesterday's New Seasons Market Piece; Lots of E-Mails; Issue Heats Up On the New Seasons Market Blog....

December 1, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Wants A Court-Mandated Financial Records Dump from Portland-based New Seasons Market; it Says For its Battle Against the FTC.

FTC v. Whole Foods: Linkage from the Natural~Specialty Foods Memo archives:

Click here, here and here for stories about the FTC-Whole Foods issue from our archives.