Showing posts sorted by relevance for query small format food retailing revolution. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query small format food retailing revolution. Sort by date Show all posts

Monday, August 4, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Independents Help Fuel Small-Format Food Retailing Revolution in the U.S. By Reinventing the 'Corner Grocery Store'

A 1920's corner grocery store in the United States.

The Return of the corner grocery store

As regular Natural~Specialty Foods Memo readers are aware, a year ago we started writing extensively about what we've deemed to be a revolution in small-format grocery store retailing internationally and in the United States.

[Click here to read a sampling of some of our stories on the topic. Also do a search in the box at the top of the blog. Search terms: small-format food retailing, small-format food retailing special report, small-format grocery stores, international small-format food retailing revolution, small-format food retailing memo, independent grocer memo.]

In the U.S., this small-format food retailing revolution continues to grow. In fact, in just the last year hundreds of new small-format food and grocery stores have opened throughout the U.S., despite the poor state of the economy.

That's evidence--along with a few other criteria like the fact giant retailers like Wal-Mart, Tesco, Aldi, Safeway and SuperValu all are committed to small-format store development-- to us it's a trend, rather than a mere fad.

SuperValu, Inc. is even extending its involvement in small-format food and grocery retailing beyond its discount Sav-a-Lot chain, into its Jewel supermarkets division. This fall it will open the first store of what are likely to be many "Urban Fresh by Jewel" stores, which are 15,000 square foot specialty food and grocery stores with an emphasis on fresh and specialty products. The first "Urban Fresh by Jewel" small-format market will be in Chicago.

We've identified the food retailing chain leaders in this revolution as no frills discount grocer Aldi USA (with around 900 stores), the U.S. division of Germany-based Aldi International; Supervalu, Inc.'s no frills, discount Sav-A-Lot chain (about 1,600 stores); specialty grocery chain Trader Joe's (300 stores) Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market (currently 67 stores and growing fast) Safeway Stores, Inc., with its new small-format "The Market" stores; Wal-Mart with its soon to open first four Marketside stores; and numerous others.

Independent grocers, America's original small-format grocers, also are putting a renewed focus on opening small-format grocery stores, especially in urban neighborhoods and in the down towns of suburban and small cities. We call this phenomenon the "new corner grocery store." The phrase is more metaphorical to describe the phenomenon rather than literal to mean a small grocery store right on the corner, although that applies as well.

And it's not just experienced and independents currently operating supermarkets and grocery stores that are opening these new small-format "new corner grocery stores." For the first time in decades, we are seeing numerous entrepreneurs, some with food retailing backgrounds, others with restaurant backgrounds (and some with both), along with entrepreneurs from other walks of professional life, starting to open small-format grocery stores throughout the U.S.

Just like the big chains--where the small-format grocery stores range from no frills, deep discount markets like Adli's and Sav-A-Lot's and combination basic grocery and fresh foods stores like Tesco's Fresh & Easy, Safeway's "The Market" and Wal-Mart's Marketside, which will open this fall in the Phoenix, Arizona region, to natural and specialty format stores like Trader Joe's and others--these independents also are opening up a variety of formats of small-format grocery stores. These markets range from upscale fresh, specialty and natural foods stores, to modern versions more basic grocery stores modeled after the corner grocery store of the past. Hence the title we are giving them: the "new corner grocery store."

Although in our analysis the small-format food retailing revolution is still in its infancy in the U.S. (and in many parts of the world as well), it is beginning to have positive effects on numerous cities and towns throughout the U.S., as well as on consumers.

Not only are the stores serving shoppers in locations often previously underserved, but the small-format grocery store revolution is starting to have a positive effect on urban, suburban and small town down towns because many of the grocery stores being opened in such areas are going into buildings which were either previously empty or rundown. In other words, grocers are improving these buildings and thus the neighborhoods in these communities, providing a higher and better use for the existing buildings and therefore the community as a whole.

This morning we read a story in the Rutland (Vermont) Herald newspaper about three independents and how they are making a go with three small-format grocer stores in three different towns in Vermont.

Those grocers--Bellomo's Market in Rutland, West Street Market in Proctor, Vermont, and California Fruit Market--are three excellent examples of independents who are helping to create this small-format food retailing revolution in the U.S. by reinventing what we call the "new corner grocery store."

Read the story, "Owners around town revitalize small-scale retail," written by Bruce Edwards here.

It's not easy competing with the big chains for independents regardless if they operate huge supermarkets or small-format food stores. However, the fact is small-format independent food and grocery stores are in a growth mode rather than in decline in the U.S.

The ingredients for success for independents, as well as chains, are the same in the main regardless of store size. Those ingredients include creating a niche and them communicating it in all a retailer does, providing excellent customer service, operating clean stores regardless of the format, and a handful of other essentials.

Small-format grocery stores do offer a couple interesting particulars for retailers however.

First, because of the smaller size, the overhead--monthly rent, energy costs, labor--are less. For independents this means fewer barriers to entry, as it costs millions to open a new supermarket of say 40,000 square feet or more.

Second, it is easier to focus on a particular niche or niches in a small-format food and grocery store. By sheer virtue of its smaller-size, a retailer is focusing on a narrower niche--neighborhood residents, gourmets, natural and organic foodies, for example--which all things being equal should allow for easier focus in merchandising, marketing and operations.

Lastly, small-format stores allow for a strategy that doesn't have to force a retailer to directly compete against the big chains. For example, a corner grocery store can focus on being a fill-in, secondary and even tertiary, store for neighborhood residents. Additionally, by creating a natural-organic and specialty niche, the small-format store can brand itself as the place to shop for affordable "quality" foods for example.

Again, creating a niche, executing and communicating it aren't any easier with a small-format grocery store. But by virtue of the smaller physical size it can allow a retailer to do so more economically and in a tighter fashion.

It's our analysis that chains like those mentioned earlier are opening small-format stores in large part because they figured this fact out. Of course, it is something many independents have know all along in the U.S.--which accounts for the fabulous success of the independent food and grocery retailing segment overall in America.

We're observing the beginnings of the emergence of the "new corner grocery store" in the U.S. This time around though it's being conducted as much by big chains as it is by independents.

Therefore, independents in this current food retailing revolution will have to be even more competitive than they have been in past campaigns and battles. Of course, that is something independents as a segment have shown they can do time and again in the United States.

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Retail Memo: The Small Format Revolution Continues to Heat Up

German food retailer ALDI is planning a major expansion of its small format, no-frills, price-impact supermarket chain in the U.S. The small format food retailing revolution in the USA is growing fast at both ends (low and high) of the food retailing spectrum, as well as in the middle. Where is it going? How fast will it get there?
ALDI USA's small format, limited assortment supermarkets (above) have about 15,000 square feet of retail selling space. The small format grocery stores are attractive but basic in design.
As our regular readers are aware, we've been writing about what we believe is nothing short of a small format food retailing revolution taking place in the U.S. It's not that small, neighborhood-style grocery stores haven't existed in the U.S. forever--they have. Rather, the reason we're calling it a small-format food retailing revolution is do to the scale of what's occurring, how fast it's happening, and the involvement of two large international retailers--Tesco and ALDI--who are leading the charge.

The catalyst for this so called small-format food retailing revolution is British grocer Tesco, which launched it's first Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets stores in Southern California and Las Vegas, Nevada in mid-November, and in Arizona three weeks ago. Tesco has opened nearly 30 of the small format grocery markets in just a little over a month. The retailer plans to have 200 of the stores open by the end of 2008, and up to 500 stores in the U.S. in five years.

In addition to Southern California, Nevada and Arizona, Tesco will begin opening Fresh & Easy grocery markets in Northern California next year. Further, as we've reported and written about here, the grocer is looking for store sights in New York, Florida and Chicago, along with land to built a distribution center on near Chicago.

Fresh & Easy grocery markets average about 10,000 to 13,000 square feet. They're a hybrid basic neighborhood grocery store and semi-upscale prepared, fresh food retailer. We describe the store format as low-price leader, limited format grocery store meets Trader Joe's.
Price-point is a big focus on the basic grocery side of the operation. The stores' thus far opened have lower retails on national brand (a limited selection though) grocery items than traditional supermarkets like Ralph's, Von's, Stater Bros. and others in their trading regions. In fact, the prices are more in-line with the deep-discount limited assortment and warehouse format stores in Fresh & Easy's current operating areas.

On the fresh, prepared foods side of the business, Fresh & Easy offers a wide variety of ready-to-eat, ready-to-heat and grab-and-go prepared foods. These range from basics like mac n' cheese and meat loaf, to more high-end offerings like Beef Tips in Burgundy Sauce and upscale, ethnic prepared foods featuring Indian, Asian and other cuisines. The stores' even sell fully-prepared complete meals that come with dessert and a bottle of wine. The prices on the prepared foods, which are all branded under the Fresh & Easy private label, are very reasonable.

In addition to the basic grocery items and prepared foods, the stores' offer fresh produce, fresh meats, other perishables and a selection of specialty and natural grocery items. About 65% of the items in the grocery markets' are private label, including fresh milk and eggs, and about 35% are national brands.

Aldi to expand its small format, no frills, limited assortment supermarkets

German food retailer ALDI was operating in the U.S. long before Tesco even thought about and created its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets concept and venture. Unlike the big splash--and rapid store opening strategy--Tesco made in the U.S. with Fresh & Easy, ALDI USA's venture has followed a low-key, low-publicity, gradual-growth model.
The international food retailer first entered the U.S. market in 1976 with a handful of stores in southeastern Iowa. Today, nearly 32 years later, the international grocer with stores in 18 countries, is a major player in U.S. food retailing.
ALDI USA currently operates over 850 stores in 26 states, and is ranked as the country's 24th highest grossing (sales) supermarket chain. The stores' are located from the Midwestern USA (Kansas, Iowa, Illinois) to the Eastern Seaboard. (you can view a map of all 26 states ALDI USA has stores in here. When you get to the linked page, go to "What is ALDI and click where it says "view a map of where we operate and divisional offices."
The German grocer's U.S. supermarkets not only are small format (they average about 15,000 square feet), limited product assortment, and price-impact focused, they're also totally no-frills. The stores' design is attractive but bare bones. If customers want to use a shopping cart they have to pay 25-cents to do so. Aldi USA stores also charge for paper and plastic grocery bags, and encourage shoppers to bring their own reusable grocery carriers. The chain's retail positioning can be summed up as "Less is More."

The small format stores' sell their own branded private label grocery items almost exclusively; with the exception of a handful of national brands, which they primarily offer only on an in-and-out basis. The grocer uses sku rationalization to its fullest, constantly evaluating categories and items and adjusting store category and item assortments. The no-frills markets offer fresh produce, fresh meats, perishables, frozen foods and non-food items, all based on that same limited-assortment merchandising philosophy.

The no-frills markets carry a total of slightly over 1,000 items across all categories. Low-price is the prime category-wide focus of the small format stores. In their trading areas, the stores' generally undercut all food retailing formats on price, including Wal-Mart, warehouse stores, and other deep discounters. ALDI supermarkets have the reputation as being the low-price leader stores in the communities they operate in.

Bring on the revolution: ALDI USA's slow growth model is about to change

With 850 stores in the USA, ALDI is considered a major food retailing player based on any score card one uses. That it is 24th in the U.S. in gross sales is impressive considering its stores are a third or more smaller than today's average American supermarket.

But the small-format, price-impact grocer is about to explode on the American food retailing scene in an even bigger way. ALDI USA just announced it is going to excelerate its new store building program in the U.S. from about 20-30 stores per year, which is it's current rate, to as many as 100 stores a year beginning next year. Additionally, the small-format grocer is going to enter Florida and Rhode Island for the first time next year, and is planning a major new expansion into Texas in 2009.

With stores in Texas and Florida, the grocer will be entering two of the most competitive and lucrative states for food retailing in the U.S., as well as establishing a retail presence in the number two and three largest states in the country respectively.

It might be televised, but the small format revolution is real

ALDI USA's rapid growth plan is predicated on the huge success the grocer has had with its 850-plus store chain. It, along with others like Supervalu Inc.'s Save-A-Lot small format, price-impact chain, have proven not only the viability but success of the format at the lower-end of the food retailing spectrum.

Of course, the international grocer isn't a stranger to high-end, small store format food retailing in the U.S. either. It owns the fabulously successful Trader Joe's specialty grocery chain, which is expanding rapidly into new markets in the U.S. as well.

We don't think it's an accident Tesco positioned it's Fresh & Easy grocery markets as a combination price-impact, specialty and prepared foods hybrid market. They saw the success of no-frills, small format operations like ALDI USA , Save-A-Lot and others--as well as the success of Trader Joe's on the higher, specialty end. In part, this influenced Tesco to craft a format they believe can serve both customer demographics--price-conscious, basic grocery shoppers tired of huge superstores, and time-pressed consumers who are looking for specialty-oriented and convenient prepared foods at not out of this world prices. Like we said earlier, it's low-price, limited assortment grocery market meets Trader Joe's.

Of course the jury is still out on Fresh & Easy. They just opened their first stores last month after all. However, Tesco's plans are to have as many as 500 stores operating in the U.S. in five years. As such, Fresh & Easy isn't an experiment. Rather, it's a full-fledged venture.

Onward small format food retailing revolution

We see what we are calling the small format food retailing revolution going full-steam ahead. As we've reported recently, Safeway Stores, Inc. is currently negotiating with real estate interests in the San Jose, California area of the San Francisco Bay Area for locations to build five stores of a new and yet unnamed small format food retailing venture. The stores will be about 20,000 square feet, and it's believed will offer a wide variety of fresh, prepared foods in addition to groceries and other offerings.

We've also written much about Wal-Mart's research into two small store formats--one a small footprint grocery/food market and the other a small format health and wellness-oriented store, which would include a health clinic in-store. The mega-retailer had a team of executives working on the concepts in the San Francisco Bay Area for a number of months earlier this year. We expect some announcements as to what they might--or might not--do in terms of their small format retailing plans by early next year.

Other retailers like supermarket chain Giant Eagle are testing the small format food retailing waters. The chain, which operates primarily superstores and conventional supermarkets, has opened two Giant Eagle Express stores. The grocery markets are about 15,000 square feet and feature a mix of basic groceries, fresh produce and meats, and upscale offerings, including prepared foods, along with specialty, natural and organic groceries. The express markets also offer some standard convenience store items and have fueling pumps next door.

Further, supernatural grocer Whole Foods Market, Inc. plans to open a small format, convenience-oriented prototype store early next year in a former Wild Oats store in Boulder, Colorado. The grocer is currently remodeling the store into its Whole Foods Express prototype format. The express store will offer lots of prepared foods, especially convenient grab-and-go items. It's also expected to have a limited assortment of natural and organic groceries, fresh produce and meats. An in-store cafe also is likely.

Other food retailers are looking closely at the small format concept and thinking about whether or not it's something they should experiment with. And of course, the original small format food retailer, the neighborhood independent grocer, is smiling and thinking perhaps he was right all along.

We also must mention Pennsylvania-based Wawa Food Markets, which is the prime chain store innovator in the U.S. in terms of mixing convenience store-type retailing and more upscale grocery and specialty store merchandising into a single format.
For decades, Wawa has been successful in building a large chain of such hybrid stores throughout the eastern U.S. The retailer also is one of the early pioneers in offering quality prepared foods offerings in a convenience store setting. Its also one of the first chains to include larger than average grocery and perishables sections in its convenience stores, offering basic groceries at a decent price, compared to the normal convenience store retail prices in the category.

Hold on to your shopping carts folks. We're just seeing the beginnings of a small format food retailing revolution. The format's success on the no-frills, price-impact end is proven--and growing. Success stories like Wawa Food Markets and Trader Joe's--and the initial popularity of Tesco's first Fresh & Easy stores--are beginning to suggest that the small format hybrid food store concept also could become a big success at the middle-to-higher end of the spectrum as well.

Which retailer will be next to test the small format store retail waters; be it low-end, high-end, in the middle, or some combination of all three? We'll let you know. And, if you know of one--do let us know.

[To read numerous stories on the small format food retailing revolution search the blog using key words: Fresh and Easy, Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets, Small Marts, The Invasion of the Small Marts, Whole Foods Express, Whole Foods Market, Giant Eagle Express, Wawa Food Markets, Safeway Stores, Inc. and Small Format Food Retailing.]



Friday, April 18, 2008

New TNS Retail Forward Study Looks at What We've Called the Small-Format Grocery Store Retail Revolution in America and Quantifies Our Analysis


As regular Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) readers know, in August, 2007 we first suggested there was emerging the beginnings of a small-format grocery store retailing revolution occurring in the United States, in which major grocery chains were more-and-more getting into the game by creating and launching stores ranging in size from about 10,000 -to- 25,000 square feet, which is what we in the main define as small-format.

[Do a key-word search in the search box at the top of the blog using phrases such as small-format grocery retailing revolution, small-format grocery stores, small-format food retailing, Small Marts, small-format revolution, small-format stores, small-format food stores and small-format price-impact stores, (one phrase at a time of course) to get a sampling of those pieces. We also suggest reading through the NSFM archives for more pieces.]

We've sited the success in the U.S. of German Retailer Aldi, with its over 850 small-format, price-impact Aldi USA grocery stores, SuperValu, Inc.'s success with it's growing Sav-A-Lot small- format discount grocery chain, the Trader Joe's phenomenon, with the rapid-growth and high demand all over the U.S. for its specialty grocery stores, which now number well over 300, and the entrance into the Western USA by Tesco, with its small-format, convenience-oriented Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market grocery stores, as examples of this growing small-format grocery store revolution.

And that's not all. From August, 2007 to the present we've also sighted as evidence of a small format grocery store revolution in America, the fact that mega-retailer Wal-Mart has developed its very own small-format grocery store, it's 15,000 -to- 20,000 square foot Marketside banner, the first stores of which are set to open in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan region this summer.

Additionally, we've reported on and written about Safeway Stores, Inc.'s planned intrance into the small-format grocery store segment. Safeway plans on opening four or five 15,000 -to- 25,000 square foot combined grocery and fresh and specialty foods-oriented grocery stores this summer in the San Jose region in the San Francisco Bay Area.

Other players in this small format revolution we've written about include Pennslyvania-based Wawa Food Markets, which operates hundreds of hybrid small-format grocery markets-convenience stores in the Eastern USA, supermarket chain Hy-Vee, which recently opened its first small-format grocery store in Lincoln, Nebraska, supernatural grocery retailer Whole Foods Market, which has created Whole Foods Express, it new small-format store of about 20,000 square feet, the first of which is set to open soon in a remodeled former Wild Oats Market building in Boulder, Colorado.

These players are just the tip of the small-format grocery store retailing revolution in the USA of which we've reported on, written about and analyzed here in Natural~Speciatly Foods Memo.

Lastly, we've also written about the fact that the original small-format food retailer, the local independent grocer, continues to thrive in Americaby building and operating small-format grocery stores. That independent is in fact the model in many ways for the small-format revolution being created by this larger, chain operators.

International small-format grocery store revolution

Further, we've also said there's an international small-format grocery store revolution occurring. Many of the players are the same--with a few more added--internationally.

Tesco, with its rapidly-growing Tesco Express hybrid grocery store/convenience store chain and German grocery chains Aldi and Lidl are leading the international small-format grocery retailing revolution.

France's Carrfour, the second largest retailer in the world, is becoming a major player in the international small-format grocery store revolution as well, especially in Asia.

And of course, many other smaller players, as is the case in the U.S., are part of the growing small-format grocery store revolution throughout parts of the globe.

New TNS Retail Forward small-format grocery store study

It's seems we were somewhat on track beginning nearly ten months ago when we proclaimed a small-format grocery store revolution was occurring in the U.S., as well as in many other parts of the world.

A new study just released by the well-respected market research firm TNS Forward's Columbus, Ohio office says consumers are ready and willing to shop at small-format grocery stores that feature convenience in shopping and fresh, prepared foods.

The study also includes a caution which we use frequently in our pieces here at NSFM, which is that the jury is still out as to whether small-format grocery stores in general will meet consumer expectations, satisfy their needs as a primary or even secondary shopping venue, and provide a return on investment for the stores' owners.

The study also hits on three key points we make often about small-format grocery stores:

>Research: The study says food retailers considering a small-format grocery store strategy must monitor and analyze shopper needs, attitudes and expectations well in advance of launching a small-format store or chain.

>Localism: The report says paying attention and focusing on local (region and neighborhood) culture (and cultural differences) and demographics is key in launching any small-format grocery store venture.

>Partnering: The research study says retailer's launching a small-format grocery store venture need to seek input from grocery, fresh foods and consumer packaged goods suppliers and partners, as they have national knowledge as well as local experience, among other reasons for doing so.

The above three aspects of small-format grocery store retailing, which we summarize as research, localism and partnering, are themes we've been including in out numerous pieces on the small-format grocery store retailing revolution occurring in the U.S. and in other parts of the world for months.

U.S. Consumer attitudes about small-format grocery stores

The TNS Retail Forward study says 64% of U.S. shoppers surveyed said they would either definitely or probably shop at a small-format grocery store. [Based on our own research and some others we think that number is a bit higher.]

The study also notes consumers surveyed indicated the combination of the small-format (convenience), combined with fresh, prepared foods offerings is a compelling offer for "the time-pressed shopper."

Jennifer Halterman, a senior consultant at TNS Retail Forward and the primary author of the study says, "The small-store trend is part of an ongoing evolution in the retail food sector, and we expect more players to throw their hats into the ring."

We agree completely with the latter part of her quote--that more retailers are throwing, and getting ready to throw, their small-format grocery store retailing hats in the ring. I

In fact, we invite Ms. Halterman--and our readers--to stay tuned over the next couple of weeks as we will be reporting and writing about some new entrants into the small-format grocery store retailing revolution who nobody else has reported on yet. In fact, look for one or more of those fresh pieces later today, along with lots of upcoming analysis in the weeks ahead.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: The Small-Format, Neighborhood-Oriented Food and Grocery Retailing Trend Continues to Emerge and Grow in the U.S.

Giant Eagle, Inc's (supermarket chain) first Giant Eagle Express small-format, neighborhood-oriented food and grocery store in Harmonville, Pennsylvania is about 15,000 square feet. (Photo credit: Pittsburgh Post Gazzette.)

Neighborhood Food Retailing USA

We've been writing extensively about what we termed the "small-format food retailing revolution" in the United States, and what we call the "international small-format food retailing revolution," since we started Natural~Specialty Foods Memo in August, 2007.

In conjunction with our small-format focus, we've written extensively about what we have called a return to neighborhood food retailing in the U.S., which goes hand-in-hand with the re-emergence of smaller-format food and grocery stores in the country.

We've received lots of correspondence from the mainstream press about our small-format food and grocery store and neighborhood food retailing reporting, coverage and analysis, including from reporters from the New York Times, Los Angeles Times (and other U.S. papers), business publications and daily papers from Canada, Mexico, Europe and Asia, and other mainstream publications, along with Blogs.

It has been interesting to receive this correspondence.

What we've also started to notice is that the mainstream press has discovered what we've been writing extensively about for 15 months -- that small-format food and grocery retailing and neighborhood food retailing is indeed a growing trend in the United States.

For example, on October 3, the Pittsburgh Post Gazette ran this story, "Tight economy has shoppers, grocers looking to neighborhood stores." The piece, by staff writer Teresa F. Lindeman discusses many of the issues we've been writing about since last August in terms of the external and economic factors involved in the small-format grocery store trend in the U.S.

It also talks about Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, Wal-Mart's Marketside, Giant Eagle's Giant Eagle Express and SuperValu, Inc's Urban Fresh by Jewel" all small format chains, all which we've written about extensively.

And today, the Associated Press, which is syndicated to nearly every newspaper in the U.S., ran this feature story, Like shoppers' budgets, grocery stores shrink, which so far has been picked up and published by a number of American newspapers.

The AP piece also features a discussion of many of the issues we've been writing about, and suggested last summer would be occurring now, for the last 15 months regarding small-format food retailing in the U.S. and the greater focus on neighborhood markets.

Our analysis of the growing small-format food retailing trend in the U.S. isn't one that says smaller format, neighborhood grocery stores, which have never gone away completely in the U.S., are going to replace larger supermarkets and mega discount stores like Wal-Mart Supercenters, Costco club stores or Super Target combination food, grocery and general merchandise stores.

Rather our analysis is that the growing small-format trend, which is a unique event because major chains like Wal-Mart, SuperValu, Safeway, Tesco and others are driving it in the U.S., is a new layer of an old concept -- the independent neighborhood grocery store -- which is an American original.

Mega stores aren't going to go away. However, in our analysis fewer of such stores will be built and more smaller, neighborhood-oriented food stores will be built over the next decade.

We already are seeing evidence of this emerging. For example:

>Wal-Mart recently said it will built fewer of its combination food, grocery and general merchandise Supercenters (which average 180,000 square feet) next year and in 2010 than its original plans call for.

Wal-Mart also is building numerous smaller Supercenters and of course opened its first four small-format food stores, Marketside, in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan region on October 4.

>Target Stores has recently decreased the size of some of its new Super target grocery and general merchandise mega-stores, and in some cases even shrank the stores significantly and decided not to add the grocery side in a few cases.

>Costco is looking at building smaller club stores in urban areas like the store it has in San Francisco's South of Market neighborhood. This even includes the possibility of building smaller, multi-story Costco stores in large cities.

>Supernatural foods retailer Whole Foods Market, Inc. has decided to downsize a number of the new stores it has in development. The retailer also is questioning whether or not it will even continue to build and open any additional stores in the 60,000 -to- 80,000 square foot range, something it has done a lot of in the last five years, in the future.

Our analysis is that just as cars, houses, bank accounts, retirement fund portfolios and other key aspects of American life are getting smaller, and will continue to do so for most Americans for the next few years, so too in many cases will food and grocery stores trend towards getting smaller.

But although size does matter, it's not just smaller square footage that's important in this analysis. What is equally important is that the reason the small-format trend is here to stay for a significant number of years is that it's neighborhood-driven. In other words, small-format food stores aren't just growing in quantity and popularity because they are small. They are doing so because they are designed to serve as neighborhood markets -- just like the independents have done and continue to do in the U.S. -- although to a far-lessor degree today than in the past because of the emergence of the big box chain store.

This means a few things.

First, it offers a new opportunity for the big chains to create small-format operations in conjunction with their larger store operations. Doing this can provide some real cost savings for retailers like Wal-Mart, Tesco, Safeway and the others.

Second, it's our analysis the small-format food retailing trend provides a renewed opportunity for independent grocers to thrive in the U.S. Independents are the original small-format neighborhood grocers and still do it the best.

Third, we see the small-format, neighborhood food retailing trend providing a new opportunity for traditional convenience store operators.

These chains and independents sit right between convenient retailing and neighborhood food retailing, straddling that definitional fence. As such, they can create new formats, as many are currently doing, that are hybrid grocery and convenience stores.

This offers the c-store chains particularly a new way to broaden their offerings away from the traditional c-store staples of alcoholic beverages, cigarettes, gasoline and "gut buster-quality" ready-to-eat foods, all of which are declining categories, into a more diversified product category mix. Not closing their traditional c-stores but diversifying with a new format. Pennsylvania-based Wawa is a good model of a very successful hybrid convenience store/grocery store retailer.

There is still a long way to go in the small-format trend in the U.S. We are just seeing the beginning of it at present. Our analysis is that the neighborhood retailing aspect of the small-format trend will get even stronger and we will see various different formats, as we are beginning to see at present, emerge to serve neighborhood residents' food shopping needs.

We will be covering and analyzing the small-format and neighborhood food retailing trend, as we have been for the last 15 months, extensively. We may even have a couple more new terms to coin.

Monday, May 12, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Special Report: France's Carrefour Takes A Mega-'No-Frills' Approach With its 'Carrefour Express' Grocery Stores in Asia


France's Carrefour Group, the world's number two retailer in terms of sales after number one Wal-Mart, Inc., is taking a mega-"no frills" approach to the small-format Carrefour Express grocery stores it's opening throughout Asia.

As you can see in the photograph above, Carrefour's Express grocery stores in most parts of Asia look no different than a mom and pop neighborhood grocery store, nor are they any bigger, which is by design.

In fact, were it not for the large red, white and blue Carrefour sign on the grocery store, one would assume its just another family-owned Asian grocery market. Carrefour means junction in English.

The store in the photograph at the top of this story is located in Wangsa Maju Section 2 in Pand Indah, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. The small-format Carrefour Express neighborhood grocery store in an urban mixed residential and commercial neighborhood. Notice the businesses and apartments above the store, with the window-mounted air conditioners?

The Carrefour Express stores are designed to offer the basic essentials for neighborhood residents. The stores mostly stock food and grocery products, with a small selection of non-foods as well.

The petite grocery stores carry fresh fruits and vegetables. Some of the Express stores sell fresh meats and fish, others don't. It depends on the neighborhood the grocery market is located in.

The format is more than a convenience store model however, which there are many of in Asia, including in Malaysia.

The Carrefour Express' format is "grocery necessities at affordable prices," in a phrase. More than a convenience store but less than a larger supermarket. The stores' prices also are more in line with Carrefour's hypermarts and supermarkets rather than the same (meaning lower) than those at convenience stores in the region's neighborhoods.

Carrefour also operates huge hypermarts and large supermarkets throughout Southeast and Central Asia, in addition to le petite Express stores.

The small-format, convenience-oriented Express format is designed to fit with the French retailer's multi-format strategy. In urban and rural areas where hypermarts or supermarkets aren't appropriate, the group will locate a Carrefour Express grocery store, for example.

The small stores, which range from about 3,500 -to-10,000 square feet, are becoming an important part of Carrefour's urban retailing strategy throughout Asia. And, of course, in many large, highly-dense cities, where space is at a premium, the Express grocery stores allow the retailer to have a food retailing presence it cannot have with its larger stores. There's no room for the hypermarts or supermarkets in such urban regions and cities.

Carrefour Group operates various types of retail format stores throughout the globe. In addition to its home base in Western Europe, the retailing group has retail operations and stores in Eastern Europe, the Middle East, Africa, Central and Latin America.

Like number one Wal-Mart and Tesco, which is the world's number three retailer, Carrefour is a broadline retailer that sells everything in its stores (depending on the format) from food and groceries, to kitchen appliances, electronics, books, clothing and more.

Also like Wal-Mart and Tesco, the retailer operates a number of different formats, ranging from hypermarts, which it pioneered in retailing, to discount stores, supermarkets, Cash & Carry stores and the small-format Carrefour Express grocery markets.

Carrefour Group had sales of about $92.6 billion in 2007. By comparison, number three United Kingdom-based Tesco's 2007 gross sales were $69.6 billion.

U.S.-based mega-retailer Wal-Mart had 2007 sales of $312.40 billion, over three times that of Carrefour Group's. An interesting fact is Carrefour has nearly twice as many stores (about 12,190) globally as Wal Mart does. Wal Mart has about 6,420 stores in the U.S. and abroad. Tesco operates about 2,500 stores in the UK and internationally.

Carrefour plans to increase the number of its Carrefour Express stores in Asia, as the company reports they are doing well and fit a particular niche, as we described above.

As we first wrote last August, there's an international small-format food and grocery retailing revolution--as is there one in the United States--occurring, being led by the world's top retail chains.

Tesco is the leader in this retailing revolution with its Tesco Express grocery stores in Europe and soon to be in Russia, as well as its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small-format, convenience-style grocery stores in the U.S.

Wal-Mart will soon join the small-format grocery store retailing revolution when it opens its first 15,000 -to- 20,000 square foot Marketside grocery stores this summer in Phoenix, Arizona in the U.S.

And of course, Carrefour is increasingly becoming a major international player with its Carrefour Express small-format grocery stores.

That's the top three retailers in the world folks; all participants in small-format food and grocery retailing.

Joining these top-tier retailers in the small-format revolution are a numerous grocery chains of all sizes, shapes and form globally.

In the U.S., SuperValu, Inc., the number two supermarket chain in the nation, operates hundreds of small-format discount grocery stores under the Sav-A-Lot banner.

Safeway, the number three supermarket chain in the U.S., plans to introduce its first small-format grocery stores this summer in the San Francisco Bay Area. We haven't learned the name of the stores yet, but you can read our latest piece about the development here.

Lets not forget the Germans, Aldi and Lidl. Aldi is a small-format discount grocery store powerhouse, with stores in Europe, Australia and the United States. Lidl, Aldi's chief competitor in Germany, also is a European small-format discount grocery store powerhouse. It operates the powerful little discount stores throughout Europe, and is having a big impact currently on food retailing in the United Kingdom.

We expect to not only see the retailers mentioned above continue to open additional small-format grocery stores in the global and domestic regions in which they operate. We also suggest you will see many of these players expand out into other countries and markets with their small-format stores.

More new players are coming into the small-format food and grocery retailing arena as well. These include retailers like Whole Foods Market in the U.S., which soon will open its first 15,000 -to- 20,000 square foot Whole Foods Express store in Boulder, Colorado in the U.S.

Stay tuned. The international small format food and grocery retailing revolution may not be televised. But we cover it regularly, write about it often, and provide comprehensive analysis always here on Natural~Specialty Foods Memo.

Monday, January 7, 2008

Retail Memo: The International Small Store Format Revolution Marches On

As our regular readers are aware, we've been reporting on, writing about, and offering analysis on the international small format food retailing revolution for the last 4-5 months.

We've written about Tesco's Express stores in Europe, the retailer's new Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small store format in the USA, German grocer Aldi's no frills, price-impact, small format grocery markets throughout the world, and others.

Among the others include: U.S. grocer Giant Eagle's Express format stores, Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s Express prototype store soon to open in Boulder, Colorado, Wawa Grocery Markets, Trader Joe's, and Wal-Mart, which is developing two small format stores: a grocery market and a small footprint health and wellness-type store. (Check out the blog's archives for the numerous small format and related stories.)

We've termed the international proliferation of small format stores--some upscale, others no frills with price-impact positioning, and still others somewhere in the middle--no less than a revolution in food retailing.

This isn't because there haven't always been small food stores throughout the world. There has been. But rather it's because of the scale in which various retailers are developing the stores, the number of stores they are building, and the fact that those retailers getting into the small format food retailing business are among the largest chains in the world.

One of those retailers, Tesco, the third-biggest retailer in the world, is a key leader in multi-small format food retailing. It began with its Tesco Express stores in Britain, and is now locating the small format Express stores throughout Europe, and is planning to enter Russia with the convenience-style grocery markets soon.

Tesco also has opened about 30 of its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small format grocery markets in the U.S. thus far--in just a two month period of time. The retailer plans to have as many as 200 of the combination basic grocery markets, fresh, prepared and specialty foods stores opened by the end of this year.

Now, Tesco is at it again: The retailer is developing a new, no frills, price-impact, small format food store for the United Kingdom (UK). The reason the retailer is developing the new format is to counter a growing threat in its home market from German grocers Aldi and Lidl, which operate price-impact, no frills, small format grocery stores throughout the UK.

The Aldi and Lild stores are becoming increasingly popular with UK shoppers, who like their limited assortments, low prices and convenience. Tesco sees these stores as a major threat to its market share in the UK, and has decided to fight back.

According to a story in today's London Telegraph.co.uk, Tesco has been hard at work on a top secret project in an old warehouse owned by its founder Jack Farmer, designing the new format. The retailer has created a mock German small format discount store (read Aldi and Lidl) in the warehouse and is using it as a model for their own future no frills, small format discount stores.

Tesco used this same strategy and model in developing its Fresh & Easy convenience-oriented grocery markets in the U.S. For about two years the retailer worked on the design of what today is a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market in an old warehouse in the states. And just like the current project in Britain, Tesco was able to keep its Fresh & Easy project quiet for some time before the press got wind of it.

But the new discount grocery format project is out of the grocery bag now, so to speak. And, once again, we see the small format revolution marching even further on.

Based on the information we have from various sources--in addition to what was reported in the Telegraph.co.uk story--the new Tesco price-impact, small format market looks like it might be similar to its Fresh & Easy stores in the U.S.--a hybrid discount grocery store, combined with low-priced, upscale specialty groceries and prepared foods offerings.

This is largely do to the fact that Aldi, and to a lessor degree Lidl, have been doing extremely well in the UK offering specialty, gourmet and natural foods items at discount prices along with private label (and some national brand) basic groceries.

Aldi has especially become adept at this--no doubt in part because the German grocer has lots of experience with private label specialty items at its Trader Joe's subsidiary in the USA. Yes, it's that same Aldi. The one that operates 900 no frills grocery stores in the U.S., and upscale Trader Joe's as well. It's also the same Aldi that operates throughout the world, and is growing its small format, discount grocery business extensively worldwide.

Tesco, the UK's number one retailer, isn't about to let Aldi and Lidl take market share away from the company in the UK though, if it can help it. Therefore, it is developing its own version of these small, category-killer, discount grocery stores.

Further, Tesco isn't waiting until it has an actual store to fight back against the two German panzer divisions of grocery retailing. Beginning this week, the mega-retailer will match Aldi's and Lidl's retail prices on over 2,000 items the grocers' sell at hot, discount prices. (Aldi and Lidl sell on average about 10,000 grocery items in their small format stores respectively.)

Additionally, Tesco is launching this week a line of 300 no frills grocery products, similar to those sold in Lidl and Aldi's UK discount stores. Further, In a few months the retailer plans to rollout another 200 items in the no frills line. These items will be sold in all of Tesco's UK supermarkets. It's also expected that this will be a good test market for the items in terms of their merchandising potential in the future Tesco no frills, small format , discount food stores.

The small format food retailing revolution may not be being televised, but it's heating up throughout the world. Stay tuned.

Resources:
Read more about the Tesco's new no frills, small format, discount store plans here.
Read more about Tesco's new no frills product line here.

Thursday, March 20, 2008

Retail Memo: The Small-Format Grocery Store Revolution Marches On: Hy-Vee, Inc. Testing A Small-Format Grocery Store in Lincoln, Nebraska


As our regular readers know, we've been writing extensively about and offering analysis on what we term the small-format grocery store revolution among major food and grocery retailers in the U.S. We also refer to it as 'The invasion of the Small-Marts.' [If you type in small format grocery stores, small-format food retailing, small-format revolution and Small-Marts(one at a time of course) in the search box at the top of the blog, or search through our archives.

The major grocery retail players in this growing small-format grocery retailing revolution in the U.S. are: Aldi USA, the U.S. division of German grocery chain Aldi, which currently operates almost 900 10,000 square foot -to- 15,000 square foot discount grocery stores in the Midwestern and Eastern U.S. (27 states); Save-A-Lot, the small-footprint, limited assortment discount grocery store division of SuperValu, Inc.; and specialty grocer Trader Joe's, which is owned by Aldi.

Additional major small-format retail players include: Wawa, which operates hundreds of hybrid small-format grocery-convenience stores in the Eastern U.S.; Giant Eagle Supermarkets, which operates a handful of Giant Eagle Express small-format grocery stores and is building more, and Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, which has opened 59 small-footprint grocery markets in the last four months in Southern California, Arizona and Nevada and plans to build at least 150 more stores in the next two years.

Other key players in the small-format grocery store revolution include: Whole Foods Market, Inc., which is getting ready to open its first Whole Foods Express store in Boulder, Colorado; Wal Mart, Inc., which will open at least four of its new, small-footprint grocery stores called Marketside this summer in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan region; Safeway Stores, Inc., which plans to open five new, small-format grocery markets in the San Jose region of the San Francisco Bay Area this summer, and a couple others.

To this fast-growing list, we can now add West Des Moines, Iowa-based Hy-Vee, Inc. to the list of major grocery retailers entering the small-format food retailing world in the U.S.

Employee-owned Hy-Vee, which operates 223 supermarkets in seven Midwest states and had 2007 gross sales of $5.6 billion, is planning to test a small-format grocery store in the city of Lincoln, Nebraska, which is among other things home to the University of Nebraska. The small-footprint grocery market will go into a neighborhood where the retailer already has an existing supermarket but is closing this week.

Hy-Vee's small-format grocery store will average about 20,000 -to- 25,000 square feet. The store will offer a more limited selection of grocery and fresh food items than the chain's larger supermarkets do but will still merchandise all of the basic categories contained in its larger stores: dry grocery, fresh produce, fresh meat, dairy, perishables and the like, according to Richard Jurgens, Hy-Vee's CEO. In other words, the store will contain all the regular categories --including some specialty and natural foods, but just have a more limited assortment, which is the case with all of the major players--to one degree or another--in the small-format grocery retailing game.

The grocery chain, who's motto is "Where there's a helpful smile in every aisle," says its been studying different format options for some time, looking for concepts that would allow it to serve different neighborhoods which have different needs. The neighborhood where the first small-format grocery market will be located is called University place. It's near the University of Nebraska and contains a mix of students, faculty and University employees, along with residents who live in the neighborhood but work elsewhere in the city.

Hy-Vee, founded in 1930, is still finishing the design of the small-format grocery store, according to Jurgens. He says the retailer will provide further information soon. After the design in finalized and signed off on in the next month to six weeks, the grocery chain plans to submit the plans to the city of Lincoln, and once they are approved it will set the construction and grand opening schedule, Jurgens says.

CEO Jurgens says the retailer sees value in creating smaller-format grocery stores with limited assortments as part of its food retailing format arsenal. "It was important for us to come up with a format that would be intriguing, practical and successful. We think we've found one," he says.

The existing supermarket in the University Place neighborhood in Lincoln is set to close this Sunday. However, a new, much larger Hy-Vee supermarket will open just 2 miles away in about two weeks, Jurgens tells us. However, the grocer is still anxious to get the new, small-format market completed and approved so the grocer can serve the neighborhood more directly by having in store right in the heart of it.

Expect the Lincoln, Nebraska University neighborhood small-footprint market to offer a decent selection of specialty, natural and organic groceries (in addition to the limited assortment of supermarket basics), along with fresh, prepared foods, to fit the neighborhood's demographics, which includes a high percentage of college educated residents.

We haven't been able to find out the name--if it exists yet--of Hy-Vee's new small-format grocery market concept. However, we plan on keeping our ears out for it.

At 20,000 -to- 25,000 square feet, the Hy-Vee small-format concept is a bit larger than most of the others mentioned in the beginning of this piece. Aldi, Save-A-Lot, Trader Joe's. Wawa, Giant Eagle and Tesco's Fresh & Easy small-format stores all average about 10,000 -to- 15,000 square feet. However, Wal-Mart's Marketside, Safeway new small-footprint markets, and Whole Foods Express are all respectively about 15,000 -to-25,000 square feet, as we've reported before.

Ironically--or perhaps by design-- 20,000 -to- 25,000 square feet is about the average size of the neighborhood independent grocery store in America today. (Many range from 25,000 -to-about 35,000 square feet as well.) And, there are thousands of thriving small-format multi-store and single-store independents across the USA operating these smaller neighborhood grocery stores in the communities in which they live and work. It's these independents, really, who are the catalysts of the small-format grocery retailing revolution among major retail players currently happening in the U.S.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Retail Memo: Wal-Mart and Safeway Stores Could 'Box' Tesco in With New Small Format Stores

Analysis & Opinion: The small format food retailing revolution has just gotten even hotter in the Western U.S, with Wal-Mart Inc.'s plans to open its new MarketSide stores in Arizona. And in California, Safeway Stores continues with its plans to open new, small format stores in the San Francisco Bay Area. Meanwhile, Tesco is being pretty quiet about the new developments, but continues to open a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market store nearly every other week.

The news that mega-retailer Wal-Mart will build four (to start) 20,000 square foot grocery markets named "MarketSide" in the Phoenix, Arizona metropolitan region adds new, additional competitive pressures to Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small format stores.

These Wal-Mart "Small Marts," which at 20,000 square feet are about 5,000 to 7,000 square feet bigger than Fresh & Easy stores but half the size of the retailer's Wal_Mart Neighborhood Market format, are likely to be similar in format to British grocer Tesco's small format grocery markets.

Based on what we currently know--from published reports and additional information from our sources--the small format stores will offer a mix of basic groceries, prepared foods, and specialty items. This mix is similar to Fresh & Easy's. At this point, we aren't sure what else the "MarketSide" stores will merchandise, but are rather sure they will feature some version of this basic grocery, fresh foods mix, along with whatever else the stores will sell.

As out readers know, we reported recently that Pleasanton, California-based Safeway Stores, Inc. has secured leases in the San Francisco Bay Area region of San Jose for five new, small format stores the retailer plans to open later this year. While we don't yet know the name of these Safeway small format stores, we have fairly good information they too will offer a mix of basic groceries and prepared foods.

Neither of these developments are good news for Tesco's Fresh & Easy. Just two months ago, Fresh & Easy stood as basically the lone food chain pioneer in this hybrid small format, basic grocery/fresh foods merchandising arena. Had this remained the case, Fresh & Easy would have had plenty of time to rollout its numerous planned stores in California, Arizona and Nevada, perfected its format, and not had to share the media limelight with two powerhouse, US-based retailers--Wal-Mart and Safeway--as they are having to do now.

This won't be the case however. Wal-Mart's initial opening later this year of four stores in Arizona, all four in areas where there are Fresh & Easy stores, and Safeway's opening later this year of five stores in the San Jose region in Northern California, will put a competitive check on Tesco. (Tesco plans to start opening Fresh & Easy stores in Northern California later this year. The grocer also will build a distribution center in Stockton, in Northern California, to serve up to 50 stores in the region it wants to build in the next two years.

Both Wal-Mart and Safeway are major retail brand names. Safeway, which is based in Northern California, will have a major marketing advantage with its small format stores against Fresh & Easy. Safeway also already has all the supply-chain and marketing infrastructure in place to serve these new, small format stores. The grocer operates about 300 supermarkets in Northern California, including numerous stores in and around San Jose. It's corporate headquarters is about 30 miles from the San Jose region. It also has a distribution facility nearby.

Wal-Mart already has a number of Supercenters in Arizona, including in the Phoenix region where it will open the small format "MarketSide" stores. The chain, like Safeway has all of it's logistics in place, to say the least. As the world's largest company and retailer, Wal-Mart will have no problem matching Tesco on selection, price and marketing muscle. Arizona also is one of the best food markets for Wal-Mart. Opening it's first small format stores there is, in addition to going head-to-head against Fresh & Easy, a smart move in general for the retailer.

Like a game of chess on a chessboard, Wal-Mart and Safeway have the ability to box Fresh & Easy in: Wal-Mart in Arizona (to start) and Safeway in Northern California (to start). Safeway also has numerous supermarkets (over 400) in Southern California, where its Vons' stores are the number two food dollar market share leader, just behind Kroger Co.'s Ralph's. Further, the grocery chain also has a retail presence in Nevada.

Safeway already is looking to Southern California to possibly locate some of the new, small format stores, and can do so easily as it has the same fully-developed infrastructure it has in Northern California. (Safeway has this fully-developed supply-chain ability for the entire Western USA. For that matter, for the entire USA.)

Wal-Mart can go anywhere. The mega-retailer actually developed the "MarketSide" stores in the San Francisco Bay Area, where a team of executives spent months developing the format. Expect stores in Northern California (urban and suburban stores), Southern California and elsewhere. The global giant knows no geographical--or supply chain--limitations.

So, just a couple months ago, the United Kingdom's biggest grocer was sitting alone on top of the small format, hybrid grocery/prepared foods format in the U.S. Today, just a blink of the eye later, there are two major competitors--the world's biggest retailer, Wal-Mart, and the number one food retailer in the Western USA, Safeway.

The result of these two retail players getting into the game in the Western U.S. means Tesco's mission has just become even harder than it already was. Creating a completely new enterprise--Fresh & Easy, a new format, supply chain and all else, is hard enough in and of itself. For Tesco to now operate and grow the venture with Wal-Mart and Safeway on its heels will be in many ways an even bigger challenge that those original red-coated British invaders faced when they tried to rest the former colony away from a bunch of upstart Americans who wanted their own, sovereign country.

Tesco is good though, and they shouldn't be discounted. They've built their Tesco Express small format chain into the best in Europe. But Wal-Mart and Safeway are equally good, especially in their food retailing homeland. Of course, Wal-Mart isn't the most nimble of food retailers. It will be interesting to see if the mega-retailer can make the transition from big box, mass food retailing to small format, niche retailing. They've done so to a certain degree with their 45,000 square foot Neighborhood Market format. However, at best they have thus far earned a B- with that format.

Wal-Mart has just hired a veteran of UK food retailing, Jack Sinclair, to run its U.S. grocery operations. Sinclair isn't just any veteran of UK food retailing. He spent many years with Tesco, and knows the British retailer's operations (including small format) well. For those who think Wal-Mart is merely dabbling with the "MarketSide" format and stores, the hiring of Sinclair should lay those thoughts to rest.

Safeway has become as nimble a retailer that exists in the U.S. (and internationally for that matter) these days. The grocer has turned its retail business around with its upscale Lifestyle format. It continues to innovate with the format with its new stores, adding new departments and in-store features.

Safeway also has what is perhaps the most successful premium and organic store brand in the business today, with its O' Organics grocery and fresh foods brand. Think we might see some O' Organics brand products in the new, small format Safeway stores?

Safeway also owns an upscale restaurant in the San Jose area, and has been using it to develop innovative, fresh prepared foods items which we believe will find their way into these new, small format markets. The small format store business isn't something Safeway just thought of. The grocer started a research project targeting Tesco's Fresh & Easy venture at least two years ago, and has been working on its small format development program for at least that long.

As we've been writing about here for nearly six months, there is a small format food store revolution happening in the U.S.--and in Europe and Canada. Doing battle are not only Tesco, and now Wal-Mart and Safeway Stores, but a host of others. German grocer Aldi plans on building as many as 100 of its no frills, price-impact, small format grocery stores a year in the U.S. for the next few years. The retailer already has nearly 900 of the little, no frills discount grocery stores in the country. Aldi also owns California-based small format specialty grocer Trader Joe's, which is another major competitor for Fresh & Easy.

Giant Eagle supermarkets also is building more of its Giant Eagle Express small format stores, which are similar to a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market store.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. will open its prototype Whole Foods Express later this year in a former Wild Oats store in Boulder, Colorado. Look for these Express stores from Whole Foods to have lots of fresh, prepared foods items, especially grab-and-go, high-quality but convenient offerings. Also, don't be surprised if some of these Whole Foods' Express stores pop-up in California, one of the supernatural grocers best markets--and one of its top target regions for store development and growth over the next five years.

There's much more going on in this small format revolution. [You can read many of the pieces we've done by typing-in the key words: small format, small format revolution, small format retail food stores, small format grocers, Small Marts, Fresh & Easy and similar phrases in the search box at the top of the blog. Type just one phrase at a time in though. Also use the tags at the end of this piece as search words.]

Meanwhile, the small format revolution's battlefield is becoming a bit more complex--and more intense--for Tesco's Fresh & Easy.

Wal-Mart and Safeway, independently, are flanking the British grocer from two sides--Wal-Mart in Arizona, Safeway in California. We will see one or both of these retailers converge on the middle--Nevada--soon as well. Of course, the big battle, and the big market, is California, south and north. It's a state of nearly 40 million people, which is bigger than most European countries. We suggest you'll see Tesco, Wal-Mart and Safeway battling it out with small format stores in California beginning later this or in early 2009.

The revolution has just started though. Don't rule Tesco's Fresh & Easy out. But don't underestimate Wal-Mart and Safeway either, especially when it comes to not wanting to loose food dollar market share in their home country--and in Safeway's case, on it's home turf.

This revolution won't likely be televised. But we will continue to report on it and write about and analyze it here for our readers. Stay tuned.

Sunday, May 18, 2008

Small Format Food Retailing Special Report: Raising (the stakes in) Arizona: Wal-Mart On-Track to Open First Marketside Stores in Arizona This Summer


Wal-Mart, Inc. is on track to open the first four of its new small-format Marketside grocery stores in Arizona this summer. Natural~Specialty Foods Memo was one of the first publications to report and write about the development of Wal-Mart's small-format Marketside last year.

The mega-retailer has added an employment web page to its WalMart.com website to recruit store managers and assistant managers for the four 15,000 square foot Arizona stores, which will be in the cities of Chandler, Tempe, Mesa and Gilbert. You can view the website at: http://www.workformarketside.com/.

As Natural~Specialty Foods Memo described the Marketside format in our previous pieces, Wal Mart is positioning the 15,000 square foot food and grocery markets as being for consumers who "have a passion for fresh and delicious food."

As a result, the stores set to open this summer will offer a mix of basic food and grocery products across all categories, with an emphasis on fresh foods: produce, meats, cheeses, perishables of all kinds and most interesting, fresh, prepared foods prepared right in the stores.

The stores also will offer a limited but strong assortment of basic food and grocery products, including new store brands designed especially for the Marketside stores.

In fact, according to planning documents filed in Arizona, Wal-Mart plans to offer the in-store prepared foods for eating right in the store as well as to take home. The planning documents show in-store kitchens in the Marketside stores, along with food counters or eating bars and seating for about nine -to- 10 people at a time.

The Financial Times newspaper was the first to report this aspect of the Marketside stores on Thursday. Natural~Specialty Foods Memo confirmed it with our Arizona sources, who were among the first to tip us off last year about Arizona being the first U.S. region in which Wal-Mart would open the small-format grocery markets.

Our Arizona commercial real estate sources, who were right on before, also tell us Wal-Mart is searching for additional locations in Arizona for its Marketside stores, especially in the Phoenix Metropolitan region.

In-store venues mixes-up prepared foods game

Preparing fresh foods in-store, and including an in-store eating venue, really mixes-up what is currently the norm in prepared foods' category merchandising in the majority of small-format food and grocery retailing chain stores in the U.S. to date.

For example, although Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market grocery stores have as a major part of their offering the merchandising of lots of fresh, prepared foods; the ready-to-eat and ready-to-heat prepared foods items are all made at a central kitchen in Southern California. [Arizona, along with Southern California and Nevada, are the three market regions where Tesco currently has its 61, 10,000 -to- 13,000 average square foot Fresh & Easy combination basic grocery and fresh foods markets.]

Virtually none of the chain's operating small-format grocery stores--Trader Joe's, Aldi USA, SuperValue Inc.'s Sav-A-Lot, Safeway's new "The Market" small format, and others--prepare ready-to-eat foods in-store in a kitchen and offer "eat"-in seating for customers.

In the case of Safeway, as we reported on Thursday, the grocery chain opened its first "The Market" small format store, called the "Market by Vons," on Thursday in Long Beach, California. Although Safeway isn't preparing foods in-store, it owns a restaurant named Citrine in Redwood City in the San Francisco Bay Area, who's chefs created the prepared foods for sale in the "Market by Vons."

The fresh, prepared foods items, branded under the "World Cuisine" label, are prepared using the chefs' recipes at a central facility or kitchen, then distributed to the store, as they will be to all of Safeway's "The Market" format stores, which average about 15,000 square feet like Wal-Mart's Marketside format.

Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market also had chefs create the prepared foods recipes for its fresh & easy brand ready-to-eat and ready-to-eat items it sells in its small-format stores. The items are made in a large kitchen facility at the grocery chain's distribution center in Riverside County, California and then delivered to the stores in Southern California, Arizona and Nevada.

In-store prepared foods as a point of difference

Wal-Mart could be on to something by preparing the foods in-store rather than at a central commissary. Consumer surveys for years in the U.S., asking shoppers if they prefer in-store prepared foods or those prepared at an outside kitchen and shipped to the stores, have overwhelming shown a preference on the part of consumers for in-store prepared foods rather than those produced at a central commissary or kitchen and shipped to the stores.

Consumers say they believe in-store prepared foods are fresher, healthier and taste better than those from a central kitchen facility. They also say in the surveys they like the idea of knowing the prepared food items were prepared right in the store rather than outside and shipped in because that way they have a better idea as to the freshness of the product.

Having a kitchen along with seating in the Marketside stores also should add a better since of place and atmosphere to the small-format grocery markets, something Tesco's Fresh & Easy grocery stores are lacking in our analysis. It also could offer a significant point of difference for the Marketside stores, especially compared to Tesco's Fresh & Easy stores.

The in-store kitchen and seating area also should reinforce Wal-Mart's "freshness" and "quality" positioning for the Marketside stores, since generally preparing food in-store like Whole Foods' Market and many other upscale grocers do is a sign of a commitment to freshness, especially in terms of consumer perceptions.

Of course, the food prepared in the Marketside stores for eating in-store or taking home needs to taste good and be fairly healthy in terms of ingredients, otherwise in-store prepared vs. central kitchen prepared really becomes a moot point. Quality-control also must be high. After all, the kitchen is right there for all to see. Do it wrong or do it in a messy way and its a negative.

As we reported here, Wal-Mart's Marketside team did its initial research and development for the small-format food stores in the San Francisco Bay Area, spending time staying in the region and studying various successful upscale grocers' in-store prepared foods programs while there.

Team Marketside also met with a number of culinary professionals while in the bay Area, as well as doing so elsewhere, to discuss potential fresh, prepared foods concepts, ideas and strategies.

We've learned Wal-Mart retained a chef or two, we can't confirm they are from the Bay Area but believe so, to create the recipes for the Marketside menu, both the foods prepared in-store for eating there and those prepared in-store for take-out.

In other words, it appears Wal-Mart not only did its research, looking for best practices in in-store prepared foods operations, but also retained highly-trained, experienced chefs to create the recipes for the retailer's prepared foods program. It's going to be very interesting to see the quality level of the Marketside in-store prepared foods when the stores open in a month or two in Arizona.

We also know pricing in the Marketside stores, in dry grocery as well as fresh foods, is going to be discount and competitive. We've learned that although the grocery prices might be a bit higher than those in Wal-Mart's Supercenters, if so it won't be by much at all.

Additionally, the Marketside store prices will be no higher than those in the retailer's Wal-Mart Neighborhood market supermarkets, which at about 45,000 square feet are still three-times larger than the Marketside format stores.

Wal-Mart plans to introduce some new store brand grocery items when it opens the Marketside stores. These new private label products will be discount-priced. As we reported before, the retailer has trademarked two brand names, "City Thyme" and Field and Vine," which we expect to see on various food and grocery products when the Marketside stores open this summer. There could be other brand names as well.

Wal-Mart also is opening an office in Phoenix, Arizona, which the retailer will operate the Marketside stores from, which also indicates more units will be on the way. Retailers seldom open central offices for just four stores.
Going for market dominance in Arizona

That Wal-Mart chose the Arizona market to launch its new small-format Marketside stores is hardly an accident. Arizona is one of the retailer's top U.S. markets. It's also one of Wal-Mart's top U.S. growth markets.

Wal-Mart currently operates 60 Supercenters in Arizona, ranging from about 180,000 square feet -to- its two newest units which are over 200,000 square feet, including even more of that space devoted to selling food and groceries than earlier Supercenter format stores.

The brawny big-box (and now small-box as well) retailer from Bentonville (Arkansas) also operates 14 of its Sam's Club Warehouse stores, which sell lots of groceries and fresh foods, and 17 of its 45,000 square foot Neighborhood market supermarkets An the state.

Wal-Mart also has a couple more Supercenters in the works for the state, and has plans to open at least three more Neighborhood Markets this year and early next year.

We don't need to do the math for you; as you can add up, Wal-Mart has lots of food and grocery retailing square footage in Arizona, with more on the way, both with the additional Supercenters and Neighborhood Markets, and the four new Marketside grocery stores set to open before the summer is over.

Just add up all the current and coming on line food and grocery retailing square footage for Wal-Mart in Arizona. Even if Tesco were to open 100 more Fresh & Easy stores in the market, it wouldn't come close to matching Wal-Mart's total square footage.

Of course, Arizona also is the number two target market for Tesco, after Southern California, for its Fresh & Easy small-format grocery stores. The retailer currently has about 18 of the combination basic grocery and fresh foods markets in Arizona, with many more on the way.

However, although we believe Wal-Mart is likely to open more than the four initial Marketside stores in Arizona, the retailer isn't looking at a mass store rollout like Tesco is doing in the state with its Fresh & Easy.

[At a recent commercial real estate industry conference in Arizona, Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market said it believes Arizona has room for it to open an additional 100 of its small-format grocery stores in the state. We aren't real sure about that. In fact, we think the Arizona market is approaching "over-stored" status.]

After all, with Marketside, Wal-Mart will be conducting a multi-format food and grocery retailing strategy in Arizona: Supercenters, Wal-Mart discount stores (which also sell lots of food and grocery products) Neighborhood Markets and Marketside. Therefore, we believe the retailer will use the Marketside format more strategically in the Arizona market in conjunction with the other formats it operates in the state.

Wal-Mart also recently opened its first store dedicated entirely to Hispanic consumers in Texas. Since Arizona has one of the highest per-capita Hispanic or Latino populations in the U.S., don't be surprised if Wal-Mart adds this other new format to the mix in Arizona. [Read our piece on Wal-Mart's new Hispanic format store here.]

Marketside & Fresh & Easy

However, it's important to note all four of the initial Arizona Marketside stores are being located near existing Tesco Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores. While Wal-Mart says the Marketside format is merely an evolution in ongoing new format development for the retailer, the stores basic grocery and fresh foods positioning--with a few twists like the in-store prepared foods--also is directly aimed at Tesco's Fresh & Easy.

And Wal-Mart's initial location targeting could be tough for Tesco's fledgling Fresh & Easy chain, especially in Arizona where it now won't only be faced with competing against Wal-Mart's Supercenters and Neighborhood Markets (a number of which are close to Fresh & Easy stores as well) but also the myriad of other grocers in what is arguably today the most competitive food and grocery retailing market in the U.S.

Along with Wal-Mart in the Arizona market, there's hometown-based Bashas, Safeway Stores' Arizona division, Albertsons, Trader Joe's, Whole Foods Market, Sprouts Farmers Markets, Sunflower Farmers Market, and a host of others including some very competitive independents and and ethnic grocers. It seems to us there's only so much "share of stomach" in any market, and it will be interesting to see if all these players can survive in Arizona.

As we've written before, in addition to possibly putting Tesco on the ropes, Marketside offers Wal-Mart a host of other win-win options.

For example, it allows the retailer a format it can pop into places where getting one of its Supercenters approved by a county or city is impossible, or will require a big fight.

Marketside also gives Wal-Mart an urban format. For example, it can now have a food and grocery retailing presence in cities like San Francisco and urban Los Angeles in California, New York City and Boston on the east coast, and elsewhere (Seattle, Denver) where urban density (and often politics) prohibits a Supercenter, and in many cases even a Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market, from being located.

For example, the city of Chicago just last week shot down plans Wal-Mart had to build a Supercenter in the city. We doubt the city of Chicago would be as likely to deny Wal-Mart a permit for a 15,000 square foot (or numerous 15,000 square foot) Marketside grocery stores in the city, especially in the inner-city where there is a shortage of grocery stores.

Wal-Mart isn't using the Wal-Mart name on Marketside, like it does with all of its other formats. This is by design, as the retailer believes it will do better with the small-format, more upscale stores by branding them merely Marketside, sans the Wal-Mart name.

Interestingly, Tesco doesn't use "Tesco" at all in regards to its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small-format USA venture: not in the name, in the branding, or even in its press releases. This is the opposite of what the United Kingdom-based international retailer does in the rest of the world, where it uses and associates the Tesco name in all its retail formats, like "Tesco Express," Tesco Extra," and the like.

On the other hand, Safeway is using the "Safeway" name and brand prominently in its new small-format food retailing venture. It's 'The market" format co-brands the region's chain banner with the "Market" name. For example, the first store which opened in Long Beach, California last Thursday is called the "Market by Vons." Safeway operates Vons-banner stores in the region. All "The Market" format stores in Southern California will be named the "Market by Vons."

In Northern California, the Pacific Northwest, Arizona, Colorado, and the Washington D.C.-Maryland-Virgina tri-state region where Safeway's stores fly under the "Safeway" banner, the stores will be named the "Market by Safeway." In other Safeway market regions the stores will go by whatever banner the retailer operates in that given region: "The Market" by...Dominick's, Genuardis, Carrs, for example.

Small-format food and grocery retailing revolution marches on

Last year, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo proclaimed there is a small format food and grocery retailing revolution going on in the United States. Some people said that was an exaggeration. We politely told them to wait and see.

Well, the largest corporation and retailer in the world as well as in the U.S., Wal-Mart, is now a participant in the small-format food retailing game in its home country of the U.S., with its 15,000 square foot Marketside stores soon to open in Arizona. (Wal-Mart has operated small-format stores, not Marketside but somewhat similar, for some time now in parts of Latin America.)

Additionally, the world's number three retailer, Tesco, is staking much of its reputation and cash on its Fresh & Easy USA small-format grocery retailing venture.

Further, the number two--SuperValu, Inc.--and number three--Safeway Stores, Inc.--supermarket chains in the U.S. are participants in the small-format food and grocery retailing revolution in in the U.S. SuperValue, with its small-format discount Sav-A-Lot chain and Safeway, with its new "The Market" format venture.

If that's not enough evidence, major small-format players include Wawa Markets in Pennsylvania, which has been a successful operator of hundreds of small-format hybrid convenience/grocery stores featuring lots of fresh, prepared foods along with basic groceries for decades.

Then there's Aldi USA, with nearly 900 small-format discount stores in the USA, and plans to build up to 100 new stores per-year over the next five years. [Aldi doesn't mess around with banners. It's uses Aldi on its small-format stores throughout the world.]

Whole Foods Market, Inc. also is entering small-format retailing with its Whole Foods Express format, which will feature lots of fresh, prepared foods, along with natural and organic products in a 15,00 -to- 20,000 square foot format store. The first Whole Foods Express store is set to open soon in a converted Wild Oats natural foods market in Boulder, Colorado.

The small-format food and grocery store retailing revolution might not be televised, but its happening anyway. And, we are covering it completely, and regularly. Stay tuned.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Giant Food Stores To Open its First Small-Format, Hybrid Convenience-Grocery Store: 'Giant To Go'


Carlisle, Pennsylvania-based Giant Food Stores (also known as Giant-Carlisle) is planning to join the small-format food and grocery retailing revolution in the U.S. with its first small-format, convenience-oriented grocery market, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has learned.

Giant Food Stores, which is owned by the the Dutch supermarket company Royal Ahold just as its sister company, Landover, Maryland-based Giant Food is (the chains are operated separately though), plans to build its first Giant To Go combination convenience and grocery store, which will be 4,442 square feet, at a new retail development called Richmond square at the northwest corner of Fruitville Pike Road and route 722 in Landcaster, Pennsylvania.

The small-format hybrid convenience and grocery store will be the first of its kind for Giant Food Stores, which operates about 140 supermarkets under the Giant Food Stores, Martin's Food Markets and Foodsource banners in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia and West Virgina. Royal Ahold owns chains that operate about 700 supermarkets in the U.S.

At 4,422 square feet, the Giant To Go market actually is in part what we define as a micro small-format food and grocery store (under 5,000 square feet), although because it will be part traditional c-store (which at 4,422 would be as large or larger than an average one) and part grocery store, we will call it small-format.

The c-store cum grocery store will feature fresh produce and meats, a deli which will include grab-and-go ready-to-eat and some ready-to-heat prepared foods, an in-store fresh bakery and an assortment of basic shelf-stable food and grocery items, along with some of the food and non-food products typically associated with traditional c-store merchandising.

The 4,422 square foot hybrid convenience and grocery store also will have an 8-pump gasoline fueling station outside.

A Giant Food Stores' spokesperson said the Giant To Go store is a prototype for the chain. If it's successful the company is likely to build more of the stores in its market regions.

Construction of the Giant to Go small-format combination convenience and grocery store at the Richmond Square retail development -- which is a "village -style" designed 30,000 square foot retail and residential mixed-use development featuring stores and offices on the ground level and apartments on top -- hasn't started yet.

However, the Giant Food Stores' spokesperson told Natural~Specialty Foods Memo plans call for construction to start soon, with a target opening date for the store by the end of the first quarter of 2009.

Other retail tenants in the new Richmond Square center will include a bank, two restaurants (Asian and Italian), a dry cleaners and a couple others, along with the office buildings, according to its developer.

The Richmond center is a part of a larger development at the location. That development includes single family homes as well as additional retail and office space.

Giant Food Stores' new Giant To Go combination convenience store-grocery store format fits into what we classify as the "hybrid grocery-convenience store format."

It's a cousin to but different than small-format grocers like Tesco's Fresh & Easy, Safeway's "The Market," Aldi, Sav-A-Lot, Wal-Mart's Marketside, Trader Joe's and Giant Eagle's Giant Eagle Express, for example. It's closet to Giant Eagle Express, which unlike the others listed above adopts some elements of traditional c-store merchandising in its concept. All of the formats listed above are convenience-oriented though, which is an element they too borrow from c-store retailing.

Giant To Go also is different than what we've termed the small-format "eco-convenience" or Econvenience hybrid convenience-grocery stores. These stores which we've written about --such as Green Spot and Conscious Convenience -- combine elements of c-store retailing and grocery retailing but also take major elements from natural products retailing, having a "green" or environmental focus to the stores.

Wawa food stores is a good example of a store we think Giant Foods' Giant To Go is likely to emulate in many ways. As we've written about, Wawa is a hybrid convenience and grocery market which puts a major merchandising emphasis on fresh foods -- produce and prepared foods particularly -- along with selling basic groceries and specialty items. The stores also have fueling stations and sell some traditional c-store items as well. Interestingly, Wawa is based in Pennsylvania just like Giant Foods Stores is.

Another example is Parker's Convenience Stores, which we wrote about earlier this week.

We simply call these chains -- Wawa, Parker's and a few others -- hybrid, upscale convenience and grocery markets or stores. This is where we think Giant to Go will fit in the small-format, convenience-oriented food and grocery retailing revolution happening in the U.S. and elsewhere globally.

Giant Food Stores has developed numerous upscale design and merchandising features for its Martin's Food Markets banner (and its newer Giant banner supermarkets), including attractive upscale-looking departments like produce, deli/prepared foods and bakery, along with top-quality natural-specialty foods, fresh meat, produce and prepared foods merchandiing programs. As a result, it can export this expertise to Giant to Go in whatever doses it thinks are appropriate.

Dutch Royal Ahold-owned Giant Food Stores of Carlisle, Pennsylvania is now joining the other participants in this revolution with its new Giant to Go format. It seems "GIANTS" are even going small (format). Stay tuned, as there will be many more new entrants to the party.