Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Whole Foods Bay Area. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Whole Foods Bay Area. Sort by date Show all posts

Saturday, October 27, 2007

Tesco Fresh & Easy Update: News & Analysis

New Retail Regions: Tesco Aggressively Seeking Fresh & Easy Store Sites in Northern and Central California

On Friday, October 19 we reported here that Tesco had secured its first store location in Northern California in the Bay Area city of San Jose. That store will be located in a former Albertsons supermarket building in San Jose's Willow Glen district.

According to commercial real estate and municipal official sources we talked to, Tesco will completely renovate the building to decrease it's square-footage and make it suitable for its 10,000 to 13,000 square-foot Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format. These sources also told us plans call for the store to open in the summer of 2008.

Talking with the same and additional sources in the San Francisco Bay Area yesterday (10-26), we learned Tesco is aggressively looking for Fresh & Easy store sights throughout the nine-county Bay Area (including in San Francisco), as well as in other Northern California regions and in the Central Valley, which is located mid-way between Southern California and Northern California.

In addition to the San Jose location, which is a done deal according to our sources, Tesco has inquired with the East Bay Area city of Danville's Economic Development Department about possibly locating a Fresh & Easy store in that city's Green Valley Shopping Center. The shopping center in the upscale, high-income community, is currently without an anchor retail food store since an Albertsons supermarket closed there in 2006.

Jill Bergman, Danville's economic development director, recently said Tesco has talked to her about tenant improvements to the center's vacant Albertsons store but hasn't filed any applications regarding the store as of yet. Commercial real estate sources also told us Tesco has been talking with the building's owner and shopping center representatives about locating a Fresh & Easy store there.

Our commercial real estate sources also told us Tesco is busy looking in other cities in the East Bay Area, including Pleasanton, Livermore, Walnut Creek, Concord and others. They also told us Tesco is interested in a number of other empty Albertsons store buildings in that region as well as in the South Bay Area, where San Jose is, and the San Francisco Peninsula county of San Mateo.

A commercial real estate agent in San Francisco told us he recently talked to a business associate who said Tesco representatives told him they plan on opening more than one Fresh & Easy store in the city of San Francisco if they can find suitable locations in the dense, urban city.

The Bay Area and other Northern California regions aren't the only areas north of Southern California where Tesco is aggressively looking to locate store locations for its Fresh & Easy convenience-oriented grocery markets.

Last week, the Bakersfield Californian newspaper reported that Tesco is in serious negotiations with a property management firm to locate a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market in Southwest Bakersfield, at a shopping center at White Lane and Buena Vista Road, south of the city's Stockdale High School.

Bakersfield is located in the center of California in Kern County, about a 100 miles from Los Angeles to the south, and about 250 miles from Sacramento to the north. Tesco wants to locate the store at that particular location and has a zoning change application before the Bakersfield City Council. The change of zoning would allow retail food stores to locate in the shopping center (which currently isn't the case for some reason) and pave the way for the Fresh & Easy store there, according to the newspaper report.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo's Analysis:

If Tesco moves aggressively into Northern California--which we believe it will based on our information and analysis--it will add an interesting competitive twist to food retailing in the region, especially in the Bay Area, which currently is home to about seven million residents.

Safeway Stores, Inc. has its U.S. corporate headquarters in the Easy Bay Area city of Pleasanton and is the food retailing market share leader in the nine-county Bay Area. Recently, Safeway has been opening up very upscale versions of its "Lifestyle" format Safeway banner stores in the Bay Area. These new stores average about 45,000 to 65,000 square-feet in size and feature numerous prepared foods offerings, including in-store restaurants, cafes with fresh baked goods and gourmet coffee, wine departments with tasting bars, gourmet olive bars, and other upscale features. Huge selections of specialty and natural groceries and expansive fresh produce departments also are part of the mix in these stores.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. also is a major upscale player in the Bay Area with about 21 stores at present. The retailer has opened three new, large natural foods lifestyle-oriented supermarkets in just the last two months, with more new stores on the way. The supernatural grocer plans to built at least 21 new stores in the next 3-5 years in the Bay Area. Upscale quality, prepared foods are a major feature in Whole Foods' Bay Area stores, like they are in Tesco's Fresh & Easy format stores.

The Bay Area also is home to numerous upscale multi-store and single store independent retailers. Many of these grocers have been national pioneers in upscale, natural and specialty foods retailing. Among these independents are Mollie Stones Markets, Andronico's, Lunardi's, Draeger's, Cosentino's, Zanotto's, Berkeley Bowl, and a number of others. All offer high quality prepared foods in their stores, which are collectively located all over the nine-county Bay Area.

Tesco's Fresh & Easy format has some major differences from these upscale supermarket and supernatural foods retailers however, despite the fact that prepared foods play a major positioning point in what all of them do. First, the Fresh & Easy format is smaller--about 10,000 square-feet--and designed to bridge the gap between huge superstores and traditional convenience stores.

Second, It's upscale, but also offers basic groceries and non-foods offerings. Fresh & Easy stores also will have fresh produce and meats, perishables of all kinds and other offerings one would expect in a neighborhood grocery store. This helps them in that they can supply basic needs to shoppers (like all the supermarkets mentioned above do) and not become just a tertiary retailer in the region.

Lastly, Fresh & Easy is non-union. All of the major supermarket chains and independents in the Bay Area (except Whole Foods and Wal-Mart) are union shops. The average retail clerk, with one year's full time experience (journey level), makes about $20.00 per hour in wages and has a full health benefits package which adds another $10-$12.00 an hour to their compensation in terms of the high-quality value of their benefits package.

However, like Whole Foods and Wal-Mart (which has only a handful of Supercenters in the region), Tesco's Fresh & Easy will be a non-union shop. With the exception of management staff, all of the retail associates in the Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores set to open in Southern California, Nevada and Arizona, will be part-time. They will work at least 20 hours a week and no more than about 35 hours a week. Their average salary will be $10.00 hour, according to Tesco. Fresh & Easy store's part-time associates will have a health care policy but it will be nowhere near as good as what the unionized supermarket retail clerks have. In fact, the union retail clerks health policy is one of the best in the U.S.

We suspect Tesco to basically try to maintain their current employment policy and wage structure for Northern California, although the retailer likely will have to increase the hourly wage by at least two or three dollars an hour in order to attract employees in the Bay Area, which has a very low unemployment rate, and was recently ranked number one as the region with the highest salaries in the U.S. The Bay Area is a much more competitive labor market than Southern California, Nevada and Arizona are.

Even if Tesco has to pay two, three or four dollars an hour more, it's still at an advantage from a labor standpoint compared to the unionized retailers. Of course, the Bay Area is a heavy union region, and shoppers support union supermarkets like Safeway, Lucky Stores, the independents mentioned above, and others who pay their employees well. In fact, it's likely Tesco will be welcomed to the Bay Area with an organized campaign against their lower wages. There is such a campaign currently going on in Southern California against Tesco but its fairly small. Expect a larger, better organized campaign in the Bay Area, which is the most liberal region in the U.S.

Either way, established Bay Area retailers like Safeway and Whole Foods won't sit back and let Tesco take significant market share with its Fresh & Easy stores in the region. In fact, Safeway CEO Steve Burd has already said the chain is studying Tesco's format and is prepared to open its own Safeway convenience-type stores if the retailer believes Tesco is becoming a threat with its Fresh & Easy format in the Western U.S.

Whole Foods also is in the process of converting a former Wild Oats store in Boulder, Colorado into a new retail concept for the grocer called "Whole Foods Express." We think this development is in part a reaction to Fresh & Easy. We also believe Whole Foods won't hesitate to roll its "Express" stores out in places like the Bay Area and Southern California if they determine Tesco is taking market share from them with its upscale, convenience-type stores.

Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format could do very well throughout the Bay Area and elsewhere in Northern California however. In the Bay Area's suburbs there's a huge base of time-pressed dual income families who like the concept of being able to get fresh, prepared foods, fresh produce and meats, basic, specialty and natural groceries in a fast and convenient way, without having to shop a large store.

In both the suburbs and cities like San Francisco, Oakland and San Jose, there also is a large, single professional population who doesn't cook often or at all and spends a sizable amount of their disposable incomes at restaurants and for prepared foods to go.

Trader Joe's has markets throughout the Bay Area and Northern California and is adding more stores at a rapid clip. Their smaller store, upscale format is very successful in the region. The Bay Area also is a "foodie" region. Its consumers have an appreciation and like for quality foods, and if Tesco is able to offer the same quality upscale fresh, prepared foods at its Fresh & Easy markets as it does at its stores in the UK, the offerings should go over well with the region's quality food loving population, helping to make Fresh & Easy stores a success.

Fresh & Easy Store Opening Update

Coming Up: The first six Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets will open at 10:AM on November 8 in Southern California cities of Los Angeles, Anaheim, West Covina, Upland, Arcadia and Hemet. Five Fresh & Easy markets will opn in the Las Vegas metropolitan area on November 14. On November 28 another store will open in the Orange County (Southern California) of Laguna. Stores will open in Arizona before the year is over, as well as additional Fresh & Easy markets in Southern California (including San Diego) and Nevada.

A Little Background Reading: This article from today's (10-27-2007) London Daily Telegraph newspaper talks about the numerous British retailers of all types who have ventured to the U.S., only to fail. As the article says, "The U.S. has long been a graveyard for UK retailers." However, in the piece Tesco says it will be different than all of the others who've ventured into the U.S. retail market, only to fail and close shop. The story provides some good background to our piece.



Thursday, August 16, 2007

End of Week Natural~Specialty Foods Roundup

News, Information and Analysis:

Important information for specialty foods importers...The issue of food importation has been heating up of late do to a number of products from Asia found to be failing to meet U.S food standards. To address this issue and discuss food importation issues in general, the Association of Food Industries (AFI), a trade association serving the food import trade, will be sponsoring a meeting in Washington, D.C. next month, September 25-26 at the Double Tree Hotel. The two-day meeting will discuss pending legislation, U.S. food standards for imported foods, new and pending regulations, and what importers can do to protect their interests, according to the AFI. Additional information can be found here:http://afi.mytradeassociation.org/

It's all in a name...Save Mart Supermarkets, Inc. Modesto, Calif.., which purchased the Northern California Albertsons banner stores earlier this year from private investment firm Cerberus Capital Management, LP., made a decision last month to re-brand all of it's Albertsons stores in the Bay Area Lucky Foods. The Lucky banner once was a very strong brand in the Bay Area..When then Boise-Idaho Albertsons, Inc. bought American Stores, Inc. in the late 1980's Albertsons changed the Lucky store banners to the Albertsons. name.

The majority of Save Mart's stores are located in the Central Valley, from Stockton in the north to Bakersfield to the south. Prior to buying the Bay Area Albertsons banner stores the chain only had a handful of it's Save Mart banner stores in the Bay Area. As a result, after running the Bay Area Albertsons banner stores for a few months, Save Mart did an analysis and decided to bring back the Lucky banner for these stores. The Lucky name was a part of the equity in the sale of the Albertsons stores to Save Mart.

Not everybody agrees the Lucky name was included in the sale however. Prior to Save Mart buying the over 200 Northern California Albertsons stores, a Bay Area discount grocery chain, Berkeley,Calif-based Grocery Outlet, put the Lucky name on a new store they built in the Bay Area. The store was a different format than Grocery Outlet's traditional ones. The grocer wanted a different name to differentiate it form the other format. Grocery Outlet argues that Albertsons had abandoned the Lucky name and trademark by never using it in the Bay Area after buying Lucky Stores, Inc. from American Stores, Inc. Grocery Outlet also got an initial ok from a local court to use the banner.

Meanwhile Save Mart strongly believes they own the Lucky name along with everything else they paid good money for in the Albertsons Northern California division purchase from investment firm Cerberus. As such Save Mart has started re-branding the Bay Area Albertsons stores with the Lucky banner, including some new design schemes--store colors, graphics and the like--which go with the Lucky store signage.

Meanwhile Grocery Outlet CEO Eric Lindberg says his company will press on with a court case against Save Mart. Lindberg says Grocery Outlet has already won the rights to Lucky corporate product brands like Lady Lee, Harvest Day, and Key Buy, and that the company is in the process of releasing products for their stores under these brands. These brands were very respected by Bay Area consumers for the decades Lucky Stores operated supermarkets in the Bay Area. Lucky Stores, Inc. was the number two market leader in the Bay Area for years, right behind Pleasanton, Calif.-based Safeway Stores, Inc.

Analysis
This current dispute between Grocery Outlet and Save Mart shows the power--or potential power--of a brand. It also shows a brand can be strong enough that companies will feel like it should be brought back and used even though it has been absent from the market place over a decade.

Frankly I'm not sure the Lucky brand has that significant of brand equity at present. Many of today's Bay Area consumers were very young when the Lucky banner was having it's best consumer response. These key consumers are more interested in things like natural foods, specialty items, in-store food-service, and takeout and the like than they are the name of a store. They also have no personal brand identity to the Lucky name.

Many older Bay Area shoppers will likely have a connection to the Lucky brand. However, since the Lucky brand vanished from Bay Area food retailing, there have been many changes in the market. For example, Safeway Stores Inc. has greatly improved their stores and solidified their market share. Costco, Inc. has opened numerous club stores throughout the Bay Area. These stores feature extensive grocery product selections, specialty foods, natural foods, and upscale prepared foods selections. Target has opened large stores in many Bay Area communities which feature large grocery departments. Whole Foods Markets, Inc., which was a minor player in the market as little as 10 years ago, is now a major player with almost 20 supernatural superstores in the Bay Area, and more on the way.

Ordering groceries online also has become popular in the Bay Area. Safeway Stores, Inc. offers online ordering and delivery to a shoppers front door. Albertson's offered the same service on a more limited geographical basis prior to the stores being purchased by Cerebus, and then sold by Cerebus to Save Mart. However that service was eliminated when Cerebus bought the Northern California Albertson's division. This gives Safeway Stores, Inc. a market advantage with the internet savvy Bay Area shoppers as they are the only grocer currently in the market with an online/delivery operation.

The Bay Area market has grown, diversified, differentiated itself in retail grocery marketing terms, and changed considerably since the Lucky banner was in it's glory. As such it will be interesting to observe the level of brand equity the Lucky banner actually has when it is flying again on a significant number of stores. Obviously two grocery companies think it will be significant as one is willing to go to court to get the brand away from the other. Right now for both of these retailers it is all in a name.

More Natural~Specialty news, information and analysis:

Whole Foods probs leak of FTC proprietary information...Yesterday in our mid-week roundup we reported that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) had released documents which detailed some of Whole Foods' plans, ideas and strategies regarding their buyout of competitor Wild Oats Markets, Inc. Generally such information is considered proprietary to a company--they have to disclose it to the FTC but the FTC is not supposed to publicly release it. As such Whole Foods is launching a probe into why the FTC released this information and related issues. This story from Progressive Grocer describes Whole Foods' probe.
http://www.progressivegrocer.com/progressivegrocer/headlines/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003626801

Speaking of Whole Foods...The current issue (July-August, 2007) of Stanford Magazine, the Stanford University alumni publication, has a profile of Whole Foods' Co-President Walter Robb. Robb is a Stanford alum. In the profile, titled Green Grocer, Robb talks about his life in the natural foods business, Whole Foods, the current state of the industry, organic and buying local, and other topics. Robb is a natural foods industry veteran and the piece is a good read both from an overall industry perspective and a personal one as well . http://www.stanfordalumni.org/news/magazine/2007/julaug/features/robb.html

Consumer Report.: Personal politics can influence food choices...An estimated 1-3 Americans choose to not eat meat. For many of them the choice has to do primarily with their personal politics. This August 14, 2007 Reuters story by Terri Coles discusses the intersection of personal politics and food choice and how some consumers make it an issue, deal with it, and in other cases balance their personal politics and food choices.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20070814/hl_nm/humane_farming_dc;_ylt=AtuVgUXzD6X89yNT2lrO13sQ.3QA
Specialty and gourmet foods research...Global Information Inc., a research firm specializing in the food industry, is offering a number of research reports focusing on various aspects of the specialty and gourmet foods industries and individual product categories. Some of their research reports are on specialty and gourmet retailing, product marketing, analysis of various gourmet foods categories, fresh foods, local foods, and much more. Information about who they are and what they offer the industry is available at their website linked below.
http://www.the-infoshop.com/topics/FD30_en.shtml
Canada's ethnic and specialty foods expo...Canada's premier specialty foods show, the Ethnic & Specialty Expo, will be held September 30-October 1, in Toronto. The ethnic & specialty show also features a natural foods pavilion called the "All Things Organic" pavillion. This combination of specialty, ethnic and natural foods under one roof demonstrates the growing convergence of all these sister industries. More information on the show http://www.ats.agr.gc.ca/events/4353_e.htm
Best merchandising ideas 2007...The current issue of Gourmet Retailer Magazine has a feature on what it's editors and writers feel are some of the best specialty and gourmet foods and related products merchandising ideas thus far in 2007. There are numerous merchandising ideas detailed in the feature as well as practical ideas for retailers and others which can be used on a regular basis in-store. The link to the feature is below:
http://www.gourmetretailer.com/gourmetretailer/magazine/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003622985



















Wednesday, May 21, 2008

Retail Memo: Whole Foods Getting Small (er) With Two New Stores in Northern California to Be Located in Vacant Supermarket Buildings

Santa Cruz's historic and famous Beach-Boardwalk turns the city of about 60,000 into a community many times that size from late spring to the end of summer when tourists from California and thorughout the U.S. flock to the seaside resort community to play, shop and eat.

Mega-supernatural foods retailer Whole Foods Market, Inc. is departing from its practice in recent years of building primarily big and super-big new stores in the 55,000 -to- 80,000 square foot range throughout the U.S.--and especially in California--in the coastal Northern California cities of Santa Cruz and Capitola, where it's currently developing smaller-footprint 32,000 square foot (Santa Cruz) and 23,800 square foot stores (Capitola).

The two stores also will be located in currently vacant, former supermarket buildings, something Whole Foods has done in the past but not often, as it prefers building stores from the ground up.

In fact, the Santa Cruz store site, which is going to be in an empty former Albertsons supermarket building at 911 Soquel Avenue in the Eastside shopping center, was only going to be 24,000 square feet, about the same size as the one in nearby Capitola.. This week however Whole Foods was able to acquire two buildings next to the empty supermarket, allowing it to expand what will be the city's future Whole Foods store by 8,000 square feet for a total of 32,000 square feet.

Locating the two new stores in the vacant buildings makes good sense because vacant land is near impossible to find in the two coastal cities, and when it's available the cost is out of this world. Additionally, the two buildings--one a former Albertsons store as mentioned in Santa Cruz and the Capitola site a former Ralph's supermarket--have been vacant for sometime, therefore Whole Foods likely acquired them for a reasonable cost. Reasonable for the region that is.

The Santa Cruz and Capitola units will be full Whole Foods Market stores rather than versions of its new Whole Foods Express format, according to a Whole Foods executive in Northern California who asked we not name them.

The first Whole Foods Express store is set to open in a former Wild Oats store in Boulder, Colorado soon. The Whole Foods Express format is about 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet, will feature a wide-variety of fresh, prepared foods, and a limited assortment of natural, organic and specialty foods and products.

At under 24,000 square feet, the Capitola Whole Foods store will be even smaller than the Santa Cruz store. That planned Whole Foods' store is located on 41rst Avenue in the coastal city, which is just a few miles from Santa Cruz.

Smaller stores aren't a new thing for Whole Foods, just a departure from its practice over the last 5 -to- 10 years of primarily building stores from the ground up in the 55,000 up to 80,000 square foot range.

Locating stores in empty retail buildings also is the exception rather than the norm for Whole Foods Market, Inc. The retailer generally likes to built brand new stores, but has renovated empty buildings before, especially in places like Northern California where vacant land can be hard to find and premium-priced.

For example, last year Whole Foods opened its European Market Hall-style store in downtown Oakland in Northern California's San Francisco Bay Area. That store is in a former automobile dealership which the grocer completely demolished and renovated into the store which is designed similar to a European food hall.

Whole Foods also has a number of smaller stores in Northern California, the majority of which were built and opened prior to the last few years however. Those stores include it's first and currently only store in the University city of Berkeley (a second, bigger store is planned for Berkeley as well), it's Los Gatos store near Santa Cruz, and its sales per-square-foot-busting store in the Marin County city of Mill Valley, along with a few others.

The Mill Valley Whole Foods store, which is where the grocer's co-president Walter Robb started with the supernatural foods retailer as a store manager in the early 1990's when he helped design it and opened it, has only 15,000 square feet of selling space but averages in the neighborhood of $600,000 a week in gross sales.

Crews from Northern California's John Sutti & Associates, a retail design and building firm which has built and renovated most of Whole Foods' stores in Northern California over the years, are currently demolishing the Santa Cruz store site in the former Albertsons' building and preparing it for renovation, according to our Whole Foods' source in Northern California.

The Santa Cruz and Capitola stores will be the first Whole Foods markets in both cities. The grocer has a fairly new store in Monterey, but that city is about a 45-minute drive from Santa Cruz and Capitola. It also has another store in Los Gatos, which is about 30 minutes away depending on traffic.

Both cities have prime natural foods retail consumer demographics--higher than average post high school educational levels, higher than average income, a large "foodie" and health/organic foods'-eating population, a large counter culture population--and Santa Cruz has a number of independent natural foods stores that all do very well.

For example, Santa Cruz-based multi-store New Leaf Community Markets currently has two stores in Santa Cruz and is in the process of building a brand new 17,800 square foot natural foods store on the city's westside. New Leaf has to a large degree "owned" natural foods' and products' retailing in the city of Santa Cruz for the three decades or so it's had it's stores in the city of about 60,000.

Whole Foods' opening a store in Santa Cruz is going to put serious competitive pressure on New Leaf, even though it's building its own new store and has two others in it's hometown city.

Additionally, New Leaf was supposed to be acquired by Canada's Planet Organic, Inc. However, a couple weeks ago Planet Organic backed out of the deal because it said it decided not to float a planned $15 million stock offering, part of which was to be used to buy New Leaf, because of poor market conditions. [You can read our May 5 piece on the Planet Organic aborted buyout of New Leaf Community Markets here.]

New Leaf had earlier indicated to Natural~Specialty Foods Memo and others it needed the cash from the acquisition/merger (New Leaf's owners were still going to run the operation post-acquisition) to finish building the new Santa Cruz store on the city's westside and to complete another new store its' currently building in nearby Half Moon Bay.

New Leaf's owners have said they are still well enough financed to complete and open the new stores, and to operate fully. However, since the grocer did say when it jointly-announced the deal with Planet Organic executives at a press conference in Santa Cruz the cash from the acquisition was needed for the new store expansion and other purposes, there is some skepticism as to whether or not New Leaf will be able to move forward completely without finding either new financing on its own or another suitor, which they likely should be able to do in our analysis.

Santa Cruz is the county seat of Santa Cruz county, which has about 300,000 residents. Capitola, an artsy and tourist-oriented city of about 15,000 located just a short drive from Santa Cruz, also is in Santa Cruz County.

The economies of both cities are heavily dependent on tourism. Santa Cruz and Capitola draw tens of thousands of visitors each week in the summer months, some for weekends, others for longer stays.

Santa Cruz is home to its historic and famous Beach-Boardwalk, a beachside playland featuring various rides, attractions, entertainment venues, food stalls and restaurants, and other attractions for kids and kids at heart. The Santa Cruz Beach-Boardwalk is one of California's top tourist destinations, drawing not only Californians but visitors from throughout the U.S.

The cities are only a short drive from the Bay Area's Silicon Valley region, and many people in San Jose and the surrounding cities have weekend homes in the Santa Cruz area, as do people from California's Central Valley where summer temperatures often top 100 degrees. For these folks, Santa Cruz is a place to get away to for cooler weather and relaxation on the weekends.

The fact Capitola is a major tourist destination and weekend home retreat should allow Whole Foods to have more than enough customers for it's new store even though the city's population is only about 15,000.

Santa Cruz also has a campus of the University of California, which is a major employer in the city and of people who live in Capitola and other nearby cities. County government also is a major employer in Santa Cruz since it's the county seat. Health care is a fast-growing industry in the town as well, especially since there are many small communities nearby without their own hospitals and major medical offices.

Lastly, food and wine industry and related businesses and industries plays a big part in the Santa Cruz and Capitola economies. Whole Foods fits in well in this regard. Both cities are home to many restaurants, ranging from cutting-edge California cuisine and organic foods-only operations, to ethnic eateries who's menus span the globe.

The area also is home to numerous organic farming and food production companies, as it's nearby America's prime growing region for fresh market vegetables, the Monterey and Salinas Valley region. The region's farmers are leaders in the U.S. organic foods industry as well.

There also are numerous specialty, natural/organic and artisan food producers in the region, which isn't surprising considering the organic farming industry and the "foodie" and wine culture which permeates the area, not to mention the prime soil inland from the coast.

The University of California at Santa Cruz also has a well-respected program in sustainable agriculture, which not only serves as an educational and research hub for the industries but also has resulted in many people staying in the area after graduating from the program because of it's coastal beauty and the numerous opportunities in sustainable farming and food production.

With the store in Santa and the one in Capitola both opening early next year, Whole Foods is going to make a major impact in the two cities and surrounding area.

With it's commitment to local foods selling, the two branches of the United State's number one natural foods' store retailer will open new market opportunities for many of the area's smaller organic and sustainable farmers and food producers.

The stores also will offer the respective communities' large base of natural and organic food shoppers more product variety compared to what's currently available to them in the area's natural foods stores and supermarkets.

Whole Foods is making a major push in Northern California, and the stores in Santa Cruz and Capitola are part of that new store growth initiative.

Whole Foods currently has 24 stores in Northern California. All but two--Sacramento and Fresno--of those stores are located in the Bay Area or the Coastal region near the Bay Area.

The supernatural food retailer currently has 20 new stores in various stages of development in California. Out of those 20 new stores in development, 13 are in Northern California. All of those 13 are set to be opened by the end of 2009.

Further, Whole Foods announced earlier this year it would double the number of stores in Northern California, from its current 24 to about 50 in the next four years. The region is not only one of the grocer's top revenue producing regions, it's one of it's top growth target markets as well.

Saturday, August 16, 2008

Retail Analysis Memo: Growth and A Tale of Two Retailers-Tesco and Whole Foods Market: Is One Ripe For Acquisition and the Other Ripe For Acquiring?


Natural~Specialty Foods Memo Analysis and Opinion

Whole Foods Market, Inc. and Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market are two very different food retailers, but they do have at least one similarity.

That similarity is the fact for the last couple years both retail chains have been locking up new store site leases throughout Northern California at a breakneck pace.

Whole Foods, which these days tends to build primarily mega-natural foods supermarkets in the 45,000 -to- 75,000 square foot range, with some exceptions of course, currently has 13 new store locations in various degrees of development in Northern California. Eleven of the 13 locations have signed leases.

Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, which is the U.S. division of United Kingdom (UK)-based international retailer Tesco, the third largest retailer in the world, is engaged in its own leasing frenzy in Northern California. Thus far, Tesco has locked up leases on 43 sites for its small-format combination fresh foods and basic grocery stores in Northern California--21 locations in the San Francisco Bay Area, 20 in the Sacramento/Vacaville/Farfield region and one in Modesto, in the Northern San Joaquin Valley, and one in the south coastal city of Seaside near Monterey.

The 43 store locations are just those Tesco has either confirmed or we have identified independently. The retailer is in the process of securing many more new store site leases at present. The first of the 10,000 -to- 13,000 square foot Northern California Tesco Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market grocery stores are scheduled to begin opening in early 2009. Just as its been the case since November, 2007 in its current Southern California, Nevada and Arizona markets, expect to see Tesco open a new Fresh & Easy store in Northern California about every 3 -to- 4 days beginning early next year.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. though, unlike Tesco's Fresh & Easy, is putting the brakes on its new store opening plans for at least the next year, including in Northern California, which strategically is one of the natural grocer's top new store development markets for the next few years.

Last week after reporting poor sales and profit numbers, Whole Foods announced it planned to scale back the number of new stores it plans to open in the U.S. next year from the 25 -to- 30 it had planned to open in 2009, to just 15. As mentioned above, 13 of those new store locations are in Northern California.

On Friday, David Lannon, president of Whole Foods' Northern California division said that as part of the grocer's 2009 new store opening reduction plan, all but two of the 13 planned new stores in Northern California are subject to not being opened next year as originally planned. He said the retailer is committed to eventually opening all 13 stores in Northern California, but that it's obvious in light of the fact Whole Foods will only open 15 new stores nationally in the U.S. next year, that most of those 13 stores won't open in 2009 as planned.

According to Lannon, the two Whole Foods stores that will open for sure in Northern California is a store in the south coastal city of Santa Cruz (set to open in the first quarter of 2009) and one in Roseville, which is a suburb of Sacramento. That store is scheduled to open in November, 2009. It will only be Whole Foods Markets' second store in the fast growing Sacramento Metropolitan region. The existing store is in Sacramento.

Lannon and a team from the Northern California division office plan to meet with landlords and developers of the 11 leased sites to determine the status of each project and discuss the future in light of Whole Foods corporate plans to reduce the number of new stores it will open next year by nearly half. Final decisions on moving forward and scaling back will be made at Whole Foods' corporate headquarters in Austin, Texas, Lannon says.

Meanwhile, Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market is moving full bore ahead, not only with its plans to open the 42 Northern California combination fresh foods and basic grocery markets next year, but also scouting out additional sites and signing additional leases for them throughout the region.

In addition to the Bay Area and Sacramento region, Tesco is looking for additional store sites (it already has the one in Modesto) in the Northern San Joaquin Valley cities of Stockton, Manteca and Tracy, additional locations in Modesto, and in other communities in the region.

Tesco also is looking for Fresh & Easy store sites in the Monterey/Salinas/Santa Cruz area where it recently inked a deal for a store site in Seaside, next door to Monterey.

Further, it's looking to lock up leases for additional Bay Area stores in all nine counties, along with more stores in the Sacramento/Vacaville/Farfield area.

The retailer's strategy is to have stores throughout the Bay Area, to Sacramento on the I-80 corridor, from Sacramento throughout the Central Valley, and out to the south coast. Five stores are set to open in the Bakersfield Metropolitan region next year, along with six in Metro Fresno. The retailer also is looking for a couple store sites in the Merced County region.

The net result will be to have Fresh & Easy Neighorhood Market grocery stores from Southern California, where there currently are about 37 of the markets (there are 71 stores total thus far in Southern California Metro Las Vegas, Nevada and in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan area), through Bakersfield and Fresno, into the Northern San Joaquin Valley, out to Sacramento, into the San Francisco Bay Area, and over to the south coast, by the end of 2009.

This strategy will give Tesco the beginnings of a critical mass of food stores in California, which it plans to then add additional units to throughout 2009 and 2010, likely ending up with around 200 stores in California by the end of 2010.

One shouldn't attribute the fact Tesco is going forward so aggressively with its new store development program in Northern California, while Whole Foods Market, Inc. is putting the brakes on its, to Whole Foods' being the only one of the two food retailers having sales and profits problems.

Although it hasn't released any sales numbers yet, we know Tesco is losing millions with its start up Fresh & Easy. A big part of this loss is just that start ups lose money, especially very aggressive retail start ups like Fresh & Easy is.

But the start up explanation is only half of the equation. Thus far Tesco's Fresh & Easy stores have been underperforming to Tesco's internal target, which was weekly sales in the average 10,000 -to- 13,000 square foot stores of about $200,000 per-week. Our sources and research says on average the stores have been doing about half that sales number, although they've been picking up in the last couple months because Tesco has been launching some aggressive promotions, including distributing lots of coupons good for a whopping $5 off total grocery purchases of $20 or more in all its Fresh & Easy stores.

The fact is though, Fresh & Easy USA is a major initiative for Tesco, which is the world's third-largest retailer with annual sales of over $83 billion last year. The United Kingdom-based retailer plans to loose money on its Fresh & Easy U.S. venture for sometime--although it didn't initially count on losing as much as it has so far.

Compared to Tesco, Whole Foods Market is a tiny food retailing fish, with sales in the $6 -to- $7 billion dollar a year range. However, Whole Foods isn't much of an international retailer, with just a few stores in Canada and a handful of stores in the United Kingdom, the rest being in the United States. Therefore, that fact, combined with its focus on the natural and organic foods categories (it doesn't have the sales luxury of selling basic groceries in other words) makes Whole Foods a very impressive food retailer in scale and sales domestically. It's just not anywhere near the scale of a Tesco--or a Walmart, Inc., Kroger, Safeway, SuperValu and numerous others.

And in the case of going forward with new store opening plans rather than putting the brakes on such plans, being an $80-plus billion a year international retailer that has lots of cash on hand helps, compared to being a $7 billion a year retailer who's fate--unlike Tesco's which has operations all over the globe---lies 100% on its U.S. stores' performance, which thanks to the poor U.S. economy is taking a serious battering right now.

Nonetheless, Tesco would covet having a $6-plus billion a year U.S. division like Whole Foods Market, Inc., although it would likely prefer it to be under a more traditional food and grocery retailing format, rather than one focused on natural, organic, fresh and specialty foods categories. Or perhaps it wouldn't? The U.S. economy will boom once again, and upscale will be back in for many.

But, we also know that Tesco senior management has looked on Whole Foods in the U.S. in many ways with a keen eye, particularly admiring what its done in the organic fresh foods and grocery categories. And when Whole Foods opened its first store in London in the UK last year, Tesco watched closely. Unfortunately for Whole Foods Market, Inc., the retailer has lost $18 million to date on that London store, but business has picked up at the 70,000 square foot London food emporium, and it's drawing many more shoppers than it was just a year ago.

In the UK, Tesco is very deep in the natural and organic foods categories across all store categories, including dry grocery, fresh foods and even non-foods, particularly with its own store brands, which are the leading selling items in many categories throughout Britain.

Tesco is the UK's leading food and grocery retailer, controlling an impressive 31% share of the country's food and grocery sales market. Number two Wal-Mart-owned Asda has about a 17% share. Number three Sainsbury's about 15.5%. The remaining percentage is split among numerous food and grocery chains, including Morrisons (4th ranked) the Co-operative Group (now number 5 after just having acquired the Somerfield supermarket chain), Waitrose, Marks & Spencer, small-format German discount grocers Aldi and Lidl, and and a few others.

Last year when the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) made the first of its many legal challenges (which are still going on) against Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s acquisition-merger of Wild Oats Market, Inc., saying the deal would give Whole Foods' monopoly power in the supernatural food retailing category--an argument we've argued is wrong--we wrote that the FTC and others are forgetting Whole Foods Market, Inc. is a rather small fish in terms of overall food and grocery retailing in the U.S. (There are 21 retailers ranked above Whole Foods in terms of annual sales in the U.S. Further, the majority of these retailers are regional rather than national food retailers like Whole Foods is.)

As a result we wrote that Whole Foods Market, Inc. itself could become an acquisition target in the near-to-medium term, especially since major U.S. retailers like Safeway Stores, Inc., Kroger Co., SuperValu, Inc. and many others have moved into the natural and organic foods retailing space in a big way.

Thinking about how Whole Foods is having to scale back its plans to open about 30 stores in the U.S. next year to 15, while Tesco will likely open well over 100 new Fresh & Easy stores next year in California alone (granted the Fresh & Easy markets are much smaller than the average new Whole Foods store is), as well as is now moving into India and further growing its already impressive international business, our thoughts turn back to that Whole Foods as a potential acquisition target, as this month marks about a year since the Wild Oats acquisition.

While we believe based on source information Tesco eventually has bigger strategic plans in the U.S. than acquiring say a Whole Foods Market, Inc.--such as possibly acquiring something on the order of a Safeway or SuperValu, Inc. for example, along with growing Fresh & Easy into the Chicago Metro, Florida and New York markets--acquisitions are as much situational as they are long-term strategic opportunities.

A year ago, with its stock at an all time high, not even a Tesco or Wal-Mart, Inc. would likely consider acquiring the natural foods chain, even if they coveted doing so. But today, Whole Foods' stock is 70% below that all time high of just a year ago, and its being forced to cut back on its rapid new store growth program dramatically for the first time in two decades.

Additionally, Wall Street, which as recent as 6-7 months ago was super-bullish on Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s stock, is now bearish on the natural foods retailer. Whole Foods after all is a public company with numerous major institutional stockholders who must be satisfied. This is particularly the case since these investors are used to Whole Foods' stock going north rather than south in terms of value--at least until now.

This brings us to Tesco. If it wants to be a major player in food and grocery retailing in the U.S., it's going to have to eventually acquire a good-sized retailer or two at least. Although it's launched what is perhaps the most aggressive food retailing start up in modern history in the U.S. with Fresh & Easy, even if it opens 150 stores a year for the next five years (doable but tough to sustain and do well), it will still be a minor overall player with about 800 small-format stores. Nothing to sneeze at, but not in the big leagues either.

With Whole Foods' stock 70% below last year's high, along with the retailer having to scale back its new store opening plans for next year by nearly 50%--which means it doesn't have enough cash to go forward even while turning in poor sales and profit numbers in the short term--Whole Foods' is ripe to be acquired. The natural grocery chain also announced yesterday it will lay off about 43 employees at its Austin, Texas corporate headquarters.

If Tesco were to acquire Whole Foods, it could do many things for the international retailer. First, it would give it an immediate annual sales base of nearly $7 billion in the U.S., which is nothing to sneeze at, even for an $83-plus billion a year international retailer.

Second, it gives Tesco what arguably is the best upscale natural, organic and fresh foods format in the world. Imagine what a retailer the scale of Tesco could do with Whole Foods if it could do it right?

Third, it gives Tesco, which has the cash to expand Whole Foods internationally, an upscale natural, organic and green retailing format that it could expand throughout Europe, Australia, parts of Asia and even to the oil rich Arab countries where the UK's upscale Waitrose and the U.S. gourmet grocer Dean & Delucca are opening stores.

Lastly, at home in the UK, which on a per-capita basis has become the world's leading organic foods retail market, Whole Foods would give Tesco a banner which it could use to eventually dominate the natural foods' retailing space like its done in the grocery and general merchandise spaces with its various Tesco banner stores, ranging from hypermarkets to its small-format Tesco Express convenience-style grocery stores.

We believe Whole Foods CEO John Mackey and the company's board of directors would fight any acquisition, and likely would fight a deal offer from a British-based chain like Tesco even more so. However, if Whole Foods' performance doesn't improve dramatically in the next two quarters say, such a fight could be very difficult if such an acquisition were to come from Tesco or any other major retail chain. Nobody knows this better than John Mackey and the Whole Foods' board, since it was a fledgling, poor performing Wild Oats Market, Inc. it acquired about a year ago.

Is Tesco interested in acquiring Whole Foods Market, Inc.? We don't know. However, like we mentioned earlier in this piece, acquisitions are as much situational as they are long-term strategic. What we do know is that a couple U.S. supermarket chains are watching Whole Foods' performance closely, and that the A (acquisition) word has been tossed around by these chains, at least hypothetically.

What we do know is that Tesco has the cash to acquire Whole Foods without any trouble if it wants to. The possible political battle if it were to be a hostile acquisition, which would likely be the case at least right now, is another matter altogether. We doubt if Tesco is up for that just now.

However, when it comes to publicly-owned food retailing chains, circumstances change rapidly. Performance rules the day. For example, before investor Ron Burkle bought a major chunk of Wild Oats Market, Inc., became chairman of the board, and engineered the replacement of the company's CEO, both Wild Oats' board and key executives were adamant they would never sell to Whole Foods. That changed rather fast once Burkle got involved.

One could see a similar situation happening with Whole Foods. In fact, Burkle was a major player in brokering the Whole Foods-Wild Oats acquisition-merger. He's been rather low-key of late in the supermarket sector, but Whole Foods' current situation is one that brings out Ron Burkle and other investors like him who are adept at engineering just such acquisitions once they make a substantial investment in a company. Burkle still has stock in Whole Foods Market, Inc. from the Wild Oats acquisition, by the way.

Don't be shocked if in the not too distant future you see Whole Foods going from being charged by the FTC and others as a monopolist acquirer to being acquired itself.

Will it happen this year; next year? We have no idea. What we do know is that the chances of Whole Foods being acquired now are about 100% higher than they were just a year ago. That alone is worth paying attention to.

Editor's note: Watch for an upcoming story and analysis of retailer's we think would benefit overall by acquiring Whole Foods Market, Inc. An 'America's top Whole Foods Market, Inc. acquisition parade' if you will.

Monday, December 10, 2007

Monday Morning Java: Safeway Small Format Stores On the Way

The small food store format invasion is coming: Safeway, perhaps Wal-Mart, to counter Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets' San Francisco Bay Area entry

As our readers know, we've been reporting on and writing extensively about Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format. In particular, we've been among the first publications to break news about the retailer's Northern California plans. (Read our December 5 story about Fresh & Easy store developments in Northern California and the Bay Area here.)

We also were one of the first publications to report that Wal-Mart has had a high-level team in the San Francisco Bay Area working on the development of two small format retail stores--one a small footprint, convenience-oriented grocery store similar in concept to Tesco's Fresh & Easy markets, and the other a stand-alone health and wellness-style format which would feature an in-store health and wellness clinic and sell a wide range of health-oriented goods, including natural products. (Wal-Mart has trademarked two retail store names, "City Thyme" and "Field & Vine," as we reported here.)

We named the Wal-Mart small format project--along with the Fresh & Easy format and other new age convenience-style stores from the likes of Giant Eagle (Giant Eagle Express) and Whole Foods Market (Whole Foods Market Express; a prototype store being developed in Boulder, Colorado)--"Small Marts," a play on words combining the Wal-Mart name and the shortened name often used for a retail market or store.

In our September 6, 2007 piece, The invasion of the "Small Marts": Will there be a small format revolution by U.S. retailers, we provided an analysis of what Tesco's Fresh & Easy format could mean in terms of other food retailers following a similar path in the U.S. In addition to discussing Giant Eagle's, (Express) Whole Foods' (Express) and Wal-Mart's developments, we also talked about Pleasanton, California-based Safeway Stores, Inc. It's CEO, Steve Burd, said the grocer is watching Tesco closely, and researching the Fresh & Easy format, it's potential locations, and possible competitive pressures on the retailer's Western U.S. operations, especially in California. (Read more here.)

In the "Invasion of the Small Marts'" piece mentioned above, and in all of our writing on the issue, we've discussed how one market in particular, Northern California and particularly the San Francisco Bay Area, will be the most competitive and difficult for Tesco with its Fresh & Easy stores thus far--compared to Southern California, Nevada and Arizona--where the British grocer now has about 20 stores open.

Among the reasons for this increased competition, we've sighted Safeway Stores--the fact that it's the food retailing market share leader in the region, that the Bay Area is home to it's corporate headquarters, and of course the small format research project articulated by CEO Burd in response to the entering of Fresh & Easy stores in the region.

Additionally, we've discussed the major expansion efforts in Northern California (focused in the Bay Area) by Whole Foods Market, Inc., which plans to build 20-25 large supernatural supermarkets in the region (in addition to the 20-plus it already has) in the next five years, according to former Whole Foods' Northern California president Anthony Gilmore, who left his position with the grocer in October to join Safeway Stores as a director of new store development.

Safeway moving from research to action in small format store development

According to a story today in The Silicon Valley/San Jose Business Journal, CEO Burd and Safeway are moving from the research phase of their smaller format food store project to an action phase. That's right, according to the publication's sources (and confirmed by a number of our own), Safeway Stores is seeking as many as five locations in the San Jose area for stores of about 20,000 square feet, which would feature extensive selections of fresh, prepared foods, Tesco's "stock-in-trade" in it's Fresh & Easy format. At 20,000 square feet, these smaller-format stores would be less than half the size of Safeway's new Lifestyle stores, which average 45,000 to 65,000 square feet, but about double the size of Tesco's Fresh & Easy markets.

According to the Business Journal story, Safeway has retained Cornish & Carey Commercial Real Estate Brokerage to find locations for the five stores in and around the San Jose area. This is the same Bay Area region where we reported Tesco has inked a deal for it's first store in the Bay Area, on Bird Avenue in San Jose, and likely will locate as many as ten to twelve stores in the city and it's immediate environs.

Word is Safeway has Cornish & Carey trying to lock up a number of former Albertsons' supermarket buildings in the San Jose area for its new small format food stores. This is interesting since Tesco's Bird Avenue location is a former Albertsons' store, which the grocer closed a couple years ago along with a number of others in Northern California. Tesco has been targeting these empty Albertsons' stores throughout the Bay Area as locations for its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets.

Safeway is a major commercial real estate player in the Bay Area, with almost 300 stores. In other words, it's a priority customer for shopping center and other commercial real estate managers. As such, it looks like the grocer is playing some store location hardball with Tesco in terms of that retailer's sight search. In the Business Journal piece, local commercial real estate sources give Safeway the thumbs up in terms of being the preferred tenant for any of the vacant Albertsons' stores. As we've reported however, Tesco already has a number of store locations locked-up in the Bay Area, with numerous other sights in negotiation.

As mentioned above, some months ago before Tesco opened a single Fresh & Easy store, CEO Burd said Safeway was preparing itself for the British grocer's small format stores, which combine basic private label and nationally branded grocery items with prepared foods offerings. Burd said, among other things, he believes Safeway has an advantage in that the grocer is a well-known brand in California (especially in the Bay Area), especially in the prepared foods niche. In fact, Safeway has been perfecting it's fresh, prepared foods over the last five years in it's Lifestyle format stores, including branding the items with an upscale flavor, using such names as Safeway Signature and Safeway Select.

Along with the extensive prepared foods initiatives in-store in its Lifestyle format supermarkets, Safeway purchased a restaurant in San Jose last summer, where it's been testing various prepared foods entrees it wants to sell in its stores. Ownership of the restaurant, called Citrine New World Bistro, was announced last month by CEO Burd. It's an innovation incubator, and consumer test kitchen for a variety of prepared foods that observers expect will be offered in the new, smaller format food stores.

Anthony Gilmore, the former president of Whole Foods' Northern California division also joined Safeway in October as a director for new store and format development. While in charge of Whole Foods' Northern California operations, Gilmore lead the development of a number of innovative formats, resulting in new stores opening this year. Among them are the European Food Hall format store in Oakland, which opened in October, and the Northern California flagship store in the Silicon Valley city of Campbell, which features a food and wine bistro in-store, along with the supernatural grocers first mini day spa, among other innovative features.

Gilmore was hired in large part to bring that experience in retail food store format innovation to Safeway, where he began his retail grocery career as a courtesy clerk. He's involved in the new small format store development, including the prepared foods offerings, as well as in another new development for Safeway--the design of a "next generation" Lifestyle format, which is part Safeway Lifestyle stores, part Whole Foods Market. As we reported three months ago, Safeway is planning to build this new, Whole Foods-like store in Pleasanton, where it's corporate headquarters is located. (More on this development soon.)

Turf war battle, small format competition could get even hotter in Bay Area

As we mentioned at the beginning of this piece, and first wrote about in August and again in September and November, a high-level team from Wal-Mart was in the Bay Area for some time researching and developing two small retail formats for potential implementation by the retailer. These two formats, a small-footprint grocery market and health and wellness store, would allow Wal-Mart to enter into markets such as the San Francisco Bay Area where they've been unsuccessful in getting permits to build Supercenters do to objections by city officials, community groups and the retail clerks union, which represents workers in nearly every Bay area supermarket.

We've continued to follow this story closely. However, our commercial real estate and industry sources in the region haven't heard much in the last couple months. Here's what we know: First, as reported earlier, Wal-Mart has trademarked two trade names for use on "unspecified retail stores." These names are "City Thyme" and "Field & Vine." Both these names sound like they would fit a retail food store but we can't independently confirm that, nor is Wal-Mart confirming it for us.

Second, we know the Wal-Mart team is no longer in the Bay Area. Our sources told us the group completed their project, at least the on-site aspects of it. We have been told, but can't confirm, that a report on the small format research has been given to Wal-Mart CEO Lee Scott.
We've also been told by multiple sources that, in terms of the small format grocery market, there's a division within the team in terms of going forward with it or just focusing on the retailer's existing smaller format grocery store, Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market. These stores average about 48,000 square feet in size, and are a full-department supermarket. Although much smaller than a Supercenter, they aren't considered "small format" in terms of the supermarket industry. Rather, they're about average size in terms of a stand-alone grocery store.

Regarding the small format health and wellness stores, we've been told Wal-Mart is more excited about their potential, especially the combining of in-store health clinics with the natural, health and wellness-oriented product mix. (Wal-Mart is putting an increasing number of health clinics in its Supercenter stores.) Beyond that, we don't currently have any further specific information we're comfortable reporting in terms of that format's status.

We do know Tesco's rapid rollout of it's Fresh & Easy stores has taken Wal-Mart a bit by surprise, and that the retailer is concerned about Tesco's taking food dollar market share away from the retailer in California. Wal-Mart has only been able to build about half of the number of Supercenters in the state as it planned to build to date, do to the highly-organized campaigns against the big box stores throughout California. As a result, this fact has caused the retailer to lower its projections considerably in terms of the share of retail food sales it planned to have in the Golden State.

Wal-Mart recently announced it would build two Neighborhood Markets in Southern California early next year, its first in the state. This has lead to speculation that the retailer will rollout this format as a way to increase its retail food dollar market share in California as an alternative to its original Supercenter strategy. There's less organized objection to this Wal-Mart format.

If Wal-Mart either rolls out its Neighborhood Market stores in a big way in California--including Northern California and the Bay Area,which is logical as that's where the strongest Supercenter objections are--or goes forward with its "Small Mart" grocery market format, this will add even more heat to the smaller food store competitive landscape in the region. Not only will Safeway be challenging Tesco with it's 20,000 square foot format, but Wal-Mart could pose a serious challenge to both with either its 48,000 square foot Neighborhood Markets or the yet to be officially announced smaller format grocery market (the "Wild Thyme" or "Food & Vine" concepts).

As we've written extensively, Northern California and the Bay Area will be a competitive and operational challenge for Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets. It also seems the region's going to become a small format food retailing laboratory of sorts as a result of Fresh & Easy's entry into the market next year. Our sources tell us there are a number of other retailers looking at the small format food retailing opportunities for them in the region as well. The small format turf battle and competitive environment in the region is just beginning--and will heat-up even more soon.



Friday, October 19, 2007

Fresh & Easy Update

British Grocer Marches North: Tesco to Open First Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market in Northern California in San Jose in Summer 2008


Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) was one of the first publications to report that UK-based Tesco was planning to branch out from Southern California, Arizona and Nevada to Northern California with its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format stores.

We've now learned from our real estate and other sources that Tesco is planning to open it's first Fresh & Easy store in Northern California's famed Silicon Valley sometime in the summer of 2008. The store will be located in a former Albertson's supermarket building in San Jose's Willow Glen neighborhood.

The former Albertson's store, which was closed along with 36 other underperforming stores in Northern California in August 2006, is located at 1409 Bird Avenue in San Jose. Tesco has confirmed it will be renovating the store and locating a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market at the site in mid-to-late 2008. Our sources tell us it will likely open in the summer of 2008. Tesco will completely renovate the former Albertson's store to fit the needs of its Fresh & Easy upscale, convenience-type format.

The shopping center where the former Albertson's store is located is managed by San Diego, California-based Asset Management Group. The commercial property manager has been trying to get a retail food store into the building since the Albertson's closed in August 2006. The firm was in negotiations for some time with local, muti-store independent Zanotto's Markets (based in nearby Scott's Valley, California), who was interested in leasing the building and putting a store there. However, Asset Management decided to go with Tesco instead.

This will be Tesco's first Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market in Northern California. The retailer is scheduled to open it's first six of the 100 stores it currently is either building or has in the pipeline on November 8. All six of the stores are in Southern California.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) has identified (and Tesco confirmed) the specific locations of three of those six stores. You can find out those specific locations by reading our Thursday, October 11 story here and our Friday, October 12 story here. Additionally, Tesco has formally announced the location of one of the six stores to open on November 8. That store is in Upland, California (San Bernardino County). The store is located on Eighth Street & Mountain Avenue. Today Tesco announced the specific locations of the remaining two stores to open on November 8. Those two stores are in the Glassel Park/Eagle Rock neighborhood in Los Angeles and in Hemet, a city in the Southern California desert region. All six stores will open at 10:AM on November 8.

Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format stores average about 10,000-13,000 square feet. The convenience-oriented stores feature an assortment of Tesco private label upscale prepared foods (including many grab-and-go items), specialty, natural and basic groceries, fresh produce, meats, perishables and other offerings in a format which puts an emphasis on quality and convenience for shoppers.

Tesco's entry into San Jose in Northern California's Bay Area in the Summer of 2008 should be interesting. The Bay Area is a very upscale food retailing market, with Safeway Stores, Whole Foods Market, Inc., Trader Joe's and many upscale independents all currently building new stores in a fairly rapid clip.

The upscale, convenience-oriented Fresh & Easy format will be most similar in the Bay Area market to Trader Joe's in size and product offerings. However, many observers believe it will take some market share from Safeway with its upscale, fresh food offerings, which has been an area Safeway has been focusing on for the past few years (and currently focusing more on) with its Lifestyle format. In fact, Safeway CEO Steve Bird has said the Pleasanton, California-based chain has been tracking all of Tesco's movements regarding its Fresh & Easy store locations, demographics and merchandising, and that Safeway is prepared to enter the market with its own convenience-oriented stores if Tesco proves successful.

We will reserve judgement however on the effect the Fresh & Easy stores will have on Safeway--and other upscale retailers in the region for that matter--for a few reasons. First, it will take a serious critical mass of Fresh & Easy stores in the Bay Area (and elsewhere in Northern California) to hurt Safeway, which is the region's market share leader. Second, Trader Joe's and Whole Foods are extremely popular natural and specialty-oriented retailers in the Bay Area. Both chains are building larger and more lifestyle-type stores (as is Safeway) in the region. These three upscale chain's stores are getting more interesting in terms of product selection and other features with each store new store built.

Further, Trader Joe's stores are already smaller than supermarkets and convenient to shop in. Additionally, Whole Foods has a prototype convenience-oriented format called Whole Foods Express, which they wouldn't hesitate to roll out in the Bay Area (where the grocer is in the process of building at least 20 new supernatural lifestyle stores over the next couple years) if they feel the heat from the Fresh & Easy format. Whole Foods, Safeway, Trader Joe's and the others mentioned (plus others) have strong brand equity and shopper following in the Bay Area. Tesco will need to create this same equity and shopper loyalty to succeed in the region.

All three--Safeway, Whole Foods and Trader Joe's--will be far from a pushover for Tesco or any other retailer starting-up in the market. The Bay Area also has numerous very sophisticated upscale independent retailers. Mollie Stone's, Andronico's, Lunardi's, Cosentino's, Draeger's, Zanotto's (and a few others) are all multi-store food retailers with stores throughout the Bay Area. These retailers offer various sized stores and do very sophisticated merchandising of upscale fresh, prepared foods and natural and specialty products.

The Bay Area is a sophisticated consumer market for fresh foods as well as natural and specialty foods. More so overall than Southern California is in many ways. Tesco will have a number of different challenges--merchandising, shopper loyalty, political and others--than the chain is going to have in Southern California, Arizona and Nevada, its first three target market regions.

We expect Tesco to build numerous Fresh & Easy stores in the Bay Area now that they have decided to open the San Jose store. This is the chain's stated strategy--to create a critical mass of stores in whatever regions they enter--and also is needed from the standpoint of logistics, marketing and advertising.

Logistically, Tesco's new distribution center is located in Riverside County, in Southern California. That's about an eight to 10 hour one-way trip to the Bay Area in a semi truck and trailer. The more Fresh & Easy stores Tesco has to deliver to the more economically efficient logistics They will have. The same for marketing and advertising. Print and radio ads for example cost a retailer as much for one store as they do for 50 stores. As Tesco's U.S. CEO for Fresh & Easy stores, Tim Mason, has said, the company plans on following a "Starbucks like" critical mass store location philosophy.

We will be observing this development closely--as we're sure Northern California retail food chains and independents will be, including those in the traditional convenience store industry.

What's On-Tap: Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets: The first six Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores to open will all be in Southern California. Those six stores will open at 10:AM on November 8, 2007. The stores are located in the Southern California cities of Los Angeles, Anaheim, West Covina, Upland, Arcadia and Hemet. Each store will have a five day grand-opening beginning at 10:00AM on November 8. The grand openings will include numerous in-store activities, food and beverage tastings, promotions and other special events. Store openings in Arizona and Las Vegas, Nevada (in addition to more Southern California store openings) will follow shortly after the first stores open on November 8, 2007

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Tesco Fresh & Easy Update: Oakland, CA

Oakland may be the central front in Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets' Northern California invasion in 2008


As we reported yesterday,Tesco is making plans to launch its Fresh & Easy convenience-style grocery markets in Northern California in a big way next year. The UK-based grocer has already secured its first location, a former Albertsons supermarket building on Bird Avenue in the Bay Area city of San Jose. Tesco will renovate the empty building to fit its 10,000 square foot Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format. The building is about 40,000 square feet.

We've now learned Tesco might make the Easy Bay Area city of Oakland the central front in its Bay Area food retailing invasion. Oakland city officials and commercial real estate sources tell us Tesco is seriously looking at five potential store sites in the city to locate its Fresh & Easy grocery markets.

The five Oakland sites are:
  • 20th and Telegraph Ave
  • 17th and San Pablo Ave.
  • West Grand and Market St
  • 606 Clara St
  • Oakland Coliseum Transit Village
The first three sites are in or near Oakland's inner city, an area underserved by retail food stores, especially those offering fresh foods, produce and meats. The fourth location is not far from the downtown core, and the fifth site is a couple miles outside the downtown, and is adjacent to the Oakland Coliseum, where the NFL's Oakland Raiders play their home football games. The Coliseum Transit Village location also is where BART (the Bay Area's light rail system) has a stop. It's also a central hub for local bus lines and taxi cab services.

For decades Oakland, like many other large U.S. cities with substantial low-income populations, has been unable to draw supermarkets or other retail food stores to the city, especially its downtown, inner city neighborhood. This situation has changing for the positive in Oakland this year however--in a big way.

Last month, Whole Foods opened its first store in Oakland. The store, located in downtown, is a European Food Hall-style market, a design first for Whole Foods. The market is in a former Cadillac dealership which the grocer renovated from top to bottom. The food hall-style store is large and offers all of Whole Foods' traditional upscale features: tons of natural and organic groceries, non foods, fresh produce, meat and seafood, an in-store restaurant, and a cafe. The market also offers many specialty and artisan foods produced by local bay area purveyors.

Further, specialty foods grocer Trader Joe's opened two stores in Oakland on the same day about three weeks ago. Both stores are only about a 15 minute drive from downtown and serve neighborhoods that are a mix of upscale young professionals and manufacturing and service workers. These two stores are the first for Trader Joe's in Oakland as well.

Additionally, Bay Area-based Safeway stores recently remodeled one if its stores, located not far from downtown Oakland, turning it into one of its upscale Lifestyle stores, featuring lots of fresh produce and prepared foods, along with natural and specialty groceries, in addition to basic grocery offerings.

On top of all this retail food store activity, the city of Oakland and a local developer broke ground two weeks ago on a huge project called the Harvest Market Center. Located at the popular Jack London Square, just a few blocks from downtown Oakland, the center will be a large public market similar to the famous Pikes Public Market in Seattle, Washington and the popular Ferry Plaza Public Market in nearby San Francisco. The Oakland public market will feature scores of boutique, artisan, natural and organic foods vendors--ranging from fresh green grocers, butchers, gourmet retailers and bakers, to local natural and organic food purveyors and more.

The possible addition of five Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets (at least three in the inner city core) would be a huge boon to Oakland and its residents. Since the stores offer basic groceries along with fresh produce, meats and fresh prepared foods, the markets could serve as primary shopping destinations for many of the city's residents. Further, based on the retail prices we observed at the Fresh & Easy stores which opened last week in Southern California, Oakland shoppers would be able to obtain basic groceries at prices at or below the prices at traditional supermarkets.

This spate of food retailing activity in Oakland--which might kick into even higher gear early next year if Tesco goes forward with its five locations--is due primarily to a policy began about 7-8 years ago by Oakland's then mayor, former Governor of California and now state Attorney General, Jerry Brown. Brown served two terms as Oakland's mayor. He left office at the beginning of this year.

As mayor, Brown instigated an aggressive downtown redevelopment plan which has resulted in the building of thousands of condominiums, townhouses and apartments in downtown Oakland, turning the once "dead after five PM" city core into a thriving residential area. The redevelopment also has brought new hotels, office buildings, restaurants, night clubs, art galleries and retail to the downtown.

The last piece of the puzzle has been food retailers--and if Tesco does locate the five Fresh & Easy stores in Oakland that puzzle will be nearly completed, along with the pieces already filled in by Whole Foods, Trader Joe's and Safeway. There's also talk in Oakland that WinCo, the large Boise, Idaho-based discount grocer, might build a huge new store in Oakland.

We aren't surprised Tesco might locate five Fresh & Easy stores in Oakland, including at least three in the inner city. Unlike Whole Foods, which bases it's store decisions largely on a neighborhood's percentage of college degree-holding residents, or Trader Joe's, which generally uses similar demographic variables when choosing store locations, Tesco has said its strategy with the Fresh & Easy format is to intentionally target areas underserved by retail food stores along with more upscale neighborhoods.

For example, its first store in Los Angeles, which opened last week, is located in that city's Glassel Park neighborhood, a primarily low-income area but one that's rapidly moving more upscale. Oakland is the same. Although the city has many lower-income residents, its growth is coming from younger, high-income professionals, who've been moving to Oakland in droves from San Francisco and other Bay Area cities to live in the new downtown housing and take advantage of the city's booming nightlife activity.

While Oakland may become the central front in British grocer Tesco's 2008 Bay Area invasion, we've also learned from our sources that the retailer is talking to city officials and real estate people in cities throughout the Bay Area, as part of its plan to be a major food retailing force in Northern California.

Cities where our sources tell us Tesco representatives have expressed a direct interest in locating Fresh & Easy stores include, in addition to Oakland: Pleasanton (home of Safeway Stores corporate headquarters), Walnut Creek, Concord, Fremont, Pittsburgh, San Leandro, Dublin, Danville, Livermore and Antioch. These cities are all in the East Bay Area.

Many of these East Bay Area locations are either already locked-up by Tesco or the grocer is in various stages of the negotiating process. City officials and real estate sources have provided us with specific locations in many cases. However, we've decided to wait to publish those locations until we have a bit more confirmation.

Tesco also is looking aggressively in the city of San Francisco for store locations. Additionally, our sources tell us the retailer is looking up and down the San Francisco peninsula, from San Francisco, throughout San Mateo county to San Jose. As we mentioned above, Tesco already has secured a store location in San Jose, its first according to the manager of the property. The retailer is looking for additional locations in the city of San Jose, including a number of sites in the downtown core, like it is doing in Oakland. Other Bay Area cities on the radar screen include San Mateo, Redwood City, Menlo Park, Palo Alto and others.

There are at least 25-30 empty former Albertsons supermarket buildings in the Bay Area, and Tesco is looking at all these locations for possible Fresh & Easy stores. These stores were closed by Albertsons LLC, the entity that bought the Northern California Albertsons division as part of the buyout of Albertsons, Inc. by Supervalu and Cerebus Capital Management. Not too long after that, Albertsons LLC sold the entire Northern California operation to Modesto, California-based Save Mart Stores, Inc. Save Mart has been converting the former Bay Area Albertsons stores to the Lucky Stores banner and the remaining stores outside the Bay Area to its Save Mart banner.

We're hearing from our sources that Tesco is looking at opening as many as 100 stores in Northern and Central California in the next two years, with the majority of those stores being located in the San Francisco Bay Area. The Sacramento metropolitan region also is high on Tesco's agenda for the Fresh & Easy stores.

Update: Five Fresh & Easy stores opened today in Las Vegas

Tesco opened five Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Markets today in Las Vegas, Nevada. The locations of the five stores are: Tropicana & Durango, Tropicana & Jones, Lake Mead & Del Webb, Bermuda & Silverado Ranch, and Warm Springs and Easter. (The store at left is one of the five that opened today.)

Today's Las Vegas' store openings come on the heels of the opening of the first six Fresh & Easy stores last week (November 8) in the Southern California cities of Los Angeles, Anaheim, West Covina, Arcadia, Upland and Hemet. A sixth store opens Friday (November 16) in the Southern California city of Chula Vista. On November 28, two more Fresh & Easy markets open in Southern California in Laguna Hills and Lakewood. The first Arizona Fresh & Easy stores are set to open on December 5 in Mesa and Chandler.

To date, Tesco has officially announced 122 Fresh & Easy locations for Southern California, Nevada and Arizona. A company spokesperson says the retailer plans to have 50 stores opened by the end of February, 2008. Tesco's goal is to have 200 Fresh & Easy markets opened by the end of 2008.

Like in Southern California, Fresh & Easy staffers opened the Las Vegas stores this morning at 10:00AM with a number of special grand opening events and promotions. However, unlike in Southern California last week when the first six stores opened, there wasn't quit as much media frenzy and fanfare this morning in Las Vegas, according to observers at the stores.

Crowds were brisk but it was much more low-key than in Southern California we're told. This also is evidenced by the huge volume of media coverage the grand openings received last week, compared to what is very little thus far about the Las Vegas; store openings.

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Ethnic Foods Memo: Matzo Shortage at San Francisco Bay Area Supermarkets For Passover Has Area's Jewish Consumers Fuming and Grocers' Searching


You can see the displeasure in shoppers' eyes and on their faces in the aisles of San Francisco Bay Area supermarkets, store managers and clerks tell us.

Also, the region's online food-oriented message boards and blogs are full of comments and requests on the topic.

And, Bay Area Supermarket managers are being inundated with phone calls from less-than-happy consumers, all in search of what normally is a grocery product in abundance in the region this time of year--but is near-impossible to find this year.

What's causing all this concern and consternation?

It's Passover and to the dismay of observant Bay Area Jews it's impossible to find that essential staple for the holiday observance--matzo.

The Jewish religious holiday of Passover began last Saturday night at sundown and runs until the end of this week.

Matzo, an unleavened bread, is an essential food for Passover. Further, not just any old matzo will do during Passover. The unleavened bread--marketed by kosher food companies such as Manischewitz, Straits and a couple others--eaten during the week-long religious observance of Passover must be certified by the proper rabbinical organization as "Kosher for Passover." Everyday matzo, even though it 's certified "kosher," won't do during Passover, according to Jewish dietary laws.

Enter the matzo shortage in the Bay Area.

On Saturday Night (April 19), the first night of Passover, Jews are required to eat only wheat-based matzo. Then, for the rest of Passover, they are required to eat matzo each day made from only four grains in addition to wheat: barley, oats, rye or spelt. No other grains are permitted.

Wheat tends to be the most popular matzo variety and normally even if a supermarket runs out of that variety for a couple days it still has plenty of the other four types of grain-based matzo.

Not this year though in the Bay Area. The stores are out of all of the grain-based matzo varieties.

Safeway Stores, Inc., the region's number one supermarket chain; Lucky Stores, owned by Save Mart, Inc. and the region's number two chain; Mollie Stone, a popular multi-store independent in the Bay Area which among other things is known for its extensive selection of kosher foods, Andronico's, another multi-store upscale independent; Lunardi's, a family owned regional chain similar to Andronico's and Mollie Stone; and pretty much every other supermarket chain and independent in the Bay Area has shelves which are minus-matzo, and there's still four -to-five days of Passover left to go.

Even Whole Foods Market, which has nearly 25 stores in the Bay Area, as well as the numerous ethnic and specialty stores in the region, including a number that specialize in kosher foods, are out of the unleavened matzo bread.

Compounding the missing-in-action matzo-matter is the fact that Costco Wholesale, which is a popular food and grocery shopping destination in the region, decided not to carry matzo for passover in its numerous Bay Area stores this year.

Additionally, specialty grocer Trader Joe's which is another popular retailer in the area, took the year off nationwide from selling matzo in order to re-evaluate the category in its stores, according to Alison Mochizuki, a corporate spokesperson for the chain. Trader Joe's has 41 stores in the nine-county San Francisco Bay Area.

None of the region's retailers' say they can put their finger on a single reason their stores are out of matzo, especially only three days into the Passover holiday.

All seem to agree though that demand is up and supply is down. Teena Massingill, a spokesperson for Safeway Stores, Inc., says the retailer ordered more matzo this year than last, but its stores are still out. She suggested because many other supermarkets in the Bay Area had little supply or ran out before Passover even began, Safeway's stores reported a run on the leavened bread beginning around the Friday before the holiday began.

The primary kosher foods distributor to most Bay Area supermarket chains and independents is the specialty and ethnic foods division of grocery wholesaler Certified Grocers, which has an office in the Bay Area city of Livermore and a warehouse and distribution center about 40 miles away in Stockton.

Certified's specialty and ethnic foods' distribution division provides kosher category food and grocery products to Lucky Stores, Andronico's, Mollie Stone, Raley's/Nob Hill and most other supermarket chains and independents in the Bay Area except Safeway, which buys kosher foods direct through its in-house Safeway Specialty Foods division.

Certified is essentially out of matzo, which means the retailers are out. In the U.S. Kosher for Passover grocery products are pre-ordered in advance by the stores from specialty and ethnic foods distributors or direct from the manufacturers. This is a long-standing industry practice.

Since the holiday only has a one week observance, that means grocery products which are strictly "Kosher for Passover" have a short shelf life. Distributors usually start bringing the special "Kosher for Passover" products into the stores about three weeks before the holiday observance begins. Most Jewish consumers know this and start stocking-up on products like Passover matzo as soon as they see it hit the stores' shelves.

When Passover is over, the "Kosher for Passover" products are either essentially sold out in the stores or picked up by the distributor. Although, less and less these days are distributors giving retailers any credits for returned Passover merchandise like used to be the common case.

As a result of the pre-ordering practice and the fact the Passover grocery products are only on the shelves for about four weeks (three weeks or so before the holiday and the week of the holiday), once a store runs out of an item like matzo--that's usually it.

Therefore, combine increased demand--many Jews celebrate Passover even though they aren't all that observant outside of the holiday--with the decreased supply--no matzo sales at Trader Joe's and Costco among other reasons--and you've got some very unhappy Jewish consumers in the San Francisco Bay Area.

Matzo symbolizes what enslaved Jews were allowed to eat. It's even nicknamed "slaves bread." Its unleavened nature refers to a time when Jewish slaves had to flee Egypt in a hurry, and therefore didn't have time to bake the unleavened bread they took with them.

Passover is the single most observed Jewish holiday among the many that exist. It's also the most inclusive in that even those who rarely or even ever attend synagogue are likely to observe Passover. Many younger Jews who aren't regularly observant have increasingly been observing the religious holiday as a way to get more in touch culturally with their Jewish heritage, if not faith. It's estimated about 80% of the six million Jews who live in the U.S. observe Passover.

Food--and especially matzo--is central to the Passover holiday observation. So central in fact that many Bay Area Jews are driving to Southern California--or having relatives and friends there ship them matzo care packages by overnight mail. Many also are ordering matzo online--if they can still get it--asking and paying for next day delivery.

With four -to-five more days until passover ends, Bay Area supermarket retailers are feeling the heat. Many are searching far and wide for more matzo inventory. Safeway for example is trying to obtain some from its East Coast and other division distribution centers.

Meanwhile, online food forums like the one at http://www.craiglist.org/ and Bay Area-based food blogs are full of requests for matzo from consumers, as well as numerous comments and questions as to what has caused the 2008 matzo shortage in the Bay Area.

There will be lessons learned and spreadsheets studied by the region's supermarket buyers once this week is over and Passover ends. You can bet your matzo (if you can find any) on that.