Sunday, April 20, 2008

Green Marketing Memo: SF Chronicle: The Proliferation of Green Certification Schemes and Logos Have Many Grocers, Consumers Confused

As pro-environmental marketing, retailing and consumerism has grown over the last decade in the United States, there's also been a growth in and proliferation of certification seals and logos ranging from those claiming "100-percent natural," "eco-friendly," "biodegradable," "earth-friendly," "green" and more.

The U.S. federal government doesn't certify "natural" or "green" products like it does organic ingredients in foods and other consumer products. The Department of Agriculture's USDA Organic logo means a user of that logo on its products has met a series of certification tests and measures set out in law, thus earning it the right to use the organic logo.

On the other hand, the dozens of seals and logos touting products as "green," sustainable," or natural, belong to either independent for-profit or non-profit certification organizations, non-profit environmental groups who allow the companies to use the certification seals or logos for a fee, or to companies themselves who have created their own "green seals" for their products.

Food, grocery and other consumer products retailers also have began to use terms such as "100% natural," "sustainable," "eco-friendly" and the like in their stores and on their own-brand products.

Since there currently is no national governmental scheme for certifying "green" or "sustainable" products in the U.S., these groups and companies are allowed to do as they wish basically.

For example, when it comes to the claim "all natural," the only category the U.S. government regulates in terms of putting the words on a product package is fresh poultry. And even in that case, poultry marketers are allowed to call birds which are injected with water or seaweed for example "all natural," in addition to the fact these fresh poultry marketers also can use the term "all natural" on birds that have had antibiotics and hormones used in their raising.

The proliferation of independent companies creating "green" seals or logos along with various companies using their own, poses difficulties for food and grocery retailers who are the agent for consumers by virtue of the business such retailers are in.

Further, the proliferation of these environmental seals and logos is causing lots of consumer confusion. Many wish there was a single certification seal or logo either administered by the U.S. Federal Government like the USDA organic certification program and logo, or by a government recognized independent organization, say on the order of the Good Housekeeping Seal for approved products.

Yesterday's San Francisco Chronicle has a good piece on this issue. The story looks at the various independent organizations in the U.S. who are certifying food, grocery and other products as "green," as well as the logos they've created.

The piece also discusses various consumer packaged goods and other consumer products companies that have created their own "green" logos and are using them on their brands.

Additionally, the piece speaks to the retailer issue--both from the perspective of what we refer to as being the consumers' agent--and also about retailer's that have created "green" sections in their stores and their own green certification programs and seals and logos.

Lastly, but far from least, the Chronicle story looks at how this proliferation of "green" and "eco-friendly product logos and certification schemes are affecting consumers.

As we approach Earth Day 2008 (Tuesday, April 22), issues of green marketing are taking center stage. Food and grocery retailers are at the very center of the environmental issue, from sustainability and energy conservation to green marketing. And, the issue and opportunities are only going to grow "greener."

Read the San Francisco Chronicle piece, "Green product seals are gray area," by staff writer Illana Debare here.

Note: The cleaning bottle graphic above is courtesy of the San Francisco Chronicle. The illustration is by Tracy Cox. The Earth Day 2008 logo at the top was created by Ms. Adrienne Lay.

Friday, April 18, 2008

Marketing Memo: Mega-Food Marketer Kellogg Co. is Launching a Line of Hip, Urban Streetwear as a Way To Earn Some 'Street Cred' From Younger Consumers


Mega-food company and breakfast cereal brand king Kellogg Co. isn't historically known as a hip and edgy brand marketer.

In fact, for decades since it's founding as the conservative food company from Battle Creek, Michigan which specializes in iconic breakfast cereal brands like Kellogg's Corn Flakes, Frosty Flakes, Fruit Loops and Rice Krispies, along with 22 other varieties, it has been a generally conservative and mainstream food product marketer.
However, Kellogg Co. did start moving into the natural foods segment a few years ago. First it acquired the natural foods brands Worthington and Loma Linda, which it still owns. Both are all natural brands of canned and frozen all-natural, vegetarian healthy foods products. Kellogg's has expanded both brands to include additional varieties of both canned vegetarian items and healthy frozen entrees.

A little later Kellogg's acquired the Morningstar Farms brand of healthy and vegetarian frozen and refrigerated entrees, side dishes and breakfast items, which it has grown considerably in the last few years.

The mega-food marketer then followed these acquisitions up by buying the Kashi natural foods brand, which at the time was primarily a line of all-natural and organic cereals with a couple other items like cereal bars under the Kashi brand name.

Kellogg's currently markets six different varieties of Kashi brand cereal, ranging from the original Golean variety to the newer Heart-to-Heart heart-healthy line. There also are energy and breakfast bars and snacks under the Kashi brand, as well as frozen foods items.

Most recently, the $11 billion a year food company acquired two strong natural foods brands: natural and organic Bare Naked Granola, a line of granola-based cereals and Garden Burger, the healthy soy-based line of burgers and related items. Both acquisitions fit perfectly with Kellogg's core natural and organic foods business, which is breakfast cereals and related items and healthy and vegetarian-based meals and breakfast foods.


In many ways the Battle Creek food and cereal maker and marketers' move into the natural foods sector shouldn't be a surprise. Not only is it a smart marketer that has spotted the huge potential of the natural and organic categories, but Kellogg's actually has its roots in making and selling healthy cereal such as All Bran and the original Kellogg's Corn Flakes, which contained no sugar or other artificial sweeteners.

Of course, it then got into sugar-sweet cereals like all of the other major cereal marketers because frankly that was--and to a large degree still is--hot. The company's best-selling cereal brands remain its sugar-filled cereals such as Frost Flakes, Fruit Loops, Frosted Mini Wheats, Apple Jacks and others.

However, even with its key brands the company has been coming out with reduced sugar varieties, as well as bulking up the cereals with more whole grains and fiber in recognition of the healthy eating trend.

Kellogg Co. also is a major maker and marketer of crackers and cookies, including mainstream brands like Keebler, Sunshine and Austin, specialty brands like Carrs and Famous Amos, and natural brands under the Kashi label.

The company also markets high sugar content snack items like Kellogg's Pop Tarts and Kellogg's Rice Krispy Treats, but also offers health snack items like Kashi granola and cereal bars and Stretch Island Fruit Leathers, which is another natural foods company it acquired.

Lastly, Kellogg's has extended its brands into a mainstream line of products it calls its specialty channel offerings. These items include Kellogg's Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Keebler Ice Cream Cones and a handful of other items.

Kellogg's gets hip with new line of urban streetwear

The purpose of the brief history above of Kellogg Co., from conservative mainstream food product and breakfast cereal marketer to a more diversified food company which is increasingly looking to the natural and organic foods categories for new growth and sales, is simply to show an evolution in the development of the mega food company, including growth in the natural channel via acquisitions.


With that diversification, as well as general changes in the culture and spirit of the times over the years, Kellogg's has decided it needs to create a bit more edgy and hip image for its brands.

As a way to do this, the company has launched a line of Kellogg-branded "urban design" apparel in partnership with the popular urban clothing design company Under the Hood. "Under the Hood" is one of the hottest new lines of clothing to hit the market, and has an urban streetwear, hip-hop style to its designs.

The Kellogg's-branded items in the line include: Kellogg's Corn Flakes-logo hip T-Shirts and pants; Fruit Loops-branded pants with the famous Fruit Loops' parrot logo on the pants' pockets, along with Fruit Loop T-shirts; Tony the Tiger Kellogg's Frosted Flakes emblazoned T-shirts, jackets and sweat pants; Honey Smacks cereal Jeans and Shirts; Jackets, pants and shirts featuring the famous Keebler Elves and other branded clothing items. Items also include shoes and "hoodies," the trendy and popular light jackets worn by young men and woman.

The Kellogg's-branded urban wear apparel line created and produced by Under the Hood is designed to appeal to young, hip kids and young adults. And, since that is the super-popular "Under the Hood" clothing companies target market--the line should do very well.

The hip street wear also is designed to strengthen sales of Kellogg's cereal and other food products among the younger demographic, as well as to help create a more hip and edgy image withing this target market for the brands.


Since the urban-style and hip hop scene which goes with it appeals to young people of all races, along with the fact that suburban youth love it as much as urban residents, the Kellogg's-branded apparel should reach a wide target audience.

The idea is to mesh a person's lifestyle with what one eats. It's sociographics mixed with psychographics, along with identity marketing.

We expect the hip streetwear line to do well because of the association with Under the Hood, which is such a hot clothing company and line right now many of its items are back ordered by consumers.

We also expect to see lots of cross-marketing by Kellogg's of its cereals and the branded urban streetwear clothing items. For example, offers on the back of cereal and snack foods item packages, in-store point-of-sale displays, giveaways and media advertising in hip publications targeted to the same demographic as Under the Hood's clothes are.

In terms of the quality of the Kellogg's-branded streetwear from Under the Hood, we recently talked to a 16 year old who bought a Tony the Tiger T-shirt, Jacket and pair of black sweat pants with Tony embossed on all three items of clothing. His comment when we asked how he liked the three items of Kellogg's-branded streetwear? He said, mimicking Tony the Tiger..."There Grrreat!

Beverage Marketing Memo: High-Energy Jolt Soda is Back and Hitting the Streets of Southern California With A 'High-Energy' Gorilla Marketing Campaign


Carbonated energy-drink brand Jolt Soda wants to rev-up its brand power and product sales, and it's developed a high-energy, creative way to do so.

The energy-drink category brand is hitting the streets of Southern California with a multi-elemental gorilla marketing or street campaign designed to create fun and excitement around the Jolt Soda brand and line of high-energy beverages.

Using a vehicle that looks like it belongs to an urban police department's Swat tactical team, accept that it has the words ABSURD ENERGY in bold letters on the sides along with colorful pictures of Jolt Soda, the Jolt street team is visiting 125 high-traffic areas in the Southern California counties of Orange, Los Angeles, Ventura and San Bernardino, between now through May.

The gorilla marketing street team (pictured at left in Hollywood) will give away more than 150,000 full-sized samples of Jolt Soda during the eight week campaign. Additionally, the street team is handing out thousands of retro-style Jolt branded free T-shirts and decals to people who come in contact with the Jolt Patrol roaming brand builders in their Swat Team-inspired vehicle.

The Jolt Patrol has numerous fun games and activities going on as part of its traveling marketing campaign, all designed to reintroduce the Jolt beverages to consumers using humor and irreverence. The result: Jolt hopes to start building an image as the irreverent or humorous energy drink brand.

One activity that's capturing the hearts--and hands--of consumers who encounter the Jolt patrol is called Grocery Cart Bowling. The Jolt Patrol marketers and funsters set up inflatable Jolt Soda cans and then let the consumers use shopping carts to bowl the makeshift bowling pins down.

The gorilla street marketing campaign is part of a more comprehensive relaunching of the Jolt brand by its owners, Wet Planet Beverages.

Another aspect of the brand relaunch and gorilla marketing campaign in Southern California is that Wet Planet has signed Jolt Soda up to be a sponsor of the Los Angeles division of the 11-team league World Adult Kickball Association. Yes, professional kickball.

Among the gorilla marketing activities Jolt will conduct, will be to have Jolt-branded coolers available to supply players at all the local kickball games with plenty of free high-energy soda.

Jolt brand ambassadors also will give free samples of the energy beverage to fans watching the kickball games, along with giving them store indicator cards that will list the names and addresses of stores within a two-mile range of where the games are being played, and a coupon for a discount on the drinks.

Jolt Soda has been around since 1985 when it was first launched. However, it's has some difficult times brand-wise, as well as getting a bit lost in all the clutter created by the dozens of new energy drinks introduced in the last decade.

But not anymore if the crative gorilla marketing campaign works. Jolt plans lots more activity like its gorilla marketing street patrol campaign and kickball team tie-in in Southern California.

Jolt also has launched a gorilla marketing campaign at numerous college and university campuses. The campaign hires students as Jolt Ambassadors. The student reps offer samples of the drink at various campus events as well as hold contests and giveaways of free Jolt brand items like the T-shirts and decals.

There currently are seven flavors of Jolt Soda: Power Cola, Cherry Bomb, Orange Blast, Blue Raspberry, Wild Grape, Passion Fruit, and one sugar-free variety called Ultra.

The goal is to re-energize the Jolt brand and do so in a way that grabs consumers' attention, offers them participation with the brand, makes them laugh and smile, and creates an edginess for the brand in the consumer's mind. After all, the drink's name is Jolt.

Green Retailing Memo: New Issues Emerging From Growing Consumer Use of Reusable Bags: Worker Injuries, Shoplifting Claims, 'Double-Bagging'


In Australia, the shop assistants' union which represents supermarket clerks, is claiming the growing use of reusable shopping bags, especially those of the canvas and cotton variety, is causing injuries to store clerks because the reusable bags can hold up to 40% more weight in groceries than single-use plastic carrier bags or paper grocery sacks. As a result, all the lifting and toting of the heavier-when-filled reusable bags are causing injuries to the store workers, according to the union.

As a result, the shop assistants' union is proposing laws that would protect the store workers from injuries caused by the heavier-when-filled reusable shopping bags.

The Aussie store clerks' union says it has statistics which show about 11.3% of the nation's supermarket clerks have been injured lifting the reusable shopping bags after packing them with a customer's grocery purchases.

The issue is beginning to gain steam in Australia because the country's government is expected to pass a law banning the use of single-use plastic carrier bags next year.

The union is just beginning to formulate a series of laws it says are designed to protect the store clerks from back and other injuries they say are increasingly being sustained because the canvas and cotton reusable shopping bags can hold many more items than a single-use plastic carrier bag, thus becoming much heavier to lift off checkout stand counters, put into shopping carts and carry out to customers' cars at supermarkets which offer that service.

In a piece earlier this week in which we mentioned that one unintended consequence (although it should have been expected) of the single-use plastic carrier bag ban for supermarkets over 10,000 square feet the city of San Francisco, California enacted last year, is that the use of paper grocery sacks in the stores has increased dramatically. The allow still allows the store to offer paper grocery sacks for free to shoppers.

Our point isn't to suggest the plastic bags should not have been banned. That's the choice of people and governments in democratic societies.

Rather, we're just pointing up that there often are unintended consequences when laws like bag bans are enacted.

It appears the supermarket clerk health and safety issue being brought up by the Australia shop assistant's union is one of those unintended consequences; in this case of the growing popularity of consumers doing the right and "green" thing by bringing their own reusable shopping bags to the grocery store rather than having the store use single-use plastic carrier bags or paper grocery sacks to pack their purchases.

The issue isn't isolated to Australia

The heavier reusable shopping bag issue and store worker injury or potential injury issue isn't unique to Australia. We've noticed it personally in stores in the USA. The eyes of supermarket clerks sometimes glaze over when they see a shopper present three or four canvas or cotton reusable shopping bags for their grocery order to be packed in.

We've asked a store clerk or two about that "look," and they told us the only problem with the reusable bags is that when full they are so much heavier than plastic bags--and even paper grocery sacks when filled. They've added that after an eight hour day--especially one in which lots of shoppers brought their own reusable grocery totes--of packing and lifting the heavier bags, their backs and shoulders get rather sore.

Others have noticed this phenomenon in supermarkets as well.

For example, below is a post a consumer wrote on the Yahoo Answers website regarding a discussion of just this issue involving reusable shopping bags at supermarkets:

When the cashier started scanning my merchandise I told her I brought my own bags. She just looked at me confused as hell and then said she couldn't use them. I was a little baffled because why couldn't she? I come to realize it was mostly due to pure laziness in wanting to pack with my bags. She told me I had 2 options 1. let her bag them in which she'd use the plastic bags or 2. I bag them and use my own bags.

A bit later on Yahoo Answers, a number of posters mentioned the reusable shopping bag being heavier than plastic grocery bags when full issue regarding this poster's reusable bag experience at her supermarket, as the likely culprit to that store clerk's attitude and behavior.

We doubt if such flat out refusal's are the norm--or even a 5% of the time issue. However, other consumers say they've experienced similar (though not refusals like the shopper quoted above) situations regarding supermarket clerks and reusable bags.

Below is an experience one consumer posted on a website called Daily Green:

2008 @ 2:18PMBigGUM said...Only once did a grocery clerk not want to use my bags. I suppose I could have thrown a fuss, but I opted to bag my own stuff instead. Usually my grocery store doesn't blink an eye and recently they've even started selling their own bags. Now just the other night at Target the cashier first attempted to scan my bags, then just went ahead and bagged my bags (!) in a plastic Target bag. When she finally understood what they were for she was flummoxed. Didn't I *like* the Target bag? Oh, I must be one of those save-the-environment people, right? No joke!

Other emerging issues regarding reusable shopping bags

This consumer's post points up another issue (other than the store clerk health and safety one) we've been recently told about regarding reuseable shopping bags in stores.

That issue is that in some cases store workers either tend to think shoppers are buying the bags at the store--and thus try to scan them like the consumer quoted above experienced--or even worse, we've been told by a number of consumers that store personal thought the shopper might be shoplifting with the reusable bags.

For example, below is a quote posted on Daily Green regarding the potential shoplifting issue:

-2008 @ 7:54PMAshleyThe Amazon said...I have literally been chased down by Wal Mart greeters when I enter a store with my own reusable bags, usually on a regular basis. One greeter claimed it was a theft issue and she needed to put a pink sticker on it to differentiate from their merchandise. These were bags emblazoned with "IKEA" and "Whole Foods" on them!! So obviously not theirs! I usually get dirty looks from the cashiers as well. They don't understand why I try to cram all of my items in the bags I brought. I have had these issues at 3, count them, 3 different stores. I wonder if its really a big company issue. Kinda makes me less likely to wanna go there.

Lastly, it seems many supermarket clerks are used to a certain routine which all shoppers are aware of. That routine has been company policy at supermarkets for years, primarily for perceptual rather than real reasons, but flies in the face of the reusable bag culture.

Here is an example: Clerks will put fresh meat, poultry or seafood for example into a separate plastic carrier bag so as to not let the package come into contact with other grocery products. They often do the same with fresh produce and other perishable or frozen items. In the latter case to keep the items frozen or cold. The concept is that in the separate bag there will be no "contamination."

Many shoppers who religiously bring their own bags to the store say this practice still happens to them when the supermarket clerk is bagging their grocery order.

The clerk, following store and company policy will "bag" fresh meat, poultry and seafood items for example in separate single-use plastic carrier bags, then put those bags along with all the other groceries into the customer's reusable shopping bags.

Of course, such practices defeat the source-reduction purpose the consumer intended by bringing his or her own bag to the supermarket. The shoppers then say they have to ask the clerk to please remove the items from the single-use plastic bags; which the clerks always do in the cases we've been told about or read about.

For example, here is what a poster on Daily Green had to say about the situation:

1-10-2008 @ 11:37AMBrigid Keely said...When I shop at grocery stores other than Whole Foods, I get confused looks when I say I brought my own bags. Sometimes the bagger bags everything in plastic bags (double bagged, t'boot) and then drops them in the bags I brought.One cashier teased me for having bags emblazoned with logos from stores other than his, but it was very friendly, and he made sure the bagger bagged our stuff correctly (ie, not in plastic).

Conclusion

Like all behavior and policy change, the growing use of reusable shopping bags isn't without its problems, as our examples point out. And since the goal is to grow this behavior and practice further, the unintended consequences are likely to grow and multiply.

However, we believe the in-store related behaviors can be fixed with effort by management, consumer patience, cooperation by the store clerks, and time.

The supermarket clerk injury situation currently being brought to attention by the Australian retail clerks union though could just be a bigger and less easily solved issue.

With the consumer use of reusable bags growing, more governments banning single-use plastic carrier bags completely, with others passing bag-fee laws and even retailers like Whole Foods Market self-banning the plastic bags in its stores beginning on April 22, we think the health and safety issue regarding the reusable shopping bags and potential and real store worker injuries is in its infancy. In other words, as the use of reusable shopping bags increases, so will the intensity of the issue, and not just in Australia.

We expect the issue to begin to emerge in the United States and Europe soon, as it is presently in Australia. As such, it promises to add another layer to the already multi-layer issue of paper, plastic--or reuseable bags.

New TNS Retail Forward Study Looks at What We've Called the Small-Format Grocery Store Retail Revolution in America and Quantifies Our Analysis


As regular Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) readers know, in August, 2007 we first suggested there was emerging the beginnings of a small-format grocery store retailing revolution occurring in the United States, in which major grocery chains were more-and-more getting into the game by creating and launching stores ranging in size from about 10,000 -to- 25,000 square feet, which is what we in the main define as small-format.

[Do a key-word search in the search box at the top of the blog using phrases such as small-format grocery retailing revolution, small-format grocery stores, small-format food retailing, Small Marts, small-format revolution, small-format stores, small-format food stores and small-format price-impact stores, (one phrase at a time of course) to get a sampling of those pieces. We also suggest reading through the NSFM archives for more pieces.]

We've sited the success in the U.S. of German Retailer Aldi, with its over 850 small-format, price-impact Aldi USA grocery stores, SuperValu, Inc.'s success with it's growing Sav-A-Lot small- format discount grocery chain, the Trader Joe's phenomenon, with the rapid-growth and high demand all over the U.S. for its specialty grocery stores, which now number well over 300, and the entrance into the Western USA by Tesco, with its small-format, convenience-oriented Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market grocery stores, as examples of this growing small-format grocery store revolution.

And that's not all. From August, 2007 to the present we've also sighted as evidence of a small format grocery store revolution in America, the fact that mega-retailer Wal-Mart has developed its very own small-format grocery store, it's 15,000 -to- 20,000 square foot Marketside banner, the first stores of which are set to open in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan region this summer.

Additionally, we've reported on and written about Safeway Stores, Inc.'s planned intrance into the small-format grocery store segment. Safeway plans on opening four or five 15,000 -to- 25,000 square foot combined grocery and fresh and specialty foods-oriented grocery stores this summer in the San Jose region in the San Francisco Bay Area.

Other players in this small format revolution we've written about include Pennslyvania-based Wawa Food Markets, which operates hundreds of hybrid small-format grocery markets-convenience stores in the Eastern USA, supermarket chain Hy-Vee, which recently opened its first small-format grocery store in Lincoln, Nebraska, supernatural grocery retailer Whole Foods Market, which has created Whole Foods Express, it new small-format store of about 20,000 square feet, the first of which is set to open soon in a remodeled former Wild Oats Market building in Boulder, Colorado.

These players are just the tip of the small-format grocery store retailing revolution in the USA of which we've reported on, written about and analyzed here in Natural~Speciatly Foods Memo.

Lastly, we've also written about the fact that the original small-format food retailer, the local independent grocer, continues to thrive in Americaby building and operating small-format grocery stores. That independent is in fact the model in many ways for the small-format revolution being created by this larger, chain operators.

International small-format grocery store revolution

Further, we've also said there's an international small-format grocery store revolution occurring. Many of the players are the same--with a few more added--internationally.

Tesco, with its rapidly-growing Tesco Express hybrid grocery store/convenience store chain and German grocery chains Aldi and Lidl are leading the international small-format grocery retailing revolution.

France's Carrfour, the second largest retailer in the world, is becoming a major player in the international small-format grocery store revolution as well, especially in Asia.

And of course, many other smaller players, as is the case in the U.S., are part of the growing small-format grocery store revolution throughout parts of the globe.

New TNS Retail Forward small-format grocery store study

It's seems we were somewhat on track beginning nearly ten months ago when we proclaimed a small-format grocery store revolution was occurring in the U.S., as well as in many other parts of the world.

A new study just released by the well-respected market research firm TNS Forward's Columbus, Ohio office says consumers are ready and willing to shop at small-format grocery stores that feature convenience in shopping and fresh, prepared foods.

The study also includes a caution which we use frequently in our pieces here at NSFM, which is that the jury is still out as to whether small-format grocery stores in general will meet consumer expectations, satisfy their needs as a primary or even secondary shopping venue, and provide a return on investment for the stores' owners.

The study also hits on three key points we make often about small-format grocery stores:

>Research: The study says food retailers considering a small-format grocery store strategy must monitor and analyze shopper needs, attitudes and expectations well in advance of launching a small-format store or chain.

>Localism: The report says paying attention and focusing on local (region and neighborhood) culture (and cultural differences) and demographics is key in launching any small-format grocery store venture.

>Partnering: The research study says retailer's launching a small-format grocery store venture need to seek input from grocery, fresh foods and consumer packaged goods suppliers and partners, as they have national knowledge as well as local experience, among other reasons for doing so.

The above three aspects of small-format grocery store retailing, which we summarize as research, localism and partnering, are themes we've been including in out numerous pieces on the small-format grocery store retailing revolution occurring in the U.S. and in other parts of the world for months.

U.S. Consumer attitudes about small-format grocery stores

The TNS Retail Forward study says 64% of U.S. shoppers surveyed said they would either definitely or probably shop at a small-format grocery store. [Based on our own research and some others we think that number is a bit higher.]

The study also notes consumers surveyed indicated the combination of the small-format (convenience), combined with fresh, prepared foods offerings is a compelling offer for "the time-pressed shopper."

Jennifer Halterman, a senior consultant at TNS Retail Forward and the primary author of the study says, "The small-store trend is part of an ongoing evolution in the retail food sector, and we expect more players to throw their hats into the ring."

We agree completely with the latter part of her quote--that more retailers are throwing, and getting ready to throw, their small-format grocery store retailing hats in the ring. I

In fact, we invite Ms. Halterman--and our readers--to stay tuned over the next couple of weeks as we will be reporting and writing about some new entrants into the small-format grocery store retailing revolution who nobody else has reported on yet. In fact, look for one or more of those fresh pieces later today, along with lots of upcoming analysis in the weeks ahead.

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Green Retailing Memo: Sainsbury's Rejects UK Bag-Fee Scheme; CEO Says Will Use A Customer 'Carrot' Instead of the 'Stick'


The combination of proposed legislation in the United Kingdom which would either levy a fee on each single-use plastic carrier bag a customer requests in a supermarket or ban the bags outright, along with a campaign called "Ban the (plastic) Bags," launched in February by London's Daily Mirror newspaper, has dramatically increased the plastic grocery bag use issue in the nation's supermarket and related retail industries, as well as among politicians and consumers.

British Chancellor Alistair Darling, who has the support of Prime Minister Gordon Brown, recently outlined a plan to pass legislation which would place a per-bag charge on the single-use plastic carrier bags unless the nation's retailers (especially supermarkets) take meaningful steps to reduce the bags' use.

In response, Sainsbury's CEO Justin King said yesterday: "Sainsbury's does not believe that charging for single-use bags is the only answer or that it is the most likely way to achieve lasting benefit for the environment."

"forcing customers to make a decision they don't fully understand is not the best way to achieve sustained behavior change," King added in a statement. "This (behavioral change) requires a series of actions to help customers to reduce, reuse and recycle."

Kings says beginning this weekend, Sainsbury's will test number of new initiatives and programs designed to determine what engages and helps people to reduce the number of single-use plastic carrier bags they use.

"Since last April, we (Sainsbury's) believe we've given away more free "bags for life" (inexpensive reusable carrier bags) than any other retailer," King says. "We now need to help customers remember to re-use them to make a difference on this issue and achieve a 50% reduction in disposable bag use."

Nearly all of the UK's leading supermarket chains--Tesco, Asda, Sainsbury's, Morrisons, Waitrose, Marks & Spencer and the Co-op among them--have pledged to reduce the number of single-use plastic carrier bags they use in their stores by 25% by the end of this year, over the amount the respective chain's used last year.

King has now set the single-use plastic carrier bag reduction goal for Sainsbury's to 50% by this time next year.

The primary "carrot" or rewarding mechanism Sainbury's plans to use in its campaign to reduce the use of the thin, single-use plastic carrier bags in its stores is to begin giving customers extra reward points for using their own reusable shopping bags in the stores.

The grocery chain will give shoppers 1-point on their reward cards for every reusable shopping bag used at the checkouts, including single-use plastic carrier bags from any retail store. In other words, bring your-own bag of any kind and get a reward point.

A survey of Sainsbury's shoppers by the retailer found that 73% of those surveyed wanted an economic reward for using their own reusable shopping bags in the stores, according to King. The reward points program will begin in June.

King says Sainsbury's also will hold store parking lot campaigns in which employees will hand out free refrigerator magnets and car stickers that remind shoppers to bring their own grocery bags to the store.

This isn't an original idea. Numerous supermarket chains in the U.S. already have a similar reward card scheme for customers who bring their own bags to the store, as does Tesco, the UK's leading retailer.

King also said Sainsbury's will soon begin using single-use plastic carrier bags made from 50% recycled content. The grocery chain's single-use plastic carrier bags currently in use are made from 33% recycled content.

Sainsbury's plans to monitor the progress of its reward card points scheme. King says as the chain learns what motivates shoppers more to reduce their desire for the plastic bags it plans on initiating other reward-based programs if needed.

Meanwhile, as we reported some time ago, Marks & Spencer, which is a food, grocery, soft goods and general merchandise retailer in the UK, is thus far the first and only grocery retailer in the nation to announce it will voluntarily charge customers a fee for each single-use plastic carrier bag they request. That fee will be about 10 cents per bag.

However, since Ireland has had a per single-use plastic carrier bag fee law in place since 2002, every UK supermarket chain with stores in Ireland must charge for the bags by law.

Meanwhile, not one of the UK's leading grocery chains--not even the "super green" Co-op--has said they will stop using single-use plastic carrier bags completely, like Austin, Texas USA-based Whole Foods Market will do in all its stores in the U.S., Canada and the United Kingdom on April 22, Earth Day.

Whole Foods currently has just one store in the UK, a huge 75,000 square foot natural foods' superstore in London. However, the retailer is in the process of scouting for numerous locations in the nation to open more stores.

Ironically, come April 22, the only supermarket in the UK then that will not offer single-use plastic carrier bags at all will be a branch of a United States-based grocery chain--Whole Foods Market.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo Analysis

With all due respect to Sainsbury's CEO Justin King, he's wrong that putting a per-bag fee on single-use plastic carrier bags doesn't change consumer or shopper behavior. There's plenty of empirical evidence--not to mention common intuitive sense--suggesting it does just that.

For example, as we reported here yesterday, Ireland passed a per-bag fee law in 2002. The government now reports single-use plastic carrier bag use has decreased by a whopping 94% since that law was passed.

A similar law in the island nation of Taiwan has achieved reduction results much the same as the Irish example.

Even absent this empirical evidence, don't we all believe in the main if a shopper is offered the choice of lets say three free paper grocery bags for their grocery order at the checkout, versus the choice of paying 10 or 15 cents each for three or four single-use plastic carrier bags to package the same grocery order, said customer will most likely on average say "paper please?"

We aren't criticizing King and Sainsbury's for its actions. Not at all. Nor are we saying the retailer's program can't achieve some results. Rather, we are merely stating facts in terms of behavior change on the issue, and offering empirical and inductive evidence for such change.

Further, whether we agree with the practice or not, the fact is laws that eliminate the use of the plastic carrier bags in retail stores most certainly change behavior fast.

For example, last year the city of San Francisco, California banned the use of the bags in grocery stores over 10,000 square feet in size.

There are about 30 supermarkets of this size in the city of about 800,000. The result: overnight there was a behavioral change since customers shopping those stores will no longer have the choice of plastic. Rather, it's either free paper grocery bags or bring their own reusable bags, which should be the ultimate goal of any scheme in our analysis.

Unfortunately perhaps for them, San Francisco's hundreds of grocery and convenience-oriented stores under 10,000 square feet in size haven't seen any increase in sales from consumers leaving the supermarkets over not being able to get plastic bags at the larger stores.

Our point is not to either advocate outright bans or bag-fees. There can be unintended consequences of even those schemes, such as a dramatic increase in the use of paper grocery bags which is occurring in San Francisco since the single-use bag ban was enacted last year.

However, although paper grocery bags actually require more energy inputs to produce than the plastic bags, and an increase in their use means cutting down more trees for the paper, they also are much easier to recycle. For example, nearly every city in the U.S. has household curbside recycling programs for paper grocery bags--but few if any take the single-use plastic grocery bags for recycling.

We hope Sainsbury's is able to achieve a 50% reduction in the number of single-use plastic carrier bags its stores use through its reward points program. However, we doubt it will, based on experience and data from with supermarket chains which have been doing similar schemes for sometime.

Further, the single-use plastic carrier bag issue is a serious one. The bags are littered all over the roadside by irresponsible individuals, are filling landfills and take decades to decompose once in them, and are clogging the Pacific Ocean with a plastic bag mass which currently is the size of the continental Unites States, and stretches from Hawaii to Japan.

Grocers are part of the problem, and therefore need to be part of the solution. Increasingly we think that solution is at least charging shoppers at the store for the plastic grocery bags. And, when done, it should be the law for all types and sizes of retail stores, not just supermarkets or grocery stores.

Of course, the main cause of the litter aspect of this issue are irresponsible individuals, who dispose of the single-use plastic carrier bags improperly. We think littering fines for this behavior should be tripled.

Lastly, but far from least, are the manufacturers of the plastic bags. The technology to make faster-decomposing (in landfills) and more-rapidly composting (compost pile) plastic carrier bags has been around for some years. However, the industry, with the exception of some entrepreneurial companies, has avoided it. Instead they've preferred to use the old technology because it's more profitable to do so rather than invest in the new technologies.

Further, rather than invest significantly in these new technologies and create a more rapidly-decomposing and faster-composting bag, the single-use plastic carrier bag industry's leading companies seem to have decided to spend that money fighting bag-bans and bag-fee legislation instead. The industry seems to have left grocers to fend for themselves on the issue.

We all know that in business, when your product no longer offers more benefits than it does negatives, it becomes obsolete. That's what has happened to the traditional single-use plastic carrier bag. As a result, the focus of the issue has become how to reduce the use--and the plastic bag industry isn't even a major player in the discussion.

Recent Related Pieces From Natural~Specialty Foods Memo:

>Green Memo: "Ireland Has Reduced the Use of Single-Use Plastic Carrier Bags By 94 Percent With Bag-Fee Law; Has Exceeded EU Recycling Targets." [Click here to read.]

>Green Retailing Memo: "California State Assembly Committee to Vote On Plastic Bag-Fee Measure Monday; Many Grocers support Bag-Fee Legislation." [Click here to read.]

>Food & Grocery Legislation Memo: "California Assembly Natural Resources Committee to Consider Second Plastic Bag Bill Along With Original Today." [Click here to read.]

>Green Memo Feature: "Scientific Evidence From the Lands and From the Oceans Suggests it's Time to Solve the Plastic Waste Issue." [Click here to read.]

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Green Memo: Ireland Has Reduced the Use of Single-Use Plastic Carrier Bags By 94 Percent With Bag-Fee Law; Has Exceeded EU Recycling Targets


A spokesman for the government of Ireland tells Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) its statistics show that since the Emerald Island put a per-bag fee on single-use plastic carrier bags in 2002, there has been a whopping 94% reduction in the use of the thin grocery and shopping bags in the country.

In 2002, Ireland passed a law which required supermarkets and other retail stores to charge shoppers a per-bag fee if they requested their purchases be packaged in a single-use plastic carrier bag rather than a paper or reusable carrier bag. Before the law was passed, single-use plastic carrier bags were given to shoppers for free in Ireland, as is still the case in many if not most country's of the world.

This data should be of particular interest to nation's like the UK, of which Ireland is a part, which are currently debating in Parliament as to if it should pass an outright ban on the single-use plastic carrier bags, and if so whether at all retail stores or just supermarkets, or if it should levy a per-bag fee scheme like the Irish have.

The data should also be of interest in California, where as we reported here on Friday April 11 and again on April 14, the California State Assembly Natural Resource Committee is considering two bills that would levy either a 25 cent or 15 cent fee per-single-use carrier bags in the state's larger supermarkets and drug stores.

And of course, the Irish example should be of interest everywhere in the world because nation's and local governments globally are in the process, and many already have done so, of voting on or proposing single-use plastic carrier bags laws of one sort or another.

The Irish example also should be noted by grocery retailers who either are completely against such bans or are debating whether to support state and local government bag fees over outright single-use plastic carrier bag bans.

National, state, provincial and municipal governments all over the world have proposed laws either banning the bags completely or adding a fee to them if requested by a shopper. Most experts believe it's just a matter of a couple years before most nation's have laws either charging for or banning the plastic bags.

Irish exceed EU packaged waste recycling targets by 14 percent

In addition to the dramatic reduction in the number of single-use plastic carrier bags, the Irish government and its citizens have also exceeded that European Union's (EU) target's for the recycling of packaged waste, such as food and grocery packaging and containers.

The government spokesperson told us the latest figures available show Ireland is recovering and recycling 64% of all its packaged waste, compared to a EU target of 50%.

This combination of the 94% reduction in the use of plastic carrier bags and the 64% packaged waste recovery and recycling rate makes Ireland arguably the biggest success story globally in both source-reduction and packaged waste recovery and recycling.

The government spokesperson told us Ireland doesn't plan on resting on it's laurels in either regard. It thinks it can decrease plastic carrier bag use to near 100% in the next couple years, as well as increasing the nation's packaged waste recycling rate even higher than the current 64%.

Other UK country's, along with states in the U.S. and elsewhere, should go to school on the Irish model as a way to increase both their recycling rates and use-reduction of the single-use carrier bags.

Grocery retailers should take note as well. Rather than fighting legislation to levy a per-bag fee on the single-use plastic grocery bags, they might want to take the advice of Ireland's grocers who agree in the main with the per-bag consumer surcharges, as well as with those grocers in Northern California's San Francisco Bay Area who we quoted in this piece last week.

We think the single-use plastic carrier bag industry might want to think about supporting some sort of per-bag fee scheme throughout the world as well, since more outright bans like those recently enacted in China, parts of Africa, in San Francisco and Oakland, California in the U.S. and other numerous other places throughout the globe, are coming fast and furiously.