Showing posts with label small format stores. Show all posts
Showing posts with label small format stores. Show all posts

Friday, March 28, 2008

Small-Format Grocery Retailing Memo: Stretching the Boundaries of Convenience Store Retailing; Some Say Japan's Natural Lawson is Awesome


Convenience stores are as ubiquitous in Japan as grains of white rice and packages of Ramon noodles are. There are about 40,000 combini, as convenience stores are called in Japan, in the nation, or one for every 3,200 residents.

One of the largest combini operators in Japan--in addition to market share leader Seven-Eleven Japan, Circle K Sunkus (number two) and number three FamilyMart,--is Lawson, which operates 8,400 convenience stores in all 47 of the nation's prefectures.

If the name Lawson sounds American that's because it is. The origin of the Lawson name originated in the U.S. state of Ohio in 1939. A man named J.J. Lawson started up a milk business there called Lawson's Milk, and opened a chain of store's in the state to sell his milk. The milk stores evolved into convenience-type stores and in 1959 Consolidated Foods Co. bought out Lawson.

In 1974, Consolidated Foods partnered with Japanese food retailer Daiei to open the first Lawson branded convenience store in Osaka in 1975. Daiei opened many more Lawson stores throughout the 1970's and 1980's. In 1989, Daiei merged another chain called Sun Chain which it operated in Japan, with Lawson and created Daiei Convenience stores. In 1996, the combined operation was renamed Lawson, Inc., with all the stores getting the Lawson banner.

The Lawson banner is long gone in the U.S. Its stores all became Dairy Mart convenience stores in the states over a decade ago.

The majority of the 8,400 Lawson combini (c-stores) in Japan are conventional convenience stores similar to those in the U.S. and Europe. However, Lawson also operates two other formats in Japan. The first is called Lawson Store 100, a 20-store chain which sells various items for 100 yen each. It's similar to a dollar or 99-cents store in the U.S.

Lawson's other format, and the one of interest in this piece, is called Natural Lawson. It's an upscale, high-end convenience store format positioned to serve Japanese women and the nation's seniors rather than salarymen. Salarymen are working men in Japan. Like their counterpart convenience stores in the U.S. and Europe, which traditionally target men, the majority of Japan's c-stores still do the same.

There currently are about 24 Natural Lawson small-format convenience stores in Japan, with 12 located in Tokyo. The stores' offer a broad selection of foods and other items for shoppers. The focus is on health and wellness, and increasingly on upscale, fresh prepared foods, along with natural and specialty groceries and non-foods.

Specialty foods brands line Natural Lawson's shelves and perishable cases. There's locally-grown produce, including organic, provided by a local Japanese farming collective. Organic groceries, coffee, teas and other foods and beverages are plentiful in the stores. High-end, all natural cosmetics for woman are offered for sale along with other natural health and wellness-oriented items, including those for pets.

An area Natural Lawson is moving further into is offering a diverse selection of healthy, upscale-quality fresh prepared foods, breads and related items. For example, the natural c-store retailer sells an all-natural healthier version of the popular bento lunchbox, which is a staple of Japan's working class. Basic bento boxes are sold in all of the nation's conventional convenience stores.

Natural Lawson recently entered into an alliance with NaturalBeat, which operates a chain of high-end sandwich and delicatessen stores in Japan. The stores' prepared food items are all homemade, using natural ingredients with no food additives, preservatives or artificial colors. NaturalBeat also has a subsidiary called Wholesome Co. Ltd. which produces all natural healthy fresh breads and other baked goods.

All Natural Lawson convenience stores are now selling NaturalBeat's healthy, upscale-quality prepared foods, including sandwiches, salads, entrees and other grab-and-go items. The stores also are featuring the healthy fresh breads and baked goods produced by Wholesome Co. Ltd. Fresh, prepared foods--especially all natural and upscale--are a rarity in Japan's combini, so natural Lawson is blazing a new trail in the category for convenience stores in the nation.

In addition to focusing on its product selection, Natural Lawson is taking great care in how its stores look, something that wasn't evident at all when its first stores opened in 2001.

Today's stores reflect the retailer's target market and positioning. Soft colors and natural woods are used inside the stores, appealing to the retailer's prime target shopper--women. There's no neon lighting like in Japan's typical conventional combini. Instead, soft, recessed lighting is used throughout the stores, complementing the natural woods and pastel colors. Many of the stores have a bar area where shoppers can lounge, and where trained staff members give out health, wellness and beauty tips. Additionally, Natural Lawson uses an upscale, attractive font-style and natural motif graphic for its logo on the signs outside each store, inviting shoppers to come inside.

The stores' brand--via its design, merchandising and product offerings--says Natural Lawson is the place to shop for premium, natural and healthy merchandise in a convenient format. This is still new to Japanese shoppers who are used to going to a combini to get coffee, tea, soft drinks, pastries and other basic convenience items. Conventional c-stores in Japan also are popular for offering mobile phones, fax services, ticket sales, photocopies and other similar service-type offerings.

There's a space in Japan's huge convenience store market for something other than traditional combini retailing, which is what Seven-Eleven Japan, Circle K and in the main Lawson itself does with all but its 24 Natural Lawson and 20 100 yen format stores. This is especially true when it comes to quality fresh prepared food and meals merchandising. It's nearly non-existent in the nation's c-stores. You can get a sandwich, standard bento box and other very basic grab-and-go prepared foods' items, but that's about it.

In fact, Natural Lawson is getting some competition in Japan in this yet to be proven merchandising niche of fresh prepared foods from British retailer Tesco. Tesco is opening a Japanese version of its popular and successful Tesco Express format stores in the nation that loves convenience stores. Tesco Express stores are a mix of convenience store and small supermarket, typically selling high-quality fresh foods, prepared meals and other offerings found in Tesco supermarkets but offered in convenience store-sized urban settings.

The British retailer, parent company of small-format Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market in the U.S., is opening 25 of these Express stores to start in Japan. The stores will sell basic grocery and other items along with lots of fresh prepared foods, meal solutions and quality grab-and-go items, as well as some other fresh and specialty grocery items. Tesco already has some of its Express format stores in Thailand through its Tesco Lotus division in that country.

Meanwhile, Natural Lawson is in the process of perfecting its merchandising mix, positioning itself not only as a higher-end combini for fresh, natural and quality foods, but also as a destination for busy urban Japanese women who want quality natural health and beauty items in an attractive and comfortable setting designed with them in mind.

There's no question Japanese consumers love their combini. After all there's one convenience store for every 3,200 Japanese. In Tokyo, there's literally a combini on every corner. And a joke in Japan says the only difference in the more rural areas is that there's a combini on every other corner. To put it in perspective, the U.S. has about 24 times more land mass than Japan does--but it has only half as many 7-Eleven's.

Natural Lawson is stretching the definition of "convenience store" not only just in the c-store capital of the world Japan but internationally as well. Just as Tesco is importing its brand of "Express" convenience retailing to places like Eastern Europe, Japan and the USA, it will be interesting to see if retailers in these western countries pick up on what Natural Lawson is doing with its 24 stores in Japan and try a similar format at home, in the U.S. or Europe.

To a degree it's happening in the U.S. already. In addition to Tesco's Fresh & Easy stores, 60 of which have thus far opened in California, Arizona and Nevada, there's Trader Joe's (a somewhat similar format to Natural Lawson), Wawa, an upscale convenience store operator in the Eastern U.S. which puts a major focus on fresh prepared foods, Giant Eagle Express and a couple others.

Additionally, as we've reported, Wal-Mart plans to open it's own version (4-5 stores) of a small-format, hybrid basic grocery and fresh and specialty foods market called Marketside in the Phoenix, Arizona region this summer. Safeway Stores, Inc. also plans to open 4-5 new, small-format hybrid grocery markets in the San Francisco Bay Area as well this summer.

Further, Whole Foods Market, Inc. is in the process of opening its own upscale, all natural convenience-type store in Boulder Colorado. The store, called Whole Foods Express, will be a prototype for the supernatural foods retailer in terms of natural products retailing in a smaller, convenience-oriented format. The store will be about 14,000 square feet. In Japan that's considered a big store, especially in Tokyo. For Whole Foods its radically small, especially since the grocer's average new lifestyle natural supermarkets range from about 55,000 to 80,000 square feet.

In Western Europe, Tesco pioneered the Express convenience format. There are a few other players who've joined the market niche as well, with more considering doing so. Tesco's also taken it's Express format creation to Eastern Europe, especially Poland, where its small-format, hybrid Express stores are doing extremely well. And, of course, Tesco Express was the inspiration for the retailers small-format, combination basic grocery and fresh and specialty foods Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market grocery stores in the U.S.

None though are doing quite what Natural Lawson is doing in Japan, with it's combination of quality natural-organic foods, non-foods and health, wellness and beauty offerings. If Natural Lawson can bring a new definition to convenience retailing in Japan--or at least add to the current definition--it could create a solid niche for itself among those its targeting--busy women and seniors who many think aren't currently being fully-served by the nation's conventional combini.

Men like natural products offerings too, even if they aren't the primary target market. And in Japan, like elsewhere, men buy lots of gifts for the women in their lives. That's another market Natural Lawson should look at.

Sunday, January 13, 2008

Retail Memo: Breaking News: Wal-Mart to Open New Small Format Grocery Stores in Arizona

The "Small Mart" food retailing battle is enjoined: Wal-Mart will open its first, new small-format grocery markets in Arizona later this year, and do battle with British retailer Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores, the first of which opened in Arizona a little over a month ago.

As our readers know, we've been reporting on, writing about, and analyzing the small format retail food store revolution in the U.S. for the last six months or so. A major part of that reporting has been about Wal-Mart's small grocery store format development, which a group of the retailer's key executives worked on for a number of months last year in San Francisco.

(Type in the keywords (one set at a time) Wal-Mart, small marts, small format stores, small format revolution, in the search box at the top of the blog and you can read our numerous pieces on the topic.)

Our (much bigger) friends at the Financial Times have also been covering the Wal-Mart small- format grocery store story and its developments.

The Financial Times is reporting in tomorrow's edition that Wal-Mart will open small-format grocery markets named "MarketSide" in Arizona later this year, going head-to-head with Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores in that market.

The new "Small Marts" are about 20,000 square feet in size, a 10th of the size of the retailer's Supercenters, but about 5,000 to 7,000 square feet larger than Tesco's Fresh & Easy stores, which average about 13,000 to 15,000 square feet.

The Financial Times reports Wal-Mart has secured leases on four properties south-east of Phoenix for the 20,000 square foot "MarketSide" grocery stores. Some of these locations are only a mile away from Fresh & Easy store locations in the region.

According to tomorrow's Financial Times, the stores should open this summer. That fits with what our sources have been telling us. They're predicting a July-August opening, although they didn't have the exact store locations.

The logo for the "MarketSide" stores, which is filed in documents with the various municipal planning departments in Arizona, is a stylised tomato, egg and grape topped by Wal-Mart's signature blue star. The lettering is in green.

The logo obviously connotes freshness. We've been reporting in our stories for the last few months that the small-format stores would offer extensive prepared foods selections, like Fresh & Easy stores do, and believe the logo--along with other information we have--reinforces our belief.

We've also reported, as has the Financial Times, that as a result of its San Francisco team's development work, Wal-Mart trademarked the names "City Thyme" and "Field & Vine." We reported these were two of a number of store names the retailer was considering for its new small-format grocery stores, and still believe that to be the case. However, obviously they didn't use either of those names--or any of the others they were considering.

The Financial Times suggests some industry analysts think the retailer might be going to use these names on a new private label line of prepared foods or grocery products (or both) for the new, "MarketSide" stores.

We agree with their analysis. Both names fit well with the "MarketSide" logo described above--and both evoke freshness and naturalness. One of our sources also told us in late December that he was told by someone he trusts that a Wal-Mart executive was talking to a couple of natural foods-oriented companies about private label product "opportunities."

All four of the Wal-Mart "MarketSide" store sites are street-corner properties that were formally occupied by drug stores, the Financial Times reports.

The locations of the four Arizona stores are: Mesa: 7561 E Baseline Road, Gilbert: 910 E. Elliott Road, Chandler: 950 N McQueen Road, Tempe: 838 W Elliott Road.

Fresh & Easy currently has five stores in Arizona, and many more are set to be opened this year. Three of the Arizona Fresh & Easy grocery markets are located in Mesa, one is in Chandler, and the fifth and newest store is in Scottsdale. That market, which is at 10781 N. Frank Lloyd Wright Blvd., opened three weeks ago before the Christmas holiday. Tesco has plans to open stores in Gilbert and Tempe soon.

In addition to its Supercenter grocery and general merchandise stores, and it's basic Wal-Mart stores, the retailer also operates its Neighborhood Market format. These stores are essentially what they sound like: basic, full-line supermarkets. The stores are about 48,000 square feet and sell a complete selection of grocery store items in a somewhat smaller space than a superstore.

Last week, Wal-Mart announced it hired British grocery retailing veteran Jack Sinclair to head its food retailing business. Sinclair worked as an executive for Tesco for many years, as well as being a former exec for UK Safeway, which is now part of the Morrisons' chain.

Sinclair knows Tesco well, and has been observing its launch of the Fresh & Easy Neighborhood market stores in the Western USA closely. Upon hearing of his hire, we knew it would be a go for Wal-Mart's small-format stores. The fit was just too tight for it not to happen.

The development of and decision making process to go forward with the "Small Marts" hasn't been easy within Wal-Mart. And until recently it wasn't a lock that the mega-retailer would go forward with the program. However, the world's largest retailer doesn't want the world's third-largest retailer, Tesco, to steal market share from it on its home turf--the USA.

Tesco and Wal-Mart, which owns the UK supermarket chain Asda, are battling for market share in Britain, Tesco's home turf, so--the battle is now fully-enjoined on both sides of the Atlantic.

Editor's Note: We're following this story closely, and will have some further information and developments to report as we are able to talk with our sources on Monday. Additionally, we're working on an analysis piece about how Wal-Mart's decision to finally join the small retail food store format revolution will impact the other retail players already in the game. Stay tuned.

Monday, January 7, 2008

Retail Memo: The International Small Store Format Revolution Marches On

As our regular readers are aware, we've been reporting on, writing about, and offering analysis on the international small format food retailing revolution for the last 4-5 months.

We've written about Tesco's Express stores in Europe, the retailer's new Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small store format in the USA, German grocer Aldi's no frills, price-impact, small format grocery markets throughout the world, and others.

Among the others include: U.S. grocer Giant Eagle's Express format stores, Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s Express prototype store soon to open in Boulder, Colorado, Wawa Grocery Markets, Trader Joe's, and Wal-Mart, which is developing two small format stores: a grocery market and a small footprint health and wellness-type store. (Check out the blog's archives for the numerous small format and related stories.)

We've termed the international proliferation of small format stores--some upscale, others no frills with price-impact positioning, and still others somewhere in the middle--no less than a revolution in food retailing.

This isn't because there haven't always been small food stores throughout the world. There has been. But rather it's because of the scale in which various retailers are developing the stores, the number of stores they are building, and the fact that those retailers getting into the small format food retailing business are among the largest chains in the world.

One of those retailers, Tesco, the third-biggest retailer in the world, is a key leader in multi-small format food retailing. It began with its Tesco Express stores in Britain, and is now locating the small format Express stores throughout Europe, and is planning to enter Russia with the convenience-style grocery markets soon.

Tesco also has opened about 30 of its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market small format grocery markets in the U.S. thus far--in just a two month period of time. The retailer plans to have as many as 200 of the combination basic grocery markets, fresh, prepared and specialty foods stores opened by the end of this year.

Now, Tesco is at it again: The retailer is developing a new, no frills, price-impact, small format food store for the United Kingdom (UK). The reason the retailer is developing the new format is to counter a growing threat in its home market from German grocers Aldi and Lidl, which operate price-impact, no frills, small format grocery stores throughout the UK.

The Aldi and Lild stores are becoming increasingly popular with UK shoppers, who like their limited assortments, low prices and convenience. Tesco sees these stores as a major threat to its market share in the UK, and has decided to fight back.

According to a story in today's London Telegraph.co.uk, Tesco has been hard at work on a top secret project in an old warehouse owned by its founder Jack Farmer, designing the new format. The retailer has created a mock German small format discount store (read Aldi and Lidl) in the warehouse and is using it as a model for their own future no frills, small format discount stores.

Tesco used this same strategy and model in developing its Fresh & Easy convenience-oriented grocery markets in the U.S. For about two years the retailer worked on the design of what today is a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market in an old warehouse in the states. And just like the current project in Britain, Tesco was able to keep its Fresh & Easy project quiet for some time before the press got wind of it.

But the new discount grocery format project is out of the grocery bag now, so to speak. And, once again, we see the small format revolution marching even further on.

Based on the information we have from various sources--in addition to what was reported in the Telegraph.co.uk story--the new Tesco price-impact, small format market looks like it might be similar to its Fresh & Easy stores in the U.S.--a hybrid discount grocery store, combined with low-priced, upscale specialty groceries and prepared foods offerings.

This is largely do to the fact that Aldi, and to a lessor degree Lidl, have been doing extremely well in the UK offering specialty, gourmet and natural foods items at discount prices along with private label (and some national brand) basic groceries.

Aldi has especially become adept at this--no doubt in part because the German grocer has lots of experience with private label specialty items at its Trader Joe's subsidiary in the USA. Yes, it's that same Aldi. The one that operates 900 no frills grocery stores in the U.S., and upscale Trader Joe's as well. It's also the same Aldi that operates throughout the world, and is growing its small format, discount grocery business extensively worldwide.

Tesco, the UK's number one retailer, isn't about to let Aldi and Lidl take market share away from the company in the UK though, if it can help it. Therefore, it is developing its own version of these small, category-killer, discount grocery stores.

Further, Tesco isn't waiting until it has an actual store to fight back against the two German panzer divisions of grocery retailing. Beginning this week, the mega-retailer will match Aldi's and Lidl's retail prices on over 2,000 items the grocers' sell at hot, discount prices. (Aldi and Lidl sell on average about 10,000 grocery items in their small format stores respectively.)

Additionally, Tesco is launching this week a line of 300 no frills grocery products, similar to those sold in Lidl and Aldi's UK discount stores. Further, In a few months the retailer plans to rollout another 200 items in the no frills line. These items will be sold in all of Tesco's UK supermarkets. It's also expected that this will be a good test market for the items in terms of their merchandising potential in the future Tesco no frills, small format , discount food stores.

The small format food retailing revolution may not be being televised, but it's heating up throughout the world. Stay tuned.

Resources:
Read more about the Tesco's new no frills, small format, discount store plans here.
Read more about Tesco's new no frills product line here.