Showing posts sorted by date for query small format food retailing revolution. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query small format food retailing revolution. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Thursday, April 9, 2009

Small Format Food Retailing Memo - Design Innovation: Supermarket Design Firm Wins Award For Design of Independent 'The Market' Specialty Grocery


Design Services Group (DSG), the supermarket design firm owned by supermarket chain Supervalu, Inc. has won the 2009 Outstanding Merit Award from the Association for Retail Environments (A.R.E.) design association for its design work on the independently-owned small-format specialty and natural foods store "The Market" (pictured above), which is located in Plymouth, Massachusetts USA.

DSG won the prestigious Outstanding Merit award at the just-ended 2009 A.R.E. Retail Design Awards event at GlobalShop, held in Las Vegas.

The award recognizes excellence in retail store design, craftsmanship and innovation. This is the second time DSG has been awarded an A.R.E. Retail Design Award: it won a grocery store category award in 2006 for its design of "Highland Park Market" in Windsor, Conn.

The 13,500 square foot "The Market" is the creation of specialty and natural foods retailing veteran Michael Szathmary, who is the store's managing director, and his associates. Szathmary's 40 year retailing career includes having founded and launched the Nature’s Heartland grocery store and Szathmary’s market/cafes in Needham and Brookline, Massachusetts. [Related post - January 20, 2008: Retail Memo: Designing the 'Perfect' Small-Format Grocery Store in a 'Near-Perfect' Place.]

The store's manager is food retailing veteran Mark Guinasso. Guinasso been in the grocery business for over 30 years, with previous management positions at Purity Supreme, Western Beef Supermarkets, Walter’s Meat Market and Nature’s Heartland, where he worked closely with Michael Szathmary.

The fresh produce department (above), named "Farmers Market," at the small-format "The Market" store keeps with the store's overall design theme of showcasing fresh foods in a rustic setting modeled after a 19th century farmers' market.

This is how the owners and management of "The Market" describe the store's format and retailing approach: "We’re The Market. And we want to change the way you shop — for the better, quicker, healthier and happier. With fresh, locally grown foods in season, expert help and our everyday value pricing on the everyday conventional groceries you need . . . every day.Our name says it all: simple, direct, not too fancy — full of good things waiting to be discovered. In fact, we want to make shopping an experience you actually enjoy.

It begins with healthy, high-quality food: like locally grown, seasonal produce. Freshly baked artisan breads. A delectable deli. Certified Angus beef and naturally raised chicken. And fish right off the boat. Fresh is best.

We also offer a constantly changing array of specialty items created in our own kitchen by our own chef and team — in case you’re too busy or tired to cook. Just heat and serve.

Plus, we have experienced people who know their stuff and are ready to help you. Whether it’s catering a party of fifty or just carrying your bags to your car. We’ve made the aisles more convenient, the displays a little tastier. You can pick up a bouquet by Martin’s Flowers just next to our bakery. And we’ve opened a doorway to Long Ridge Wine & Spirits next door. We’ve even selected great music for you to shop by."

You can learn more about the small-format grocery store at its Web site here.

The Deli department (above) at the independently-owned, small-format "The Market" features scores of deli items and ready-to-heat and ready-to-eat fresh, prepared foods.

DSG's Architecture and Engineering department designed the interior of "The Market" the store, working closely with Elkus Manfredi Architects, a Boston firm that designed the exterior shell.

With only 13,500 square feet to work with, DSG store planners had to carefully account for every bit of available space. They settled on an open layout with relatively low shelves to give shoppers a broad view of the entire store from nearly every vantage point, the design firm says. The small-format store has the look of a country store of decades best with a modernistic twist.

The store's design philosophy, according to DSG, is to showcase fresh foods in a rustic setting modeled after a 19th century farmer's market.

"The Market" looks like a modernistic barn by design. An open floor plan directs customers from one department to the next, from the full-service cheese, deli, meat and seafood departments to the bake shop, seasonal and locally grown produce department, the prepared-food section, salad bar, dairy, frozen foods, chef’s cove and floral department, and then to the aisles of groceries.

The 13,500 square foot store features basically all of the departments a large supermarket offers: dry grocery, fresh produce, meat-seafood, deli-prepared foods, bakery, wine, cheese and the like, each designed to fit into the small-format footprint and limited store interior space.

The store has high arched ceilings which make it appear much larger than its 13,500 square feet.

The small-format store is in the Pinehills development in Plymouth, Massachusetts. "The Market" opened in September, 2008.

As Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) first declared in the summer of 2007, there's a small-format food and grocery store mini-revolution happening in the U.S. and in many other parts of the world. This includes chains like Aldi (Europe and U.S.), Lidle (Europe), Supervalu, Inc.'s Sav-A-Lot (U.S.), with there small-format, deep-discount grocery stores; Tesco (globally) with its mid-range small format stores like Tesco Express in Europe and Fresh & Easy in the Western U.S., along with Giant Eagle and its small-format Giant Eagle Express format; Safeway (its The Market format), Supervalue (Urban Fresh by Jewel), Wal-Mart (Marketside) and others in the USA (plus Waitrose and Sainsbury's in the UK) on the more upscale end, and numerous independents focusing on small-format stores, the original small-format grocers. Many other chains are playing in the small-format world as well, in the U.S. and internationally.

The current severe global economic recession has slowed down what in 2007 to mid-2008 was a very robust small-format revolution. But the fact is it has slowed down a ll new store development in the U.S. and globally considerably.

But despite the recession, small-format innovation continues.

And in the case of "The Market" in Plymouth, Massachusetts, it continues on an award winning pace.

[You can view "The Market" store's complete design project from DSG at the link below:
Download Project PDF (7790kb).]

[You can view a slide show of the store's interior here. There are links to photographs and information about other food stores designed by DSG at the site.

[Readers: You can follow Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on Twitter.com at www.twitter.com/nsfoodsmemo.]

Monday, November 24, 2008

Retail Memo: What's Next For U.S. Retailers if the Economy Picks Up in 2010?


Retailing in trying economic times

The Kiplinger Business Resource Center, which has been forecasting business, economic and consumer behaviors and trends in the fields of agriculture, retailing, finance and other sectors for many decades in the U.S., and writing about these forecasts and trends in its popular Kiplinger Letter newsletters, is out today with a retail forecast for the U.S. for 2010. The premise of Kiplinger's forecast is what retailers in the U.S. can expect if and when (as optimists we say when) the economy picks up in 2010.

Among the trends Kiplinger suggests could stick after the current severe economic recession include consumers sticking to value and continuing to trade down to discount retailers like Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., a current phenomenon we wrote about earlier today in this piece: "Consumer Behavior Memo USA: 'Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Frugality' - America's New Consumer Frugality."

Additionally, Kiplinger sees quality making a comeback -- but it must come with value. Again this is something we've been saying in regards to upscale, specialty and natural foods stores in terms of the need to offer a value proposition even on organic, higher-end and premium food and grocery products. For example, Whole Foods Market, Inc. has learned that lesson and is trying to do just that -- create and communicate a value proposition for its stores.

The Kiplinger 2010 forecast also suggests consumers will do much less frivolous buying than they did before the current recession (American consumers have been buying frivolously from about the mid-1980's to 2007 in fact, with the exception of a couple years during the recession of the early 1990's), even if the U.S. economy comes roaring back strong in 2010.

This consumer behavior change (less frivolous buying, trading down, searching for value) which is happening right now is something we've suggested could last after the recession is over. We see a deep recession all through 2009. Consumers will trade down even more because they have to all of next year, we believe, and once the economy improves (hopefully by 2010) will have developed some learned behavior in this regard, which we think will prevent them from going right back to the old shopping patterns.

However, we also think there is going to be some pent-up buying desire among consumers once the recession is over. We think that will be good for upscale-oriented food retailers because it's our analysis the first things consumers will start buying again in significant volume are affordable luxuries like organic, specialty and premium food products. They won't be able to buy a new car perhaps, and certainly not a new house, but can afford to spend a little extra at the grocery store, and receive the gratification doing so brings, once the recession ends and things look more optimistic.

Additionally, as we've suggested previously, if the recession lasts all of next year, which we believe it will, consumers will have had nearly two years worth of trading-down and penny-pinching retail shopping behavior. They likely are going to expect value even when the economy improves. After all, the loss in home values and retirement savings, for example, will still be there in 2010. Much of the meager wealth, which was mostly in housing equity, of the middle and upper-middle classes in the U.S. has been wiped out already.

Other 2010 forecasts from Kiplinger include a continuation of retailers building smaller stores -- what we call the "small-format food and grocery retailing revolution" in the U.S -- a beefing up of customer service by retailers of all formats, and retailers developing a whole new set of coping strategies in order to deal with the challenges ahead.

On the small-format store front, Kiplinger agrees with Natural~Specialty Foods Memo that retailers like Wal-Mart who build and operate huge stores won't stop doing so. Rather, as we often write, they will continue what's already been started, which is building smaller-format, sibling formats and stores to go with the mega-stores like Supercenters and Sam's Club formats. We think other chains will join the small-format sibling store club as well in 2009-2010, despite the recession.

Read the latest retailing forecast, written by Laura Kennedy, from Kiplinger: "What’s Next for Retailers? What can retailers expect when the economy finally picks up in 2010? here.

The Kiplinger forecast in our analysis is a good snapshot of some likely consumer and retailer behavioral trends come 2010, assuming the U.S. economy improves by then. If it doesn't improve though, all bets are off, as a recession still strong in 2010 is going to result in some serious changes not only in consumer and retailer behavior, but in the entire structure of the U.S. economy, we believe.

And the government, corporate and individual debt load by 2010, even if the economy comes roaring back by then, still is going to alter retailing as usual for some time, in our analysis.

Just look at what's happening across the board already in terms of consumer debt and lack of credit. Now unemployment and job insecurity has been added to those negatives. In just two months many middle class consumers have gone from cutting back to not knowing if they can even afford the basics in food and groceries each week or month.

For these reasons we believe all food and grocery retailers, regardless of format, must develop and communicate their own unique value proposition now. We strongly believe doing so is a matter of survival as things continue to first get worse then shake out in 2009 and beyond.

We even believe high-end specialty-gourmet food retailers like Dean & DeLuca, which tend to cater to upper middle-class and wealthy consumers, need their own unique value propositions. As an example, in the quarter just ended Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. reported the average income of the shoppers in its stores has increased considerably in the last six months. That's because higher income consumers are trading down to the retailer.

Retailers must remember the upper middle-class and even many of the wealthy are hit hard by dramatic losses in the value of their homes and retirement savings. Housing values are down by 25-50% in many parts of the U.S. And down by at least 10-15% even in the best regions. Retirement accounts are down for many people by as much as 40-50% because of the poor performance of the stock market.

As a result, the upper middle class and even many of the wealthy (or we should say the recently former wealthy) are in growing numbers looking for value, even at Dean & DeLuca and other upscale and specialty food and grocery retailers.

Saturday, November 15, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Schenectady, New York-Based Price Chopper Supermarket Chain Creating New Small-Format, Urban-Concept Grocery Store


The Schenectady, New York USA-based Price Chopper supermarket chain is designing a small-format, urban-concept food and grocery store it will use to serve primarily urban neighborhoods in the eastern U.S. and New England markets it operates in, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has learned.

Neil Golub, the president and CEO of Price Chopper, which is owned by his family's Golub Corporation and is celebrating its 75th anniversary as a family-owned supermarket chain this year, says the supermarket chain's new urban-concept food and grocery store format will be a brand new small-format rather than just a smaller version of its Price Chopper banner supermarkets, which are located New York, Vermont, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, New Hampshire and Massachusetts. [You can read a history of the Price Chopper chain here, along with other information about its 75 years of food and grocery retailing history.]

Privately-held Price Chopper operates 116 supermarkets in the regions listed above. It's 2008 annual sales are estimated at $3.2 billion by the supermarket industry trade publication Supermarket News, which publishes an annual ranking of the the top 75 food and grocery retailers (all formats) in the U.S. Supermarket News ranks Price Chopper as the 38th-largest food and grocery retailer in the U.S. in terms of the grocery chain's 2008 annual gross sales.

The new small-format, urban-concept market will be about 15,000 square feet in size, according to Golub. The format's size is similar to small-format stores created in just the last couple years by Safeway ("The Market"), Wal-Mart (Marketside), Tesco (Fresh & Easy), Supervalu's Jewel Foods (Urban Fresh by Jewel) and others. Those small-format stores run from 10,000 -to- 16,000 square feet.

The urban store will have most of the departments -- produce, meat, grocery, deli/prepared foods, dairy, ect. -- the chain's larger Price Chopper Supermarkets have, Golub says. However, he adds the departments and product selections will be geared to the urban neighborhood consumer base and the size of the stores, making the ultimate look of the store much different than the grocer's standard-size supermarkets.

Golub also said its likely the new, small-format urban-concept grocery market will have a different name, other than Price Chopper, or that if Price Chopper is used in the name it will include and additional word or two in order to differentiate the format and store(s) from the Price Chopper banner supermarkets.

Price Chopper has just started designing the urban-concept format based on a location already chosen for the first store. That store will be in Saratoga Springs, New York, in the city's downtown core.

The Golub family's Price Chopper chain operates an old (built in 1957) 24,000 square foot Price Chopper banner supermarket not far from the new downtown Saratoga Springs location where it will build the first of its small-format urban food and grocery stores, once the company has completed the design.

The lease on the 24,000 square foot supermarket, which is located at 19 Railroad Place in the city, runs out in a little less than three years, according to Golub. The new urban market will open shortly before that lease expires. Price Chopper will then close the 19 Railroad Square supermarket.

Saratoga Springs, New York-based Bonacio Construction bought a 2.8 acre piece of property at Church Streets and Railroad Avenue in downtown Saratoga Springs earlier this month. The new, urban-concept small-format market will be located on that parcel, according to Golub Properties, which is the property arm of the Golub Corporation, which owns Price Chopper.

Sonny Bonacio, the owner of the construction company that's worked with Golub Properties and Price chopper before, will built the new urban, small-format grocery market at the location, which will be completely developed with other retail and perhaps housing as well.

Since Price Chopper is working on creating the new urban market format, and the old Price Chopper supermarket at 19 Railroad Avenue still has nearly three years left on the lease, its likely construction on the retailer's first small-format, urban grocery store at the location won't begin until 2010.

The store will be built at the end of the 2.8 acre downtown Saratoga Springs parcel over part of the parking lot that's now located in the space, Sonny Bonacio says.

Price Chopper's Neil Golub says the chain decided to close the 19 Railroad Place Price Chopper, which was built in 1957, last year. However, the company did not want to give up on serving downtown Saratoga Springs, so it decided to create a completely new urban-concept, small-format store it could built in the new, nearby location, plus use in other urban areas in the markets it does business in, according to Golub.

In fact, earlier this year word got out Price Chopper planned to close the old 19 Railroad place 24,000 square foot supermarket when its lease is up in about three years. A group of downtown Saratoga Springs residents who are customers of the store organized and petitioned Price Chopper not to close the supermarket because they said they would have to travel too far outside the neighborhood to buy groceries if it closed.

One of the urban neighborhood's residents, Caroline Stem, who collected 1,250 signatures on a petition to keep the store open, feared Boacio construction would buy the downtown Saratoga Springs property and then bring in a high-end grocery store that lower- and middle-income neighborhood residents wouldn't be able to afford, she says.

However, Bonacio and representatives from Price Chopper met with local neighborhood residents and explained to them in general the type of urban grocery store they plan on creating and building at the downtown location.

Price Chopper's Golub says the new small-format urban market format will be one that offers basic groceries as well as specialty items. He also says the prices in the small-format urban grocery store will be affordable, just as they are in its Price Chopper supermarkets. In other words, based on what Golub says thus far, it looks like the grocery chain's small-format concept will be a neighborhood-focused, 15,000 square foot store that offers everyday food and grocery products along with specialty items rather than an upscale or gourmet market.

"It (the downtown Saratoga Springs small-format grocery market) will be a grocery store that will serve the basic needs of the community," Golub says. "It's not meant to be something that's going to have things that are priced way up here that people won't want," he adds.

That appears to have pleased Caroline Stem and the other neighborhood residents who want a grocery store that serves all of their needs in the downtown core; a neighborhood food and grocery market.

Earlier this month Bonacio Construction, Price Chopper and the mayor of Saratoga Spring, New York invited the downtown neighborhood residents to an announcement of the new, small-format grocery store in downtown Saratoga Springs. All appeared to be pleased with the development, and what the store will and won't be, we're told by people who attended the announcement at city hall.

Of course our interest goes beyond that first, single store, although we are pleased the neighborhood is getting it. Our thoughts go to the fact Price Chopper is yet another U.S. food and grocery retailing company that's creating a small-format prototype store.

In this case Price Chopper's small-format market will focus on urban neighborhoods.

The small-format food and grocery store revolution in the U.S., and elsewhere in the world, continues on, adding New York-based Price Chopper, which in its 75 years of in business as a family-owned chain has been a major innovator, to those chains that have already joined the trend towards creating format-specific, small-format food and grocery stores.

And of course, independent grocers, America's original small-format, neighborhood-focused food and grocery retailers, continue to be strong in smaller store neighborhood retailing, as well as continuing to innovate in the small-format and neighborhood grocery market realm.

Friday, November 14, 2008

Retail Memo: Supervalu, Inc.-Owned Cub Foods Opening Second Store of its 'Neighborhood-Focused' Supermarket Format in Eagan, Minnesota USA


Neighborhood Food & Grocery Retailing USA

Supervalu, Inc.'s Stillwater, Minnesota USA-based Cub Foods supermarket chain opened its second smaller-format (for the retailer), neighborhood-oriented supermarket in Egan, Minnesota today.

The new 42,000 square foot Cub Foods neighborhood-focused supermarket is located at 1020 Diffley Road in the eastern part of the city. It's the food and grocery retail store anchor of the new Diffley Marketplace center just recently completed in Eagan, Minnesota, which has a population of about 64,000 residents.

Cub Foods, which originally was an independently-owned Minnesota supermarket company, was acquired by Supervalu, Inc. in 1980. There currently are 57 Cub Foods supermarkets operating in Minnesota's Minneapolis-St. Paul Twin Cities region.

At 42,000 square feet, the grocer's new neighborhood-oriented supermarket format, is considerably smaller than the average Cub Foods supermarket, which are 68,000 square feet.

The neighborhood-focused stores are still called Cub Foods. The retailer didn't create a separate name for the stores and it doesn't use "neighborhood market" in the name.

The smaller supermarket that opened today in Eagan, which is the second store of the design and the second supermarket in that particular Twin Cities region city, is specifically designed to be a neighborhood supermarket, according to the retailer. Both of Cub Foods' neighborhood-focused supermarkets are located in Eagan thus far.

The store uses warm colors and incorporates design elements from the local neighborhood into its look in order make the statement the store is the neighborhood residents' neighborhood supermarket, for example.

The neighborhood-oriented design also is more upscale than Cub Foods' standard 68,000 square foot supermarkets, which are full-scale superstores with a discount pricing emphasis.

"Customers will notice an original layout for the fresh produce section, offering an expanded and unique product assortment. The store will also feature a larger selection of frozen food items, a more substantial natural and organic foods section and a full-service floral department," a Cub Foods spokesperson told Natural~Specialty Foods Memo.

"Other amenities include a pharmacy, a large bakery and a full-service TCF Bank," the spokesperson added in describing some additional unique features of the retailer's neighborhood-focused supermarket format and new store, compared to its standard average 68,000 square foot Cub Foods superstores.

Scott Lichtenberg, the store director of the new Eagan East Cub Foods supermarket, tells Natural~Specialty Foods Memo, "The store has a strong focus on the fresh (in-store departments and product selection) side of the business, and our customers will notice many unique offerings. The store was designed and built to maintain the great Cub tradition of low prices and great values," along with being more upscale and neighborhood-oriented.

Although not a "small-format" grocery store (we define small format as between about 10,000 -to 25,000 square feet), the new Cub Foods format without a doubt is a "smaller-format" for the grocer. And at 42,000 square feet compared to 68,000 square feet (the average size of 55 of the chain's 57 supermarkets) it's a significant smaller footprint for the retailer -- 26,000 square feet less worth of significance to be precise.

Even more interesting is the specific focus on creating a "neighborhood" supermarket format, and doing so not only via the store's design but also using the neighborhood framework in choosing the store's departmental and category emphasis.

Small-format and neighborhood market trends

Cub Foods' focus in doing this fits well into two trends we've been writing about and have put a considerable editorial focus on since August, 2007. Those trends are the growing significance of small-format food and grocery stores as well as the trend towards neighborhood-oriented supermarkets.

Small-format stores, 10,000 -to 25,000 square feet, tend by their size and nature to be neighborhood-oriented food and grocery stores. Although that's not always the case, particularly with the hard discount formats like Aldi, Lidl, SuperValu's Sav-A-Lot and others that depending on the country they are located in (Aldi and Lidl are global, Sav-A-Lot is U.S. only) are often positioned to be a bit more regional than just "neighborhood" in terms of the customer base the retailers' want to attract. In other words, there is no rule small-format stores must be neighborhood-focused stores.

Neighborhood-oriented supermarkets however don't have to be small-format by our definition in terms of size. They are nearly always smaller than superstores though, per the Cub Foods comparison to its average store size -- 42,000 square feet compared to 68,000 square feet, for example.

Generally speaking, in the U.S. neighborhood-focused supermarkets (other than small-format) range from about 20,000 square feet to about 45,000 square feet. For example, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market supermarkets are in the 40,000 -to- 45,000 square foot range.

U.S. multi and single-store independent grocers, which are America's original neighborhood food and grocery store retailers and still hold majority distinction in that category in most states, are all over the place in terms of the sizes of their neighborhood supermarkets. The supermarkets range as small as 8,000 -to- 10,000 square feet to as big as 45,000 square feet. A good average seems to be about 15,000 -to 35,000 square feet for U.S. independents operating neighborhood and community-focused supermarkets.

Independent supermarkets need not be neighborhood-focused either. In the U.S. there are numerous multi and single-store upscale and discount format independents that are more regional in nature, for example. Gourmet, specialty and natural foods-focused stores are one example, as are large independent discount superstores as well as ethnic food markets.

A possible small-format future for Cub Foods?

Being a regional chain, we think its smart for Cub Foods to have created this neighborhood-focused, smaller -format banner or format because it allows the grocer to go into more locations in its market region, the Minneapolis-St. Paul region. With 55 of the average 68,000 square foot superstores in the market, finding more niche locations is key for such a food and grocery retailer.

We would suggest Cub look at adding "neighborhood supermarket" to the stores' title though. Perhaps: "Cub Neighborhood Supermarket." would be good, allowing the format to be differentiated from the discount store. along with using the name to reinforce the "neighborhood-focus" of the format and stores.

Urban Fresh by Cub

Additionally, since Cub Foods is owned by Supervalu, Inc., which is experimenting with its own small-format banner, "Urban Fresh by Jewel," at its Illinois-based Jewel supermarket chain, which operates supermarkets throughout Illinois and Indiana, it might be a good idea for the company to use this expertise to experiment with a small-format store with its Cub Foods chain. [Read this September 18, 2008 piece from Natural~Specialty Foods Memo for more information on "Urban Fresh by Jewel": Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: First 'Urban Fresh by Jewel' Small-Format Food and Grocery Market Opens Today in Chicago's Lincoln Park Neighborhood.]

Cub Foods' market area, Minneapolis-St. Paul Twin Cities, is an urban region anchored by two big cities, the Twin cities mentioned above. Both cities have vibrant urban cores, like Chicago where the first 15,000 square foot "Urban Fresh by Jewel" opened earlier this year.

Minneapolis-St Paul also also have other similarities to Chicago: All three are big Midwestern cities with a similar consumer culture, for example. Downtown Minneapolis and St. Paul, like downtown Chicago, also have a lack of food stores in the downtown core, as well as in a number of urban neighborhoods. These are all good criteria for a small-format store.

Cub Foods could even name the small-format store "Urban Fresh by Cub Foods." We would locate the first "Urban Fresh by Cub Foods" test store in downtown Minneapolis, which is a vibrant downtown in a vibrant city, has lots of upscale workers and residents, and increasingly is seeing more and residents moving downtown into new condominium projects. Since "Cub" means little (like a bear cub) a small-format store is a natural for the chain.

We even think Supervalu could adopt the basic "Urban Fresh by Jewel" format, which is an upscale format which features lots of fresh, prepared foods, specialty, natural and organic products, fresh produce and meat departments, wines and craft beers -- but also offers a good selection of basic food and grocery items at decent prices -- customizing and localizing the format a bit in design and merchandising for downtown Minneapolis. Localizing is always key.

It's food for thought.

After all, as we've been writing about since August, 2007, there's a small-format food and grocery retailing revolution going on both in the United States and globally. That size and format trend is ties to the neighborhood food retailing trend in the U.S.

It's our analysis the small-format and neighborhood-oriented food retailing "revolutions" will only gain steam because the current global financial crisis and recession are slowly forcing people to think smaller -- smaller homes, smaller cars, smaller bank accounts, smaller budgets and the like. This change to a smaller and more frugal lifestyle will result we believe in a growing popularity among consumers to shop at smaller grocery stores, assuming the pricing is as or near as good as it is larger stores and the product selection is of a limited assortment but still decent.

The majority of U.S. consumers will still shop at big stores like Wal-Mart Supercenters Costco and supermarket company superstores. But we think they will shift a significant portion of their spending to neighborhood-oriented markets because of the convenience, savings on gasoline and a desire for a more simple, easier shopping experience.

This is already happening with Aldi and Supervalu's Sav-A-Lot stores in the U.S., as well as in the case Trader Joe's specialty markets, which draw shoppers from as much as 40-50 miles away in many cases. Numerous competitive neighborhood-oriented supermarkets also have been reporting increased sales this year, particularly when gasoline was at an over $4 a gallon. It is about 40% less than that right now. But it will go back up.

Further, in the U.S. there is a trend towards people moving from the suburbs to big cities in many parts of the country. This trend and the resulting increased population in these cities -- Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, Seattle, Minneapolis to name just five -- is and will create more demand for stores located in the urban centers that offer a good selection of both basic groceries and more upscale product selections, including specialty, natural, organic and premium, prepared foods.

Cub Foods also is doing a neighborhood-oriented thing with the opening of its second neighborhood-focused supermarket in the Twin Cities region city of Egan. The retailer is donate a half-ton (1,000 pounds) of non-perishable food items to Second Harvest Heartland Food Bank that serves residents of Eagan, Minnesota.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: The Small-Format, Neighborhood-Oriented Food and Grocery Retailing Trend Continues to Emerge and Grow in the U.S.

Giant Eagle, Inc's (supermarket chain) first Giant Eagle Express small-format, neighborhood-oriented food and grocery store in Harmonville, Pennsylvania is about 15,000 square feet. (Photo credit: Pittsburgh Post Gazzette.)

Neighborhood Food Retailing USA

We've been writing extensively about what we termed the "small-format food retailing revolution" in the United States, and what we call the "international small-format food retailing revolution," since we started Natural~Specialty Foods Memo in August, 2007.

In conjunction with our small-format focus, we've written extensively about what we have called a return to neighborhood food retailing in the U.S., which goes hand-in-hand with the re-emergence of smaller-format food and grocery stores in the country.

We've received lots of correspondence from the mainstream press about our small-format food and grocery store and neighborhood food retailing reporting, coverage and analysis, including from reporters from the New York Times, Los Angeles Times (and other U.S. papers), business publications and daily papers from Canada, Mexico, Europe and Asia, and other mainstream publications, along with Blogs.

It has been interesting to receive this correspondence.

What we've also started to notice is that the mainstream press has discovered what we've been writing extensively about for 15 months -- that small-format food and grocery retailing and neighborhood food retailing is indeed a growing trend in the United States.

For example, on October 3, the Pittsburgh Post Gazette ran this story, "Tight economy has shoppers, grocers looking to neighborhood stores." The piece, by staff writer Teresa F. Lindeman discusses many of the issues we've been writing about since last August in terms of the external and economic factors involved in the small-format grocery store trend in the U.S.

It also talks about Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, Wal-Mart's Marketside, Giant Eagle's Giant Eagle Express and SuperValu, Inc's Urban Fresh by Jewel" all small format chains, all which we've written about extensively.

And today, the Associated Press, which is syndicated to nearly every newspaper in the U.S., ran this feature story, Like shoppers' budgets, grocery stores shrink, which so far has been picked up and published by a number of American newspapers.

The AP piece also features a discussion of many of the issues we've been writing about, and suggested last summer would be occurring now, for the last 15 months regarding small-format food retailing in the U.S. and the greater focus on neighborhood markets.

Our analysis of the growing small-format food retailing trend in the U.S. isn't one that says smaller format, neighborhood grocery stores, which have never gone away completely in the U.S., are going to replace larger supermarkets and mega discount stores like Wal-Mart Supercenters, Costco club stores or Super Target combination food, grocery and general merchandise stores.

Rather our analysis is that the growing small-format trend, which is a unique event because major chains like Wal-Mart, SuperValu, Safeway, Tesco and others are driving it in the U.S., is a new layer of an old concept -- the independent neighborhood grocery store -- which is an American original.

Mega stores aren't going to go away. However, in our analysis fewer of such stores will be built and more smaller, neighborhood-oriented food stores will be built over the next decade.

We already are seeing evidence of this emerging. For example:

>Wal-Mart recently said it will built fewer of its combination food, grocery and general merchandise Supercenters (which average 180,000 square feet) next year and in 2010 than its original plans call for.

Wal-Mart also is building numerous smaller Supercenters and of course opened its first four small-format food stores, Marketside, in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan region on October 4.

>Target Stores has recently decreased the size of some of its new Super target grocery and general merchandise mega-stores, and in some cases even shrank the stores significantly and decided not to add the grocery side in a few cases.

>Costco is looking at building smaller club stores in urban areas like the store it has in San Francisco's South of Market neighborhood. This even includes the possibility of building smaller, multi-story Costco stores in large cities.

>Supernatural foods retailer Whole Foods Market, Inc. has decided to downsize a number of the new stores it has in development. The retailer also is questioning whether or not it will even continue to build and open any additional stores in the 60,000 -to- 80,000 square foot range, something it has done a lot of in the last five years, in the future.

Our analysis is that just as cars, houses, bank accounts, retirement fund portfolios and other key aspects of American life are getting smaller, and will continue to do so for most Americans for the next few years, so too in many cases will food and grocery stores trend towards getting smaller.

But although size does matter, it's not just smaller square footage that's important in this analysis. What is equally important is that the reason the small-format trend is here to stay for a significant number of years is that it's neighborhood-driven. In other words, small-format food stores aren't just growing in quantity and popularity because they are small. They are doing so because they are designed to serve as neighborhood markets -- just like the independents have done and continue to do in the U.S. -- although to a far-lessor degree today than in the past because of the emergence of the big box chain store.

This means a few things.

First, it offers a new opportunity for the big chains to create small-format operations in conjunction with their larger store operations. Doing this can provide some real cost savings for retailers like Wal-Mart, Tesco, Safeway and the others.

Second, it's our analysis the small-format food retailing trend provides a renewed opportunity for independent grocers to thrive in the U.S. Independents are the original small-format neighborhood grocers and still do it the best.

Third, we see the small-format, neighborhood food retailing trend providing a new opportunity for traditional convenience store operators.

These chains and independents sit right between convenient retailing and neighborhood food retailing, straddling that definitional fence. As such, they can create new formats, as many are currently doing, that are hybrid grocery and convenience stores.

This offers the c-store chains particularly a new way to broaden their offerings away from the traditional c-store staples of alcoholic beverages, cigarettes, gasoline and "gut buster-quality" ready-to-eat foods, all of which are declining categories, into a more diversified product category mix. Not closing their traditional c-stores but diversifying with a new format. Pennsylvania-based Wawa is a good model of a very successful hybrid convenience store/grocery store retailer.

There is still a long way to go in the small-format trend in the U.S. We are just seeing the beginning of it at present. Our analysis is that the neighborhood retailing aspect of the small-format trend will get even stronger and we will see various different formats, as we are beginning to see at present, emerge to serve neighborhood residents' food shopping needs.

We will be covering and analyzing the small-format and neighborhood food retailing trend, as we have been for the last 15 months, extensively. We may even have a couple more new terms to coin.

Monday, September 29, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Wal-Mart Studying Second Small-Format Grocery Store Concept; Inside Marketside One Week Before the First Stores Open


The Blog Fresh & Easy Buzz, which covers and writes about Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, small-format food and grocery retailing, and related topics and issues, has two stories today about Wal-Mart, Inc. and small-format food retailing.

The first piece reports on and details comments Wal-Mart, Inc. CEO Lee Scott made earlier this month at the 15th Annual Goldman Sachs Global Retailing Conference in New York City about a second (besides its small-format Marketside) small-format grocery store concept the retailer is studying.


The second piece from Fresh & Easy Buzz provides new information about Wal-Mart's Marketside grocery and fresh foods stores -- the first four of which will open on October 4 in Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa and Tempe, Arizona, in the Phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan market region -- offering a look inside Marketside prior to the stores opening in a week.


The four Marketside stores (which we coined as "Small-Marts" in August, 2007) which are about 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet will open in just one week.

The combination grocery, fresh and specialty foods stores -- which will feature basic groceries, natural, organic and specialty products, fresh baked goods, fresh produce and meats, craft beers, wines and spirits, and in-store prepared foods -- will herald a new era for Wal-Mart, one in which the world's largest retailer joins the prepared and natural/specialty foods categories in a major way.

The Marketside development also places Wal-Mart square in the center of the small-format food and grocery retailing revolution we've been talking about in Natural~Specialty Foods Memo since we first published the Blog in August, 2007, over a year ago.

The small-format food and grocery retailing revolution -- and small-format competition -- has just started. Stay tuned.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Giant Food Stores To Open its First Small-Format, Hybrid Convenience-Grocery Store: 'Giant To Go'


Carlisle, Pennsylvania-based Giant Food Stores (also known as Giant-Carlisle) is planning to join the small-format food and grocery retailing revolution in the U.S. with its first small-format, convenience-oriented grocery market, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has learned.

Giant Food Stores, which is owned by the the Dutch supermarket company Royal Ahold just as its sister company, Landover, Maryland-based Giant Food is (the chains are operated separately though), plans to build its first Giant To Go combination convenience and grocery store, which will be 4,442 square feet, at a new retail development called Richmond square at the northwest corner of Fruitville Pike Road and route 722 in Landcaster, Pennsylvania.

The small-format hybrid convenience and grocery store will be the first of its kind for Giant Food Stores, which operates about 140 supermarkets under the Giant Food Stores, Martin's Food Markets and Foodsource banners in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia and West Virgina. Royal Ahold owns chains that operate about 700 supermarkets in the U.S.

At 4,422 square feet, the Giant To Go market actually is in part what we define as a micro small-format food and grocery store (under 5,000 square feet), although because it will be part traditional c-store (which at 4,422 would be as large or larger than an average one) and part grocery store, we will call it small-format.

The c-store cum grocery store will feature fresh produce and meats, a deli which will include grab-and-go ready-to-eat and some ready-to-heat prepared foods, an in-store fresh bakery and an assortment of basic shelf-stable food and grocery items, along with some of the food and non-food products typically associated with traditional c-store merchandising.

The 4,422 square foot hybrid convenience and grocery store also will have an 8-pump gasoline fueling station outside.

A Giant Food Stores' spokesperson said the Giant To Go store is a prototype for the chain. If it's successful the company is likely to build more of the stores in its market regions.

Construction of the Giant to Go small-format combination convenience and grocery store at the Richmond Square retail development -- which is a "village -style" designed 30,000 square foot retail and residential mixed-use development featuring stores and offices on the ground level and apartments on top -- hasn't started yet.

However, the Giant Food Stores' spokesperson told Natural~Specialty Foods Memo plans call for construction to start soon, with a target opening date for the store by the end of the first quarter of 2009.

Other retail tenants in the new Richmond Square center will include a bank, two restaurants (Asian and Italian), a dry cleaners and a couple others, along with the office buildings, according to its developer.

The Richmond center is a part of a larger development at the location. That development includes single family homes as well as additional retail and office space.

Giant Food Stores' new Giant To Go combination convenience store-grocery store format fits into what we classify as the "hybrid grocery-convenience store format."

It's a cousin to but different than small-format grocers like Tesco's Fresh & Easy, Safeway's "The Market," Aldi, Sav-A-Lot, Wal-Mart's Marketside, Trader Joe's and Giant Eagle's Giant Eagle Express, for example. It's closet to Giant Eagle Express, which unlike the others listed above adopts some elements of traditional c-store merchandising in its concept. All of the formats listed above are convenience-oriented though, which is an element they too borrow from c-store retailing.

Giant To Go also is different than what we've termed the small-format "eco-convenience" or Econvenience hybrid convenience-grocery stores. These stores which we've written about --such as Green Spot and Conscious Convenience -- combine elements of c-store retailing and grocery retailing but also take major elements from natural products retailing, having a "green" or environmental focus to the stores.

Wawa food stores is a good example of a store we think Giant Foods' Giant To Go is likely to emulate in many ways. As we've written about, Wawa is a hybrid convenience and grocery market which puts a major merchandising emphasis on fresh foods -- produce and prepared foods particularly -- along with selling basic groceries and specialty items. The stores also have fueling stations and sell some traditional c-store items as well. Interestingly, Wawa is based in Pennsylvania just like Giant Foods Stores is.

Another example is Parker's Convenience Stores, which we wrote about earlier this week.

We simply call these chains -- Wawa, Parker's and a few others -- hybrid, upscale convenience and grocery markets or stores. This is where we think Giant to Go will fit in the small-format, convenience-oriented food and grocery retailing revolution happening in the U.S. and elsewhere globally.

Giant Food Stores has developed numerous upscale design and merchandising features for its Martin's Food Markets banner (and its newer Giant banner supermarkets), including attractive upscale-looking departments like produce, deli/prepared foods and bakery, along with top-quality natural-specialty foods, fresh meat, produce and prepared foods merchandiing programs. As a result, it can export this expertise to Giant to Go in whatever doses it thinks are appropriate.

Dutch Royal Ahold-owned Giant Food Stores of Carlisle, Pennsylvania is now joining the other participants in this revolution with its new Giant to Go format. It seems "GIANTS" are even going small (format). Stay tuned, as there will be many more new entrants to the party.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: A Professional Chef Turned Grocer Creates A 'Sub-Urban' Small-Format Fresh Foods and Grocery Store in Maryland USA


Small-Format Food Retailing Special Report

The U.S. economy may be going to hell in a handbasket (or perhaps shopping cart), with banking failure after banking failure, fast-rising unemployment, soaring food and gasoline prices and other assorted economic maladies, but even such tough times aren't stopping entrepreneurs from opening small-format food and grocery stores.

A case in point: Andre Cavallaro, the former executive chef at the popular Addies restaurant in Rockville, Maryland USA, recently opened a small-format food store, Sub*Urban Trading Company, in nearby Kensington, Maryland.

The food store, which is designed to look like a modern version of the old general store, takes a "green" positioning stance, offering organic fresh meats and produce, along with natural, organic and specialty food and grocery items, with a major emphasis on "locally-produced" products.

natural and specialty grocery items include oils, condiments, marinades, salad dressings and items in numerous other categories. Natural and specialty perishable items are sold in themarkets as well.

Here's what Katie R. from Kensington, Maryland recently had to say about the store in a review on the yelp.com review website:

"The best word I can think of to describe sub*urban trading co. is 'yum'. Then I guess I would use amazingly fresh, organic, and friendly.

But whether I am biting into a warm rustic blackberry tart made with the ripest blackberries for breakfast or a slice of wild mushroom and goat cheese tart for lunch, all I can think of is yum.

How lucky Kensington is to have this new gourmet carryout owned and run by the friendly and knowledge pair, Andre and Alison Cavallaro.

Not only are there fresh pastry items everyday, but produce, dairy, meat, fish, baking items, and a few choice cookbooks. The fresh meats look so inviting - some marinated with fresh herbs; some small portions cooked to go. Many items are supplied by local farmers so it is worth the drive."

Utilizing his experience as a chef, Cavallaro is making fresh, prepared foods a major part of the market, which opened in August. Each day the store features ready-to-eat in-store fresh, prepared food items -- four different selections for lunch and one offering each evening for dinner. All are chef-quality prepared meals made by Cavallaro.

A Natural~Specialty Foods Memo reader who recently talked with Cavallaro tells us the four main statements the small-format food store makes are -- environmentally-friendly, organic, fresh and local.

All paper products used at the store are recycled, all plastic products used in the foodservice operation are corn-based and biodegradable, and all of the fresh produce and meats sold in the store are organic and, when possible, locally sourced.

A central feature of the market are its fresh, prepared foods to go, sales of which our reader says seem to be picking up since the store opened a little over a month ago. Cavallaro hopes to become a destination venue, where shoppers will stop in after work and pick up dinner to take home from his daily rotating menu, along with visiting regularly for take-home or take back to the office lunches.

The market is designed to be a neighborhood store; a store locals will shop daily if possible in the European tradition. Although we doubt if the owner would mind customers from outside the neighborhood.

In fact, our reader says Cavallaro had a strong following when he was executive chef at the restaurant in Rockville, Maryland, saying she expects numerous take-out prepared foods customers will stop in from there and elsewhere once they learn about the small-format combination natural, specialty and fresh, prepared foods market.

For example, Heather C from Rockville, Maryland, another reviewer on yelp.com offers positive comments about the store's fresh, prepared foods, along with other aspects of the market:

"I absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE this place!!!!!

I've been in a couple times since they've opened and have been so pleased with the atmosphere, the ambiance, the employees/owners, and obviously the products they sell.

The former chef of Addie's, Andre Cavallaro, and his mother Alison Cavallaro, run this "green" and organic minded market. They focus on all organic, sustainable, and local products. On top of all that, all of their bags, to go containers, cups, "plastic" silverware are made from either corn or recycled products and are all biodegradable!!!

I read Libby's response, and often times I shop at Safeway and organic eggs cost $4.99 and to tell you the truth, don't even know where they come from. So I'm happy to buy my eggs at Sub Urban.

I've been telling everyone I know about this place and highly recommend it to whoever reads this!! Check it out, you won't regret those awesome peach turnovers baked fresh every morning or those kick a** savory tarts!!! (I had the beet and goat cheese one the other day....OMG!)

As we often write about, small-format stores offer much opportunity in terms of geography -- they can be located in urban, suburban or rural area -- and format. Such stores can be more upscale natural-organic-specialty like Sub*Urban Trading Company, no frills, deep disconters like Aldi or Supervalu, Inc.'s Sav-A-Lot, or in-between markets like Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, Wal-Mart's soon to open Marketside and the hundreds of independently-owned small-format food and grocery stores operated by individuals, family's and partnerships throughout the U.S.

Small-format food stores, because of their smaller size and lower cost to get started, also offer an opportunity to independent and entrepreneurs that otherwise would be unable to open a traditional size supermarket because of the expense of doing so. They also are the perfect fit for natural and specialty foods stores offering a specific focus like fresh, prepared foods.

We're seeing a revolution in the U.S., as we frequently write, in small-format food and grocery stores across all formats -- from hard discount -to- upscale organic, prepared foods and gourmet (or a combination of all those) -- despite the poor economy.

The good news is that if these stores can make it now, they can make it nearly anytime. Additionally, if they do make it now, the stores will be well positioned to thrive once the U.S. economy turns around. This is particularly true for natural and specialty foods'-oriented small-format food and grocery markets.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Not Technically 'Small-Format' But Whole Foods Market, Inc. is Going 'Smaller'


Small-Format Food Retailing Special Report

Amid a sluggish economy and slowing sales growth, Whole Foods Market Inc. is scaling down the size of new stores as the company finds massive grocery stores in most markets can't be justified.

The Austin, Texas, natural and organic grocer now plans to target new stores sized between 35,000 -to- 50,000 square feet, more than 20% smaller than what the company identified a year ago as its "sweet spot" amid successes with some large locations. The company is also renegotiating leases at several stores for smaller spaces than originally signed.

The size reduction by Whole Foods doesn't now make it a charter member of what we've coined as the small-format food retailing revolution going on in the USA. Instead it puts Whole Foods' stores right about in the middle in terms of the current average size of new supermarkets being built in the U.S.

For example, supermarket chains such as Safeway Stores, SuperValu, Inc., Kroger and most others are building new supermarkets that average about 45,000 -to- 60,000 square feet on the one end. Others such as regional players Wegmans (eastern U.S.) and HEB (Texas) have been building mega-supermarkets of about 100,000 square feet, at the other end. Then you have the small-format stores from Tesco (Fresh & Easy), Safeway (The Market) and Wal-Mart's soon to open Marketside, all which average from 10,000 -to- 20,000 square feet.

At its new "sweet spot" of 35,000 -to- 50,000 square foot stores, Whole Foods actually returns to its roots of the 1990's, when that was the size stores the natural grocer was focusing on. In the late 1990's to the present, Whole Foods went mega, opening numerous stores in the 70,000 -to- nearly 80,000 square foot range.

Smaller stores come with a host of lower fixed costs for rents and utilities, and also require fewer employees to run. That can help bolster key profitability metrics like sales-per-square-foot and sales-per-employee and improve the company's return on invested capital.

The smaller format was on display last week when Whole Foods opened its latest location in Richmond, Va. With 45,000 square feet of selling space, the store is smaller than most new ones open in recent years. But the store has mostly the same merchandise as larger stores, which should equate to comparable sales at lower costs.

It was also without any sit-down eateries that have driven up development and operating costs at some other stores. A Whole Foods in Fairfax, Va., for example, has four in-house restaurants including a barbecue joint called the Smokehouse.

The smaller Richmond store, meanwhile, has barbecue dishes available for self- service in addition to a hot food and salad bar, brick-oven pizza and a wine bar and cafe.

The moves for smaller locations come as Whole Foods is exhibiting signs that even the wealthiest consumers are cutting back on their consumption. Same-store sales rose just 2.6% at Whole Foods locations open at least a year, a far cry from the double-digit gains the food retailer enjoyed just a few years back.

Strong sales growth led to seemingly unmitigated growth by the chain, and store sizes followed suit. In 2005, Whole Foods opened its largest location, an 80,000-square-foot store in its Austin backyard that the company calls " enormously successful," and started to steadily increase the size of new locations.

But those larger format stores failed to live up to the performance of its Austin location and those in other dense, urban environments like New York. "

To be sure, Whole Foods, whose 270 stores average roughly 35,500 square feet, has continued to sign leases and open locations similar to its traditional layout and size. But the consumer spending slump has caused the company to rethink its development strategy, and retrench to store sizes from the past.

"With hindsight, reflection and some data points in front of us, we see that the really large stores are very powerful in limited markets and circumstances, and that smaller stores can also produce great returns for us," Chief Executive John Mackey said in an earnings call with food retailing analysts and media last month.

The real estate strategy is one of several moves Whole Foods is using to get back on track after its shares have lost more than half their value this year. The company has recently tried to emphasize value by offering more discounts and incorporating a value message into its marketing.

It is also planning on cutting back on new stores altogether, lowering its fiscal 2009 target to 15 new stores, down from a prior estimate of 25 to 30, as we reported previously.

Whole Foods also recently fired 42 headquarters employees as a cost savings measure.

As we've reported previously in Natural~Specialty Foods Memo, Whole Foods has had plans to open the first of its small-format Whole Foods Express concept stores in a former Wild Oats natural foods store building in Boulder, Colorado.

Initial plans called for that first Whole Foods Express store--which is designed to average 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet and offer a limited assortment of natural and organic grocery items and feature fresh foods, such as produce and ready-to-eat and ready-to-heat prepared foods--to open this fall. However, as we previously reported, Whole Foods has been unable to agree on a new lease with the building's landlord at the Boulder site, which currently is still being operated as a Wild Oats banner store, so it has yet to start converting the building into the Whole Foods Express prototype store.

In fact, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has now learned the Whole Foods Express concept is under review, as nearly everything at Whole Foods is, because of the supernatural grocer's significant drop in profits in the last quarter, which has resulted in the new strategies discussed in this piece, along with others.

Building and operating smaller stores isn't anything new for Whole Foods. In fact one of the chain's best-performing stores from a sales per-square-foot perspective is it 14,000 square foot store at 414 Miller Avenue in Mill Valley, in Marin County in the San Francisco Bay Area. That store averages between $500,000 -to-$600,000 a week in gross sales, according to sources in a position to know.

The Mill Valley store is where Whole Foods' co-president Walter Robb got his start. He opened the store in the early 1990's as the store manager, using his success with the Mill Valley store to move on to President of the Northern California Division and then eventually into his current position.

Additionally, the majority of the stores Wild Oats stores Whole Foods acquired in the merger last year are no bigger than 35,000 square feet, many being much smaller than that.

Whole Foods currently has plans to build some new stores even smaller than its new "sweet spot" size of between 35,000 -to- 50,000 square feet. These include two stores in San Francisco, one in the city's Noe Valley neighborhood and the other in the famous Haight-Ashbury district. Both of these stores are in the 17,000 -to- 20,000 square foot range. Another new store in development in Capitola, which is in Northern California's coastal region, also is smaller than 30,000 square feet.

We generally define a small-format food store as from 10,000 -to- 20,000 square feet in size, as do most others. The two San Francisco Whole Foods stores in development listed above fit that small-format definition. The Capitola store comes very close.

These however aren't specifically designed small-format stores like the Whole Foods Express prototype is. Therefore, it's our analysis that Whole Foods should move forward with its Express format.

If it can't open the first store in Boulder because of the lease problems that's fine. There still are numerous places where it makes even better sense to open one of the stores, particularly in an urban location where such a store makes much more sense for Whole Foods than it does to do so in Boulder, where the decision to do so was based largely on the fact that after acquiring Boulder-based Wild Oats, Whole Foods found itself overstored in the city of Boulder.

However, it pledged not to close any of the stores in the city that was home to Wild Oats. Therefore the natural grocer decided to turn one of the former Wild Oats stores into the Whole Foods Express as a way to differentiate the Whole Foods brand in the now overstored city.

We suggest opening a Whole Foods Express store in San Francisco or New York as a first test. It makes good sense to do from numerous perspectives, including geography, density, cost, maximization of sales per-square-feet, and more.

Feel free to agree, disagree and offer your perspective by clicking the comment link below.

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: The 'Eco-Convenience' Hybrid Store Trend Continues to Emerge: 'Locali Conscious Convenience' to Open First Store


Small-Format Food Retailing Special Report

A new small-format, hybrid grocery and convenience-oriented store is coming to Hollywood, California. And the company hopes to create a regional chain of the stores throughout Southern California.

Locali Conscious Convenience, which is currently under construction, is set to open its doors this fall. The market, located at 5825 Franklin Avenue in Hollywood, seeks to make healthy eating and eco-friendly household necessities easily accessible to those on the go, says CEO Greg Horos. Roughly translated from Italian, locali means "community" or "where it's happening. "

According to CEO Horos, the small-format, environmentally-focused hybrid grocery and convenience market "will be a hip version of the mom and pop corner store. Locali will also be a place for people in the community to connect with each other and their food sources. There will be an emphasis on local and organic food artisans, producers and growers in the inventory line up. However, refined sugar, hydrogenated oils, high fructose corn syrup and genetically modified products will be missing from the shelves," he says.

"I like to describe it as the sustainable version of 7-11," Horos says. "We’ll have healthy and eco-friendly versions of the all the typical things you’d find at a convenience market…with the exception of cigarettes and lotto tickets…No clean versions of those," he added.

"We’re building (the store) to LEED (strict green building guidelines) standards and working with the city of Los Angeles to make sure we can supersede those standards as much as possible. We have a lot of terrific value adds for the community. I’m most excited that we’re offering exclusively organic and biodynamic wines and beers, too."

Besides the energy efficient building measures and appliances, Locali Conscious Convenience will also provide for the disposal of compost, in addition to recycling waste. A percentage of their proceeds will benefit a variety of local and international charities geared towards improving overall wellness, according to Melissa Rosen, a company spokesperson. The retail space is being designed by Los Angeles-based MASS Architecture & Design, Ms. Rosen says.

"Locali conveniently connects the community to eco-friendly food, beverage and lifestyle products. By providing easy access to socially and environmentally responsible goods, Locali promotes conscious consumerism and healthy living," Ms. Rosen says.

Locali Conscious Convenience is a unique hybrid concept, combining green retailing with small-format food and grocery retailing, natural and organic niche. However it's not the first or the only retail format of its kind in the U.S.

In June of this year we wrote and published this piece,"Retail Innovation Memo: The 'Econvenience Store' Will Be the Next New Thing, and is A Convenience Store Industry Green Retailing Trend in the Making," about Green Spot Market & Fuels, a hybrid small-format convenience and grocery store that opened in the Dallas, Texas region earlier this year.

In the story, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo predicted we would soon begin seeing other, similar format stores opening in the United States, calling the eco-hybrid convenience/grocery store an emerging trend.

Hybrid eco-convenience stores popping up all over

It appears we're on to something with that prediction. In addition to Texas' Green Spot and Los Angeles' soon to be Locali Conscious Convenience, we've learned a hybrid eco-convenience-grocery store chain named Good to Go ECOnvience Center recently opened its first store in Grand Chute, Wisconsin USA on May 1, 2008.

Good to Go, which like Green Spot and Locali Conscious Convenience also bills itself as "the first eco-convenience store in the U.S.," says it has plans to open 150 of the green convenience-oriented stores in Wisconsin, Iowa and Northern Illinois by the end of 2010, which is a very ambitious store opening program.

Good to Go says its stores also are built using LEED green building guidelines. The Good to Go ECOnvenience Center features a green roof with plants and sod that minimize absorption of sunlight that could heat the building and force overuse of its HVAC system; energy savings during the summer cooling season can be as much as 25 percent. The soil also acts like a sponge to absorb rain and reduce storm water runoff by as much as 95 percent after a one-inch downpour.

"When it comes to our customers, we haven't set out to change the direction the wind blows. Rather, we have adjusted our sails," said Angie Nikolas, vice president of neighborhood relations for the retailer. "We're very proud to bring 24-hour convenience that minimizes the impact we make on our environment.

"Similar to Green Spot and Locali Conscious Convenience (although each have unique aspects as well), Good to Go's focus is on selling healthier natural and organic food, grocery, beverage, snack and prepared foods items as part of its green theme.

In Portland, Oregon, a company called Full Moon Foodies is working on creating a chain of small-format hybrid convenience-grocery stores with a green and natural products focus.

"I got tired of having to hop into the car to drive to a mega-organic mart, fight for parking and waste time standing in long lines whenever I needed a few items," Ellisa Wee, the retailer's founder says.

According to the company, "the retail concept provides customers with a knowledgeable staff; a modern, upscale store design; multiple community-based urban locations; and extended hours past those of grocery stores."

"We're not trying to re-invent the convenience store or the organic/natural food concept, we're trying to make it more accessible," Wee says.

The Full Moon Foodie's aren't the only retailers looking to penetrate (or perhaps create) the eco-convenience grocery niche however. A company called SeQuential Biofuels, which operates numerous fuel stations throughout Oregon and Western Washington state, has created a natural convenience market, which it is locating on site at its many fueling stations. Those stations offer conventional gasoline, biofuels and other green technologies. Many of the eco-convenience stores are solar powered. The stores also buy used vegetable oil form businesses and consumers and then turn it into biofuel.

The small-format store, called the Natural Market, sells conventional, natural and organic snacks and beverages, along with a limited assortment of grocery items. It features fresh, prepared foods, along with fresh produce. The stores also sell beer and wine, putting a special emphasis on locally-produced brews and wines from the Pacific Northwest region where the stores are located.

All of the coffee cups and straws used for the store's fresh brewed organic coffee are 100% compostable. Additionally, the retailer says it picks each product to sell in the stores "based on where, how, when, and by whom it was made," "Every effort has been made to source local, organic products, a company spokesperson says.

Part of the small-format continuum

We see this emerging small-format eco-convenience hybrid grocery-convenience store retailing trend as a "kissing-cousin" to the small format food and grocery retailing revolution happening in the United States, as well as in Europe and Asia. The eco-convenience stores are a variant of what is a multi-format small-format food and grocery retailing trend if you will.

For example, while there are qualitative differences between Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, which now has 86 stores in Southern California, Nevada and Arizona, and what these retailers are doing--chiefly that Fresh & Easy is putting more of an emphasis on being a primary shopping venue with a low price focus on selling basic groceries and prepared foods--there are numerous similarities as well.

For example, the Tesco Fresh & Easy format puts a major emphasis on healthy and natural foods, preparing its fresh, prepared foods without using artificial ingredients and colorings. Fresh & Easy stores also sell lots of natural and organic grocery products and are positioned as environmentally-friendly markets just like the hybrid eco-convenience stores are, along with offering craft beers and specialty wines like the hybrid eco-convenience-grocery stores are doing.

Therefore, we view this format development as a continuum of sorts, as well as a natural foods variant of the tradition C-store format just as in many ways the natural foods store is a variant of the traditional supermarket.

As part of this format continuum, you have small-format grocers like Trader Joe's with a specialty and natural products focus, and Safeway's "The Market" format which offers basic and specialty groceries in a more upscale environment on one end. In the middle you have Tesco's Fresh & Easy and the soon to open Wal-Mart Marketside, which are hybrid combination basic grocery stores and fresh foods markets. And at the other end you have the small-format, no frills stores like Aldi and SuperValu, Inc.'s Sav-A-Lot, which are deep or hard discount limited assortment grocery stores.

Sitting alongside these various small-formats on this continuum you have the traditional convenience store, the supermarket and the natural foods store. It's like taking a piece from each one; the sums becoming the whole (format).

You can add to this the new hybrid eco-convenience stores, which are combining the traditional C-store format with a mini combination grocery and natural foods store, while still including gasoline fueling stations which offer traditional petroleum-based gas but also are adding cleaner biofuels.

All of the formats are going after two things in the main: the time-pressed shopper who might be tired of shopping at big box stores, along with a share of that shopper's stomach. Each has a similar but different niche. But in one way or the other all are competing against one another for that share of the consumers' stomach, and in many cases her 21rst century "green" conscious as well.

Thursday, August 7, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Does Wal-Mart Plan to Build A $10 Billion A Year 'Small-Mart' Empire?


The Financial Times is reporting today that Wal-Mart, Inc. had an advertisement it later pulled on its Marketside.com website that described the small-format Marketside combination fresh, specialty, natural foods and basic grocery stores to eventually be a chain of over 1,000 stores doing about $10 billion in annual sales.

Below is today's report from the Financial Times:

Wal-Mart sees Marketside as $10bn chain

From the: Financial Times
By Jonathan Birchall in New York
August 7, 2008

Wal-Mart, the world’s largest retailer, says the new small Marketside grocery stores it is to launch this autumn could expand to a chain of more than 1,000 stores, delivering $10bn-plus in annual sales.

The retailer plans to open 10 of the 15,000 sq ft Marketside stores initially, including four in the Phoenix area, where they will be competing directly with Tesco’s recently launched US Fresh & Easy store concept. Wal-Mart’s executives have described the Marketside stores as a pilot project, although it is the first new store format to be launched by the company in a decade. But a job advertisement for the retailer indicates the scale of its ambitions for Marketside, saying the format “is expected to start with 10 stores and evolve to between 1,000-1,500 stores with over $10bn annual sales."

At less than a 10th of the size of the average Wal-Mart superstore, Wal-Mart said the new stores would be aimed at “the needs of a time-starved, higher-income consumer that is interested in convenience and premium fresh, natural and organic offerings.”

The approach contrasts with Wal-Mart’s experience with the Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market stores it launched 10 years ago, which are about the size of a traditional US supermarket.

In response to an inquiry from the Financial Times, Wal-Mart stressed the Arizona stores were a pilot project. The retailer subsequently removed from its website the job advert that included the more ambitious targets.

Wal-Mart’s superstores are built around high volume and low cost, and the group has faced challenges in adapting to the supermarket-sized Neighborhood Market stores it launched in 1998, opening more than 140 outlets. The Marketside stores will require a fast turnover of stock, which could be a difficult fit with Wal-Mart’s distribution system.

Tesco has opened more than 60 Fresh & Easy stores in California, Arizona and Nevada since November and plans to have several hundred operating during the next two years.

Wal-Mart, the largest US grocer with more than 20 per cent of the market, is developing the Marketside format as growth slows at its 2,500-plus superstores.

The Marketside format is also expected to spearhead a broader drive by the retailer to improve its overall grocery offering.

Safeway and SuperValu, two of the largest US supermarket chains, are also experimenting with small, local formats.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo Analysis

As our readers know, we've been covering Wal-Mart's Marketside format development closely as part of our extensive coverage of what we termed the small-format food and grocery retailing revolution in the U.S.

The Marketside stores, which will feature in-store, fresh prepared foods (and in-store seating for about 9-10 customers along with take out), specialty and natural foods and groceries, fresh meats and produce, along with a limited selection of basic grocery items, will average about 15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet--which is a fraction of the size of its Supercenters, which are about 180,000 square feet on average, and less than half the size of its 45,000 square foot Wal-Mart Neighborhood Market supermarkets.

The format's focus will be on consumers who desire quality foods at reasonable prices. The first four Marketside stores are scheduled to open in the phoenix, Arizona Metropolitan region this fall.

We started covering the Marketside format development last year, and have broken numerous stories about its progress. During this more than one year coverage of the story, we've developed some very good sources.

We talked to a couple of our Wal-Mart sources today about the Financial Times report. One of those sources, who has been very good thus far, told us the mention of an eventual 1,000 store, $10 billion a year Marketside chain was on the job advertisement online board. However, the source says not to take it too seriously, not to think it means plans call for such a chain in the near future.

Rather, the source says its an internal long range goal number, and it didn't belong on the job board website, which is why it was taken down after the Financial Times reporter contacted the company about it.

This doesn't mean Wal-Mart doesn't plan to be aggressive with its Marketside format--just not 1,000 stores, $10 billion a year aggressive in the short to medium term.

As we've reported, Wal-Mart is looking for additional Marketside sights in Arizona, in addition to the four set to open this fall. The retailer also is looking throughout California and Nevada (Tesco Fresh & Easy country along with Arizona), as well as in other U.S. states.

Thus far we've reported for example that Wal-Mart is considering signing a lease for site in Reno, Nevada, along with in various particular California locations for the stores.

The current poor U.S. economy also has factored into Wal-Mart's planning for its Marketside small-format fresh food and grocery stores, according to our source. That source says because the stores will be more upscale in design and positioning--along with putting an emphasis on fresh, prepared foods--the retailer is exercising caution as it is well aware of the current consumer trend in the U.S. to trade down to discount food stores like its Wal-Mart Supercenters.

This fact isn't putting the brakes on Marketside. Rather, its providing a moderating theme to how fast the retailers grows the stores.

After all, there is no need to open Marketside stores in the way for example that Tesco is opening new Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores--about at a pace of one new store every three or four days on average--since Wal-Mart's strategy with Marketside is part of a multi format strategy while Tesco is engaged in a single format--Fresh & Easy--U.S. food and grocery retailing strategy.

Having said that, we are currently working on reporting about a couple possible Marketside store sites in California. We hope to write about just where those locations are soon. Like we said, Wal-Mart is taking a moderate, but still plenty aggressive, approach with its new, small-format Marketside retail development and format.

Monday, August 4, 2008

Small-Format Food Retailing Memo: Independents Help Fuel Small-Format Food Retailing Revolution in the U.S. By Reinventing the 'Corner Grocery Store'

A 1920's corner grocery store in the United States.

The Return of the corner grocery store

As regular Natural~Specialty Foods Memo readers are aware, a year ago we started writing extensively about what we've deemed to be a revolution in small-format grocery store retailing internationally and in the United States.

[Click here to read a sampling of some of our stories on the topic. Also do a search in the box at the top of the blog. Search terms: small-format food retailing, small-format food retailing special report, small-format grocery stores, international small-format food retailing revolution, small-format food retailing memo, independent grocer memo.]

In the U.S., this small-format food retailing revolution continues to grow. In fact, in just the last year hundreds of new small-format food and grocery stores have opened throughout the U.S., despite the poor state of the economy.

That's evidence--along with a few other criteria like the fact giant retailers like Wal-Mart, Tesco, Aldi, Safeway and SuperValu all are committed to small-format store development-- to us it's a trend, rather than a mere fad.

SuperValu, Inc. is even extending its involvement in small-format food and grocery retailing beyond its discount Sav-a-Lot chain, into its Jewel supermarkets division. This fall it will open the first store of what are likely to be many "Urban Fresh by Jewel" stores, which are 15,000 square foot specialty food and grocery stores with an emphasis on fresh and specialty products. The first "Urban Fresh by Jewel" small-format market will be in Chicago.

We've identified the food retailing chain leaders in this revolution as no frills discount grocer Aldi USA (with around 900 stores), the U.S. division of Germany-based Aldi International; Supervalu, Inc.'s no frills, discount Sav-A-Lot chain (about 1,600 stores); specialty grocery chain Trader Joe's (300 stores) Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market (currently 67 stores and growing fast) Safeway Stores, Inc., with its new small-format "The Market" stores; Wal-Mart with its soon to open first four Marketside stores; and numerous others.

Independent grocers, America's original small-format grocers, also are putting a renewed focus on opening small-format grocery stores, especially in urban neighborhoods and in the down towns of suburban and small cities. We call this phenomenon the "new corner grocery store." The phrase is more metaphorical to describe the phenomenon rather than literal to mean a small grocery store right on the corner, although that applies as well.

And it's not just experienced and independents currently operating supermarkets and grocery stores that are opening these new small-format "new corner grocery stores." For the first time in decades, we are seeing numerous entrepreneurs, some with food retailing backgrounds, others with restaurant backgrounds (and some with both), along with entrepreneurs from other walks of professional life, starting to open small-format grocery stores throughout the U.S.

Just like the big chains--where the small-format grocery stores range from no frills, deep discount markets like Adli's and Sav-A-Lot's and combination basic grocery and fresh foods stores like Tesco's Fresh & Easy, Safeway's "The Market" and Wal-Mart's Marketside, which will open this fall in the Phoenix, Arizona region, to natural and specialty format stores like Trader Joe's and others--these independents also are opening up a variety of formats of small-format grocery stores. These markets range from upscale fresh, specialty and natural foods stores, to modern versions more basic grocery stores modeled after the corner grocery store of the past. Hence the title we are giving them: the "new corner grocery store."

Although in our analysis the small-format food retailing revolution is still in its infancy in the U.S. (and in many parts of the world as well), it is beginning to have positive effects on numerous cities and towns throughout the U.S., as well as on consumers.

Not only are the stores serving shoppers in locations often previously underserved, but the small-format grocery store revolution is starting to have a positive effect on urban, suburban and small town down towns because many of the grocery stores being opened in such areas are going into buildings which were either previously empty or rundown. In other words, grocers are improving these buildings and thus the neighborhoods in these communities, providing a higher and better use for the existing buildings and therefore the community as a whole.

This morning we read a story in the Rutland (Vermont) Herald newspaper about three independents and how they are making a go with three small-format grocer stores in three different towns in Vermont.

Those grocers--Bellomo's Market in Rutland, West Street Market in Proctor, Vermont, and California Fruit Market--are three excellent examples of independents who are helping to create this small-format food retailing revolution in the U.S. by reinventing what we call the "new corner grocery store."

Read the story, "Owners around town revitalize small-scale retail," written by Bruce Edwards here.

It's not easy competing with the big chains for independents regardless if they operate huge supermarkets or small-format food stores. However, the fact is small-format independent food and grocery stores are in a growth mode rather than in decline in the U.S.

The ingredients for success for independents, as well as chains, are the same in the main regardless of store size. Those ingredients include creating a niche and them communicating it in all a retailer does, providing excellent customer service, operating clean stores regardless of the format, and a handful of other essentials.

Small-format grocery stores do offer a couple interesting particulars for retailers however.

First, because of the smaller size, the overhead--monthly rent, energy costs, labor--are less. For independents this means fewer barriers to entry, as it costs millions to open a new supermarket of say 40,000 square feet or more.

Second, it is easier to focus on a particular niche or niches in a small-format food and grocery store. By sheer virtue of its smaller-size, a retailer is focusing on a narrower niche--neighborhood residents, gourmets, natural and organic foodies, for example--which all things being equal should allow for easier focus in merchandising, marketing and operations.

Lastly, small-format stores allow for a strategy that doesn't have to force a retailer to directly compete against the big chains. For example, a corner grocery store can focus on being a fill-in, secondary and even tertiary, store for neighborhood residents. Additionally, by creating a natural-organic and specialty niche, the small-format store can brand itself as the place to shop for affordable "quality" foods for example.

Again, creating a niche, executing and communicating it aren't any easier with a small-format grocery store. But by virtue of the smaller physical size it can allow a retailer to do so more economically and in a tighter fashion.

It's our analysis that chains like those mentioned earlier are opening small-format stores in large part because they figured this fact out. Of course, it is something many independents have know all along in the U.S.--which accounts for the fabulous success of the independent food and grocery retailing segment overall in America.

We're observing the beginnings of the emergence of the "new corner grocery store" in the U.S. This time around though it's being conducted as much by big chains as it is by independents.

Therefore, independents in this current food retailing revolution will have to be even more competitive than they have been in past campaigns and battles. Of course, that is something independents as a segment have shown they can do time and again in the United States.