Showing posts sorted by date for query Safeway O Organics. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Safeway O Organics. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market's April Fools Day Web Page Offers Mirth, Pokes Fun At Itself, But Also Good PR Move For Natural Grocer's Image


The April Fools Day spirit has struck the Whole Foods Market Web site today.

The natural grocery chain, which gets its share of ribbing with nick names like "Whole Paycheck," has turned the front page of its Web Site into a humorous self-look at itself in the spirit of April Foods Day, which is today, April 1, 2009.

The Web site home page is full of mirth. You can view the site here.

For example, the mock advertisement pictured at the top of this story leads off the Whole Foods Market April Fools Day Web site home page. As you can see, the natural grocer is offering four varieties of Organic Air under its "365 Everyday Value" store brand. It's not just air packaged in an attractive clear bottle with a spritzer top mind you -- but organic air at that. We don't see the USDA Organic certified seal on the product though, which bothers us a bit.

Good humor is that which comes closest to reality in many cases. That's why we wouldn't be surprised if Whole Foods Market were to put up a display of its "new" organic air item in its stores that sales would probably be fairly decent -- at least for a while.

And since "air" is a 365 day a year essential, offering the organic air under the "365 Everyday" store brand is pure brand marketing genius, of course.

Below its "365 Everyday" store brand organic air advertisement, Whole Foods then gets into the news of the day -- April Fools Day news at Whole Foods.

First up is a brief item about "today's featured local grower at Whole Foods. Here it is: "Featured Local Grower Peter Parker of Tulsa, OK raises Huntsman spiders, often mistaken for deadly Brazilian Wandering Spiders. Whole Foods Market is proud to offer one free spider with every 50-lb. purchase of organic bananas."

A rare spider was recently found in bananas at a Whole Foods Market store. This is a great way to "hang a lantern" on a problem. Poke fun at yourself, using April Fools Day to do so. PR grade=A+

In the spirit of its green retailing philosophy, Whole Foods Market then announces its latest strategic move in the paper v. plastic and reusable carrier bag controversy. That breaking April Fools Day news is this: "An Even Better Bag: Continuing our quest to keep plastic bags out of landfills, we introduce our reusable pet waste bags. Pick up after your pooch with our eco-chic Better Doggie Bag, designed by Cookie Fleck and Whole Foods Market."

Whole Foods pokes fun at its own image in the above "news" item. The grocer eliminated single-use plastic carrier bags from all its stores in April, 2008, on Earth Day. It's also been teased for selling numerous varieties of designer chic reusable carrier tote bags. The item shows Whole Foods can make fun of and laugh at itself. Consumers love this. PR grade=A+.

Whole Foods Market also tosses in some new store breaking news on its April Fools Day homepage. You have to click here to read this breaking news. But we will give you a hint: The store is "green" because it doesn't need refrigerated or frozen food cases to keep perishable products fresh.

The natural grocery chain also incorporates the April Fools Day theme into some of its regular Web site features.

For example, below are today's featured items in Whole Foods' regular "What's Cooking" at the stores feature:

~Deep-Fried Pork Eclairs
~Chianti-Gorgonzola Popsicles
~Indian Amazonian Guatemalan Honduran Balinese Rice
~Toast

The natural grocer's "Whole Story" Blog also gets the April Fools Day treatment.

Below are the five April Fools Day posts in today's "Whole Story" Blog:

Whole Story Blog

~When milk goes bad: 12 daring recipes
~No such thing as too much salt
~Experts find: eating food curbs hunger
~"Whole Deal" splits into 500 tiny deals
~Money-saving tip: bathtub wine

We actually think Whole Foods' could be on to something with the money-saving tip: bathtub wine post. After all, it taps into a number of hot-button consumer issues.

First, consumers are attempting to save money with every purchase in this severe recession, including wine. That hits the frugal hot button.

Another popular trend right now is "do it yourself" (DIY). Stomping grapes in the bathtub fits the DIY bill extremely well. Ties in with frugality in the recession as well.

Making bathtub wine at home is extremely sustainable production. You can't get much more natural-sustainable than bare feet, after all.

Combine all these factors with making sure the grapes used are organic and locally-produced, and Whole Foods just might want to make this do it yourself wine production idea a regular feature in its stores. We suspect it also might tap into the small but significant foot fetish consumer segment out there among America's natural products consumer base.

Whole Foods concludes its April Fools Day 2009 special feature page with... what else, a featured video. The title of the featured video: Change a flat tire the organic way with our step-by-step tutorial.

Some thoughts - and breaking news

Kudos to Whole Foods Market for stepping outside the box and offering up a bit of merchandising mirth for April Fools Day. Double kudos for poking fun at itself and some of its practices in the feature as well.

Consumers certainly need as much humor as we can get at present. And showing it has a sense of humor, including of the self-deprecating variety, is a good image booster for Whole Foods Market, which often comes across as...well, stuffy and a bit elitist.

Cheers to the creative minds who came up with the items featured in today's April Fools Day Whole Foods Market Web site extravaganza.

But all kidding aside...we have a funny feeling that the organic air item would probably be a pretty solid seller if it were to be marketed in the Whole Foods stores.

In fact, we were going to hold this back for a separate, breaking news story in the Blog, but we'll reported it here and now because of the ironic tie-in.

So here it is: According to our sources, Safeway Stores, Inc. is preparing to introduce what CEO Steve Burd is calling another revolutionary new product line under its popular, $500 million a year grossing "O' Organics" organic food and grocery product line.

Safeway has kept the new line, which Burd says will show Safeway to be the leading retail private label organics brand marketer in the U.S., under wraps in a secret campaign borrowed from the CIA.

However, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has learned about the new "O' Organics" brand line from the Safeway Stores, Inc. buyer who came up with the new product line, and was so excited about it he said he just had to tell somebody.

The Safeway Stores' buyer, who spoke to us on the condition we not mention his name, said Safeway's research shows that consumers will perceive the new "O' Organics" product as "a breath of fresh air" in new product development. That new product line: Safeway "O' Organics" organic fresh air, packaged in clear bottles with a spritzer top. April Fools!!!

[You can follow Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on Twitter.com at www.twitter.com/nsfoodsmemo. And that's no April Fools.]

Monday, March 30, 2009

Store Brand - Private Label Memo: 'Big Score' At 'Big Y' Chain For Safeway's 'Eating Right' Healthy Foods Brand


Retailer Store Brands: Special Report

The family-owned, Springfield, Massachusetts-based Big Y supermarket chain is the first major food and grocery retailer in the U.S. to introduce and carry at least one of the two Safeway Stores, Inc. organic and healthy foods store brands -- "O' Organics" and "Eating Right" -- that the Pleasanton, California-based supermarket chain began marketing to other U.S. grocery retailers and wholesalers through its Lucerne Foods Inc. brands division last year, in its stores.

In Big Y's case, the popular supermarket chain is introducing numerous "Eating Right" brand healthy food and grocery items across multiple categories in its stores in New England.

Privately-held Big Y, which was founded in 1936 by Paul and Gerald D'Amour and was named after an intersection in Chicopee, Massachusetts where two roads converge to form a Y, currently operates 57 high volume supermarkets located in Massachusetts and Connecticut.

Among the Safeway Stores, Inc. "Eating Right" healthy food products being introduced this week at Big Y include: frozen entrees; cereal; soups; pasta; salad dressings; snack bars; cookies; and items in numerous other dry grocery and perishable categories, according to Carrie Taylor, Big Y's corporate dietitian, who's in charge of the supermarket chain's "Living Well Eating Smart" chainwide healthy foods program.

"With healthier eating a priority for many of our customers, we are pleased to bring new options to our shelves with the introduction of the 'Eating Right' brand at Big Y stores," Ms. Taylor says. "Our shoppers have long relied on us to meet all of their supermarket needs and with 'Eating Right' we're able to offer a great selection of functional and tasty products designed to help our customers reach their specific health objectives."

Safeway Stores Inc.'s Lucerne Foods, Inc. brand marketing division is handling the marketing of the "O 'Organics" and "Eating Right" brands to supermarket chains and wholesale grocers in the U.S. and globally.

There are currently 225 SKUS in 20 categories under the "Eating Right" brand, according to Alex Petrov, president of Safeway Stores' Lucerne Foods Inc. division.

Neither Big Y supermarkets nor Safeway Stores, Inc. is touting the fact that the "Eating Right" brand being introduced in the 57 Big Y supermarkets in Massachusetts and Connecticut is produced, owned and marketed by Safeway Stores, including the fact that the brand is a Safeway healthy foods store brand. Both are handling the introduction and marketing of the brand just as they would any other brand, regardless of its origin or ownership.

That's also why the marketing of the "Eating Right" brand to grocers like Big Y is being conducted by Safeway's Lucerne Foods Inc. division as a separate function from the store brand merchandising and marketing of the brand (and of "O' Organics") in Safeway's about 1,750 supermarkets in the U.S. and Canada. Safeway Stores, Inc. strategically views the brands not just as store brands, but as what the company hopes will become standalone organic and healthy food brands both in the U.S. and globally in the future.

Safeway doesn't operate any supermarkets in the New England states of Massachusetts or Connecticut where Big Y has its 57 supermarkets.

The closest states where Safeway has stores are in Washington, D.C., Maryland and Virgina.

This is an important distinction because in Big Y's case its customer base won't in most cases even be aware that the "Eating Right" brand items are a Safeway store brand, since there are no Safeway-owned supermarkets in the two states.

Our analysis is that Safeway will need to use this type of strategy to launch the two brands in the U.S., focusing on regional chains like Big Y which operate in markets where Safeway does not have a retailing presence.

For example, we don't see many retailers in the Western U.S., where Safeway is a major player and in many markets is the market share leader, carrying the "O Organics" and "Eating Right" brands because with little exception every retailer in the Western U.S. is a competitor of Safeway's.

Major competitor's like Kroger Co, Supervalue, Inc., Wal-Mart and Costco have their own organic and healthy store brands and aren't going to offer the store brands of a major competitor in their respective stores.

Major regional chains throughout the west also in many cases either have their own organic and healthy foods store brands or carry such private label brands through arrangements with a wholesaler. Additionally, since these regional chains are direct competitors with Safeway in states like California, Oregon, Washington, Colorado, Arizona and the like, they won't in all probability offer Safeway's "Eating Right" or "O Organics" store brands on their respective shelves either. It makes little sense for these chains to compete with Safeway on the brands.

We believe this will hold true in other parts of the U.S. where Safeway has a retail presence like the Washington D.C./Maryland/Virgina tri-state market region, Texas, Florida, Illinois-Indiana and Alaska, in addition to the Western U.S.

As a result, that's why we believe Safeway will have to conduct a niche retailer strategy, placing its "O Organics" and "Eating Right" brands in non-competitive, select chains primarily in parts of the U.S. where it isn't a retail player.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) was one of the first, if not the very first, publication to report that Safeway Stores, Inc. was marketing its "O Organics" brand to another retailer, France's Carrefour (the world's third-largest global retailer) internationally, in the three stories from December, 2007, and the January 8, 2008 piece, linked below:

~December 27, 2007: Marketing Memo: Safeway's O' Organics Brand in Asia
~December 23, 2007: Safeway's O' Organics Brand: Part Duex
~December 21, 2007: Friday Fishwrap: Safeway's O' Organics Brand
~January 8, 2008: Media Memo: Safeway's O' Organics Brand In Asia

In April of 2008, we first reported in this piece [April 28, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway Stores, Inc. to Market its 'O' Organics' and 'Eating Right' Organic and Healthy Brands to Other Retailers in U.S. and Globally] about Safeway's corporate plans to market its "O 'Organics" and "Eating Right" brands to other supermarket chains in the U.S.

Linked below are four related past pieces on the topic from Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM):

~August 6, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway's Challenge: Going From Store Brand Marketer to Consumer Brand Marketer With its O' Organics and Eating Right Brands
~April 28, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway Stores, Inc. to Market its 'O' Organics' and 'Eating Right' Organic and Healthy Brands to Other Retailers in U.S. and Globally
~April 28, 2008: Retail Memo: Safeway CEO Burd Says Shoppers Buying Store Brands Over National Brands By As Much As Six -to- One in it's North American Supermarkets

Safeway's Lucern Foods, Inc. division isn't confirming or not confirming, but based on our reporting, sources and research, Springfield, Massachusetts-based Big Y appears to be the first U.S. supermarket chain that's agreed to carry one of the two Safeway brands, "O Organics" and "Eating Right." In Big Y's case, it's carrying the "Eating Right brand" only at present.

Big Y is a popular, high volume retailer in New England. As a result, landing the chain is a major niche retailer score for Safeway and its "Eating Right" brand, in our analysis.

Big Y also is a well-known regional chain in the trade. Safeway's landing of the chain for its "Eating Right" brand should create greater interest in the brand from similar retail chains in other parts of the U.S., particularly in market regions where Safeway doesn't operate supermarkets in.

We expect to see at least two more regional chains in the U.S. announce their respective plans to carry either just the "Eating Right" healthy foods brand or both the "Eating Right" and "O' Organics" brands from Safeway in the next couple months.

[Readers: You can follow Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on Twitter.com at www.twitter.com/nsfoodsmemo.]

Friday, March 27, 2009

Store Brand - Private Label Memo: Store Brand Organic Products Gaining Prestege With Consumers Says New Study of What Shoppers Are Discussing Online


Retailer Store Brands: Special Report

The introduction and aggressive marketing of high-quality retailer store brand organic products is leading to a change in consumer perceptions in a positive direction, according to a soon to be released research report called the J.D. Power & Associates Private Label Industry Report.

The report is from J.D. Power & Associates Web Intellegence Division, which conducts content analysis research using information from a variety of online sites and sources as a way to guage consumer attitudes and perceptions. Most people know J.D. Power for its industry ranking of automobile quality. However, it's a full service research firm which also focuses on consumer package goods in addition to other consumer products research.

Janet Eden-Harris, vice president of J.D. Power and Associates Web Intelligence Division, which is based in Westlake Village, California, offered a preview of the firm's research into consumer attitudes of store brand organic products this week at the IRI (Information Resources, Inc.) Summit in Las Vegas, Nevada.

She said the J.D. Power Web-based research project shows that consumer attitudes about many store brands have shifted in the last couple years. Rather than has has been the case in the past, in which generally store brands, including organics, have been considered by consumers to be of lower-quality, with a low-price focus (including poor packaging quality), private label brands, particularly store brand organics, are now being thought of as unique and as having quality commensurate with that of traditional manufacturer-marketer brands.

"It's clear that consumers have begun to discard the idea that private label brands are of lower quality than traditional brands, which provides an opportunity for retailers to differentiate themselves with high-quality, reasonably priced store brands," Ms. Eden-Harris said in her presentation at the IRI conference.

The firm's report analyzed about 50,000 spontaneous conversations between March, 2008 and March, 2009 in various Blogs and online message and review boards that mentioned and discussed store brand/private label products from a variety of retailers, according to Ms. Eden-Harris.

Retailers with one-half of 1 percent or more of all discussions during the year are included in the report, she said.

The research report is designed to provide insight to retailers on what drives consumers to purchase their private label brands, as well as to help consumer packaged goods manufacturers develop strategies for differentiating and marketing their brands.

Ms. Eden-Harris said in her presentation at the conference that the complete study and its results will be released in April.

Below are a few highlights of the firm's report regarding private label or store brand organic products from Janet Eden-Harris' presentation at the IRI Summit:

>The report finds that the amount of online conversation about private label products has increased steadily during the past year, with volume peaking during the fall of 2008 as the economic crisis was unfolding.

>Organic store brand pricing is a strong motivator for consumers. But the quality and flavor of private label organic products drive the highest levels of positive sentiment, according to the Web-based content analysis study.

> Store brand food products from Safeway, Trader Joe's and Whole Foods garner particularly high levels of positive consumer recommendations, compared with other private label brands, and are perceived as being particularly healthful and flavorful.

>Positive consumer sentiment for store brand food items, especially organics, is higher than it is for non-food products such as diapers, paper products and cleaning supplies. The report's conclusion: This suggests that these products are perceived by consumers as commodities, purchased for their lower cost rather than as a favored brand in their own right.

In her presentation, Ms. Eden-Harris said the improved perception of store brand organic products doesn't mean opportunity has to be lost by brand manufacturers' and marketers.

"While retailers continue to gain ground with their private label products, there is still enormous opportunity for consumer packaged goods manufacturers," she said. "Innovation is still a big growth driver, and CPG companies still lead in that regard. New and differentiated products that are priced to value will win market share."

We agree with that conclusion since at least in "phase one" of store brand organic product development most of the retailer brand products have been versions of products already produced and marketed by brand manufacturers' and marketers. In fact, retailers like Safeway Stores with its O' Organics brand used sales data from its in-house natural-specialty foods department to decide which items to create under the private-label organics brand.

Additionally, most retailers rely on traditional manufacturers not only to produce their store brands but in many cases to offer advice and suggestions on private label product development.

However, we're now seeing what we call "phase two" of retailer brand organic product development in which select retailers like Safeway, Kroger, Wal-Mart, Trader Joe's (TJ's has always been a "phase two" natural-organic product developer and innovator), Target, Whole Foods, Costco and a few others are innovating and actually creating some products under their respective natural and organic store brands that don't exist under manufacturer brands in the retail marketplace.

In our analysis though food company manufacturers and marketers, particularly in the natural and organic segment, continue to be the innovators when it comes to new product creation and development. Retailers still tend to be followers rather than brand innovators overall in the categories.

J.D. Power's Web Intelligence Division analyzes consumer behavior online by using proprietary Natural Language Processing and machine-learning algorithms to dissect the who, what and why of online opinion, offering in-depth insights for some of the world's leading brands, according to Ms. Eden-Harris. It's a form of content and opinion analysis based on what consumers are commenting and opining on on the Web.

The purpose of the Web-based content and attitude analysis research is to glean what consumers are saying online as a way of better understanding consumer behavior, attitudes, opinions and trends.

With so many consumers now using online product review sites, Blogs, chat forums and social networking sites like Twitter and Facebook, we think such research is now essential, along with more traditional methods, in order to better understand consumer attitudes in the food, grocery and consumer products space.

In fact, Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) uses our own form of Web-based content analysis often to spot, analyze and write about consumer behavior and trends based on information gleaned from search engines, social networking sites, online review sites and message boards and Blogs.

Using the Web to better understand consumer behavior and attitudes will become even more important sense so many consumers are using the Web to search for products, retailers and related information, along with reviewing products at online review boards, and generally increasingly using the Web as an integral part of overall consumer and shopper behavior.

Below is a linked selection of past stories from Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on and directly related to the retailer store brands topic:

~March 12, 2009: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market is Selling Brand 'Wild Oats'- We Offer Three Retailers We Suggest Could Benefit From Buying the Brand

~January 31, 2009: Store Brands - Private Label Memo: Smart & Final-Owned Henry's Farmers Market Preparing to Debut New Natural & Organic 'Sun Harvest' Store Brand

~August 24, 2008: Marketing Memo: Store Brands 2.0: Better Store Brands and Brand and Shopper-Marketing Changing How Food Retailers Sell Their Own Brands

~August 6, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway's Challenge: Going From Store Brand Marketer to Consumer Brand Marketer With its O' Organics and Eating Right Brands

~April 28, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway Stores, Inc. to Market its 'O' Organics' and 'Eating Right' Organic and Healthy Brands to Other Retailers in U.S. and Globally

~April 28, 2008: Retail Memo: Safeway CEO Burd Says Shoppers Buying Store Brands Over National Brands By As Much As Six -to- One in it's North American Supermarkets

~June 4, 2008: Marketing Memo: Ingredients For 'Free Media' Marketing Success: Safeway Stores Finds Them With Announcement of its New 'Eating Right For Kids' Line

~May 9, 2008: Retail Marketing Memo: Safeway Uses Mother's Day Holiday to Launch its New 'mom to mom' Store Brand Baby Products Line in its Stores

~December 27, 2007: Marketing Memo: Safeway's O' Organics Brand in Asia

~December 23, 2007: Safeway's O' Organics Brand: Part Duex

~December 21, 2007: Friday Fishwrap: Safeway's O' Organics Brand

~January 8, 2008: Media Memo: Safeway's O' Organics Brand In Asia

~February 6, 2008: Retail Memo: Raley's Attempts to Come 'Full-Circle' With New Private-Label Natural and Organic Products' Brand

~April 7, 2008: Retail Memo: Wal-Mart, Target, Drug Chains Further Blur the Natural~Specialty Foods' Retail Class of Trade Lines

~October 11, 2007: Thursday Talking Points Memo:
Category Marketing Dominance: How Whole Foods Market, Inc. Became King of the Supernatural Retail Grocery Category and Why it Will Continue to Reign For Some Time

~February 11, 2008: Retail Trends Memo: UK's Asda Pioneering the 'Store-Grown' and 'Store-Raised' Niche: Will Raise its Own Kobe-Style Beef and Grow its Own Truffles

~December 9, 2008: Organics Category Memo: Wither Organics? Organic Food & Grocery Category Sales Down; But Double-Digit Growth Still Possible With Mass Market Lift

~November 28, 2008: Consumer Behavior Memo USA: 'Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Frugality' - America's New Consumer Frugality

~November 28, 2008: Retail Memo: Target Corp. Launching Major Expansion of Food and Grocery Products in its Target Discount Format Stores

~May 3, 2008: Retail Memo: Loblaw's New President Charts A Course to Return the Grocer to Its 'Glory Days' of Being Canada's 'Best' as Well as Biggest Food Retailer

~December 12, 2007: Mid-Week Marketing Memo: Tesco's Fresh & Easy

~January 28, 2008: Monday Marketing Memo: Cost-Plus World Market Restructuring: We Think Specialty Foods and Beverages Can be the Key to a Successful Repositioning

~July 25, 2008: Retail Field Report Memo: Specialty Retailer Cost Plus World Market Is At A Serious Crossroads: We Offer Analysis and Suggestions For Moving Forward

~January 30, 2008: Retail Memo: A Peak Inside a New Trader Joe's Store

[Reader Note: You can follow Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on Twitter.com at www.twitter.com/nsfoodsmemo.]

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market Opens New Store in Santa Cruz, California Today ... And There's Plenty of Competition

Pictured above is the famous "Giant Dipper" roller coaster at the Santa Cruz Beach Boardwalk in Santa Cruz, California. Built in 1924 it is one of the oldest roller coasters of its kind in America. With Whole Foods Market opening its first store in Santa Cruz today, we suggest there will be a natural foods retailing competitive roller coaster ride soon hitting the city.

Fresh from reaching its settlement agreement with the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) on March 6, Whole Foods Market, Inc. today opened a 31,500 square foot natural foods supermarket in the coastal Northern California city of Santa Cruz, home to the famous Santa Cruz Beach Boardwalk, and what's considered one of the most attractive campuses of the University of California, the University of California, Santa Cruz, the campus with the unique mascot -- Sammy the Banana Slug.

The new store is the first for Whole Foods Market in the city of Santa Cruz, which has a very high natural-organic foods shopper demographic. Northern California, which is one of the U.S. regions in which Whole Foods Market has the greatest number of stores, is one of the best market regions for the natural grocery chain in the country.

An interesting aspect of Whole Foods' opening its new natural foods supermarket in Santa Cruz so soon after its March 6 settlement agreement with the FTC regarding the regulatory agency's near 20-month legal battle to overturn the 2007 acquisition by Whole Foods Market, Inc. of Wild Oats Markets, Inc., is that Santa Cruz, a city of about 100,000 residents, is a very competitive natural foods retailing town.

For example, in the natural foods retailing class of trade, locally-based New Leaf Community Markets has long been the leader in Santa Cruz. In fact, New Leaf just opened on March 11 a brand new nearly 18,000 square foot natural foods market on the westside of the city. The New Leaf store is about three miles from the new Whole Foods store, which is located on the city's east side. The new store replaces an older New Leaf market on the westside. There's also a New Leaf store in downtown Santa Cruz. There are six New Leaf units in the region.

Another popular independent natural foods market in Santa Cruz is Staff of Life Natural Foods Market, which has operated in the city for many years and has a loyal following.

There's also a Trader Joe's natural and specialty grocery store in Santa Cruz. With its extensive selection of natural, organic and specialty products, Trader Joe's draws many of the same customers that Whole Foods Market stores do.

Safeway Stores, Inc. has a supermarket in Santa Cruz. The grocery chain, which is based in Northern California's San Francisco Bay Area, is in the process of building one of its brand new "Lifestyle" format supermarkets in the coastal community.

In addition to being filled with conventional food and grocery products, the new Safeway in Santa Cruz will be stocked full with natural, organic and premium food and grocery items, including the chain's popular "O' Organics" organic products brand and its "Eating Right" healthy foods brand. The two Safeway brands combined did about $1 billion in gross sales in Safeway's 1,750 stores in the U.S. and Canada in 2008.

The new Santa Cruz "Lifestyle" format Safeway also will feature a fresh, prepared foods-deli department and in-store special features like a fresh nut bar, which Safeway includes in its new "Lifestyle" stores. The new wave "Lifestyle" format stores often look in many cases very similar in design to a larger, new Whole Foods store.

Sacramento, California-based Raley's (130 stores, $3.5 billion in annual sales) has one of its Nob Hill banner supermarkets in Santa Cruz. Raley's is a major player in natural and organic foods retailing and the Santa Cruz Nob Hill store offers a strong selection of natural and organic products, reflecting Raley's competitiveness in the categories.

Add to this competitive mix Shoppers Corner, a longtime Santa Cruz independent supermarket that offers both conventional groceries and natural, organic and specialty foods. The grocer "stacks product high" and "sells it cheap," often offering natural and organic items for less than all its competitors.

In other words, Santa Cruz is a perfect laboratory to test the FTC's (now historic) antitrust argument that a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats is monopolistic. As we argued throughout the legal case, in today's natural-organic foods retailing world in the U.S., Whole Foods competes against not only natural foods stores, but also certain supermarket chains (like Safeway) and hybrid format retailers (like Trader Joe's).

Therefore, since Santa Cruz has three high volume and competitive natural foods markets -- the two New Leaf units and Staff of Life -- along with Safeway and Trader Joe's, plus Shoppers Corner, it's our analysis that Whole Foods will have its competition cut out for it in the coastal city. It won't be a cakewalk on the boardwalk for Whole Foods Market in Santa Cruz.

By the same token, Whole Foods will inject a massive dose of competition into the food and grocery retailing business in Santa Cruz. The natural foods supermarket chain is going after the city's consumers aggressively with discount pricing, hot promotional deals, special events and other merchandising and marketing schemes designed to fill the store's aisles.

But the local guys will fight back. That's why the market was right, and why the FTC ultimately gave Whole Foods a sweet settlement deal. The competition abounds and is always changing and growing.

[Suggested reading: Jondi Gumz, a staff writer for the Santa Cruz Sentinel newspaper, has a comprehensive and insightful piece published in the paper today about Whole Foods' opening of its new store in Santa Cruz, and the competitive aspects having the new big league player in town might have on the city's existing retailers. Read the story here. There's also a color slideshow of photogrpahs of the new store at the link.]

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Food Show Memo: A Fancy Food Show in A Not So Fancy Food-Desirable U.S. Economic Climate

The 34th Annual NASFT West Coast Winter Fancy Food Show begins tomorrow (running until Tuesday, January 20) at the Moscone Convention Center in San Francisco, California. Just like fancy food shows past, the huge convention center floor will be filled with exhibitors from all over the world, displaying their respective specialty, gourmet, ethnic and natural-organic food and beverage products to members of the retail trade.

This year the show will be packed with retailers, brokers, distributors, food service operators and other assorted members of the specialty foods trade, as it is every year. The show is sponsored by NASFT, the National Association For The Specialty Food Trade, the leading trade group for members of the specialty foods trade.

Sellers will be selling, brokers will be looking for new lines, specialty foods makers and marketers will be networking, and although the fancy food show isn't traditionally a "selling show," some orders will be taken and deals struck betwen buyers and sellers, as happens each year. And you can bet exhibitors will be selling more aggressively this year than perhaps in any time in the recent past.

On the exhibit floor, the thousands of specialty food and beverage companies displaying their respective wears will be putting the best face on the business, introducing some new products and promoting existing goods. There will be plenty of spin, something that always makes the fancy food show fun, along with some complaining about the currrent bad economic times.

But the true reality of how bad the current times are for specialty foods makers and marketers, as well as brokers, distributors and retailers that focus primarily on the specialty category, will be discussed most seriously off of the exhibit floor, in the hotel bars and San Francisco restaurants where the real business and talk goes on during fancy food show time.

And the times they are rather tough for most in the specialty foods business right now.

Below are some of the things members of the specialty foods trade will be talking about in those San Francisco hotel bars, restaurants (and perhaps at a gentleman's club or two) and on the sidelines off the main exhibit floor at Moscone Center starting tomorrow:

>The recession and financial/credit crisis: The situation is hurting near everybody in the industry, from the big specialty foods makers and marketers to medium-size companies and small-entrepreneurial operations. Manufacturers can't get credit, which for many is needed for production, selling, promotion and in some cases even to temporarily make payroll. The frozen credit markets are allowing only the most credit-worthy to access lines of credit.

>Payables-Receivables: Everybody is holding payables in this down economy. In many cases retailers are paying distributors late, which in-turn means distributors are paying specialty foods suppliers late. As a result, suppliers in-turn are paying their brokers' commissions late. They also are paying other suppliers -- glass makers, label makers, printers -- late. It becomes a vicous circle. And with credit so tight it's near-impossible to get short-term bridge loans to help with cash-flow when payments are late. Many have turned to factoring firms that are in the business of advaning companies money on receivables in return for a substantial percentage of the amount due.

>Consumers trading down: During the two most recent economic recessions, in 2001-2002 following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks and in the 1992-1993 recession, consumers still bought plenty of specialty and gourmet foods in the main. Those two recessions were much milder and nowhere as deep as the present one is, and their was no financial/credit crisis like at present, so consumers tended to buy specialty and gourmet products at their near-same levels because it was the one affordable indulgence they could splurge on.

Not now. Consumers have cut way back on everything, including food and grocery products. The first items to go have been items like expensive flavored olive oils, fancy mustards, imported preserves, gourmet cookies and other mainstays of the specialty foods trade. Specialty foods makers and marketers, ranging from the divisions of huge consumer packaged goods companies to mid-level and small artisinal producers, are feeling this sting strongly.

>The shelf space crunch: Retailers ranging from the mega-supermarket chains to the regional U.S. chains, as well as mass merchandisers like Wal-Mart and Target, along with specialty foods chains like Cost-Plus World Market and others, have been increasing the number of skus of their own store brand specialty, natural and organic foods items dramatically over the last few years. This includes the "Big Three" U.S. supermarket chains -- Kroger, Safeway and Supervalu. Store shelf space that once held the products from exhibitors at the fancy food show has now in many cases been replaced by store brands. This trend is growing fast. Grocery wholesalers such as Unified Western Grocers in the west (and others throughout the U.S.) and specialty distributors like Tree of Life, Inc. and others also are pushing their own provate label specialty and natural products more so.

On top of this trend, food retailers are taking shelf space that has been used to merchandise specialty foods and in many cases replacing the space with more basic, value-oriented (more inexpensive skus of white rice replacing basmati and wild rice skus, for example) food and grocery items because that's what the consumer is demanding in the current severe recession.

Safeway Stores, Inc. is a good example of this. Since late in the first quarter of 2008, Safeway has been adding numerous new items to its store shelves under its Safeway and other value store brands. In many cases these items took the place of manufacturer branded specialty foods items. And this is on top of Safeway's introduction over the last couple years of thousands of skus across all categories of its "O' Organics" and "Eating Right" premium organic and healthy foods store brands, along with its "Safeway Select" premium and specialty foods brand.

There's only so much "share-of-the-shelf." When space is needed for store brands it often comes at the expense of manufacturer, especially smaller manufacturer, specialty food and grocery brands because they have slower movement compared to a store brand -- even if that store brand is a premium one. REtailers also make higher margins on their own brands.

The 130 store Raley's supermarket chain and the upscale Wegmans chain on the east coast are two regional chains, both key customers for specialty foods marketers, that have also been dramatically reducing the amount of space devoted to manufacturer specialty foods brands on their respective store shelves in favor of their own store brands. Both regional chains, as have many others, have been introducing store brand specialty product after specialty product in the last year, ranging from basic items like olive oil to more exotic products like fig and raspberry-infused balsamic vinegar, which is one of the latest lines introduced by Raley's under its "Raley's" store brand.

When retailers like Safeway, Raley's and Wegmans, which are just three examples of the many retailers doing the same, eliminate specialty foods brands for their store brand items, that also hurts distributors and brokers, as well as the brand's manufacturers and marketers. Distributors lose sales and brokers lose commissions.

Cost Plus World Market, long a key customer for specialty foods companies and importers, is another example of this store brand trend. Cost-Plus has been banging out specialty items after specialty item, in category after category -- condiments, oils and vinegars, snacks, confections, beverages and more -- under its "World Market" store brand. Every time it introduces a new line and item it has to either reduce facings of manufacturer specialty brands or eliminate those items all together -- or both. And of course when this happens it also hurts brokers, who lose commissions on lines discontinued by the 300 store chain, which is one of the top specialty foods venues in the U.S.

We haven't even mentioned an additional fact yet -- that in addition to store brand specialty items displacing manufacturer brand items on the shelf, the store brands, which are almost always prices at least 15% (and most often more) lower than the supplier brands take sales away from those manufacturer brands. For example, placing a 16oz bottle of "Safeway Select" Balsamic Vinegar next to two manufacturer specialty brands on the shelf and pricing it 15-20% lower can easily reduce the average weekly sales volume of those two manufacturer brands by 50%. That's dramatic.

>More aggressive buyers: Specialty foods manufacturers and marketers also are getting hit hard by retail buyers and distributor buyers for deeper and longer deals, more promotional monies and higher spoils allowances, among other chargebacks. Distributors are aggressively asking for higher off-invoice promotional amounts and not always passing the full amount on to the retailer. In turn, retailers are demanding better deals from distributors, including more promotional money. In turn, the retailers aren't always passing those deals on to consumers at the shelf. This has always gone on in the industry. However in these bad economic times it's happening more. Everybody is struggling and looking for ways to ease that struggle.

Those specialty foods companies that sell primarily to specialty foods retailers, and there are many, perhaps the majority who exhibit at the fancy food show, are hurting the most. Sales at specialty and gourmet food stores are way down. Shopping at a specialty foods store is generally a planned trip for consumers, unlike a trip to the supermarket which they have to do is. As such, many consumers are completely avoiding specialty foods stores because they know once inside they are likely to spend money they don't have. Better to avoid the stores completely goes the reasoning.

Despite the struggles going on across the specialty foods industry at present, the fancy food show, which starts tomorrow, will still be packed. Perhaps not as busy as last year in terms of exhibitors, but we suspect there will be as many attendees. For some its the only chance they have all year to network with other members of the trade.

And the specialty foods industry is vibrant. It will survive. But we do know of a number of long established specialty foods companies that are on the ropes. We also know a couple that have gone under this year. There also are many specialty foods professionals, ranging from marketers and operations people to sales folks, at all levels, out of work. You can bet there will be lots of networking for jobs at this year's San Francisco fancy food show as well. Most are out of luck though. Hiring is near non-existent. Layoffs are happening. More cutbacks are to come.

But we think there's reason for optimism. The 34th NASFT Annual Winter Fancy Food Show ends on Tuesday, January 20, the day a new American President, Barack Obama, is sworn-in as the country's 44th President. And with Obama's taking office there's a new spirit blowing across the land in which serious people want to do serious things to improve this economy.

Doing so will take time. We suspect all of 2009, and most economists agree, is going to be a wash in terms of remaining in economic recession. We also believe things are going to get worse before they get better.

But members of the specialty foods trade, which includes many natural foods players as well, are a resourceful group. Most are tough. Most are determined. They have seen bad times before. Some will go out of business but most will survive. Additionally, there will be a new wave of industry consolidation once the credit crisis is over as well, we believe.

Right now job one is to survive for a better day. Use the bad economic times to innovate. Some of the best merchandising and marketing ideas are born out of hard times, for example.

As members of the specialty foods trade arrive in San Francisco today for the show's three day run we suggest you look around you at the City By The Bay. It's a perfect example of renewal and reinvention. It was rebuilt after the earthquake and fire of 1906. Much of the city had to be rebuilt again after the 1989 earthquake. It's a place where people from throughout the country and even the world have come to reinvent themselves, despite the high cost of living.
Once the financial capital of the western U.S., that ended. But San Francisco reinvented itself, becoming the advertising and muti-media capital of the west instead, as an example of business renewal.

And of course, Northern California and the San Francisco Bay Area is arguably the top region in the United States, and one of the top globally, for innovation in the specialty, gourmet, natural and organic foods industry.

So, look around. And think like many San Franciscans did after the fire of 1906 completely destroyed the city when they said to each other: "This too shall pass." And so too will the current hard times pass.

But in the meantime its all about being smart, frugal and innovative. The most innovative folks in the specialty foods trade today will become the most successful folks in the business when the recession ends.

Come up with ways to market specialty products in the recession. Themes like the "frugal gourmet." Offer added value. Get creative in promoting; use PR and free media rather than paid advertising. So few specialty foods companies are using social media sites and Blogs for marketing, for example. This is particualrly true of many medium and smaller companies who's Web presence looks like what one would expect in the first or second year of the existance of the World Wide Web, rather than in 2009. The cost of doing so is near-free -- and the potential impact huge.

Innovate, innovate, innovate. And have a good show.

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Retail Memo: Natural-Organic Foods and U.S. Retail Marketplace Realities; Why the FTC's Case Against the Whole Foods-Wild Oats Merger is Pure Folly


Analysis: FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) believes the U.S. Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) legal case and argument against the merger of Wild Oats Market, Inc. and Whole Foods Market, Inc., the friendly acquisition by Whole Foods of Wild Oats that the regulator has been fighting in court since the summer of 2007, is folly.

NSFM has no affiliation with Whole Foods Market. We have nothing to gain from the merger's holding firm. In fact we think part of the reason the FTC continues to so strongly oppose the deal, despite the fact its been over 18 months since it was done and is now near fully-completed in terms of integration, is because of the decade-plus public comments of Whole Foods' CEO John Mackey and a couple of other company executives about "dominating" natural foods retailing in the U.S.

We also think part of the reason for the FTC's resolve has to do with John Mackey's silly postings on Yahoo Finance message boards during the run up to the deal in which using an assumed screename he described Wild Oats essentially as a bankrupt company in need of a new owner; that new owner being of coourse Whole Foods Market, Inc. We happen to agree with Mackey that Wild Oats was basically that, as do most of the investors who were four-sqaure behind the deal with Whole Foods, but his method of communicating that opinion was less than stellar. Mackey was investigated by the federal government for the postings and was foound to have broken no laws.

However, neither of these are or should be valid reasons for the FTC to continue to challenge the merger, assuming as we suggest they might play a part in the regulator's doing so.

The FTC's central argument against the deal is that a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats is a monopoly retailer in 29 U.S. markets in what the regulatory agency has termed the "premium natural and organic foods retailing segment." As a result the FTC says Whole Foods Market, Inc. presents an anticompetitive position vis-avis other retailers in the selling of natural and organic foods in these U.S. markets.

The creation of this food retailing segment by the FTC forms the entire central premise of its ongoing attempt to unwind the merger.

But the problem is the "premium natural and organic food retailing segment" is at best irrelevant and at worse a creative fiction in terms of the retailing of natural and organic foods and related consumer goods in today's U.S. market.

Instead, natural and organic foods retailing in today's America is what we call a multi-retailer and multi-format business.

At one end of this spectrum there are serious and strong regional competitors in the natural-organic retailing class of trade that are dealing a serious blow to Whole Foods Market, Inc. These retailers include such regional natural foods chains as Sunflower Farmers Market, Sprouts Farmers Market, Henry's Marketplace (which Whole Foods sold to Smart & Final, Inc. after acquiring it in the Wild Oats deal in 2007, Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage, PCC Natural Foods Co-op (Washington State) and New Seasons Market (Portland, Oregon Metro region) and a number of others in the Western U.S.

Elsewhere in the U.S. other fast-growing natural foods chains like Mrs. Green's Market (New York state region), which is owned by Canada's Planet Organic, Inc., Earth Fare (southern U.S.), Fresh & Wholesome (eastern U.S.) My Organic Market (Washington D.C./Maryland/Virginia region) and others are strongly competiting against Whole Foods in those and other U.S. regions.

Further, along with these small but in most cases fast-growing natural and organic foods chains, there are thousands of independent and co-op natural foods stores that competite head-to-head with Whole Foods stores in their respective U.S. markets.

Along with the natural foods class of trade described above, the biggest development in category retailing in the last decade has been the entry of supermarkets into natural and organic products retailing. This includes mega-chains like Safeway Stores, Inc. with its Lifestyle format supermarkets (1,750 in the U.S. and Canada and growing), Kroger Co., including its new "Fresh" format, as well as mega-regional chains like H-E-B in Texas, Publix in Florida, Raley's in Northern California, Wegemans on the east coast and so many others. These retailer's stores offer nearly as much variety of natural and organic food and grocery products as a Whole Foods market does and generally offer the category items at a lower everyday price that Whole Foods does.

But the supermarket class of trade's major and fast-growing position in natural and organic foods retailing isn't all there is in terms of the competitive landscape today in the U.S. Huge mass merchandisers like Wal-Mart, Target, Wal-Mart's Sam's Club, Costco, B.J's Wholesale and other national mass merchandiser chains are in the natural and organic products retailing business in a major and serious way.

For example, all of the mass merchandisers mentioned above offer their own private label brands of natural and organic foods, selling the products a lower everyday prices than Whole Foods stores do. These retailers also offer organic foods and consumer packaged goods marketed by national and regional manufactuers (brands), as well as selling organic fresh produce, meats and other perishables in their respective stores.

On top of all this competition are what we call the discount and hybrid natural and organic foods retailers. This category includes the mighty Trader Joe's, which with about 312 small-format disount natural and specialty foods stores throughout the U.S. is a major force in natural and organic products retailing. Trader Joe's is a natural-organic category killer retailer and steals much market share away from Whole Foods throughout the country.

Examples of the hybrid category include Cost Plus World Market which sells lots of natural and organic food products in its nearly 300 combination specialty foods and imported consumer goods stores located throughout the U.S. In the last couple years Cost-Plus has created numerous natural and organic food products across all categories under its World Market store brand, becoming a competitor for share of stomach with Whole Foods Market and all of the other retailers in the U.S. that retail natural-organic category products in their stores, regardless of format.

Another hybrid is the fast-growing Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, which is owned by United Kingdom-based Tesco, the third-largest retailer in the World. (Wal-Mart is the number one global retailer and France's Carrefour is number two. In just a little over a year, Tesco has opened about 110 of its small-format Fresh & Easy combination fresh foods and grocery markets in Southern California, Nevada and Arizona, with more to come. Along with selling basic grocery items and lots of fresh, prepared foods, including organics, the stores offer a solid selection of natural and organic packaged foods, groceries and perishables under its fresh & easy store brand. The natural and organic items are priced below those at natural foods stores like Whole Foods Market and are designed to steal away business from Whole Foods and traditional supermarkets.

Another hybrid retailer is Beverages & More, which has numerous stores throughout the Western U.S. The stores are beer, wine, spirits and specialty and natural foods category killers, offering items in each of these respective categories at discount prices. Every package of organic cereal, bottle of Vitamin Water or jar of organic mustard bought at a Beverages & More store could have been purchased at the monopolistic Whole Foods, for example.There are numerous other examples of hybrids located throughout the U.S.

There also are what we call hybrid upscale/specialty/natural foods superstores. These retailers include regional chains such as Fresh Market in the southern and Mid-Atlantic regions of the U.S., United Supermarkets' Market Street chain in Texas, Supervalu, Inc.'s Bristol Farms in California and numerous others. They retail specialty, natural and fresh foods, along with basic groceries, in very upscale (every bit as upscale as Whole Foods) stores ranging from 30,000 -to- 60,000 square feet, putting an emphasis on most of the same categories and practices that Whole Foods focuses on.

But we aren't finished yet with our natural-organic category retailing competitive review. In addition to all of the competition we've detailed above, American consumers can today buy natural and organic food and grocery products at drug stores owned by huge chains like Walgreens, CVS and Rite Aid, at 99 cent and dollar stores, online through retailers like Amazon.com and others, and in the case of organic fresh produce at thousands of farmers markets across the U.S. Although these alternative channels offer limited item selections, taken with the retailers described above they add significantly the the competitive natural-organic retailing landscape in the U.S. today.

The point is, looking at natural-organic products retailing through the blurred lense the FTC is using -- its "premium natural and organic retailing segment (PNOS)" -- is like the old philosophical saying of failing to see the forest through the trees. Create a definition, PNOS, and then use that non-realistic definition of today's market as the basis for your argument against the merger is how we view what the FTC is doing in continuing to oppose the Whole Foods-Wild Oats merger under this framework.

But this is not merely our analysis or opinion. The marketplace agrees with us. For example, Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Market both last year raised tens of millions of dollars to expand their respective businesses and store counts, which both chains have been doing aggressively. Both natural foods chains, as is the Natural Grocers By Vitamin Cottage natural foods chain, are going right at Whole Foods Market, opening stores in its home state of Texas, along with taking Whole Foods on in Colorado, California, New Mexico, Utah, Arizona, Nevada and elsewhere. Would these retailers really risk this if they believed Whole Foods held category retail monopoly power? Of course they wouldn't. Many of the states mentioned above are part of the 29 in which the FTC says Whole Foods Market, Inc. post-merger holds a monopoly, by the way.

Add to this market-based evidence Safeway Stores' march into the natural and organic foods retailing business over the last few years. The national supermarket chain, which has about seven times the annual gross sales of Whole Foods Market, Inc., has converted nearly all of its about 1,750 (Whole Foods has about 280 stores) supermarkets in the U.S. into its upscale Lifestyle format, which among other things puts a major emphasis on natural, organic and prepared foods, which are the three key merhcandising pillars of Whole Foods' business. Safeway has had huge success doing so.

For example, a little over years ago Safeway introduced its "O' Organics" store brand of organic food, grocery and non-foods items. Today the brand has over $500 million in annual sales and is growing fast. It's estimated 2008 sales will be about $700 million for the brand. O' Organics sales are growing so fast in fact that Safeway is in the process of marketing the brand to competitor supermarket chains in the U.S., along with marketing it globally. France's Carrefour is already selling numerous "O' Organics" brand items in its stores in Asia and Central America, for example.

Just over a year ago Safeway introduced its "Eating Right" store brand of healthy foods. The brand includes natural and healthy products across all categories, from dry grocery and dairly to fresh produce. Sales of the brand already are at about $300 million. Safeway says first year sales of 'Eating Right" were even higher than those of "O' Organics." The supermarket chain also is in the process of marketing "Eating Right" to competitor retailers, along with doing so to global chains outside the U.S.

Does anybody really believe that a significant portion of this nearly $1 billion worth of annual sales in just these two Safeway natural, healthy and organic store brands didn't in part come out of the sales hide of Whole Foods? Of course it did. Shoppers who just a decade ago had to seek out Whole Foods and otehr natural foods retailers for such items can now find most all they need in the natural and organic categories at supermarket chains like Safeway.

Many of Safeway's newest Lifestyle format supermarkets look very similar in upscale design and product selection to a Whole Foods natural foods supestore. However Safeway's stores have the added benefit of selling conventional food and grocery products along with the natural-organic.

It's our analysis that the FTC either has failed to understand the dynamics and realities of how natural and organic foods are retailed today in the U.S. or that it intentionally has decided it wants to break-up the Whole Foods-Wild Oats merger for reasons other than actual real competitive ones. In looking at Whole Foods' performance since the deal was finalized in late 2007, there is zero evidence of a monopolist at work. Just some of the empirical and performance-based evidence that Whole Foods looks not like a monopoly but rather more like a struggling retailer:

>Whole Foods' income was down by about 40% in its last quarter. It had a similar drop in net income the previous quarter.
>Whole Foods' stock share price is off by about 70% compared to its high after the Wild Oats merger.
>In the last quarter of 2008 Whole Foods fired about 100 workers at its Austin, Texas headquarters in order to conserve operating cash on hand.
>In December, 2008 Whole Foods sold 17% of the company to private equity firm Leonard Green & Partners for a mere $465 million because it needs the cash. One year ago a 17% stake in Whole Foods was worth more than double that $465 million.

In addition to all the evidence we've presented in this piece, there's a far more simple and telling test as to why a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats isn't a monopolist retailer of any sort. That test is that not one natural foods chain -- not Sunflower, not Sprouts, not Henry's -- or even an independent we've been able to find -- has spoken out publicly, saying that a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats is a monopolist and because of it that retailer can't compete. Even when the merger was first announced, and when the FTC first issued its formal opposition to the deal in the summer of 2007, did we hear any natural foods retailers speak out and say they felt seriously threatened by a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats. Instead there has been a deafening silence of concern from natural foods retailers over any real anti-competitive aspects of a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats.

As we write this, Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s energy is being near-used-up fighting its legal case against the FTC, rather than in doing food retailing. Meanwhile, the combination of the severe recession and the competitive environment, in which all of the various format retailers we've discuss are in many cases offering natural and organic food and grocery products at prices considerably below Whole Foods, is taking a toll on the company.

For example, last week supermarket industry investor Ron Burkle bought a 7% stake in Whole Foods Market, Inc. through his Yucaipa Cos. investment and private equity firm, saying he believes the natural grocery chain is undervalued based on its problems with the FTC and in the current bad economy. The last time Burkle said something similar was when he bought an 18% stake in Wild Oats, and then as a powerful member of Wild Oats' board he played a major role in engineering the merger with Whole Foods. Could he have a similar plan in mind with his 7% Whole Foods stake? Investors think so. After Burkle disclosed his stake in Whole Foods last Thursday the company's stock rose by 23%. Its still down about 52% over a year ago though.

With Ron Burkle's 7% stake and Leonard Green & Partners' 17% stake in Whole Foods, that now puts 24% of the natural grocery chain's ownership in the hands of just two entities. Leonard Green & Partners also placed three people on Whole Foods' board as a result of its investment. A 24% ownership isn't a majority but its enough to play a major role in engineering an acquisition or merger should Burkle and Leonard Green & Partners, both of which are based in Southern California, decide to get together and talk potential deal creation.

We wonder if the FTC would cry monopoly for example if Safeway Stores, Inc. or Kroger Co. acquired Whole Foods? What about Wal-Mart or Target? After all, none of these mega- retailers, all of which are super-giants in terms of annual sales compared to Whole Foods Market, Inc., aren't technically players in the "premium natural and organic retailing segment." Therefore, adding a mere 280 stores and a little over $6 billion (Whole Foods annual sales) wouldn't, using the FTC's logic and argument against why a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats is a monopoly, make any of these retailers monopolistic, not even Kroger which has about 12 times Whole Foods' annual sales or Wal-Mart, which has about 50 times Whole Foods' annual sales, right?

Therein lies the folly of the FTC's argument. It's created a fiction it calls the "premium natural and organic retailing segment," then used that non-market-reality-based definition to argue a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats is a "category monopoly," leaving out the fact that the reality of natural and organic foods retailing today is what we've described it as -- a multi-retailer, multi-format, highly competitive business in which no one retailer, including Whole Foods Market, Inc., at present holds any type of monopoly. And in select markets where one retailer might monopolize category business to a certain degree, be it Wal-Mart, Safeway or Whole Foods, the effect is so minimal as to be irrelevant.

Even more significant is that nature of food and grocery retailing in the U.S. is so dynamic that something new -- think Sunflower, Sprouts, Tesco's Fresh & Easy -- all of which didn't exist in any significantly competitive way three years ago -- keeps coming along and changes the dynamics of the market. That's the true competitive reality of natural and organic foods retailing in the U.S. today.

Monday, January 12, 2009

Retail Memo: FTC Asks Judge to Force Whole Foods to Put Most of the Wild Oats' Genie Back in the Bottle Pending A Resolution of its Merger Challenge


FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.

The ongoing legal battle and saga between the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Whole Foods Market, Inc. took a serious turn today when the FTC filed a brief asking U.S. Federal Judge Paul Friedman to order a complete halt to the integration of Wild Oats into Whole Foods (and more), a process that after more than 18 months since the 2007 merger is nearly completed. Whole Foods-Wild Oats: Two peas in a pod no more if the FTC gets its way from the judge.

The FTC says in its motion it wants the federal judge to force Whole Foods to stop any further integration activities while the multiple disputes between the regulator and the natural grocer over its acquisition of Wild Oats is handled in court. Judge Friedman is currently preparing to rule on motions filed by the FTC regarding the acquisition/merger, along with ruling on Whole Foods' lawsuit against the FTC in which the natural grocery chain is asking that the entire issue be removed from FTC jurisdiction and settled in Judge Friedman's federal courtroom.

The FTC said in its legal filing that the request is "appropriate, and reasonable" to preserve the assets of Wild Oats until the conclusion of the hearings.

This is the trifecta of pain the FTC wants to put Whole Foods Market, Inc. through: It wants the judge to order Whole Foods to rebrand (change the signs on the stores) the about 100 Wild Oats stores it's converted to the Whole Foods banner back to Wild Oats. It's legal filing also asks the judge to order Whole Foods to stop converting any remaining Wild Oats banner stores into Whole Foods. There still are a few left to be converted. Lastly, and most ominous for the natural grocer, The FTC wants former Wild Oats stores now operating as Whole Foods locations to be put in the hands of a third party, and their original signs returned, until its challenge to the merger is resolved.

The federal regulatory agency said in its filing today that if the judge rules that it has a strong enough case, it's likely it will attempt to unwind the entire merger and force Whole Foods Market, Inc. to establish Wild Oats as a standalone company and operate it that way.

The FTC has set a trial for April before an agency-picked Administrative Law Judge in which the fate of the deal is to be determined. Whole Foods' lawsuit before U.S. Federal Judge for the District of Columbia Paul Friedman asks, among other things, for that hearing to be cancelled and the FTC to be removed from determining the legal status of the merger. Instead Whole Foods wants the judge to hear the case and decide on the deal once and for all.

It appears to Natural~Specialty Foods Memo that the dramatic legal move today is the FTC's response to Whole Foods' lawsuit, which it filed in early December, 2008, as well as the natural grocer's high-profile lobbying and public relations campaign against the FTC, which we've reported on and written about extensively.

In other words, the gloves are now completely off on both sides.

Whole Foods Market CEO John Mackey shot back at the FTC today through a spokesperson and through his legal counsel, calling the FTC's request "absurd" and saying the process of integrating Wild Oats is done.

"They want us to put the toothpaste back in the tube," lead Whole Foods Market, Inc. attorney, uber-Washington, D.C. lawyer, and friend of the (Bill and Hillary) Clinton's Lanny Davis said in a statement late today. "How can you halt something that is already done?"

If the judge rules in the FTC's favor and orders Whole Foods to change the 100 or so stores back to the Wild Oats banner, stop any further integration of the few remaining stores, and to place what was Wild Oats in the hands of a "third party" as requested in the regulator's court filing today, it's our analysis that doing so would basically be the death of Whole Foods Market as you know it, a retailer that's already near death's door in so many ways.

Those ways include: a loss of income of about 42% in its last quarter; a drop in the value of Whole Foods Market, Inc. stock of about 75% in the last year; an ongoing erosion in sales, customer counts and store customer market basket purchase sizes because in the current, severe recession shoppers are trading down; and growing competition from discount-priced natural foods retailers like Sunflower Farmers Market, Sprouts Farmers Market and others, as well as increased competition from mass merchandisers like Wal-Mart, Costco and Target and supermarket chains, all increasingly selling natural and organic foods, in most cases for less than Whole Foods Market does.

We see the FTC's demands as both unrealistic -- the merger is near completed for heavens sake -- and draconian -- the financial cost of doing what the FTC is asking in this severe recession and financial/credit crisis environment amounts to basically wishing a bankruptcy filing on Whole Foods Market, Inc., or at best forcing the company to fire hundreds or even thousands of employees as a way to conserve cash; cash it will need to do the expensive things contained in the FTC's filing.

We don't like to make predictions but we must: Judge Friedman has shown himself to be a fair and even-handed judge throughout the FTC-Whole Foods legal saga since the summer of 2007 when the case was assigned to him. Therefore, it's our belief that the judge will deny all or most of the requests being made by the FTC. However, we think he might grant one, which is that Whole Foods cease any further integration of remaining Wild Oats stores into Whole Foods. But even doing that would be difficult. Why? there's no Wild Oats entity anymore. It exists essentially only in FTC world.

Of course, we could be wrong. And if we are, and if the judge were to rule completely in favor of the FTC on its filing today, we expect a drop in Whole Foods' stock share price that will be so dramatic that it could likely render the value of the retailer so low that its new, major stockholders -- supermarket industry magnate Ron Burkle, who like Lanny Davis is a BFF of the former first family (particularly Bill Clinton), and the private equity firm Leonard Green & Partners, L.P., get together and engineer some sort of an acquisition of Whole Foods Market, Inc.

Leonard Green & Partners acquired 17% of Whole Foods Market, Inc. for $425 million on December 2, 2008.

Legendary supermarket industry investor Ron Burkle, who as a major investor (he held an 18% stake in Wild Oats at the time of Whole Foods acquisition) and board member was the driving force from the Wild Oats corporate side behind the merger with Whole Foods in 2007, revealed in a filing with the Security and Exchange Commission last Thursday that his Yuciapa Companies investment firm, which counts among its investors the once poor-as-President but now multi-millionaire (thanks in part to Burkle's efforts on his behalf) former President Clinton, bought a 7% stake in Whole Foods Market, Inc.

Burkle, a billionaire, is an activist investor. He made his fortune over a two-decade period primarily by buying supermarket chains and combining them, resulting in his ultimate deal, which was the sale of his huge supermarket holding company to Kroger Co. in the 1990's for billions of dollars.

Private Equity firms like Leonard Green & Partners and activist shareholders like Ron Burkle (his Yuciapa Cos. is essentially a private equity firm) both play the same endgame -- they acquire stakes in company's, get involved in how those companies operate, and eventually look for an exit strategy that makes them a substantial profit. This most often involves a merger or acquisition.

Mark our words, with Leonard Green & Partners and Ron Burkle now holding a combined 24% ownership stake in Whole Foods Market, Inc., the natural foods grocery chain, whatever the outcome of the FTC legal case, will not end up being the same company a couple years from now (or in less time) than it has been historically or is today. After word got out on Thursday that Burkle took a 7% stake in Whole Foods, the natural grocer's stock shot up by 23% above its previous day's share price.

Meanwhile, FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc. continues. Stay tuned.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) Linkage:

>In this story [Retail Analysis Memo: Growth and A Tale of Two Retailers-Tesco and Whole Foods Market: Is One Ripe For Acquisition and the Other Ripe For Acquiring?] on August 16, 2008 we suggested Whole Foods Market, Inc. could (then) be ripe for an acquisition. Nearly five months later, and in much more dire straights, we think the probability is even higher that it is. The only limiting factor: Does anybody want Whole Foods in Today's economic climate? Not to mention it's little FTC problem as well.

>Linked below are a couple past stories from Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) about billionaire supermarket industry investor Ron Burkle:

~Food & Politics Memo: Billionaire Supermarket Industry Investor Ron Burkle Makes Millions For The Clinton's Post-Presidency

~Retail Memo: [Heard on the Street]: Will SuperValu, Inc. Be Supermarket Industry Investor Ron Burkle's Next Play

>More on Ron Burkle: Click here to read a piece from August, 2007 about Burkle and the Whole Foods-Wild Oats deal. As a note: NSFM has been the only publication we found to suggest in the past that we could see Burkle making a major investment in the combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats. He did just that on Thursday, January 9, 2009.

Supermarket chains v. Whole Foods: The FTC is so "1986" when it comes to understanding the food and grocery retailing industry in the U.S.:

>Our argument regarding why the FTC is wrong in its legal case in which it is claiming that a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats is a monopoly in what it calls the natural and organic premium retailing segment basically boils down to this: such a classification by the FTC is a fiction because it is irrelevant to the reality of the retailing of natural and organic products in the U.S. today in which retailers of all types and formats -- from Wal-Mart, Target, Costco, Safeway, Kroger Co., Trader Joe's, regional supermarket chains, independents and even Amazon.com, to fast-growing natural foods chains like Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Market and many others -- all are battling it out in the category arena.

In August, 2007 we wrote this piece [Will the Big 3 Supermarket Chains Challenge Whole Foods in its Niche? Our answer today: Yes, in the 17 months since we wrote the piece the "Big 3" have increased their merchandising in the natural and organic foods categories significantly. For example, at the end of 2008 sales of Safeway Stores' "O' Organics" organic products store brand was over $500 million in its 1750 supermarket in the U.S. and Canada. Four years ago the brand didn't even exist.

Additionally, on the market for just a bit over a year, Safeway's "Eating Right" healthy foods brand has over $200 million in annual sales. Such sales doesn't come only from new customers. Rather, most of it comes from stealing other retailers' and manufacturers brand sales. A significant share of these new stomachs for the Safeway brands comes from consumers who used to buy like products at Whole Foods Market stores.

More NSFM Linkage:

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo reported extensively on, wrote about and offered analysis on the FTC v. Whole Foods issue and related topics in December, 2008. Below is a linked bibliography of all of our December stories and posts:

December 29, 2008: Retail Memo - Breaking News: New Seasons Market Doesn't Turn Over Trade Secrets to Whole Foods Market Despite Deadline to Do So Being Today....December 29, 2008: Independent Grocer Memo: Natural-Organic, Local, Fresh and Premium Keys to Pacific Northwest USA's Haggen Foods; Now Adding Value....December 28, 2008: Retail Memo: Web Site and Blog-Driven Viral Boycott of Whole Foods Market Stores in Portland, Oregon Region Going On; Could it Intensify?....December 28, 2008: Retail Memo: Tomorrow Deadline For Portland, Oregon's New Seasons Market to Turn Over Trade Secrets to Whole Foods Market's Legal Counsel

December 24, 2008: Christmas Eve Memo 2008: 'Twas the Night Before Christmas' - FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc. Version....December 24, 2008: Independent Grocer Memo: From Mrs. Gooch's to the Auto Body Business, Then Back to Retail, Chris Kysar is On A Healthy Organic Foods Retailing Roll....December 24, 2008: Retail Memo: It's 'Deja Vu All Over Again' - Judge Paul Friedman to Whole Foods Market, FTC: 'What's My Role Here?'....December 23, 2008: Retail Memo: FTC Postpones Scheduled February 16 Administrative Hearing on Whole Foods-Wild Oats Deal Break-Up Until April 6, 2009....December 23, 2008: Independent Grocer Memo: National Grocers' Association Asks President-Elect Obama to Look Out For Independent Grocers When He takes Office in January....

December 22, 2008: Retail Memo: Only Slightly More Than Half the 93 Natural Foods Retailers Issued Subpoenas By Whole Foods in its Case against the FTC Have Complied.... December 22, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market Wants to Depose and Obtain Internal E-Mails From FTC Commissioner, Suggesting Possible Conflict of Interest Situation....December 22, 2008: Retail Memo: At Hearing Today Judge Tells FTC to Provide Road Map of How Whole Foods Could Take About Merged Companies Should Ruling Go In its Favor....December 19, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods' Lobbying Effort Baring More Fruit - House Committee Leaders Send Letter to FTC Chair Similar to One Sent By Senate Leaders....

December 18, 2008: Retail Memo: 'This Isn't Over Yet' - New Seasons Market CEO On Judge's Decision the Natural Gorcer Must Turn Over Trade Secrets to Whole Foods Market.... December 18, 2008: Retail Memo: The 'Whole Primary Source Scoop' -- FTC and U.S. Federal Court Documents on the FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc. Case....December 17, 2008: Breaking News: Judge Orders New Seasons Market to Comply With Whole Foods' Subpoena and Submit Sales Data, Financial Records and Other Trade Secrets....December 16, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods, Wild Oats and Boulder, CO...And the Rocky Mountain News' Editorial Take On FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc....

December, 15, 2008: Retail Memo: Eight Members of U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee Send Letter to FTC Chairman Regarding FTC's Legal Case Against Wild Oats' Acquisition....December, 13, 2008: Retail Memo - Analysis & Commentary: More On FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc. and Whole Foods Market, Inc. v. FTC....December 9, 2008: Organics Category Memo: Wither Organics? Organic Food & Grocery Category Sales Down; But Double-Digit Growth Still Likley With Mass Market Lift....December 9, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Markets' 'Whole Legal Paycheck:' Three Top Washington, D.C. Law Firms Teaming Up On The Natural Grocery Chain's FTC Lawsuit....

December 9, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market CEO John Mackey and Team Launch First Aggressive Attack Against the FTC's Legal Case at Press Conference This Morning....December 8, 2008: Retail Memo: Mr. Mackey (and the Whole Foods Market Troops) Goes to Washington....December 8, 2008: Retail Memo: Breaking News - Whole Foods Market, Inc. Files Lawsuit Against the FTC; Argues the Regulator Violated the Company's Due Process Rights....December 7, 2008: Retail Memo: New Seasons Market CEO Brian Rohter and Whole Foods Market Co-President Walter Robb Discuss and Debate the Subpoena Issue Online....

December 7, 2008: Retail Memo: New Seasons Market CEO Brian Rohter Speaks Out Again Today on the Whole Foods Market, Inc. Subpoena of His Company's Data....December 7, 2008:Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market Retains Top Washington D.C. lawyers and Politically-Connected Lobbyists to Plead its Case Against the FTC....December 6, 2008: Retail Memo: Fast-Growing and Scrappy Sunflower Farmers Market Ventures Deep in the Heart of (Whole Foods Country) Texas....December 6, 2008: Retail Memo: Fast-Growing NF Chain Sunflower Farmers Market Responds to Whole Foods Market, Inc. Subpoena For Sales, Financial and Related Information....

December 3, 2008: Retail Memo: More on the Whole Foods Market-New Seasons Market Subpoena Issue; FTC Holding Firm For February, 2009 Hearing....December 2, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market, Inc. Closes $425 Sale of Stock to Private Equity Firm; Adds Members of the Firm to its Board of Directors....December 2, 2008: Retail Memo: Portland, Oregon-Based New Seasons Market CEO Brian Rohter Responds to Whole Foods Market's Paige Brady....December 2, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods' Paige Brady Responds to Yesterday's New Seasons Market Piece; Lots of E-Mails; Issue Heats Up On the New Seasons Market Blog....December 1, 2008: Retail Memo: Whole Foods Wants A Court-Mandated Financial Records Dump from Portland-based New Seasons Market; it Says For its Battle Against the FTC.

FTC v. Whole Foods - Linkage from the Natural~Specialty Foods Memo archives:

Click here, here and here for stories about the FTC-Whole Foods issue from our archives, including pieces about mass market and natural foods class of trade retail competitors.

[Note: Natural~Specialty Foods Memo holds no Whole Foods Market, Inc. stock at present.]