Showing posts sorted by date for query Aldi USA. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Aldi USA. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Thursday, April 9, 2009

Small Format Food Retailing Memo - Design Innovation: Supermarket Design Firm Wins Award For Design of Independent 'The Market' Specialty Grocery


Design Services Group (DSG), the supermarket design firm owned by supermarket chain Supervalu, Inc. has won the 2009 Outstanding Merit Award from the Association for Retail Environments (A.R.E.) design association for its design work on the independently-owned small-format specialty and natural foods store "The Market" (pictured above), which is located in Plymouth, Massachusetts USA.

DSG won the prestigious Outstanding Merit award at the just-ended 2009 A.R.E. Retail Design Awards event at GlobalShop, held in Las Vegas.

The award recognizes excellence in retail store design, craftsmanship and innovation. This is the second time DSG has been awarded an A.R.E. Retail Design Award: it won a grocery store category award in 2006 for its design of "Highland Park Market" in Windsor, Conn.

The 13,500 square foot "The Market" is the creation of specialty and natural foods retailing veteran Michael Szathmary, who is the store's managing director, and his associates. Szathmary's 40 year retailing career includes having founded and launched the Nature’s Heartland grocery store and Szathmary’s market/cafes in Needham and Brookline, Massachusetts. [Related post - January 20, 2008: Retail Memo: Designing the 'Perfect' Small-Format Grocery Store in a 'Near-Perfect' Place.]

The store's manager is food retailing veteran Mark Guinasso. Guinasso been in the grocery business for over 30 years, with previous management positions at Purity Supreme, Western Beef Supermarkets, Walter’s Meat Market and Nature’s Heartland, where he worked closely with Michael Szathmary.

The fresh produce department (above), named "Farmers Market," at the small-format "The Market" store keeps with the store's overall design theme of showcasing fresh foods in a rustic setting modeled after a 19th century farmers' market.

This is how the owners and management of "The Market" describe the store's format and retailing approach: "We’re The Market. And we want to change the way you shop — for the better, quicker, healthier and happier. With fresh, locally grown foods in season, expert help and our everyday value pricing on the everyday conventional groceries you need . . . every day.Our name says it all: simple, direct, not too fancy — full of good things waiting to be discovered. In fact, we want to make shopping an experience you actually enjoy.

It begins with healthy, high-quality food: like locally grown, seasonal produce. Freshly baked artisan breads. A delectable deli. Certified Angus beef and naturally raised chicken. And fish right off the boat. Fresh is best.

We also offer a constantly changing array of specialty items created in our own kitchen by our own chef and team — in case you’re too busy or tired to cook. Just heat and serve.

Plus, we have experienced people who know their stuff and are ready to help you. Whether it’s catering a party of fifty or just carrying your bags to your car. We’ve made the aisles more convenient, the displays a little tastier. You can pick up a bouquet by Martin’s Flowers just next to our bakery. And we’ve opened a doorway to Long Ridge Wine & Spirits next door. We’ve even selected great music for you to shop by."

You can learn more about the small-format grocery store at its Web site here.

The Deli department (above) at the independently-owned, small-format "The Market" features scores of deli items and ready-to-heat and ready-to-eat fresh, prepared foods.

DSG's Architecture and Engineering department designed the interior of "The Market" the store, working closely with Elkus Manfredi Architects, a Boston firm that designed the exterior shell.

With only 13,500 square feet to work with, DSG store planners had to carefully account for every bit of available space. They settled on an open layout with relatively low shelves to give shoppers a broad view of the entire store from nearly every vantage point, the design firm says. The small-format store has the look of a country store of decades best with a modernistic twist.

The store's design philosophy, according to DSG, is to showcase fresh foods in a rustic setting modeled after a 19th century farmer's market.

"The Market" looks like a modernistic barn by design. An open floor plan directs customers from one department to the next, from the full-service cheese, deli, meat and seafood departments to the bake shop, seasonal and locally grown produce department, the prepared-food section, salad bar, dairy, frozen foods, chef’s cove and floral department, and then to the aisles of groceries.

The 13,500 square foot store features basically all of the departments a large supermarket offers: dry grocery, fresh produce, meat-seafood, deli-prepared foods, bakery, wine, cheese and the like, each designed to fit into the small-format footprint and limited store interior space.

The store has high arched ceilings which make it appear much larger than its 13,500 square feet.

The small-format store is in the Pinehills development in Plymouth, Massachusetts. "The Market" opened in September, 2008.

As Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) first declared in the summer of 2007, there's a small-format food and grocery store mini-revolution happening in the U.S. and in many other parts of the world. This includes chains like Aldi (Europe and U.S.), Lidle (Europe), Supervalu, Inc.'s Sav-A-Lot (U.S.), with there small-format, deep-discount grocery stores; Tesco (globally) with its mid-range small format stores like Tesco Express in Europe and Fresh & Easy in the Western U.S., along with Giant Eagle and its small-format Giant Eagle Express format; Safeway (its The Market format), Supervalue (Urban Fresh by Jewel), Wal-Mart (Marketside) and others in the USA (plus Waitrose and Sainsbury's in the UK) on the more upscale end, and numerous independents focusing on small-format stores, the original small-format grocers. Many other chains are playing in the small-format world as well, in the U.S. and internationally.

The current severe global economic recession has slowed down what in 2007 to mid-2008 was a very robust small-format revolution. But the fact is it has slowed down a ll new store development in the U.S. and globally considerably.

But despite the recession, small-format innovation continues.

And in the case of "The Market" in Plymouth, Massachusetts, it continues on an award winning pace.

[You can view "The Market" store's complete design project from DSG at the link below:
Download Project PDF (7790kb).]

[You can view a slide show of the store's interior here. There are links to photographs and information about other food stores designed by DSG at the site.

[Readers: You can follow Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on Twitter.com at www.twitter.com/nsfoodsmemo.]

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Retail Memo: The 'Whole Analysis' - Whole Foods Market Inc's First Quarter Financials, FTC v. Whole Foods...The Natural Grocer At Home and Abroad

Whole Foods Market's flagship store and corporate headquarters in Austin, Texas. [Photo Credit: Whole Foods Market, Inc.]

Whole Foods Market, Inc. reported its first quarter fiscal year sales and profits on Wednesday afternoon (February 18), after the financial markets closed. [You can view Whole Foods' detailed financial release at the link here: Whole Foods Market Reports First Quarter Results.]

The good news

Whole Foods' beat stock analysts estimates in terms of its Q1 profits, despite the fact the natural foods grocery chain's profit dropped by 17% during its first quarter, to $32.3 million, compared to $39.1 million for the same quarter last year. Overall Q1 revenue increased by $2.5 billion over last year's first quarter revenue.

As a result of beating analysts estimates, Whole Foods Market, Inc's stock soared by a whopping 34% in trading on Thursday and Friday, following Wednesday's report. That's a much needed boost for Whole Foods' stock since its per-share value had dropped by about 75% (from its 52-week high) prior to Wednesday.

The bad news

In addition to the 17% Q1 net income loss, Whole Foods Market, Inc. experienced for the first time in the company's history a quarterly drop in same-store sales. Sales at stores open for at least one year decreased by 4% in the first quarter. Same-store sales are an important industry indicator of a retailer's performance.

Whole Foods' senior management has found great pride, as it should, in the fact that same-store sales has increased every quarter, until now, for the natural foods grocery chain.

But in the current severe economic recession, it isn't a surprise to Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM), nor should it be to investors and industry observers, that Whole Foods Market, Inc. experienced the decrease in same-store sales in its first quarter. Having said that, this is something the natural grocer must reverse in the second quarter.

As we've previously reported, Whole Foods Market made a number of cost-cutting moves last summer, including laying off about 100 employees at its corporate headquarters in Austin, Texas, in hope that in the face of reduced sales it could stem its loses. It's likely that without those cost-reductions the natural and organic foods grocer would have shown poorer Q1 results.

During a conference call with analysts on Wednesday, Whole Foods said it has enacted a salary and hiring freeze going forward as a way to further cut costs.

In the conference call, Whole Foods' CEO John Mackey said the company is seeing early signs that increased sales, do largely to more aggressive pricing and promotions by the retailer, may be stemming the same-store sales decrease experienced in the first quarter. Of course, with the recession continuing to get deeper and worse, it's near-impossible what the next couple of months will bring for more upscale, specialty-oriented grocers like Whole Foods Market.

It's our analysis that Whole Foods still likely has some cutting to do because we believe, as do most experts and analysts, that the recession is going to get worse before it gets better, even with the $787 billion economic stimulus package signed by President Obama, and that the remainder of 2009 will see cash-strapped consumers continuing to trade-down in terms of shopping more at discount food retailers, along with spending less money overall on food and groceries because the plain just have less to spend.

We do see some positive signs, based on store visits and interviews and discussions with shoppers, that Whole Foods' new value emphasis, in which it has lowered some prices, is offering better promotions, including coupons, focusing more on basic items, along with featuring less expensive store brands more often, is beginning to bare some sales fruit at store-level.

FTC v. Whole Foods: The FTC-induced bad news

As Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) has been reporting on writing about regularly, Whole Foods Market, Inc. continues to battle the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) over the natural grocery chain's friendly 2007 acquisition of Wild Oats Market, Inc. At present, Whole Foods and the FTC are in negotiations over a possible settlement to the long and protracted FTC legal case against the deal.

The FTC has a halt of further legal proceedings in place until March 6, while the two parties are negotiating a possible settlement.

Should a settlement not be reached by then, the FTC will go forward with its legal challenge to the merger. The regulatory body has an April 6, 2009 date set to begin an Administrative trial in which an FTC Administrative Law Judge will hear arguments from Whole Foods and the FTC on the deal and rule on its outcome, which could include an order to break-up the now nearly-100% merged grocery chains.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. reported Wednesday that it spent a whopping $11 million in the first quarter alone on legal costs related to fighting the FTC challenge to the merger. This $11 million is a significant contributor to the natural and organic grocer's 17% income loss in Q1.

Since it's our argument that the FTC is wrong in its argument and legal case that a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats represents a monopoly in 29 U.S. markets, in what the regulator calls the "premium natural and organic retailing segment (PNOS),"we strongly suggest this $11 million expense was an unnecessary one for Whole Foods. In fact, were we an investor in Whole Foods Market, Inc., we would protest the FTC's continued legal challenge to the merger to the President and Congress, arguing that doing so by the FTC is a misuse of taxpayer funds.

Because of the serious challenges Whole Foods is facing due in large part to the the bad economy, along with increased competition from other natural foods class of trade retailers, supermarket chains moving increasingly into the natural and organic products space, and discounters like Wal-Mart, Costco, Target, Trader Joe's and others, it could have used that $11 million for promotional and other merchandising purposes rather than having to spend it on legal counsel.

After all, do Whole Foods' first quarter financials look to any reasonable person reading them like the sales and income numbers of a retailer that holds a monopoly in any so called segment of the U.S. food and grocery retailing industry?

We think not. And just because the company's stock soared by 34% on Thursday and Friday, that means very little in the medium-to-long run. Wall Street plays the expectations game. Whole Foods Market's Q1 numbers were much better than many analysts thought they would be. Therefore, the natural and organic grocer's having beat these estimates, the stock soared. Remember, what goes up, particularly in the stock market, also comes down -- and often times nearly as rapidly as it went up. Investors also were looking hard for companies to invest in last week, which helped fuel a flight of cash into Whole Foods' stock.

It's our analysis and opinion that the FTC case against Whole Foods Market, Inc. has actually become an economically punishing one for the company and its shareholders. This at a time when the federal government is spending hundreds of billions of dollars of taxpayer money to keep companies in other industries -- financial services, automobile manufacturing -- alive.

General Motors is now asking Congress and President Obama for another $21 million and Chrysler, which is majority-owned by the Cerebus private equity firm (about 80% ownership) is asking for an additional $5 billion.

Meanwhile, an agency of this very same government, the FTC, is prosecuting a legal battle against Whole Foods Market, Inc. that cost the retailer and its investors $11 million in the first quarter, millions more before that, and possibly million more in the next couple months unless a settlement is reached with the FTC.

This is just wrong. The FTC argument is folly, in our analysis. And at a time when the federal government is bailing out a host of companies, it is doubly-wrong that the FTC is pursuing a course of action that is significantly contributing to severe struggles by Whole Foods Market, Inc., as well as costing its investors money.

There is some indication our argument, and those of others, has sunk into the heads of some of the FTC Commissioners -- and we hope it has -- which could be one of the reasons they've decided to work towards a settlement agreement with Whole Foods.

The 'whole' conference call

There were a number of other announcements and points of information of interest during the analysts' conference call with Whole Foods on Wednesday. Below is a summary of those key points of interest as stated in the conference call by the company's senior executives:

~"Although transaction count and basket count are still down, the decline in transaction count has improved slightly. While it is obviously still too early to say our sales are stabilizing, we (Whole Foods) are encouraged by these trends."

~"Competition continues to be a factor as retailers fight over fewer food dollars being spent. Cannibalization also remains a factor, but to a lesser degree."

~"Whole Foods Market private label SKU count increased 11% year-over-year, accounting for 22% of our total grocery and Whole Body sales."

~"We (Whole Foods) plan to roll out a 5-Step Animal Welfare Rating system beginning in our United States stores later this year."

~"We (Whole Foods) reduced our planned new store openings by 50% for fiscal year 2009 to 15 from a prior range of 25 to 30. We terminated 11 leases in development, totaling approximately 570,000 sq ft, and down-sized nine leases by an average of 10,000 sq ft each."

~"We (Whole Foods) spent a lot of time in Q1 really focusing on values especially in produce, meat and seafood. And we've seen a lot of very good reaction to our promotions that we've done in those areas."

~"We (Whole Foods) believe the long-term growth and return potential in the United Kingdom is much greater than Canada, and we're taking some proactive steps to improve our operations there."

Whole Foods United Kingdom

This last point about Whole Foods Market's favoring the long-term growth and return potential in the United Kingdom over that in Canada (those are the only two international markets the company operates in outside the U.S.) is extremely interesting.

During the conference call Whole Foods' said it is breaking up its UK stores into separate geographical regions, similar to what it does in the U.S. That shouldn't be too hard a task at present since all of its UK stores are located in London, England.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. currently operates five stores in the UK, all in London, England, as mentioned above. Only one of the five stores, its nearly 80,000 square foot natural-organic and premium food emporium in the huge The Barkers Building on 63-97 Kensington High Street in London, has operated under the Whole Foods banner since it was opened, which was in 2007. The other four London stores have operated under the Fresh & Wild banner. Fresh & Wild was a small, UK-based natural products chain Whole Foods Market, Inc. acquired a few years ago.

Whole Foods is in the process of changing the name of the remaining Fresh & Wild banner stores to its Whole Foods banner, so that all of its UK (read just London for now) stores operate under the same banner -- Whole Foods. The rebranding is set to be completed by the end of this month. [You can view a list of Whole Foods' UK-London stores here.]

The nearly 80,000 square foot Kensington High Street Whole Foods banner store the retailer opened about two years ago has been a struggle for the natural grocery chain. During its first year of operation, 2007, the aisles of the huge market were almost always empty. However, beginning towards about the end of the first quarter in 2008, business started to pick up considerably at the market, after Whole Foods made a number of changes to the store, along with initiating more aggressive promotions and other merchandising and marketing initiatives.

But beginning in about October of last year, business dropped at the upscale store, as it began doing at most all of Britain's premium and natural foods-focused food stores because of the financial-credit crisis and deepening of the global economic recession. The struggle in the down UK economy continues for the Kensington High Street Whole Foods, as it does for other natural grocers and upscale UK supermarket chains like Waitrose and Marks & Spencer.

Like in the U.S. at present, British consumers are flocking to discount stores where they can save money on their food and grocery purchases. The fastest-growing food retailer in the UK in terms of sales and market share growth over the last year has been Aldi-UK, the British division of the global small-format, hard-discount Aldi International chain, which is based in Germany.

Aldi's U.S. division, Aldi USA, which operates almost 1,000 small-format, hard-discount stores in the U.S., also has seen a dramatic increase in business during the recession. It's growing fast and plans to open 100 new stores in the U.S. this year, including moving into the new markets of New York and Texas, where Whole Foods market is based. Aldi USA also moved into Florida for the first time in late 2008.

Aldi-UK is increasingly (more so than Aldi USA) offering natural, organic, specialty and premium food and grocery products in its UK stores, in most cases under one or more of its various store brands. These items sell for 15% -to- 30% less everyday than comparable items at UK natural foods stores and upscale supermarkets like Waitrose. As a result, Aldi-UK is taking some share away from these format stores in the natural and specialty categories just like it's taking share away from leading UK supermarket chain Tesco in the basic food and grocery segment.

During the Wednesday conference call, Whole Foods Market, Inc. CEO John Mackey said the natural foods chain has determined that the nearly 80,000 square-foot Kensington High Street Whole Foods store is just plain too big, which he said is the primary reason for its struggles in the UK. Mr. Mackey announced that going forward, any new Whole Foods stores opened in the UK would be in the 20,000 square foot range, which by UK standards is still a good-sized food store.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) reported and detailed last year in this March 4, 2008 piece [Retail Memo: Whole Foods Market to Dramatically Expand in the United Kingdom; Will Open Up To 30 New Stores in the U.S. in Fiscal 2009] how at the time Whole Foods Market was aggressively looking for new store sites in the UK, particularly in and around London. Those store locations-sites were closer to the nearly-80,000 square-foot size rather than the 20,000 square foot model the natural grocer now says it will follow in the UK. (Note to the March, 2008 linked piece. As we've reported since, Whole Foods Market reduced the number of planned new stores to about 15 for this year. Another cost-cutting move.)

But Whole Foods' aggressive search for new store locations in the UK has cooled dramatically in the current recessionary climate. As far as we are aware, the natural-organic grocer has no new UK store openings planned for 2009.

Further, we aren't sure a UK growth strategy, even long-term, is a good one for Whole Foods. The UK, particularly Britain, and especially England, is a very retailer brand loyal market. For example, just four grocery chains -- Tesco, Wal-Mart-owned Asda, Sainsbury's and Morrisons -- control a whopping 73%-75% of the total food and grocery sales market share.

If you add in the Cooperative Group chain, which last year acquired the Somerfield supermarket chain, making the Co-op the UK's fifth-largest grocer after number four Morrisons (Tesco is number one, Asda number two, Sainsbury's number three), the five chains control about 82% of all grocery sales in the country. All also sell plenty of natural, organic and specialty-premium food products.

There is room for niche players, such as upscale Waitrose and Marks & Spencer, which combined control about 9% of the remaining 18% of share in the nation -- that leaves about 9% for everybody else, and about half of that 18% is controlled by the UK hard-discount grocers Aldi, Lidl, Iceland and Netto -- but it's a tiny niche. And, there are numerous UK-based natural products retailers, such as Boots and others, filling a big part of that tiny niche.

Whole Foods could make it in the UK -- but not without spending a considerable amount of money on marketing and advertising, in our analysis. And the retailer needs to do a much better job of adapting to the British style of food retailing to do so. However, in its quarterly financial report, Whole Foods said its UK operations were a major contributor to the company's overall income loss, which isn't a good sign going forward right now.

And even if Whole Foods can do well in the UK down the road, one has to ask at what level? In other words, can the UK really contribute a significant amount of sales and profits to Whole Foods Market, Inc. over the next five, or even ten years, to make it worth the effort? The jury of course is out on that -- but we think it is something worth looking at closely by Whole Foods in its strategic planning process.

Whole Foods Canada

Last month we heard a rumor that Whole Foods Market, Inc. could be considering selling its stores in Canada, assuming of course it could find a buyer in the current frozen credit market. We have been unable to substantiate such rumors to date.

The conference call comments by CEO John Mackey -- that the UK holds far more long term promise for the natural foods grocery chain than Canada does -- are interesting ones though in light of those rumors.

The reason this is interesting -- and it is based on deductive reasoning and not source information -- is because Whole Foods has historically been a growth-based retailer in all of its markets. Therefore if it believes Canada holds minimal long-term growth potential then selling the stores there might make good sense. The natural-organic grocer could then use the cash from such a sale to grow the business in the UK and for other purposes.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. currently operates six stores in Canada. Four of the stores are located in Vancouver, British Columbia. The other two stores are in Ontario; one in Toronto and the other in Oakville. [Click here for a list of the Canada stores.]

With only six stores in the entire country of Canada, and in only two market regions (Vancouver and Ontario) to boot, Whole Foods' really can't make much of an impact in the country at present. And, based on the conference call comments, it doesn't sound like any additional stores are planned in Canada in the near or even medium-to-long term. Therefore, selling the stores starts to make even better sense.

One likely candidate, should Whole Foods decide to sell its stores in Canada, would be Canadian natural products retailer Planet Organic, Inc. Planet Organic has been growing fiarly rapidly in Canada and even entered U.S. natural foods retailing in 2008 when it acquired the Mrs. Green's chain of 11 natural foods stores based in upstate New York.

However, Planet Organic had to back out of a deal to acquire Santa Cruz, California-based New Leaf Natural Markets last year because it couldn't raise the about $15 million needed to do the deal. Planet Organic had floated a new stock offering on the Vancouver stock exchange for about that amount, which it was planning to use to make the acquisition, but decided to pull the offer because of the financial-credit crisis and the related drying up of investment capital, after it determined there wasn't an investor appetite for the new offering by the company.

But, since the Whole Foods stores are right in Planet Organic's backyard -- it just might be better able to find the money should the Austin, Texas-based natural foods grocery chain decide to unload its stores in British Columbia and Ontario, Canada.

FTC v. Whole Foods settlement deal

Meanwhile, Whole Foods Market, Inc. needs to come to a settlement agreement with the FTC so that it can get back to focusing on what it does best, merchandising and selling natural, organic and premium food and grocery products, rather than fighting legal battles. It also needs to reach a settlement, assuming one that's not to devistating to its acquisition of Wild oats, so that it can stop burning cash paying for legal fees related to the legal case.

We say this, that a settlement deal needs to be reached between Whole Foods and the FTC, despite the fact we believe the FTC's case is pure folly.

At this point though, reaching a decent settlement deal is far better for Whole Foods Market, Inc. than continuing to have to fight the FTC in court, the end result of which could be a break-up of the now combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats, which at this point in Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s nearly 100% integration of Wild Oats could be a very costly process and end result.

Monday, February 16, 2009

Food Retailing, Society & Economics Memo: UK E-Commerce Salvage Grocer 'Approved Food' Sees Sales Boom As Shoppers Favor Saving Cash Over Code Dates


Food & Grocery Retailing in the Global Recession

The United Kingdom's (UK) "Approved Food & Drink" is an online, e-commerce grocery store and home delivery service with a unique twist. That unique twist is that unlike the e-commerce shopping and delivery operations of leading UK food retailers such as Tesco, Wal-Mart-owned Asda or the online-only grocery and delivery service Ocado, at which consumers order the same types of food and grocery products featured in supermarkets and then receive home delivery, "Approved Food & Drink" specializes strictly in closeout items and non-perishable food, grocery and beverage products that are either near or recently past the products' "best buy" code dates.

The online salvage grocer offers food and grocery products ranging from major global brands like Nestle, Heinz, Coca-Cola and Pepsi, to natural, organic, specialty and gourmet products, including iconic British specialty brands like Walkers, Marmite, Bovril and most others. "Approved Food," as it is called for short, offers the items at about 20% -to- 60% less than non-salvage items offered in UK supermarkets.

"Approved Food & Drink" is similar to what are commonly referred to in the United States as salvage grocers or close-out supermarkets -- accept it is an online operation, as well as the sister to a brick-and-mortar operation. These U.S. salvage grocers are brick-and-mortar retailers, such as the California-based Grocery Outlet chain and others like it, along with numerous independents located throughout the county, that specialize in selling "short-coded" goods, as well as manufacturer's overstocks and products with slightly blemished or mislabeled packaging. They sometimes are referred to as "Scratch & Dent" grocers.

The code-busting online salvage grocery store sells overstocks and blemished food and grocery products as well. But is specializes in the "short coded" and even past-"best buy" code date products.

Most salvage brick-and-mortar grocers in the U.S. don't sell food and grocery products that are past the "best buy" code dates, generally pulling any of the expired goods from the shelves and displays once they are past the date on the package. [We aren't aware of an online salvage grocer in the U.S. comparable to the UK's "Approved Food & Drink." If you are, let us know.]

The UK's "Approved Food" actually has an affiliation with a British version of a brick-and-mortar salvage grocer. The e-commerce grocer is the online division of Crag's Cash & Carry, a UK brick-and-mortar food and grocery wholesaler and retailer of salvage groceries and near and past-"best buy" code date expired goods. [You can learn more about Crags's Cash & Carry at its Web site here. You can learn more about "Approved Food & Drink's" philosophy at its e-commerce site here.]

Differing industry practices, differing social norms

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) readers not familiar with the norms and practices of food and grocery retailing in the UK might find the notion of an e-commerce grocer specializing in the selling of goods near, and particularly past the "best buy" package code dates bizarre.

However, the practice of marking down both fresh and shelf-stable packaged foods on a daily basis is a common one among UK supermarkets. Fresh foods like meats, produce and baked goods get marked down each day in UK food stores, often by as much as 50%. The same is the case with non--perishable, packaged food and grocery products. As the packaged goods items near their "best buy" code date, the grocers mark them down as a way to sell them and "salvage" some economic value on the items, as a regular practice.

In the U.S. supermarkets do some mark downs, particularly on fresh category items like meats, bakery and produce. But it's generally done on an ad-hoc and store-by-store (and even store department-by-department) basis rather than as a common industry practice, as it is in the UK. Some U.S. supermarkets also mark down shelf-stable grocery items, but generally only when a particular items is being discontinued, and often not even then.

The practice of marking down non-perishable packaged goods by U.S. supermarkets as a matter of policy is nearly non-existent. Instead, such items, as well as most all perishable products, are donated to food banks or food pantries (or thrown away) when they near their "best buy" expiration code dates rather then being marked-down. Some U.S. chains even have a company policy against stores doing any product markdowns at all.

Part of the reason the U.S. supermarket industry doesn't do markdowns on a systematic basis, as is the case in the UK, has to do with U.S. food safety laws. Retailers in the U.S. generally fear lawsuits if they sell food and grocery items that are close to or near the package expiration date.

Another reason has to do with the cost of labor. U.S. supermarket chains, many of which are unionized and pay a premium hourly wage, generally don't believe the benefit of having store employees devote time (and the company's money) to marking down products pays off in terms of the reduced profits and outright loss of profit that the sales of such products bring, particularly once the labor cost is factored in. As such, they prefer to donate the goods to food banks right from the start.

Additionally, most U.S. consumers, unlike most UK consumers, have a less liberal attitude towards buying goods near their expiration date, and an even stronger attitude against purchasing those past the expiration date. Although in the current recession that is changing as business at U.S. salvage grocers, those that sell near expired code date goods as well as the closeouts, is up considerably, as shoppers search for bargains.

So there are cultural differences between UK and U.S. consumers that account in part for the differences in the two countries regarding the practice of supermarket industry mark-downs. We think in the UK the severe food shortages the nation experienced for many years during two World Wars accounts in large part for the mark-down system in that country -- the concept that wasting food is culturally (and economically) wrong.

The U.S. also suffered some food shortages and had rationing during World War II, for example, but it wasn't as near-severe as what the UK experienced.

We think the two allied nations came out of that experience with different points of view. Two generations of UK consumers (post World War I and World War II) came out of the war experience stressing the relative importance of not wasting food, hence in part the adoption by the UK supermarket industry of the mark-down system, focused as the nation was on the severe shortages of food over a long period of time.

In contrast, the U.S. came out of the war experiences with an attitude of abundance, that the country would produce more food than it needed, which it has, and that food waste was a part of that abundance rather than something to be concerned with in an serious way. As a result, the concept of daily markdowns never caught on within the mainstream U.S. supermarket industry.

An additional reason for this cultural and industry difference we believe is the simple fact that the U.S. grows and produces so much food. It need not import any food if it chose as a matter of policy not to. On the other hand, although the UK produces a great amount of food for such a geographically small nation, it isn't able to be a self-producing nation like the U.S. is under current demand conditions.

None of this is to suggest food isn't wasted in the UK, as it is in the U.S. According to statistics publish by the British government, it's estimated that UK consumers throw away about 4.1 tons of food each year after they purchase it at the supermarket. That's lots of food waste for the population of the UK. What we are saying is that food and grocery items go through a formal, industry-wide step in the UK, the markdown process at the supermarket, that doesn't systematically occur at U.S. supermarkets and other food stores.

There is one exception to this rule though. UK-based Tesco, which operates about 111 small-format Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market grocery and fresh foods stores in Southern California, Nevada and Arizona in the Western U.S., has brought the UK supermarket industry's "mark-down" process with it across the pond to America.

As part of the retailer's policy, Fresh & Easy store employees mark down near-expired fresh foods -- bakery, produce, meat, prepared foods -- each day, reducing the retail prices from about 20% -to- 50%, depending on how close to its expiration date the product is and how fast they want to move it. The stores regularly do the same thing with shelf-stable food and grocery products nearing their expiration dates. We haven't seen the Fresh & Easy stores selling any items that are past their "best buy" dates however.

Business appears to be booming at 'Approved Food'

The brief explanation of the markdown process and practice in the UK supermarket industry better helps explain the "Approved Foods'" business model, we think. We also think it demonstrates the model's potential to do well, particularly in bad economic times like the present.

The e-commerce, home delivery-based salvage grocery store was doing a steady but not earth shattering business until about September-October of 2008, when the financial-credit crisis and economic recession began to get severe in the UK, as it did in the U.S. and elsewhere throughout the world.

Along about that time the volume of orders to the Web site started to pick-up considerably. "Approved Food & Drink" says it's experienced an about ten-fold increase in business since September-October, 2008. And over the last few months that volume has kicked-up even higher. So much so in fact that on February 4 the online salvage grocer put a notice on the front page of its Web site in red font saying this:

Important information:

Due to the large number of orders that we continue to receive, there is a temporary backlog of about a week.

For those who plan to place an order with us we would like you to be aware of this delay for the time being.

The store is open daily for local customers who may wish to shop in person.

We ask for you to continue to be patient over this period whilst we work around the clock, literally, to ensure orders are sent out to you ASAP.

Thank you all for your support, especially Martin Lewis and all the Money Saving Experts at www.moneysavingexpert.com

Please visit Approved Foods again and feel free to register for our newsletter.

Regards
The Approved Food Team

[Click here to view the Web site front page.]

The e-commerce-based salvage grocer also has been so busy of late it has at times closed down for a day or two in order to catch up on its back orders, pulling workers from various parts of the operation to help fill the customer order backlog.

Additionally, "Approved Food" has recently put a notice on its Web site to UK-based food and grocery suppliers and supermarkets, letting them know it's looking to buy large quantities of closeout products as well as food and grocery items with short expiration "best buy" code dates.

In the UK, as in the U.S., the code dates don't mean the product has spoiled. Rather the dates mean just what they say -- that the product is "best" if purchased by that date. That's the legal definition in both countries.

Food retailing, economics and society

How people obtain their food and where they shop for it is a psychological, anthropological and social phenomenon as well as an economic one. But economics is arguably the most significant determinant of how and where most consumers get and buy the food they eat in bad economic times like the present. This is a cross-cultural and cross-societal phenomenon as well.

For example, in both the U.S. and UK the sales of fruit and vegetable seeds and plants are up considerably over about the last six months to a year. Numerous retailers are reporting sales of the fruit and veggie seeds and seedlings at the highest levels they've ever seen. Increasing numbers of consumers are taking to home gardening as a way to grow some of their own food and thus save money.

At retail, there's a significant shift going on from consumers shopping at higher-end and mid-range supermarkets, to discount food retailers.

In the U.S., chains like discounter Wal-Mart and Aldi USA (the U.S. division of Germany-based Aldi International) are doing well, for example. In terms of growth, both chains recently announced plans to open numerous new stores this year, and are even pushing into new market regions, while numerous higher-end and mid-range supermarket chains are struggling, postponing new store openings, in some cases closing stores, and even in a couple instances beginning to layoff employees. One of those examples is the privately-held Bashas chain in Arizona. Bashas, which operates about 159 supermarkets in Arizona, laid off 300 employees, or about 3% of its total workforce, last week, saying in a company statement that it had to do so because of the economic recession and increased competition in the Arizona market.

Wal-Mart said this week in a statement it plans to open about 125-145 new stores at home in the U.S. in 2009. The global retailer just acquired a food and grocery chain in Chile, is expanding its Asda chain in the UK, and is pushing into Russia, as well as growing its joint-venture retail operations in India, among other growth plans plans.

Germany-based Aldi International announced recently it plans to open about 100 new stores this year (on top of the about 1,000 it currently operates) in the U.S., and nearly that many new stores in the UK in 2009. Aldi USA also is moving into New York and Texas this year, two brand new markets for the small-format, hard-discount grocery chain. Aldi USA entered the Florida market for the first time in late 2008, as well.

The same is the case in the UK. Hard-discounters Aldi-UK and Lidl (also a German small-format, hard-discount grocery chain) are picking up market share largely at the expense of British chains like Tesco, Waitrose, Marks & Spencer and Sainsbury's. Wal-Mart's discount-focused Asda supermarket chain also is picking up share in the UK in the recession as it cut and continues to cut prices considerably.

Further, the use of manufacturers "cents off" coupons is at about an all-time high in usage among consumers in the U.S. and the UK, which is another indicator of how shoppers are striving to save even pennies at the supermarket in these tough economic times.

In the away-from-home eating space, global fast food chain MacDonald's is having one of its best years in recent times due largely to its low-price model, and recently announced it plans to open about 1,000 new stores globally this year. Meanwhile, higher-end and even mid-range restaurants are struggling as consumers throughout the world have cut back on meals eaten away from home.

It's in this recessionary socio-economic environment in which the UK's "Approved Food & Drink" is finding its business of selling salvage groceries, including those items with near-expired and even expired "best buy" dates, apparently booming.

It's all part of a new trend we've been observing among consumers that we call the "new frugality." It's a new frugality created primarily out of need (economic) rather than out of desire or choice. But it's a reality, despite the primary motivating cause. And from a historical perspective it isn't anything new. It's just new in the era of consumption.

It's also our analysis and view that this "new frugality" could last long after the recession ends because in prolonged periods of economic struggle like this one looks to be such new behavior patterns like frugality and searching out discounts tend to take stronger hold in terms of consumer behavior.

This changing consumer behavior is currently reshaping food and grocery retailing in numerous ways. The majority of those ways have to do with retailers of all formats having to more strongly and aggressively compete against one another other for fewer food dollars and among more tight-fisted shoppers, and as a result having to lowering prices, offer stronger promotions, and cut expenses to the bone.

Meanwhile, alternative format retailers like UK e-commerce salvage grocer "Approved Food & Drink," and the numerous brick-and-mortar salvage grocers in the U.S., are taking a greater piece of that food dollar pie as consumers seek out stores (and e-commerce grocers) where they can get more for their money (perceived or real) -- even if the food and grocery products happen to have nearly-expired or expired "best buy" code dates. And this phenomenon in turn adds an additional element to the ongoing reshaping of food and grocery retailing in these recessionary times.


Friday, December 19, 2008

Marketing Memo - USA: Meet the New 'Middle-Age Simplifiers,' For These Affluent Consumers Less Will Be More Says Harvard Business School Professor

The New Consumer Minimalism

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has been arguing for many months that upscale food and grocery retailers -- including supermarkets, specialty retailers and premium-oriented natural foods reatilers like Whole Foods Market and others -- must focus on creating, implementing and aggressively communicating value-based retailing propositions during the current, severe economic recession, which we believe will last all of next year, and is going to get worse before it gets better between now and the end of 2009, if it ends then.

We've also offered this same analysis to premium specialty and natural/organic products brand suppliers and marketers in the natural-specialty foods space. Even if they sell specialty and organic brands geared to higher income consumers, value is King in these times, we've argued -- and still do.

By value we certainly mean price -- as low as is possible. But we mean more than that. By a "value proposition" we mean the creation of a marketing strategy (a set of things) that offers consumers a reason to purchase higher priced specialty and organic food and grocery items because doing so, at a decent price, offers value in the ways of good quality (such as nutrition, safety, ect.) combined with an afforable price, along with providing other "value" benefits.

For retailers in the segment it means cutting margins a bit to create a better everyday price profile in their stores. It also means buying smarter; including negotiating more and deeper deals and reflecting that savings at retail to consumers. It also means more solution selling, along with a focus more on specialty-oriented and organic product basics (oils, grains and condiments rather than packaged organic ready-meals, for example) rather than fancy niche items. It even matters how the stores are designed -- too fancy is a turn off; minimal could be in.

Most recently we've been arguing that if the current recession lasts as long and becomes as deep as we think it will, it's likley we could see some long-term changes in consumer behavior in the food and grocery product categories in the natural/organic and specialty segments. These changes could take the form of simplification -- consumers buying considerably fewer higher margin, value-added processed and prepared foods items for example in favor of more ingredient-oriented ones. Back to basics.

We are already seeing this as consumers cook more at home and not only buy more basic items, seeking the best available prices on them, but also are buying less in terms of total weekly grocery purchases. Less is more -- out of economic neccessity. They also are using coupons in record numbers, cheery-picking store weekly ads for bargains and buying items much more often in bulk form.

Harvard Business School marketing professor John Quench argues we're already seeing long- term changes in consumers, particularly in a consumer segment he calls the "middle-aged simplifiers." (His focus is in the United States.) These "new consumers" are the ones who most frequently shop at Whole Foods Market and other upscale chains. They are folks with plenty of money and plenty of education -- the folks who've been driving the U.S. consumer economy for many years.

Professor Quench argues that's over. He says the new, "middle-aged simplifier" "finds herself surrounded by too much stuff acquired. She is increasingly skeptical in the face of a financial meltdown that it was all worth the effort. Out will go luxury purchases, conspicuous consumption, and a trophy culture. Tomorrow's consumer will buy more ephemeral, less cluttering stuff: fleeting, but expensive, experiences, not heavy goods for the home," he says.

While these new consumers still have to eat -- and shop for and buy food and groceries (although it can be done online as well as in person, and that might become a "simple solution") -- its likely, if the professor is correct, they will adapt their new, simplified consumer lifestyle to food and grocery shopping as well as all else.

Lavish food emporiums like Whole Foods' mega-premium organic markets and H-E-B's uber-gourmet Central Market (and those of many other retailers) stores could be out, in favor of no frills, small-format minimalist markets like Sav-A-Lot or Aldi perhaps, as well as the more minimalist natural foods stores like those operated by fast-growing Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Market, for example. Or, perhaps, the Whole Foods' of the U.S. will adapt and create that value proposition, if the professor is right about the extent of this new, "middle-age simplifier" consumer cohort.

Professor Quench argues his point in a recent essay, "How Recession Will Accelerate Consumer Downsizing," first published in his "Marketing KnowHow" Blog. The thrust of his focus and examples are mostly on premium and luxury consumer durable goods. However, make no mistake about it, if his prognostications are correct, this new, emerging consumer segment could have a profound change on the food and grocery segments in the areas of marketing and retailing.

And like all new consumer trends, this one too offers opportunity to the natural and specialty foods industry.

For example, quality-oriented natural and specialty food and grocery products with minimalistic features could be big with such consumers under the professor's scenario.

In addition, minimal yet attractive specialty supermarkets and natural foods stores that emphasis quality but not conspicuous consumption could be the ticket? (Time to read Thorstein Veblen if you haven't before or re-read him if it's been a while)

The key as always is to capitalize on a new consumer segment and trend in an honest and real way by offering true value and something consumers want to buy and consume regularly -- and in the case of food stores, shop in regularly. Adapt to thrive is always a good mantra. Natural~Specialty Foods Memo believes a new era of consumer minimalism is being ushered in by the current recession.

Below is professor Quench's essay:

How Recession Will Accelerate Consumer Downsizing
By John Quench
Professor of Marketing, Harvard Business School

Watch out for a new brand of consumer in 2008: the middle-aged Simplifier. She finds herself surrounded by too much stuff acquired. She is increasingly skeptical in the face of a financial meltdown that it was all worth the effort. Out will go luxury purchases, conspicuous consumption, and a trophy culture. Tomorrow's consumer will buy more ephemeral, less cluttering stuff: fleeting, but expensive, experiences, not heavy goods for the home.

The economic boom of the 1990s fuelled consumption and democratized access to a wider than ever spectrum of goods transforming former luxuries into "must-have" necessities. Millions played the lotteries or aspired to what they viewed on "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous". As they grew richer, pressure increased on those below to trade up. And, as they traded up, pressure increased in turn on the well-off to buy even more--the second home, the big screen TV and the latest sport-utility vehicle. Enter the big houses that measured success in thousands of square feet of floor space, topped by the 40,000 square feet, $50m palace that Bill Gates has built outside Seattle. In 2006, 35% of new homes exceeded 2,400 square feet in floor space compared with 18% in 1986. Ironically, these mansions, many owned by business people on the road half the time, grew in number as the size of the average American household declined.

These huge houses had to be filled with more stuff, good news for the home-appliance and home-furnishing industries. Even grocery manufacturers benefited. Larger homes with bigger refrigerators can absorb more inventory. Flat birth rates in developed economies have put pressure on durable consumer-goods companies desperate for top-line growth. Product quality improvements mean these goods break down less often. So durable-goods sales depend on two things: the launch of new, higher-priced, higher-featured, often customized products that persuade consumers to trade in their existing appliances before they break down (think cell phones), as well as household penetration of products such as fax machines and printers previously used only by businesses.

As the world economy slumps, one consumer segment will grow faster than ever. The Simplifiers have four characteristics.

First, they perceive that they have more stuff than they need. Sure, they may collect something specific like porcelain figurines as a hobby, but they are the opposite of the pack rats who fill their attics and basements with "you-never-know-when-you-might-need-it" stuff.

Second, they want to collect experiences, not possessions. And they give experiences rather than goods as gifts to friends and relatives. Experiences may seem ephemeral. They cannot be inventoried except in the form of "Kodak" moments; but they do not tie you down, require no maintenance, and permit variety-seeking instincts to be quickly satisfied. Dining out, foreign travel, learning a new sport will prove more resilient than expected in the face of recession.

Third, their stuff embarrasses them. Their Range Rovers no longer tell the world that they are sophisticated town and country socialites. There are simply too many of them on the road to offer much social status. Worse, they now signal the irresponsible selection of a gas-guzzler.

Fourth, they have wealth that is so assured that it no longer requires conspicuous display. They lease their cars, rent other people's holiday homes, and would happily outsource other aspects of their lifestyles. They reject the marketer's continual pressure to spend more money on possessions rather than on education, health care, and other social goods.

These are the consumers who are now trading in their sport-utility vehicles. They include the empty-nester baby-boomers, less confident than before, who are tired of heating unused spaces in cavernous mansions, now preferring smaller houses with architectural character and intimate spaces, more charm and less maintenance. Their families are scattered, unable to share conveniently the family holiday home and often unwilling to inherit the burden of something they will never use. The new economy has made it even easier for consumers to get rid of their stuff. The high-tech equivalents of the yard sale, electronic auction sites, bring Simplifiers together with those who are yet to catch the habit.

This growing segment of Simplifiers presents a challenge to marketers. These are well-off people who value quality over quantity and do not buy proportionately more goods as their net worth increases. Their increasing reluctance to consume will dampen expected demand growth in developed economies further and therefore slow economic recovery, requiring consumer-goods multinationals to further focus their efforts on emerging markets where stuff will still be king.

Saturday, December 13, 2008

Retail Memo - Analysis & Commentary: More On FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc. and Whole Foods Market, Inc. v. FTC

Whole Foods' CEO John Mackey announces the natural grocery chain's lawsuit against the FTC at a press conference on Capital Hill in Washington, D.C. on Tuesday. [Photo credit: Mark Wilson/Getty Images.]

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) has been arguing in our writing and analysis about the U.S. Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) legal case against Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s friendly acquisition last summer of rival Wild Oats Market, Inc. that the regulator's argument that a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats constitutes a monopoly in what the agency calls the "premium organic retailing segment" in the U.S. is folly because current and growing marketplace realities as they pertain to the retailing of natural, organic and premium food and grocery products demonstrate the exact opposite to be the case.

Those market realities are that when it comes to the retail selling of natural and organic food and grocery products in the U.S., it no longer makes any sense to talk about retailing segments such as "the premium organic retailing segment" because in America there today exists a multi-format retailing explosion when it comes to sellers of natural and organic products, either of basic items or premium ones.

Gone are the days of thinking about natural and organic products' retailing as something that's done primarily by natural foods retailers in the U.S. Today, the format explosion of retailers selling category items in a deep and serious way includes huge mass merchandisers like Wal-Mart, Costco, Target and BJ's Wholesale, mega-supermarket chains like Kroger Co., Safeway Stores, Inc. and Supervalu, along with hundreds of regional supermarket chains and multi and single-store independents.

Don't believe us? Ask any organic products' marketer of significance if he or she thinks only or primarily about the natural foods retailing class of trade when preparing to launch a new product into the organic food and grocery market. If they do, the company is either a small, niche marketer, or the marketer doesn't understand today's multi-retail channel industry.

Add to this list of players in the organic products' multi-format explosion online grocers like Amazon.com and others, and of course the popular 300-plus store national specialty grocer Trader Joe's, which sells natural, organic, specialty and premium foods and groceries at a discount.

On top of all this, we've argued, contrary to the FTC's central argument that in about 29 U.S. markets the combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats is monopolistic, that within the natural foods retailing segment itself, never before in recent history have so many smaller but fast-growing players challenged Whole Foods dominance of that particular class of trade.

In fact, as we've argued since last summer, it's our analysis that the Whole Foods-Wild Oats merger actually has resulted in what we term "creative deconstruction" in the natural foods retailing industry and has thus opened the door for more innovative, aggressive players like Sunflower Farmers Market and Sprouts Farmers Market, for example, to take on Whole Foods Market, Inc. in numerous U.S. markets, particularly in the Western U.S. This includes in Texas, where both Sunflower and Sprouts are opening stores, right in the heart of Austin, Texas-based Whole Foods' backyard.

By "creative deconstruction" vis-a-vis the acquisition, what we mean is that for many years the natural products industry looked at Whole Foods and Wild Oats as the "supernatural foods segment" giants and rivals, both fighting over dominance of that what in our analysis is today a fictitious category; the supernatural foods retailing category. It's an irrelevant classification today, just like the classification "premium organic retailing segment" the FTC has created in order to have a premise for basing its case that a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats constitutes a "segment monopoly" in those some 29 markets as defined by the lawyers and regulators, is

Once Whole Foods merged Wild Oats into Whole Foods Market, Inc., a process that's essentially completed, it created a breath of fresh air and fresh new competitive thinking in natural foods retailing. Players like Sunflower Farmers Market; Sprouts; Canada's Planet Organic, which bought the New York-based Mrs. Green's natural foods chain earlier this year; Seattle-based PCC Natural Markets, Henry's, which Whole Foods sold to Smart & Final, Inc.; and many others -- all that are growing their store counts and businesses despite this so called Whole Foods monopoly -- looked at the combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats and essentially said: "So what. We can compete." And compete they are.

Our argument all along, since the summer of 2007, has essentially been comprised of these key elements:

1. Looking at natural and organic foods retailing in the way the FTC is defies marketplace reality. In the U.S. today natural products retailing is a multi-format business, which is getting more multi-format and more diverse, rather than contracting. Monopolists contract markets, not expand them. Therefore we see no Whole Foods' monopoly.

2. If Whole Foods holds monopoly status in 18-29 U.S. markets, it not only should be thriving -- it isn't -- but it should not have had to reduce prices across the board in all its U.S. stores. It has. And the chain is going to half to do so even more in order to survive in the recession, as well as to compete against all the multi-format players, including the natural foods class of trade fighting tigers like Sunflower, Sprouts and a number of others. Monopolist retailers don't have to reduce retail prices, and thus margin, in order to compete.

3. If Whole Foods had anything even close to monopoly status you would not see natural foods retailers taking the retailer on directly. Sunflower and Sprouts are doing this in Colorado, Texas, Arizona, Southern California and other Western U.S. states, for example. Henry's is doing so in Southern California, PCC in Washington state, Mrs. Green's in New York, and others elsewhere in the U.S. are doing the same. Colorado-based Natural Grocers also is taking on Whole Foods in Texas, as we wrote about in this piece in October.

4. The blurring of class of trade. Safeway's Lifestyle format, Kroger's Fresh format, United Supermarkets' Market Street format in Texas, H-E-B (also in Texas), Wegmans in the east, Publix in Florida, Raley's in Northern California, Fresh Market in the south: What do they, and numerous other supermarket banners, have in common? Many of these stores look just like a Whole Foods market store in terms of design and product offerings in the natural, organic, specialty and premium product categories. They are more than "premium organic retailers." But they also are "premium organic retailers." Get it?

5. The organic deep discounters. Walk into one of Wal-Mart's Sam's Club stores, or Costco, or BJ's Wholesale. What will you see? Lots and lots of fresh and shelf-stable natural, organic and premium foods items priced at a discount.

You also will see sustainable, "cruelty free" and fair trade goods and more, categories that just a decade ago were generally sold only in natural foods markets. Not any more. Even more interesting, many of these premium organic and fair trade items in these club stores are of the respective chain's own store brands.

Wal-Mart for example is rolling out more an more organic and fair trade premium organic items and using its Sam's Club stores as the premiere venue for testing these items.

Wal-Mart is now the top seller of food and groceries in America. Costco is number three, after Kroger. Does anybody think all this customer traffic isn't taken organic category share away from Whole Foods?

When you roll all of or key arguments up into a logic ball, and we've made others over the last 16 or so months, the empirical evidence is overwhelming in our analysis that the FTC's argument against the Whole Foods-Wild Oats merger not only is incorrect, it's irrelevant.

The marketplace has and is moving so fast that such artificial categories like the FTC's "premium organic retailing segment" make no sense at all.

For example, in just the last 18 or so months since Whole Foods acquired Wild Oats, Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market has opened over 100 of its small-format combination grocery and fresh foods markets in Southern California, Nevada and Arizona. These stores sell lots of organic fresh food and grocery items along with basic groceries. The organic items are priced far below similar items in Whole Foods stores.

Fresh & Easy isn't a supermarket. It isn't a natural foods store. It isn't a convenience store. What it is is a combination of all three of these formats -- a small-format, neighborhood grocery/fresh foods/natural foods market that puts an emphasis on convenience.

Additionally, look at Trader Joe's. The chain is widely popular and sells natural, organic and specialty fresh food and grocery items. It's neither a traditional supermarket nor is it a traditional natural foods store. It's a hybrid. The hybrid is the primary shopping venue for millions throughout the U.S. for their natural and organic food and grocery needs.

Wal-Mart opened its first four small-format (15,000-20,000 square feet) Marketside stores in Arizona in October. The stores are a combination basic grocery/in-store premium fresh, prepared foods/natural-organic-specialty food market. Not so easy to classify, are they? Basic grocery, yet premium. Fresh foods, yet shelf-stable too.

Even the fast-growing, 1,000-store small-format Aldi USA hard-discount chain, with stores in the Midwest, Mid-Atlantic, southern and eastern regions of the U.S. (and is now moving into Texas) is increasingly selling natural, organic and premium food and grocery items, including many under its own various store brands. They are selling the category items at a steep discount over the prices at Whole Foods Market stores, by the way, as well as selling them for less than most supermarket chains are.

The independent food retailing sector, both supermarkets and natural foods markets, had one of its healthiest years in 2007-2008 in terms existing independents opening additional stores and new independents coming into the business by opening their first stores. Of course this was pre-recession. But it's hurting everybody.

At this year's National Grocers Association (NGA) convention, which we attended, the consensus was that the independent grocer is not just surviving in America -- but in the main thriving. One key factor for this situation mentioned throughout the convention was that many of the independents doing the best today are those who've moved significantly into the natural, organic, premium and specialty categories, Whole Foods' bread and butter.

These independent grocers and natural foods market operators are benefiting from another key trend in the U.S., which is a serious and significant "shop local" movement. This is especially strong in the natural foods sector. It's helping independents and hurting Whole Foods, which many "shop local" consumers have been tagged as the "natural foods Wal-Mart." The use of this term places emphasis on the negative aspects of Wal-Mart (attempting to dominate, ect.) and what those using it say are Whole Foods similar negatives in the natural foods retailing sphere.

Further, natural and organic product sales have proliferated into other classes of trade as well. Drug stores like Walgreens, Rite Aid, CVS and Long's offer lots of organic items in their respective stores, for example. Dollar and 99-cents stores are expanding their organic selections as well. Thousands of farmers' markets across the U.S. offer organic fresh produce. And the retail food cooperative movement, which in total has annual sales of billions in the hundreds of co-op stores throughout the U.S., is experiencing a resurgence.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has been one of the few, until recently, publications making this overall argument since last summer, when right after the Wild Oats acquisition by Whole Foods Market, Inc. the FTC challenged it in court.

Today, the FTC continues that challenge. And as we've reported, Whole Foods Market has now fought back, filing a lawsuit against the FTC, along with launching a major public relations and lobbying campaign in Washington D.C. and throughout the country calling for "Fair Play For Whole Foods by FTC."

Today however, the esteemed New York Times has agreed with our position in a piece by business staff writer Andrew Martin, who covers the supermarket industry, including Whole Foods market, Inc. for the paper. You can read the piece, "Wait. Why is the FTC after Whole Foods," here.

Martin even uses language, (eg: "marketplace realities") like we been using since last summer in describing the FTC legal case against Whole Foods.

While we don't seek nor need validation for our long-held position on the issue, we have our own extensive analysis of "marketplace realities" behind us after all, we welcome the New York Times' agreement with our long argued position in the form of the piece today by Andrew Martin, who does a very informed job in his coverage of the food and grocery retailing industry in the U.S.

Conclusion:

Whole Foods Market, Inc. only began last week making an argument, and launching a real educational campaign, about the FTC's case, using many of the arguments Natural~Specialty Foods Memo started making last summer and has been making all year on the Blog.

We fault CEO John Mackey for waiting so long before doing so; before talking about the "marketplace realities" we've been describing, offering analysis on and writing about these many months.

We also respectfully suggest Mr. Mackey has become more a part of the problem rather than part of the solution to Whole Foods' winning over the FTC. We know first hand there are members of the FTC who let us say have serious differences with CEO Mackey's style and behavior involving the acquisition of Wild Oats. This includes his numerous postings leading up to the acquisition under a fictitious screen name on Yahoo Finance Message boards like this one he made in March of 2006: "The end game is now under way for OATS. Whole Foods is systematically destroying their viability as a business market by market, city by city." There were many more using similar language, as well as a number of posts that ridiculed Wild Oats' then CEO.

Think about it this way. It seems to us that instead of basing its case on marketplace realities, which our argument we believe demonstrates that the FTC is wrong in its case, its almost like the FTC is basing its case on John Mackey's written words, and perhaps his intent, which they conclude was to dominate the retail sales of "premium organic products."

The FTC discovered it was Mackey making the posts using a fictitious screen name. There was an investigation and he was cleared in terms of breaking any laws in doing so. However, many of questioned the ethics of making the postings considering the nature of them in the run up to the Wild Oats Market, Inc. acquisition. Had CEO Mackey thought doing so was kosher, many ask why he simply didn't use his own name instead of making one up, for example.

However that behavior, as well as statements Mackey has made in the past -- along with pre-acquisition internal e-mails the FTC has seen in which the CEO wrote things like: Wild Oats stores are a "cash cow" and a "monopoly" in markets where Whole Foods don't exist, and that Whole Foods was waging "war" on prices in markets where the two compete -- has left a very bad taste in the mouths of some members of the FTC vis-a-vis John Mackey as CEO of Whole Foods, even though those of us who've worked in the industry know such language to not be that uncommon -- and perhaps even a bit fun.

The point is, despite the FTC's saying it ain't so, the regulator's case against Whole Foods is tainted by these personal feelings some agency members have regarding John Mackey. Therefore, in our analysis and opinion, it would be prudent for Whole Foods' and Mr. Mackey too dramatically decrease his public exposure regarding the FTC issue and make co-president Walter Robb, who already is involved in speaking out on the issue, the public face and executive spokesman for Whole Foods on the entire matter.

CEO Mackey already last week made some public statements, and statements to the press, that are personal in nature regarding the FTC. That really does no good, although we can understand his emotions. Robb is and has been the voice of reason at Whole Foods compared to Mackey's more emotional style. Both styles have there advantages, and are needed at different times depending on the situation. In this case, the FTC v. Whole Foods and Whole Foods v. the FTC, it's the public voice of reason (Robb) we believe is needed and that will be most beneficial to Whole Foods Market, Inc. in defeating the FTC.

Since we recently learned numerous members of the Whole Foods Market, Inc. senior administrative team have been following our analysis in Natural~Specialty Foods Memo, we know there's been much talk at corporate headquarters in Austin about when the natural foods chain should go on the attack against the FTC.

That attack by Whole Foods began last Monday (December 8) with its lawsuit filed against the FTC, as we reported here, followed the next day by a press conference on Capital Hill by CEO Mackey and the grocer's legal team, led by Lanny Davis, and comprised of top antitrust lawyers from three of Washington D.C.'s top law firms.

Along with this legal challenge, Whole Foods has hired one of Washington's most Democrat-connected lobbying firms, The Glover Park Group, to lobby Congress in Whole Foods' favor.

Additionally, thousands of Whole Foods Market store employees across the U.S. are being mobilized in a grass roots campaign, contacting their U.S. Senators and members of Congress, essentially asking them to back the grocer against the FTC.

Meanwhile the FTC has set a trial over the merger for February 16, 2008 in Washington, D.C. That trial or hearing, before an administrative law judge, will determine whether or not the merger holds. If Whole Foods loses, it can appeal the merger to a U.S. federal court. However, it will have to start taking apart the combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats following such a ruling unless a federal court stays the FTC administrative hearing administrative law judge's ruling should it be in favor of the FTC, pending Whole Foods' appeal.

The stakes are high for Whole Foods Market, Inc. in what some think are the closing years of the John Mackey era.

Of course, a new, Democratic President, Barack Obama, will take office in less than 40 days, on January 20, 2009.

President-elect Obama gets to name a new chairman of the FTC, as we wrote about in this recent piece. Currently three of the five members of the FTC are for overturning the merger. Should an Obama-appointed chairman be against doing so, as are two current members of the commission, there could be a political decision to drop the matter and legal case completely.

The stakes are high.

It's a political as well as legal issue, hence the political campaign by Whole Foods along with the lawsuit it filed against the FTC last Monday.

Meanwhile the current recession is going to be with us at least through the end of 2009 we believe. And as a result Whole Foods Market, Inc. isn't likely to see a reversal of its recent sad fortunes, which include the value of its stock dropping by 70% in the last year, record drops in net income, corporate employee layoffs and sagging sales, anytime soon. In other words, even if the FTC loses and the merger stays, Whole Foods is going to have a very tough 2009 and probably a near as tough 2010.

If the FTC wins, and Whole Foods fails in winning an appeal of that decision and the merger is overturned, it's our analysis that taking apart a combined Whole Foods-Wild Oats will probably send the value of Whole Foods (it's stock already is at an all time low of about $10 share) stock down so low that the natural grocer might never recover from the blow.

The best case scenario is that the FTC would force Whole Foods to sell off a certain number of the Wild Oats stores in these 18-29 or so markets where the regulator says the natural grocery chain holds a monopoly in the "premium organic retailing segment." Depending on how many stores Whole Foods would be forced to sell off, that is a scenario we think the natural grocer could emerge in decent shape from.

The problem with this though is that Whole Foods still has so much debt from the Wild oats acquisition -- it took on about $150 million in debt when it bought the company -- that if it's forced to divest too many of the stores, which there isn't a market for anyway in the main right now, that could demenish its future sales so much that paying off that debt would be very difficult without further diluting the value of Whole Foods Market, Inc. significantly.

Therefore, under either scenario -- win or lose with the FTC -- the next couple years will be difficult ones for Whole Foods Market, Inc.

The empirical reality though is having to fight the FTC, both in spending the millions on outside legal and related talent, as well as the time consumption doing so takes, is making it much more difficult for the natural grocery chain to focus on improving sales and profits during this serious economic recession.

There is a sad irony to this in that while industry after industry is asking for and getting bailouts from the U.S. government (ie: the taxpayer), Whole Foods is only asking to be freed from fighting the FTC so it can build the business and bring back shareholder value.

We have no professional or personal dog in the FTC-Whole Foods fight -- don't own Whole Foods stock, don't do any business with Whole Foods -- but we do know marketplace realities and wrong-headed government regulation when we see them.

In the case of the FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc., the regulator is wrong. It's argument, that Whole Foods' holds a monopoly in those 18-29 U.S. markets is premised on the false analysis by the FTC that the category "premium organic retailing" has any real meaning. Therefore the FTC's entire legal argument in our analysis is based on a false premise.

It's all about that marketplace reality we discussed earlier -- that the retailing of natural, organic and premium foods in the U.S. today has become a multi-format, competitive business in which neither Whole Foods or any other U.S. retailer which sells natural and organic products currently has anything approaching a monopoly. Because this is the empirical reality of the market, the FTC case against Whole Foods Market, Inc. is pure folly, in our analysis.

FTC v. Whole Foods - Whole Foods v. FTC: Recent Natural-Specialty Foods Memo linkage:







FTC v. Whole Foods: Linkage from the Natural~Specialty Foods Memo archives:

Click here, here and here for stories about the FTC-Whole Foods issue from our archives.

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Green Retailing Memo: Whole Foods Market Tops List in Greenpeace's Top 20 U.S. Chain Seafood Sustainability Scorecard


Whole Foods Market, Inc. may not be the U.S. Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) favorite food and grocery retailer currently, but the natural grocery chain is at the top of environmental group Greenpeace's retailer hit parade, at least when it comes to seafood sustainability.

Greenpeace has named Whole Foods Market [WFMI] the number one retailer in the United States in seafood sustainability for its program of selling sustainably harvested seafood in its stores.

The newest Greenpeace report scoring retailers on the environmental responsibility of their seafood selections singles out Whole Foods Market's new quality standards for aquaculture, (farmed seafood), which have made the natural products retail chain a leader in the industry, as one of the factors in their higher score, the global environmental organization said today.

Greenpeace evaluates and ranks the major U.S. food and grocery retailers on their seafood sustainability practices, then chooses the company it believes not only has the best practice but also is engaged in continuous improvement in regard to its seafood sustainability program and merchandising.

Whole Foods was one of only (number 1) four U.S. grocery chains (Greenpeace ranked the top 20 U.S. chains) that passed the environmental organization's sustainability test. The other three chains are, in order of their scores or ranking:

2. Ahold USA, which operates the Giant Food and Stop & Shop supermarket chains.
3. Target, which only sells fresh seafood in its Super Target combination supermarket-general merchandise Supercenters.
4. Harris Teeter (supermarket chain).

The other 16 top U.S. chains failed Greenpeace's evaluative criteria. Those 16 are, ranked from best (which means they barely failed) to worst:

5. Wal-Mart
6. Safeway (Dominick's, Genuardi's, Randall's, Von's)
7. Wegmans
8. Kroger (Baker's, City Market, Dillon's, Owen's, PayLess, Ralph's,Scott's, Smith's, Quality Food Center)
9. Aldi
10. Costco
11. A&P (Food Emporium, Pathmark, Super Fresh, Waldbaum's)
12. Giant Eagle
13. Publix
14. Winn-Dixie
15. Delhaize (Bloom, Food Lion, Hannaford Bros., Sweetbay)
16. Supervalu (Acme, Albertson's, Bristol Farms, Jewel-Osco, Shaw's)
17. Trader Joe's
18. Meijer
19. H. E. Butt (H.E.B., Central Market)
20. Price Chopper

Wal-Mart, Safeway and Wegmans (5,6 and 7) came close to passing the Greenpeace evaluation (bairly failing). Kroger, Aldi and Costco (8, 9 and 10) have a ways to go, according to Greenpeace, but could move up dramatically with improved sustainability practices. The other ten have lots of work to do in terms of harvested seafood sustainability, particularly the bottom five (16-20) chains.

Wal-Mart's nearly making the sustainable seafood A-list is interesting, and appears to us to be a reflection of the mega-retailer's increased emphasis on sustainability and "green" retailing.

"We are proud to be recognized for our efforts as we go to great lengths to ensure these products meet our high standards for quality, safety, sustainability and culinary excellence," Margaret Wittenberg, Whole Foods Market's global vice president of quality standards and public affairs said today after being told Greenpeace chose the natural grocery chain as its top retailer for seafood sustainability. "We have done more than any other retailer when it comes to sourcing and promoting environmentally responsible, quality seafood, and we will continue to evaluate all species of seafood we sell to ensure we are doing our part to care for our planet and its tenants."

Whittenberg also announced today Whole Foods Market is now embarking on a process for further enhancing its quality standards for wild-caught species similar to its quality standards project for aquaculture, and will include creating sourcing guidelines for wild-capture fisheries not already certified by the Marine Stewardship Council. This is a practice Greenpeace has been encouraging retailers to adopt, along with their sustainability programs for harvested seafood.

After hearing Whole Foods announcement, Greenpeace issued a statement today congratulating Whole Foods on adopting the stronger sustainability standards for wild-caught seafood.

"Whole Foods Market is making significant strides in improving its seafood sustainability, and Greenpeace expects Whole Foods' wild-caught Quality Standards will be as thorough as its Aquaculture Standards," Greenpeace said.

In June of this year, Greenpeace first ranked the top 20 chains. All 20, including Whole Foods Market, flunked that review.

The new review, which ranked Whole foods number one and included the other three chains, took into account what Greenpeace says are some "small but significant changes" in some of the retailer's sustainability policies. In other words it's sort of a redo, taking effort and improvement into account this time around.

Whole Foods, which operates 275 stores in the U.S., Canada and the United Kingdom and had 2008 sales of $8 billion, made the "most significant" improvements, landing it in first place, according to Greenpeace.

Speaking of improvements, it appears 16 of the top 20 chains have nowhere to go but up when it comes to seafood sustainability.

Whole Foods Market, Inc. also was named "America's Healthiest Grocery Store" this year by Health Magazine, which each year picks "the healthiest" in a variety of business categories like grocery stores, restaurants and more.

Whole Foods might be a "premium organic retailing segment" monopolist in about 29 U.S. markets, if one buys the FTC's argument, which as we written we don't. However, it appears it's a very sustainable and health-oriented retailer when it comes to the foods and other products it monopolizes those respective market places with. That certainly should count for something.

The full Greenpeace top 20 retailer seafood sustainability report along with additional details is available at: http://www.greenpeace.org/seafood