Showing posts sorted by relevance for query safeway. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query safeway. Sort by date Show all posts

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Retail Memo: New Details and Analysis About Safeway's Small-Format Summer Bay Area Surprise for Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market


We were one of the first publications to report on December 10, 2007 that Pleasanton, California-based Safeway Stores, Inc. was developing a new, small-format (15,000 -to- 20,000 square feet) grocery store similar to Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, which the San Francisco Bay Area-based supermarket chain plans to initially open in the San Jose area sometime this summer.

Tesco plans to open an initial 18 of its small-format, combination basic grocery/semi-upscale fresh foods and specialty grocery stores in the San Francisco Bay Area beginning in late 2008, or more likely in early 2009. A number of these 18 initial stores will be located in the South Bay Area, in San Jose and the surrounding communities.

Since we reported the Safeway small-format grocery store development story, we've followed up with a couple analysis pieces, and have been following Safeway's development process closely, doing research and talking to as many industry--and industry-affiliated--sources as we can. As a result we've learned some additional facts about the new small-format stores.

Stores likely to open in July or August, 2008

First, based on information from our various sources, we believe the first of the four -to- five pilot Safeway small-format grocery stores will open in either July or August of this year in the San Jose area. Part of Safeway's reason for wanting to open the stores this summer, is so that the retailer can have the intial stores opened for a significant period of time prior to Tesco entering the market in either late 2008 or early 2009.

It was initially believed Tesco would open the first of its Bay Area Fresh & Easy stores this summer. However, Tesco says it won't open stores in the region until 2009. We still believe its possible Tesco will try to open a few Fresh & Easy markets in the Bay Area in late 2008. The first store location lease (of the 18 signed to date) the British retailer signed in the Bay Area was for an empty Albertsons supermarket building on Bird Avenue in the city of San Jose, which it will remodel into a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market store.

Safeway wants to have its small-format grocery stores open and doing business before Tesco's Fresh & Easy even comes to town, so to speak. By opening the first stores in July or August of this year, it could give Safeway anywhere from six months to close to a year of retail operations before the first key is even turned in a Fresh & Easy store door by Tesco in the Bay Area.

Safeway small-format grocery stores: A few snapshots

We don't have a complete picture of what the Safeway small-format grocery stores will look like in terms of design or overall product mix. However, based on conversations with sources and much analysis ,we do have some pieces of the puzzle filled out thus far.

In terms of design, we expect something fairly upscale inside and out. However, the stores aren't going to be super upscale. Rather, they will be attractive in terms of design but also somewhat utilitarian looking. They aren't designed for only high-end consumers.

In October, 2007 Anthony Gilmore, the former Northern California Region President for Whole Foods Market, Inc. resigned his position with the supernatural foods grocer to accept an executive position with Safeway Stores, at its corporate headquarters in the East Bay Area city of Pleasanton.

While leading Whole Foods' Northern California division, Gilmore completed an aggressive and varied new store opening program for the supernatural grocer in the region. His strength was in being able to organize and lead the development of "new generation" Whole Foods' stores, giving each of the new stores its own local flair.

Small-format grocery stores aren't really a new development for Safeway. In fact, it's more of a retro, "back to the future" concept, if not in actual store format, at least in size. Pictured above is a small Safeway grocery store located in San Francisco, California circa the 1940's. The store was located in either the city's Nob Hill or Tenderloin neighborhoods. Notice the "tag line" on the Safeway sign, "Distribution Without Waste." It's a perfect slogan for 21rst century "green" grocery retailing. (The grocer might want to bring the slogan back.) Pictured below, is a small-format Safeway store which was located at 228 Seventh Street SE in Washington D.C. The market was built and opened in 1940 and remained open and profitable for 46 years, closing in 1986.
For example, under Gilmore Whole Foods built its biggest and most comprehensive food store in Campbell, California, which is located in the famed Silicon Valley, and is only a few miles from San Jose. This store, which is now called the Northern California flagship, is nearly 80,000 square feet. It's a double-story superstore, filled with numerous in-store dining venues, a wine bar, a mini day spa, and much more. The store also fits its location well, both in design and in its product mix.

Further, Gilmore lead the creation of what is arguably Whole Foods' most innovative store to date: its European-style market hall store in downtown Oakland, California. The store, which opened in October, 2007, is designed like a European food hall, yet contains all of the departments--and more--the supernatural grocer is famous for.

In addition, Gilmore pioneered the building of Whole Foods' lifestyle-oriented superstores as retail anchor stores for upscale multi-unit housing developments in the city of San Francisco.

For example, the newest San Francisco store, which is located in the hip, up-and-coming Potrero Hill neighborhood, is the ground floor retail anchor of a huge, high-end condominium development which is becoming a very popular place to live in the city. The store design is modern, like the condo project, but also incorporates the history of the neighborhood. Among the store's unique features are an indoor-outdoor wine bar and bistro which features a DJ who spins tunes for customers on weekend evenings.

Gilmore's charge in his position at Safeway is primarily retail format development. He's been working on the chain's successful lifestyle format, including a project which involves creating a "second generation" lifestyle format for Safeway's supermarkets. Some of these "second generation" developments are already beginning to show up in the retailer's new lifestyle stores.

What we refer to as the "second generation" aspects include more upscale design and interior packages--colors, flooring, shelving, and the like--and added in-store features like the fresh nut bars and similar new in-store venues appearing in a number of the grocery chain's recently-opened lifestyle supermarkets.

Gilmore also was brought on, in part, to work on the small-format grocery store project, both from a format design and product selection and merchandising standpoint. Expect to see his input in how the 15,000 -to- 20,000 square foot grocery markets look, the products sold in them, and how they reflect the communities (localism) they are in. We expect some unique and creative flourishes in the store's design and product selection.

Prepared foods to be central to the small-format Safeway stores

Safeway is nearing completion of a line of fresh, prepared foods which it will begin rolling out in its lifestyle stores soon. The prepared foods' line includes ready-to-heat and ready-to-eat entrees, side dishes and grab-and-go type foods. Some of the prepared foods' items will be under the retailer's O' Organics brand, others under its Eating Right healthy foods brand, and still others under one or more new brands. These prepared foods items will be sold in all of the grocer's lifestyle stores--as well as in the new, small-format grocery markets, we believe.

Safeway already has extensive prepared foods offerings--which it has grown dramatically over the last couple years--for sale in its lifestyle supermarkets. For example, it offers fresh soups, sandwiches, pizzas and other items under its Safeway signature brand. The grocer also offers prepared entrees and side dishes under various store brands, along with many other ready-to-eat and ready-to-eat items.

A little over a year ago, Safeway bought a restaurant in the San Jose area. The grocer has been using that restaurant to develop and test items with consumers as a way to develop its fresh, prepared foods items. Look for an extensive array of fresh, prepared foods in the new small-format Safeway grocery stores. These items should range from basic, inexpensive items, to much higher-end gourmet items, which are being developed by professional chefs at the company-owned restaurant.

A limited assortment of discount groceries

In a conference call with supermarket industry analysts last week, Safeway CEO Steve Burd said because of the inflationary and recessionary nature of the U.S. economy, consumers are increasingly filling their shopping carts with cheaper groceries in his stores. He even said the company is seeing more shoppers buying generic groceries in Safeway-owned stores.

Safeway's stock tumbled to a 52-week low last week, even though the grocer's fourth-quarter profit met analysts expectations. Analysts--and Burd--attribute this decline in stock value to the current bad economic climate in the U.S., which like Burd argued to the analysts is causing even middle-to-upper end consumers to buy more discount grocery products.

During the conference call, Burd described the current rate of grocery inflation as "the highest I've seen in my 15 years as Safeway's chief executive."

We wouldn't be surprised to see Burd and company use the new, small-format stores to merchandise a limited assortment of basic grocery items (say 60% store brand/40% national brand) at discount prices, along with the fresh, prepared foods and other offerings. (We don't know this for a fact, and nobody at Safeway has gone on the record with us either confirming or denying this. Our view is based on discussions with numerous sources, as well as our own analysis.)

Safeway has two very strong selling value-positioned store grocery product brands. One is a low-end, near generic line, the other a mid-range brand. They also have Safeway Select, a premium, yet competitively-priced multi-category store brand, in addition to a number of other store brands.

In fact, these three--low-end, midrange and premium--store brands are the top market share sellers in many of their respective categories, such as various canned fruits and vegetables and other packaged goods. These product brands--like the Safeway retail brand--are strong in the Bay Area. Unlike Tesco's Fresh & Easy store brand, which will be new to the region, Safeway's brands have extremely strong equity with Bay Area consumers.

For example, the San Francisco Chronicle, the region's highest-circulation newspaper, runs a column in its food section every Wednesday in which it compares at least 10-12 grocery brands in a different grocery products category each week. Safeway's store brands (even the value brands) frequently place in the top three, beating out in many cases the top national brand in a given category, which sells for much more at retail than the Safeway store brand.

Safeway has a huge advantage over Tesco in this approach. First, the grocer knows the Northern California (and especially Bay Area) market inside-out. It's far-and-away the number one market share leader in the region. Second, the grocer has decades of market-specific scan data in its databases. This is an invaluable tool when choosing a limited basic grocery products selection for a store.

Lastly, Safeway has over 20 years' of consumer/shopper data from its club card program. From a consumer-buying and behavior perspective, this information, combined with the market-specific scan data, can help the grocer not only choose the optimum limited-assortment basic grocery selection for its new, small-format stores, but also the club card data can guide the retailer in custom-tailoring the stores to each and every neighborhood. This is powerful information that even the world's number three retailer Tesco can't buy for any price. If they could, the retailer's Southern California stores would have a different basic grocery item product mix, and be tailored much better to the city's and neighborhoods they are located in.

What's in a name?

Lastly, and actually the most fun, is the question: What will Safeway name its small-format grocery stores?

While we don't have any specific information from sources inside or outside of Safeway Stores, Inc. who can provide us with information credible enough for us to go on the record and give you the name Safeway's new, small-format grocery stores will go by, we are willing to go out on a limb and offer a potential or even probable name, based on three key factors we've identified and anlalyzed. Those three factors are:

>First, Safeway Stores, Inc. likes the Safeway name and brand. All of its 271 stores in Northern California are branded Safeway, with the exception of a small division of warehouse stores called Pak 'n Sav. In addition, all of the grocery chain's stores in the Pacific Northwest, Arizona, Colorado and western Canada fly under the Safeway banner, as do the stores in the Washington D.C./Maryland/Virgina tri-state region.

All of the company's other banners--Vons, Pavillions, Dominicks, Randall's, Tom Thumb, Genuardi's and Carr's--were formerly independent chains which Safeway acquired, and as a result decided to keep the chain's names rather than change them to Safeway. The grocer sells its Safeway brand-named private label products, such as the Safeway Select, in all of these banner stores however.

The Safeway food retailing brand has strong consumer equity in Northern California, and especially in the Bay Area, where most of its stores are located, along with its corporate headquarters. As a result, we believe the grocery retailer is likely to use "Safeway" as part of the name for its new, small-format grocery stores when they open this summer.

Second, over the last four or five weeks we have floated a name for the small-format stores around to industry sources inside and outside of Safeway. We also have heard this name used by some Safeway suppliers, and others such as food brokers, who do regular business with Safeway at its corporate headquarters in Pleasanton.

While none of our sources (in the case of those outside Safeway) know for sure what the grocer will name the new, small-format stores, a number of them told us they've heard the name we put out there discussed among some fairly serious industry people in Northern California. In terms of people inside Safeway (who either don't know the name, or if they did likely wouldn't tell us) the name we floated received some interesting responses. Not one of the insiders dismissed the potential name for the new, small-format stores we mentioned out of hand to us.

All this is purely anecdotal, and we aren't claiming otherwise. Rather, its merely one part of the three-part puzzle we are analyzing, along with a couple other factors. (Did you really think we would give you everything?)

The third piece of this three-part analysis puzzle involving the possible name for the small-format, convenience-style grocery stores involves history. Many of our readers may not know this but there is a Safeway chain in the middle eastern country of Jordan.

Safeway Jordan isn't owned by or affiliated with U.S.-based Safeway Stores, Inc. However, there
is an historic connection. U.S.-based Safeway Stores, Inc. once was an international food retailing company. Among it's international operations was Safeway plc. in the United Kingdom. Safeway Stores, Inc. USA sold UK-based Safeway a long time ago. And non- Safeway USA-affiliated Safeway plc. was recently acquired by Britain's Morrison's supermarket chain, which has nearly completed removing the Safeway banner from the stores in the UK.

Prior to selling UK-based Safeway plc. to Morrison's, the companay owned Safeway Jordan and operated stores in that country and in Kuwait. In 2003, Safeway plc. sold its Jordan division to The Sultan Center (TSC), a Jordanian supplier and retailer of food, grocery, perishable and general merchandise items in the middle east. Jordan is a monarchy, so although it has a vibrant private sector, the ruling government family and business sectors are strongly tied-in together.

This is where the history gets interesting. Now, remember UK-based Safeway plc. was once long ago owned by USA-based Safeway, Inc. Safeway USA sold its UK operations to a group there who named it Safeway Plc. That group established Safeway Jordan, then sold the Jordan division to Jordanian-owned TSC.

TSC-owned Safeway Jordan operates three Safeway branded retail formats in that country. Those three retail grocery store formats are:

>Safeway service stores or supermarkets, which are similar to a western supermarket.
>Safeway Wholesale Center, which are a cash & carry-type format.
>Safeway Express, which is a hybrid basic neighborhood grocery store/convenience store/food-service store.

Yes, you guessed it: we are suggesting (not stating as fact or saying we have any confirmation) there is a decent probability that Pleasanton, California-based Safeway Stores, Inc. will name its new, small format grocery stores, which will open this summer in the San Francisco Bay Area, Safeway Express.

There's an added caveat for Safeway Stores, Inc. in going with the Safeway Express name for its new, small-format grocery markets as well: Tesco, parent company of Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market, operates Tesco Express small format grocery stores throughout the UK and in other parts of Europe. These stores are the model from which Tesco created its Fresh & Easy grocery market format in the U.S. There are significant differences between the two formats--Tesco Express and Fresh & Easy--but also many similarities.

It would be ironic if Safeway names its new 15,000 square foot -to- 20,000 square foot grocery stores in the Bay Area--which will go head-to-head with Tesco's 10,000 square foot -to- 15,000 square foot Fresh & Easy grocery markets beginning at the end of this year or in early 2009--Safeway Express. In many ways, using that name for the stores would set the stage for an all out premptive summer surprise by Safeway for Tesco's Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market in the Bay Area and elsewhere in Northern California.

Monday, March 30, 2009

Store Brand - Private Label Memo: 'Big Score' At 'Big Y' Chain For Safeway's 'Eating Right' Healthy Foods Brand


Retailer Store Brands: Special Report

The family-owned, Springfield, Massachusetts-based Big Y supermarket chain is the first major food and grocery retailer in the U.S. to introduce and carry at least one of the two Safeway Stores, Inc. organic and healthy foods store brands -- "O' Organics" and "Eating Right" -- that the Pleasanton, California-based supermarket chain began marketing to other U.S. grocery retailers and wholesalers through its Lucerne Foods Inc. brands division last year, in its stores.

In Big Y's case, the popular supermarket chain is introducing numerous "Eating Right" brand healthy food and grocery items across multiple categories in its stores in New England.

Privately-held Big Y, which was founded in 1936 by Paul and Gerald D'Amour and was named after an intersection in Chicopee, Massachusetts where two roads converge to form a Y, currently operates 57 high volume supermarkets located in Massachusetts and Connecticut.

Among the Safeway Stores, Inc. "Eating Right" healthy food products being introduced this week at Big Y include: frozen entrees; cereal; soups; pasta; salad dressings; snack bars; cookies; and items in numerous other dry grocery and perishable categories, according to Carrie Taylor, Big Y's corporate dietitian, who's in charge of the supermarket chain's "Living Well Eating Smart" chainwide healthy foods program.

"With healthier eating a priority for many of our customers, we are pleased to bring new options to our shelves with the introduction of the 'Eating Right' brand at Big Y stores," Ms. Taylor says. "Our shoppers have long relied on us to meet all of their supermarket needs and with 'Eating Right' we're able to offer a great selection of functional and tasty products designed to help our customers reach their specific health objectives."

Safeway Stores Inc.'s Lucerne Foods, Inc. brand marketing division is handling the marketing of the "O 'Organics" and "Eating Right" brands to supermarket chains and wholesale grocers in the U.S. and globally.

There are currently 225 SKUS in 20 categories under the "Eating Right" brand, according to Alex Petrov, president of Safeway Stores' Lucerne Foods Inc. division.

Neither Big Y supermarkets nor Safeway Stores, Inc. is touting the fact that the "Eating Right" brand being introduced in the 57 Big Y supermarkets in Massachusetts and Connecticut is produced, owned and marketed by Safeway Stores, including the fact that the brand is a Safeway healthy foods store brand. Both are handling the introduction and marketing of the brand just as they would any other brand, regardless of its origin or ownership.

That's also why the marketing of the "Eating Right" brand to grocers like Big Y is being conducted by Safeway's Lucerne Foods Inc. division as a separate function from the store brand merchandising and marketing of the brand (and of "O' Organics") in Safeway's about 1,750 supermarkets in the U.S. and Canada. Safeway Stores, Inc. strategically views the brands not just as store brands, but as what the company hopes will become standalone organic and healthy food brands both in the U.S. and globally in the future.

Safeway doesn't operate any supermarkets in the New England states of Massachusetts or Connecticut where Big Y has its 57 supermarkets.

The closest states where Safeway has stores are in Washington, D.C., Maryland and Virgina.

This is an important distinction because in Big Y's case its customer base won't in most cases even be aware that the "Eating Right" brand items are a Safeway store brand, since there are no Safeway-owned supermarkets in the two states.

Our analysis is that Safeway will need to use this type of strategy to launch the two brands in the U.S., focusing on regional chains like Big Y which operate in markets where Safeway does not have a retailing presence.

For example, we don't see many retailers in the Western U.S., where Safeway is a major player and in many markets is the market share leader, carrying the "O Organics" and "Eating Right" brands because with little exception every retailer in the Western U.S. is a competitor of Safeway's.

Major competitor's like Kroger Co, Supervalue, Inc., Wal-Mart and Costco have their own organic and healthy store brands and aren't going to offer the store brands of a major competitor in their respective stores.

Major regional chains throughout the west also in many cases either have their own organic and healthy foods store brands or carry such private label brands through arrangements with a wholesaler. Additionally, since these regional chains are direct competitors with Safeway in states like California, Oregon, Washington, Colorado, Arizona and the like, they won't in all probability offer Safeway's "Eating Right" or "O Organics" store brands on their respective shelves either. It makes little sense for these chains to compete with Safeway on the brands.

We believe this will hold true in other parts of the U.S. where Safeway has a retail presence like the Washington D.C./Maryland/Virgina tri-state market region, Texas, Florida, Illinois-Indiana and Alaska, in addition to the Western U.S.

As a result, that's why we believe Safeway will have to conduct a niche retailer strategy, placing its "O Organics" and "Eating Right" brands in non-competitive, select chains primarily in parts of the U.S. where it isn't a retail player.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) was one of the first, if not the very first, publication to report that Safeway Stores, Inc. was marketing its "O Organics" brand to another retailer, France's Carrefour (the world's third-largest global retailer) internationally, in the three stories from December, 2007, and the January 8, 2008 piece, linked below:

~December 27, 2007: Marketing Memo: Safeway's O' Organics Brand in Asia
~December 23, 2007: Safeway's O' Organics Brand: Part Duex
~December 21, 2007: Friday Fishwrap: Safeway's O' Organics Brand
~January 8, 2008: Media Memo: Safeway's O' Organics Brand In Asia

In April of 2008, we first reported in this piece [April 28, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway Stores, Inc. to Market its 'O' Organics' and 'Eating Right' Organic and Healthy Brands to Other Retailers in U.S. and Globally] about Safeway's corporate plans to market its "O 'Organics" and "Eating Right" brands to other supermarket chains in the U.S.

Linked below are four related past pieces on the topic from Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM):

~August 6, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway's Challenge: Going From Store Brand Marketer to Consumer Brand Marketer With its O' Organics and Eating Right Brands
~April 28, 2008: Marketing Memo: Safeway Stores, Inc. to Market its 'O' Organics' and 'Eating Right' Organic and Healthy Brands to Other Retailers in U.S. and Globally
~April 28, 2008: Retail Memo: Safeway CEO Burd Says Shoppers Buying Store Brands Over National Brands By As Much As Six -to- One in it's North American Supermarkets

Safeway's Lucern Foods, Inc. division isn't confirming or not confirming, but based on our reporting, sources and research, Springfield, Massachusetts-based Big Y appears to be the first U.S. supermarket chain that's agreed to carry one of the two Safeway brands, "O Organics" and "Eating Right." In Big Y's case, it's carrying the "Eating Right brand" only at present.

Big Y is a popular, high volume retailer in New England. As a result, landing the chain is a major niche retailer score for Safeway and its "Eating Right" brand, in our analysis.

Big Y also is a well-known regional chain in the trade. Safeway's landing of the chain for its "Eating Right" brand should create greater interest in the brand from similar retail chains in other parts of the U.S., particularly in market regions where Safeway doesn't operate supermarkets in.

We expect to see at least two more regional chains in the U.S. announce their respective plans to carry either just the "Eating Right" healthy foods brand or both the "Eating Right" and "O' Organics" brands from Safeway in the next couple months.

[Readers: You can follow Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) on Twitter.com at www.twitter.com/nsfoodsmemo.]

Monday, April 28, 2008

Marketing Memo: Safeway Stores, Inc. to Market its 'O' Organics' and 'Eating Right' Organic and Healthy Brands to Other Retailers in U.S. and Globally


Safeway Stores, Inc. has formed the "Better Living Brands Alliance," a marketing consortium that will market its O' Organics organic food and grocery brand and its Eating Right health and wellness category brand across all retail channels in the U.S. beginning this year.

Through the "Better Living Brands Alliance," Safeway will market the two natural and organic food and grocery brands to various U.S. retailers, including supermarket chains, mass merchandisers and independent grocers through grocery wholesale houses.
Safeway also will expand its international distribution of the O' Organics brand and include it's Eating Right brand in its expanded international marketing and distribution program.

As we reported in December, 2007, Safeway signed a deal with international retailer Carrefour to distribute the O' Organics brand in its stores in Asia and South America. Carrefour, which is based in France, is the world's second-largest retailer after number one Wal-Mart, Inc.

We've learned Carrefour will not only expand the number of its stores in Asia and Latin America which currently carry the O' Organics brand, but will probably add the Eating Right healthy food and grocery products brand in those stores as well.

Safeway also plans to go beyond its relationship with Carrefour in Asia and Latin America and market both natural and organic foods' brands in Europe and elsewhere around the globe.

Back in the U.S., Safeway has put together a strategic alliance of manufacturing, marketing and distribution firms as the brand licensees in its "Better Living Brands Alliance." Among those partners will be the food and grocery brokerage firm Crossmark, which will handle new item introductions, headquarters' sales calls and retail merchandising for the brand nationally and internationally for Safeway.

EMAK Worldwide will handle U.S. and global consumer marketing and communications for the O' Organics and Eating Right brands for Safeway.

Safeway Stores, Inc.'s Lucerne Foods Inc. subsidiary, which already markets Safeway products to external customers, will manage the overall licensing of the O' Organics and Eating Right brands and is a key member of the "Better Living Brands Alliance."

As we reported before in Natural~Specialty Foods Memo, Safeway's O' Organics brand is a major success story for the retailer. Although the brand has only been in Safeway's 1,740 stores in U.S. and Canada for less than two years, it's already the number one organic food and grocery products brand by total sales volume in the U.S. Sales of the O' Organics brand in the U.S. last year was over $300 million dollars, and that's with distribution in just the 1,740 Safeway-owned supermarkets.

The health and wellness category Eating Right brand has only been in Safeway stores for about a year. However, last December Safeway CEO Steve Burd told analysts that the brand's first year sales were poised to be even higher than the first year sales for the popular O' Organics brand were.

Safeway has been extending both brands throughout all categories, from the dry grocery, perishable and frozen categories, to fresh meat and poultry, fresh produce, prepared foods and deli categories.

In addition to marketing the two brands to food, grocery and other retail formats in the U.S. and internationally, Safeway also will sell items under both brands in the foodservice class of trade domestically and globally through it's "Better Living Brands Alliance," Safeway spokesman Brian Dowling told Natural~Specialty Foods Memo.


We've learned that a number of major U.S. supermarket chains are interested in selling the O' O' Organics and Eating Right brands in their stores. This is particularly the case in those regions in the U.S. where Safeway doesn't operate its supermarkets.

We've also been told numerous large wholesale grocers who distribute to regional chains and independents will take on both the O' Organics and Eating Right brands for distribution to their retailer customers.

Internationally, look for both brands to appear in European supermarkets for the first time before the year is over.

Safeway operates stores in California, Oregon, Washington State, Nevada, Arizona and Colorado in the Western USA. The retailer also operates stores in parts of the Midwestern USA, in Alaska, Texas, the East Coast, and in the Washington D.C/Baltimore/Virginia tri-state area, as well as in Canada.

We expect this U.S. and international mass-marketing of the O' Organics and Eating Right organic and healthy category brands to easily double sales of both brands in the next year.

In terms of the O' Organics brand, the increased number of new skus Safeway has been creating, combined with growing sales and aggressive promotion in its stores, plus the initial international marketing agreement with Carrefour, has led some analysts to predict sales growth in the 30-40% range by the end of this fiscal year compared to last for the organic products' brand.

We knew this move--the mass marketing in the U.S. and globally-- was coming based on the fact we were the first industry publication in the U.S. to report on the Carrefour international licensing deal last year.

Our analysis is that with increased new product development, more aggressive in-store promotions at Safeway stores--both which are coming for both brands--combined with the new U.S. and international mass-market program through the "Better Living Brands Alliance," it's likely that by the end of this year combined sales for the O' Organics and Eating Right brands could easily reach $1 billion in gross sales.

By taking the two proprietary brands national and international and marketing them to competitors--something that's almost unheard of in the U.S. supermarket industry--Safeway is proving its a creative and nimble marketer, which is something we've been arguing is the case for the past nine months or so.

For example, Safeway has built its own in-house natural and specialty foods department over the last few years, the result of which is bringing the retailer gross margins of 50% and higher on category items sold in its stores.

Additionally, Safeway has grown its Blackhawk gift card business into the largest marketer of gift cards to other retailers in the U.S. The business started out a few years ago as an in-house venture designed to market third-party gift cards to Safeway's stores. It's now grown into a full-fledged business far beyond an in-house operation.

Now, Safeway is becoming a brand marketer with its creation of "The Better Living Brands Alliance," which will take its O' Organics and Eating Right brands nationally to various classes of trades and retail formats in the U.S. and internationally.

We also expect to see a couple other Safeway proprietary brands join the alliance down the road a bit. In particular, might be some of the new fresh, prepared foods' brands Safeway is currently working on and testing at a restaurant it owns called Citrine in Redwood City, California, in the San Francisco Bay Area's Silicon Valley region.

If you think about it, Safeway has the perfect national test market for a brand marketer--1,740 supermarkets located across the U.S. If a brand--like O' Organics has done--does well in its stores after a year or two, Safeway can then make it a candidate for the alliance and national and international distribution to other food and grocery retailers and wholesalers.

Some will suggest Safeway could lose its competitive advantage by selling the two brands to other retailers. After all, they might say, that's why they are called proprietary brands, to give a retailer that competitive advantage.

However, we disagree. Number one, Safeway will still maintain a competitive advantage in that it can choose which retailers to license and market the brands to. Number two, Safeway still will be able to sell the branded products for less than other retailers can in its own stores, while also making a higher gross margin while doing so because it's the producer and marketer of the products.

Lastly, we tend to belong to the rising tides lift all brands' boats' school. In other words, the stronger the O' Organics and Eating Right brands become in the marketplace, the more we think Safeway will actually sell in its own stores--not to mention the more of the branded products it will sell to other retailers.

It all about leverage at that point. For example, does Safeway sell less Clorox bleach or Best Foods mayonnaise just because every supermarket, drug store and mass merchandiser in America also sells it? We don't believe that's the case.

While the bulk of Safeway's retail sales will likely always come from it's supermarkets, the company's diversification into also becoming a major third-party gift card marketer and now and organic and health and wellness food and grocery products category brand marketer, is a smart and savvy move in our analysis.

Doing so helps the grocer diversify beyond the volatile food and grocery retailing space. It also gives Safeway synergies which complement its grocery retailing base.

Friday, May 9, 2008

Retail Marketing Memo: Safeway Uses Mother's Day Holiday to Launch its New 'mom to mom' Store Brand Baby Products Line in its Stores


Safeway Stores, Inc. is adding a brand new store brand to its already impressive line-up of food, grocery and non-foods store branded product lines.

Joining such Safeway store brands as its upscale Safeway Select and O 'Organics food and grocery brands, it's value-priced Safeway brand, its Signature Cafe prepared foods' store brand and Eating Right health and wellness brand, is mom to mom, a branded baby products' line of over 80 items, including disposable diapers, infant formula, baby wipes, toiletries and more.

Safeway Stores developed the mom to mom baby line with the help of real moms, according to James White, the supermarket chain's senior vice president for consumer brands.

White tells Natural~Specialty Foods Memo Safeway developed the 80-plus item baby products' line based on extensive research and conversations with moms about their babies, their lives and motherhood.

In the research and conversations with the real world moms, White says the concepts of "gentleness" and "ease-of-use" were the two key variables or take-aways from that process.

"The mom to mom line reflects the truth of the adage 'Mother Knows Best," White says in explaining how Safeway created the products based on the input and feedback from the mothers who participated in the brand's development.

As an example of what Safeway learned about the importance of ease-of-use from the moms, White says the mom to mom brand baby wipes for example are hypoallergenic and come in a flip top package with an extra-wide dispenser, making them easy to access with one hand by mom when she's feeding or changing her child's diaper. This design attribute came directly from the research with the real word moms, White says.

Safeway has chosen Sunday, May 11, to introduce the mom to mom store brand in its 1,740 supermarkets in the United States and Canada. We like the timing.

The real world moms, who's input was used extensively in designing the over 80-item baby products' line, also will have their say in Safeway's in-store merchandising of the brand.

The retailer will use parenting tips from experienced mothers on its mom to mom brand in- store point-of-purchase displays. Shelf talkers featuring these parenting tips also will be used for each of the items shelved throughout the store.

Among the tips provided by real world mothers for the displays and shelf talkers include this one: "Read to your little one everyday. It's great bonding time, and it will help prepare her for school."

The baby products line will be sold exclusively in Safeway-owned stores. There are currently no plans to sell the items to other retailers like Safeway recently announced it will do with its O' Organics and Eating Right brands. [Read our recent piece on that development here.] Not yet at least.

We say not yet because we believe it's Safeway's strategy to eventually do the same with the mom to mom brand if it's successful in the grocer's 1,740 supermarkets.

The O' Organics brand proved successful in the stores over a one year period. The brand is less than two years old and Safeway is already planning to license it to other retailers and wholesalers internationally, as we reported here on April 28.

Further, the Eating Right health and wellness brand is barely a year old, if that, and it's been so successful according to CEO Steve Burd, Safeway decided to include it along with O' Organics in its new brand marketing venture.

We suspect the retailer to look at the mom to mom baby products' brand after about a year and evaluate whether or not it too should go into the brand marketing partnership its created to market, license and sell O' Organics and Eating Right in the U.S. and internationally.

As we've discussed on Natural~Specialty Foods Memo before, Safeway Stores, Inc. is evolving from being a retailer only to being a brand marketer in general, as well as a marketing-driven food and grocery retailer.

In addition to its new brand marketing venture described above, the company also has build its Blackhawk gift card business into a substantial entity.

Additionally, Safeway has created a small division in which it will assist other companies in saving money on their health care costs by using some of the innovative market-based measures its created to keep its own corporate health care costs from rising as high as most other U.S. supermarket chains and corporations in general have

Safeway had among the lowest increases in corporate health care costs among U.S. corporations in the last two years thanks to a number of innovations the company has made in how it offers and handles employee health care and insurance.

Safeway also continues to improve its online/home grocery delivery division. It's the leader in home grocery deliver via Internet ordering in most of the markets where it offers the service.

The San Francisco Bay Area-based brand marketing-driven grocery retailer also continues to brand all of its in-store prepared foods offerings.

For example, it's private label deli meats now carry the Primo Taglio brand, its in-store prepared foods offerings sport the Signature Cafe brand, it's fresh beef is branded as Ranchers Reserve brand, and its most upscale and premium fresh bakery items and other specialty products have been branded Safeway Select Artisan.

Safeway also has extended its O' Organics brand into fresh produce and fresh poultry, and its Eating Right brand into the fresh produce, refrigerated and prepared foods categories.

The grocery chain also is expanding the variety and quantity as well as upgrading the look of its value brands, such as its Safeway brand for grocery and non-foods products and its Lucerne brand for dairy goods.

Safeway also recently created a "branded generic" grocery and non-foods brand called Basic Red. The minimalist-looking yet attractive package, which appears on basic items like toilet paper, paper towels, napkins, facial tissues and other grocery and non-foods items, has a simple red, round circle on the package with the words "Basic Red" in white against the background.

The supermarket chain has been promoting Basic Red brand items like 4-roll white toilet paper and 50-ct packages of white napkins for 10 items for $10, or $1 a package. This is part of the value package offering Safeway said it would start doing this year in its Lifestyle stores as it begins to close in on its goal of converting 100% of its supermarket format stores in Lifestyle format markets. The company says it's about 70% finished with that massive project to date.

The increased emphasis on the store value brands, while at the same time creating and positioning more upscale brands, also has much to do with the state of the economy in the U.S. as well as the soaring food price inflation currently occuring in the nation, Safeway CEO Steve Burd told Natural~Specialty Foods Memo earlier this year.

Burd says consumers are trading down and buying far more store brands in Safeway's stores than they are national brands. He says Safeway is enhancing its value brand offering to stay competitive with the big box discounters like Costco and Wal-Mart, while at the same time offering shoppers its upscale and organic brands for lower prices than comparable national and regional brands.

With its growing brand marketing emphasis, coupled with its evolving Lifestyle retail format, Safeway's positioning could be summed up as the store is the brand, and the brands are the store, in our analysis and observation.

Resources:

>Safeway has created a seperate webpage on its corporate website for the mom to mom brand baby product's line. You can view that webpage here.

>You can learn more about Safeway's market-based healthcare reforms by viewing a video of a presentation CEO Steve Burd gave at the recent annual Food Marketing Insitute (FMI) convention held this year in Las Vegas, Nevada. There's a link to the video here.

>If you want to take a look at some of Safeway's store brands mentioned in our piece above, you can take a look at the grocery chain's weekly advertisement here.

>Safeway donates about $154 million a year to various charities throughout the U.S. and Canada through its Safeway Cares charitable organization. You can learn more about the organization and its charitable giving here. Many of the retailer's donations go to organizations helping mothers and their children.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Retail Memo: Washington D.C's Famous Georgetown Neighborhood Could Finally Get its Long-Desired 'Social Safeway' Supermarket


From the Natural~Specialty Foods Editor's Desk: Nearly three years ago Pleasanton, California USA-based Safeway Stores, Inc. embarked on the huge task of converting what are now about 1,755 supermarkets under numerous retail banners in the United States into what it calls its "Lifestyle" format.

Safeway's "Lifestyle" format is a fairly upscale store design package which features soft colors inside the store, hardwood flooring in departments like produce and wine, and spot lighting instead of bright lights, along with numerous other attractive design elements.

The "Lifestyle" format combines Safeway's traditional value-oriented style of food and grocery retailing with a greater focus on natural, organic, premium and specialty products merchandising across all store categories.

This merchandising emphasis includes expanded selections of natural, healthy and organic food and grocery products like Safeway's own popular O' Organics and Eating Right store brands, along with manufacturers' brands.

The "Lifestyle" merchandising focus also includes store branding of Safeway's fresh, prepared foods offerings, including its premium Signature Cafe brand of ready-to-eat and ready-to-heat items. Additionally, under the "Lifestyle" format Safeway has dramatically expanded the number of premium, specialty, ethnic and gourmet food and grocery items it carries in its supermarkets.

Perhaps the most interesting and important aspect of the "Lifestyle" format is that with it Safeway has tried to create a much more social supermarket. The retailer has used design features like outdoor patios and terraces in some cases, farmers market-style produce departments, wine cellars and old fashion butcher shop-style meat departments in both its new and remodeled supermarkets as ways to create a more social and enjoyable shopping experience for customers.

By and large the "Lifestyle" format has been a big success for Safeway, which has thus far converted about 70% of its U.S. supermarkets--which operate under such banners as Safeway (Northern California, Oregon, Washington state, Arizona, Colorado, Washington D.C., Maryland and Virginia); Vons (Southern California and Nevada); Carrs (Alaska); Dominicks (Illinios and Indiana) and others--into the "Lifestyle" format, according to CEO Steve Burd. Plans call for all of the supermarket chain's stores (except the handful of Pak-N-Sav warehouse stores it operates in Northern California) to be converted to the "Lifestyle" format by the end of 2009, Burd told Natural~Specialty Foods Memo earlier this year.

One strategy Safeway has been using during its three year "Lifestyle" conversion format is to expand the size of certain stores and upscale them considerably in neighborhoods in which the shopper demographics are strong for food stores offering a lifestyle experience along with expanded selections of natural, organic, premium and specialty foods.

The supermarket chain has a number of stores that were opened long ago that sit in such premium demographic neighborhoods. Many of those stores, such a one currently being proposed (a remodel) in Oakland, California's upscale College neighborhood, another in Berkeley, California and yet another in the upscale Georgetown district in Washington D.C., are older, small supermarkets that once fit well in these neighborhoods but have long outgrown the gentrification and upscaling that's gone on in them. These stores and others present a huge sales opportunity (at least a doubling of annual gross sales) if expanded and remodeled based on the respective neighborhoods' demographic profiles.

Washington D.C's Georgetown, home to Senators, lobbyists and the well known Georgetown University, has long wanted Safeway to grow and upscale the Safeway supermarket that's been in the neighborhood for decades.

This has particularly been the desire of Georgetown University students and faculty who like most university communities are on the cutting edge of the natural and organic foods trend. Additionally, the wealthy political and business movers and shakers of Washington D.C., many who reside in Georgetown, have wanted a Safeway supermarket in the neighborhood like the ones ("Lifestyle" format) in nearby Alexandria, Virginia, which is one of the more wealthier suburbs of the nation's capital city.

This desire for a more "social" Safeway has been discussed in the Washington Post newspaper, on numerous area online food forums, and in the pages of the Hoya, the student newspaper of Georgetown University.

Well, it looks like Georgetown University students and the Georgetown neighborhood's who's who of political and corporate residents and their frequently entertaining spouses are going to get their long-desired "social Safeway", according to a story in today's edition of the Hoya, the Georgetown University student newspaper that was founded in 1920.

And, according to the article reprinted below, it looks like Safeway plans to serve up a "Lifestyle" format supermarket for Washington D.C.'s Georgetown neighborhood (where former President John F. Kennedy lived before being elected to office) befitting the areas demographics, love of food and desire for a more social grocery shopping experience.

Perhaps the new Georgetown "Social Safeway" will be ready for the new U.S. President and his family when he--either Barack Obama or John McCain--takes office next year?

Safeway to Get a Little More 'Social'
The Hoya--Georgetown University
By Sep 01 2008

Who would have thought that a mundane trip to Safeway could turn into a social event?

In an effort to create a more welcoming atmosphere, owners of the Wisconsin Avenue Safeway are planning extensive renovations to turn the current grocery store into a “Social Safeway” shopping center almost 50 percent larger.

The new establishment is envisioned as a curbside, two-level shopping complex complete with an outdoor terrace and two parking levels.

Craig Muckle, a Safeway public affairs manager, said the renovation plans are still in the developmental stages. “We are still working with the Advisory Neighborhood Committee and the District government, so the start date hasn’t been identified yet,” Muckle said.

The building would be moved curbside to make it more accessible and inviting than its current spot behind a large parking lot. It would also be turned into a two-level complex, with the lower level occupied by separate businesses and the grocery store on the top. Safeway administrators are currently unsure which businesses would occupy the downstairs level, according to Muckle.

Muckle also said the terrace would be added to give weary shoppers a place to rest. “It essentially will be like an indoor/outdoor café setup where you can purchase food, sit and overlook the store.”

The enormous parking lot will be scaled down, but according to the renovations, parking won’t become scarce: There will be two levels of parking behind and below the store. As a result, there will also be two entrances.

The Georgetown store’s redevelopment is part of Safeway’s long-term rebranding strategy announced in 2004 in which existing stores in North America will get hardwood floors, muted lighting and improved produce, delicatessen, bakery and floral sections.

The renovations specific to the Wisconsin Avenue Safeway, though, such as the shopping area and outdoor terrace, were designed to suit the Georgetown community.

“Every store is different in and of itself, but this plan is strictly for Georgetown,” he said.

The square footage of the new store would be approximately 65,000 square feet, which will be nearly 45 percent larger than the existing store.

“I definitely think it will make the shopping experience more enjoyable, and it will definitely be a way for more people to meet,” said local resident and frequent Safeway customer Elizabeth Williams. “This already is considered the ‘social Safeway’ in D.C., but these changes will only make it that much more social.”

The closure of the current store during construction is projected to be an issue for local customers, but Muckle said he hopes customers will remain loyal to Safeway and use its home delivery service or visit nearby grocery stores in the interim.

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Marketing Memo: Safeway's Challenge: Going From Store Brand Marketer to Consumer Brand Marketer With its O' Organics and Eating Right Brands


Pleasanton, California USA-based Safeway Stores, Inc. is preparing to roll out its popular O' Organics organic foods and Eating Right healthy foods store brands to a wider audience-- competing food retailers in the U.S.--along with to grocers globally, as we reported and wrote about in this April 28 piece: Marketing Memo: Safeway Stores, Inc. to Market its 'O' Organics' and 'Eating Right' Organic and Healthy Brands to Other Retailers in U.S. and Globally.

The supermarket retailer's target date to begin selling the brands (they won't be store brands anymore) to other U.S. food retailers and wholesalers is sometime this fall, just a few short months away.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo was the first publication of any kind to report in this piece in December, 2007 and in others that Safeway Stores, Inc. was already selling some items in its O' Organics organic food and grocery product brand in Asia and South America through a distribution deal with the giant French supermarket chain Carrefour, which is the second largest retailer in the world after Wal-Mart, Inc.

Safeway plans to extend international sales of both its O' Organics and Eating Right brands to other international retailers and to other parts of the world. Plans call for the increased international marketing also to begin this fall in conjunction with the launch to various U.S. supermarket chains and wholesalers at home.


Today's Advertising Age, the trade publication for the marketing and advertising industry in the U.S., has a story about Safeway's plans to launch the two brands into the stores of many of its competitors this fall, as we've previously detailed in Natural~Specialty Foods Memo.

Safeway's O' Organics brand--which currently consists of an impressive 300 items in over 30 product categories, including dry grocery, perishables, fresh meats, dairy and fresh produce--did about $150 million in gross sales in its first year, 2005. Last year the brand did about $300 million in annual sales. Safeway is projecting sales of $400 million for the brand this year in its 1,750 stores in the U.S. and Canada. That's impressive by any score card.

Safeway CEO Steve Burd told Natural~Specialty Foods Memo earlier this year that the Eating Right healthy foods brand was on track to do even more the O' Organics' $150 million in its first year, which won't be until a bit later this year. Safeway is projecting annual sales of about $200 million for Eating Right this year. That would surpass first year sales of the O' Organics brand by about $50 million. Even more impressive.

In our earlier pieces we've projected that with the rollout to competing retailers in the U.S. beginning this fall, along with the expanded international marketing program, O' Organics and Eating Right have the potential to become the leading brands/product lines in their respective categories--organics and healthy foods--in the U.S. By this we mean not the leading store brands--but the leading brands period in those respective categories.

Safeway is banking on this as well, as it makes its unique for a U.S. supermarket chain transition from store brand marketer to consumer brand marketer.

In fact, in today's Ad Age article, James White, president of Safeway's Lucerne Foods division, which is handling the marketing for the two brands, and Safeway corporate vice president for consumer brands, says he believes the organic food and grocery market particularly is strong enough in the U.S. and internationally that Safeway will neither see a drop in sales in its own stores, or have a problem gaining distribution and sales to its competitors, with the O' Organics brand.

The O' Organics brand is "democratizing the organics market by making organics available for everyone." He (James White) said both lines represent a "great-tasting, highest-quality, more-affordable option [than established organic brands], which allows for the mainstreaming of market," White is quoted as saying in the Ad Age story.

Further, the Ad Age piece quotes Mr. White as saying: "The economy isn't affecting the organic segment's pricing power. "There is a significant consumer market for organics, and I don't think that will slow down."

We disagree with Mr. White on these two counts, despite being fans of both O' Organics and Eating Right, as well as being very impressed with the two brands' performance.

First, in terms of O' Organics' democratizing the organics category, we think that's yet to be seen. In fact, when it comes to price, O' Organics products are far from being all that reasonably priced. For example, in its current weekly advertising circular, Safeway is promoting O' Organics Boneless,-Skinless Chicken Breasts for $8.99 pound in its California, Nevada and Arizona stores. Natural~Specialty Foods Memo has seen independent natural foods stores selling organic boneless-skinless chicken breasts for $2 less per pound everyday.

This pricing scenario plays itself out on many of the O' Organics brand products vis-a-vis other supermarkets' and natural and specialty foods retailer's house brands. For example, overall Trader Joe's, Kroger divisions, Costco and Tesco's new Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market stores in California and elsewhere in the Western USA have considerably lower everyday and promoted prices on organics than Safeway offers with its O' Organics brand.

Safeway does offer some good deals on a variety of O' Organics brand items--but its far from a pricing policy one could call a democratizing of the organics category in our analysis. The Safeway O' Organics' marketers' pricing pencils need to be sharpened a bit to achieve that.

It will be very interesting to see the retails on the O' Organics brand items in competing retailers' stores, since they should be higher priced than what they currently are selling for in Safeway stores since the company has to take a margin on the items as a brand marketer and distributor, along with building some margin into the cost of goods to retailers and wholesalers for marketing and promotional brand building expenses.

Further, if Safeway doesn't sell the O' Organics brand items for less than competitors' stores do, it could lose substantial sales in the brand. Conversely, if Safeway sells the brand's items for too much less than its competitor's are, it will create a disincentive for those retailers to carry the brand. A fine balancing act it will be indeed.

We happen to know Safeway makes a very healthy gross margin, based on its current retails, on the O' Organics brand items. Therefore, it has some room to get more value-centered with the brand in its stores if it wants to--and might have to because of the current poor U.S. economy--and lower the retail prices across the brand.

Safeway itself is seeing its customers move from higher priced national brands to value-based store brands like its Safeway, Lucerne and other economy branded food and grocery product lines, as company CEO Steve Burd himself said in this April 28 story in the blog. Within the store brand organics category this has helped O' Organics in part since Safeway makes sure the items in the brand are about 10 -to-15% cheaper overall than similar national and regional organic branded items in its stores, thus tapping into the consumer store brand trend within the organic category to take sales away from those national and regional brands and drive shoppers to buy O' Organics over the national and regional brands.

But in this poor U.S. economy, average consumers just can't afford $8.99 per-pound organic chicken breasts or $7 per gallon organic milk. Not when they can buy conventionally-raised boneless-skinless chicken breasts at the very same Safeway store on sale for $2.19 pound; or Lucerne non-organic milk for less than half the price of the O' Organics organic milk next to it in the dairy case. For most shoppers the discretionary money for organics just isn't there right now.

Whole Foods Market, Inc's poor quarterly sales performance this week demonstrates how even organic-loving shoppers are trading down in the poor U.S. economy out of need rather than choice.

Safeway shoppers are no different, nor are customers of those competitor stores Safeway plans to sell O' Organics to. We are going to see organics take a considerable sales hit until the U.S. economy turns around. Retailer scan data already is showing lower organic category sales across the U.S. Sales numbers for 2008 category sales don't come out until next year--and we bet they show a drop in overall category sales.

It's also important to note that once O' Organics is marketed by Safeway to competing retailers, it no longer becomes a store brand. This means no favored shelf placement, no special treatment by those retailers in terms of end-cap display space, no "free" weekly ad circular feature ad placement, and the like. The brand will have to be marketed as and compete equally without the advantages Safeway is able to give it as a store brand. Those home court advantages after all are part of the reasons we call them store brands.

As a result, Safeway will have to compete with its organics brand just like all of the national and regional organic products' brand marketers are in this down economy--along with suffering the lower sales fate most category marketers are currently suffering ,which has as a key feature soaring food price inflation--because the average (and many above average) U.S. consumers just can't afford to buy that $8.99 pound organic chicken, even if the breasts are boneless and skinless. Just ask the Whole Foods guys. They are seeing organic category sales dropping across the board--from fresh produce and meats to dry grocery.

However, while we disagree with Mr. White regarding his view that the poor U.S. economy won't hurt organic sales in general and O' Organics' sales specifically, we understand and appreciate his marketers' optimism. We also think the O' Organics and Eating Right brands have the potential to do very well at competing supermarkets, as well as continue to sell well and grow in Safeway's stores.

One important note is that sales of the O' Organics brand in Asia have been at best mediocre. A regular reader who lives on the island of Taiwan has reported to use that since our piece about the brand being sold in Carrefour stores there, she has seen many of the O' Organics brand items discontinued in the Carrefour hypermarts on the island. She has been told by store managers it is for lack of sales performance. (Well, that's what happens to non store brands.)

Of course that's Taiwan, not the U.S. or Western Europe. But it does illustrate that Safeway will need to market the brand in ways other than just using price promotions--which has been the case in the Carrefour stores--if it hopes to build the brand in stores other than those owned by Safeway.

Food and grocery retailers can use push marketing to build a store brand and grow sales in their own stores, using the techniques we mentioned above, but it's much more difficult to do so in competitor's stores when its just a brand and not that particular retailer's store brand.

Despite these concerns, we see a bright future inside of and outside Safeway stores for O' Organics and Eating Right. Of course, in the competitors' stores it will all come down to distribution, marketing, merchandising and promotion, along with allocating the budget to achieve all four.

And, of course, Safeway will get a taste of being on the other end of those slotting fee, ad space and display space fees in its role as a consumer brands marketer. Our advice: Better build in plenty of extra margin on the O' Organics items as brand marketers have learned to do with the brands they sell to Safeway Stores, Inc.

Friday, August 31, 2007

End-of-Week NSFM Roundup


Safeway Planning A Whole Foods-Style Store in its Hometown

Safeway Stores, Inc. is planning to built a 65,000 square-foot upscale "Whole Foods style" natural and organic foods supermarket in Pleasanton, California. Safeway's corporate headquarters is located in Pleasanton.

Safeway would build the store on a 35 acre site near their corporate headquarters according to the Pleasanton Weekly News, a weekly community publication. The site is being developed to include several large office buildings.

Safeway isn't discussing the proposed project but the Pleasanton Weekly obtained a copy of the proposed site plan.

The proposed new Safeway would have a major focus on natural and organic products and look much like a new Whole Foods store according to the proposed plans. For Safeway this would be a major step in taking their current focus on natural, organic and specialty foods in their top-tier "Lifestyle" format stores and extending it considerably in a full-blown natural foods retail format.

NSFM expects Safeway to also include a deep selection of specialty, ethnic and gourmet foods in this store if the chain does build it. This would build on Safeway's expertise honed over the last 10 years by the retailer's in-house specialty and natural foods department. This would include specialty and natural/organic foods across all store categories, including perishables and well as produce, meat, seafood, nonfoods, prepared foods and grocery.

Pleasanton would be a good location for such a store for Safeway. Safeway's corporate headquarters is in Pleasanton and the supermarket chain is one of the city's largest employers.

Second, Whole Foods currently doesn't have a store in Pleasanton or the immediate surrounding area. The natural grocer's nearest store is about 25-30 miles away.

Third, Pleasanton is a urban area in that there are 4-5 cities within a few minutes drive from the community. There are about 500,000 people within a 25 minute drive from Pleasanton.

Lastly, Pleasanton and the surrounding area has a high percentage of the population with college degrees and many with graduate and professional degrees. Whole Foods says this is the number one criteria they use in selecting a retail store site/location.

Currently the only retailer (other than an existing Safeway Lifestyle store) doing significant specialty and natural foods merchandising in Pleasanton is an independent, Gene's Fine Foods. The independent does a good job but the store is relatively small and the natural and organic selection limited.

A 65,000 square-foot Safeway, similar in look and merchandising philosophy to a Whole Foods, would likely draw from Pleasanton (about 100,000 population), next door Dublin, and nearby Livermore, San Ramon and Danville, as well as other areas close by.

Safeway has conventional and "Lifestyle" format stores in all of these areas. But a Safeway Natural Foods Supermarket shouldn't hurt these stores as it's likely many shoppers in these communities would still shop their local Safeway primarily but also shop the nearby natural Safeway secondarily. Better that for Safeway than to have these consumers shop at Whole Foods or another natural foods store in the area.

In an article earlier this week titled "Will the Big 3 Supermarket Chains Challenge Whole Foods in its Niche" Natural!Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) posed the question asked in that title. (you can find the our article in NSFM's Tuesday Talking Points Memo.)

In our Tuesday piece we concluded that one or more of these big 3 chains would. If Safeway goes through with this proposal it could be the beginning of that challenge for one of the Big 3.

NSFM is looking further into Safeway's proposed natural foods store and will bring our readers more as things develop.

More Retailer News, Information & Analysis:

Tesco's Fresh & Easy...NSFM has written much about Tesco's development of it Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format which the UK-based retailer is launching in the U.S. The first
stores are slated to open beginning in November, 2007 in California, Arizona and Nevada. Writing in the online publication the Huffington Post, writer Al Norman offers an interesting take on Tesco's new convenience format and compares it to Wal-Mart's new small format developments (which we have written about on NSFM). You can read his story from the August 29, 2007 Huffington Post here: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/al-norman/british-invader-forces-wa_b_62357.html In the story Norman mentions how Tesco carried out a stealth campaign in the U.S. as they developed the Fresh & Easy format.

Coffee king to invade Russia...Starbucks is opening its first Starbuck's Coffee Shop in Russia next month (Sept., 2007). The first Russian Starbucks will be opened in a popular mall near Moscow. The mall already has 5 cafes located in it. You can read more here: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2003859960_russia30.html

Starbucks inks Deal with A&P...Starbucks also is increasing its partnerships with supermarket retailers, placing a growing number of Starbucks cafes, coffee bars and kiosks inside stores. The latest retailer to ink a deal with Starbucks is the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co., Inc., otherwise know as A&P. A&P said it will begin placing Starbucks cafes in some of its stores beginning in November with a store located in New Jersey. You can read more here: http://www.reuters.com/article/bondsNews/idUSWNAS318420070830

Starbucks has been growing it's in-store cafe partnerships with retailers at a fairly rapid pace. Supermarket chains like the idea of having the Starbucks brand inside their stores as a drawing card. And Starbucks likes the foot traffic avaliable inside a supermarket location.

All Aboard...
Whole Foods' Market Express Format: A Brief Analysis

On Thursday NSFM reported on Whole Foods Market, Inc.'s decision to turn an existing 18,500 square-foot Wild Oats banner store in Boulder, Colorado into a convenience-type format called "Whole Foods Market Express" as part of the supernatural grocer's post-merger plan.

Whole Foods says the "Express" market will offer a "value-oriented product mix, grab-and-go offerings and will be a practical fit for its neighborhood." The store will be located in the current Baseline Road Wild Oats store in Boulder. The neighborhood includes a high concentration of University of Colorado at Boulder students.

Whole Foods' decision is very interesting in light of Tesco's current roll out of its Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market format (stores scheduled to open starting in November in California, Arizona and Neveda) and Wal-Mart's development (in the planning stages) of a small footprint upscale convenience-type store.

In the case of Whole Foods and Wal-Mart (relative retailing David's and Goliath's) their paths seem to be crossing more and more these days despite the retailers' significant size and sales differences. Wal-Mart's major natural and organic grocery sales initiative ("organics for less") for its stores has the potential to strike at the heart of some of Whole Foods' bread and butter business. Whether or not intended, Whole Foods is a target of this initiative in terms of taking category market share away from the top natural and organic products retailers.

In turn, no sooner had it been reported (about a week ago) that Wal-Mart is in the planning stages for development of an upscale, convenience-type store, we not only see Whole Foods announcing it will test one but also preparing to open it very soon. This just shows how all retail players and formats are converging when it comes to the natural, organic and specialty foods categories.

In the case of Tesco they are the first mover of the three in terms of this upscale, fresh food-oriented convenience format. (It's important here to note that a C-store chain, Wawa Food Markets based in Pennsylvania, has being operating numerous fairly upscale convenience stores which feature lots of prepared foods and specialty items for well over a decade. There are some significant differences to the Tesco, Wal-Mart and Whole Foods concepts but Wawa has been a leader in this segment on a regional basis in the eastern U.S. for over a decade.)

NSFM has no doubt that UK-based Tesco played a major role in both Wal-Mart and Whole Foods' wanting to test this format. Tesco is the world's third largest retailer and put lots of research and study into the Fresh & Easy format before breaking ground. The chain conducted much of this research in a stealth mode and suprised the industry when their plans came out in the media. Tesco also has put much research in the convenience chain's product mix--and since Tesco is considered one of the world's retail leaders in prepared foods merchandising the "fresh" concept comes naturally to them.

It's too early to tell if a small footprint convenience-oriented format will work in the U.S. on a national basis. Wawa Food Markets has proven it can on a regional basis, although they also retain many traditional C-store merchandising aspects in their stores.

It's good though to see Tesco, Wal-Mart and now Whole Foods experimenting with this concept. Many American consumers are looking for alternatives to "big box" shopping and that fact could spell success for the retailer(s) who can come up with the right format and product mix--at the right retails--to draw these shoppers.

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Marketing Memo: Ingredients For 'Free Media' Marketing Success: Safeway Stores Finds Them With Announcement of its New 'Eating Right For Kids' Line

The marketing positioning statement for Pleasanton, California-based Safeway Stores, Inc. is Safeway: Ingredients For Life. The marketing message ties-in and communicates the grocer's "Lifestyle" food retailing format, which involves its store design and decor, overall and category-specific merchandising philosophy and program, product assortment, and additional elements of the grocer's identity and practice as a food retailer.

Natural~Specialty Foods Memo's Analysis is that Safeway has become not only a good food retailer but a supreme food marketer as well over the last decade. It's also become entrepreneurial, as well as a solid learning organization.

Under its Lifestyle format program, Safeway has upscaled its stores--going from what were basic supermarkets to attractive stores with soft but attractive color schemes inside, soft lighting, hardwood flooring in departments like produce, wine and gourmet foods, and much more attractive and modern lifestyle-looking store exteriors.

The chain's merchandising mix--especially its store brands like O' Organics, Eating Right, Signature Cafe fresh, prepared foods and others scream "Lifestyle." And that "Lifestyle is one of good foods bought at Safeway. The retailer has even redesigned its Safeway and Lucerne value-priced store brands in such a way as to make them look modern yet not upscale, which would befeat the purpose of a price-value store brand.

Today Safeway distributed a brief press release about a new line of Eating Right brand healthy foods for kids called "Eating Right Kids." The new line is part of a licensing agreement Safeway has inked with Warner Bros., in which the Eating Right brand food and grocery products targeted to kids will feature Warner Bros cartoon and related characters on them. Warner Bros. also will use its various venues to co-market the Safeway branded products to consumers.

All of the "Eating Right Kids" products will have a healthy focus, just as the regular Safeway Eating Right brand products do.
Ingredients for good press coverage

Before writing, and as we write this piece, the Natural~Specialty Foods Memo (NSFM) email box has been overflowing Safeway "Google Alerts" to publications of all kinds who are running stories on the Safeway/Warner Bros Eating Right Kids product introduction press release, which was just issued today by Safeway Stores, Inc and Warner Bros.

Online publications from CNN, Business Week and Forbes, to numerous newspapers and blogs of all sorts--from business and marketing-oriented blogs to motherhood an healthy foods-oriented publications--are already running pieces based on the news release.

Here's why: The ingredients for generating lots of positive coverage for a new product introduction in the food and grocery industry go something like this:

>Have a good story to tell
>Have a good angle
>keep the release brief
>Be topical
>Find a "hot button." In the food industry health is a hot button. Healthy foods for kids is an even "hotter" button. Cartoon characters to boot creates some sizzle.
>Tie the story in with an already popular brand.
>Be topical but on point.
>Tell how the new product introduction fits into what you do everyday.
>Tie-in the new product introduction release in with a wider social purpose.

The Safeway/Warner Bros introduction of the "Eating Right Kids" healthy foods line hits all the above hot buttons and a few others we won't mention for brevity sake.

Reprinted below in italics is today's Eating Right Kids new product introduction press release. As you read the release, we suggest you do so asking yourself how well it meets the nine criteria above. The Press Release:

Safeway Inc. (NYSE:SWY) and Warner Bros. Consumer Products announced a partnership today that will create a better-for-you line of food products for children, uniting flavor and nutrition. Through a licensing agreement with Safeway(R), the Warner Bros. animated Looney Tunes characters will be featured on the new Eating Right Kids(TM) line of food and beverages, to be sold at Safeway.

Eating Right Kids, an extension of the successful Eating Right(TM) adult line, will launch later this year with select products arriving on store shelves this summer. The line will initially be carried at over 1,700 Safeway locations throughout the United States and Canada. In early 2009, Eating Right Kids will also be available nationally via the Better Living Brands(TM) Alliance. Each product in the multi-category, competitively priced line will feature such world-renowned Looney Tunes characters as Bugs Bunny, Tweety, Taz, Sylvester, Wile E. Coyote, Roadrunner, Marvin the Martian and Daffy Duck.

Eating Right Kids is the first broad product line to feature entertainment characters and be dedicated solely to a healthier eating philosophy. Parents will now have an ally helping them show their kids that better-for-you foods can taste good and be fun at the same time.

"The Warner Bros. Consumer Products partnership will allow us to extend the Eating Right brand to a line of products that will appeal to children, and at the same time give parents the comfort that these products are healthier choices," said Mike Minasi, Safeway President, Marketing. "Integrating such well-recognized characters into our brand architecture will make the line more attractive to our target audience and augment the line's success."

"This partnership with Safeway allows us to utilize the Looney Tunes characters' enduring popularity with kids and teens to promote a lifestyle choice that's healthier for them," said Barry Meyer, Chairman & CEO, Warner Bros. "Using our iconic characters as ambassadors of health and fitness, the Eating Right Kids program helps simplify good nutrition for parents and their children."

The broad product line will feature more than 100 items across 30 categories including breakfast foods, portable meals, dairy, snacks, and beverages. Products are formulated based on the most recent dietary recommendations and regulations from several federal and state agencies, including Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS), the Department of Agriculture (USDA), the Alliance for a Healthier Generation, and the California School Nutritional Guidelines SB12.

The product packaging will retain the Eating Right design architecture while taking full advantage of the personalities associated with the beloved Looney Tunes characters. The Looney Tunes characters will serve as 'Mother's Helper,' making it easy for moms to spot better-for-you food and beverage items for their kids that taste great. The characters will also be integrated into the Eating Right "Spot Your Needs(TM)" easy-reference system, which helps customers quickly identify the nutritional benefits of each product. "

As our nation continues to struggle with the issue of childhood obesity, Safeway has taken a leadership role in providing parents and consumers with food products that are healthier for children, and we believe in this philosophy," said Brad Globe, President, Warner Bros. Worldwide Consumer Products. "Not only will the Eating Right Kids line provide a healthier eating solution for kids and their parents, but we've taken the additional step across the entire Looney Tunes product line in North America to ensure that the majority of food products featuring the characters meet this better-for-you standard and will be exclusively available through the Eating Right Kids line."

Today's announcement is the latest component in a larger, ongoing Safeway initiative focused on providing health and wellness solutions to its customers. The Eating Right line launched in April 2007 with products produced primarily for adults and now has nearly 200 items in more than 30 categories. The philosophy behind the brand is to offer healthier eating solutions across multiple categories with a "Spot Your Needs" easy reference system so consumers can easily identify foods that meet their individual requirements. Safeway also developed FoodFlex, an innovative online nutrition tool that provides personalized information about food, nutrition and alternative grocery options. Last year, Safeway launched its Good to Know program, an in-store and online guide to food nutrition. Good to Know signs are posted throughout stores and on www.safeway.com showing the health benefits of certain products, including the cancer-fighting benefits. For example, the Good to Know product signs on broccoli and tomato sauce note that these foods may help reduce the risk of certain types of cancer, including breast cancer.

We don't normally run press releases in NSFM, except for illustrative purposes like this one.

As you can observe from reading it, the release offers lots of information. However, all of it exists around a central them: healthy eating and lifestyle; which is what Safeway's positioning is as a food retailer. The announcement also ties-in the new product line with the bigger social problem of childhood obesity. Pretty tight media marketing in our analysis.

The Safeway/Warner Bros. Eating Right For Kids" new product line announcement news release just hit media email boxes today, June 4, as mentioned above. We didn't see it until afternoon. Here's a list of the media coverage the healthy foods product line announcement has gotten as of 9pm tonight. Remember, the news release was just issued today.

As we said, pretty good ingredients for media marketing success....as in "Life."